To ask the Scottish Executive whether it is planning more private prisons in the next three years. (S1O-3825)
Official Report · Chamber
Prisons (Private)
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Iain Gray Lab 4
- Christine Grahame SNP 2
- Janis Hughes Lab 1
- Phil Gallie Con 1
The record
8 contributionsPlanning the future long-term shape of the prison estate is the purpose behind the on-going estates review, on which the Executive plans to consult shortly.
That is a year and a half late. Will the minister comment on this week's announcement of the transfer of two senior and respected prison governors at Barlinnie and Peterhead out of front-line prison management, which has reduced staff morale even further and is seen as a deliberate move to ease in privatisation? Will he say categorically whether he agrees with Tony Blair who, before coming into power, stated:
"We consider prison privatisation wrong in principle and in practice … A Labour Government would bring the prisons back within the proper public prison system at the earliest opportunity"?
"We consider prison privatisation wrong in principle and in practice … A Labour Government would bring the prisons back within the proper public prison system at the earliest opportunity"?
The position of the Scottish Executive is very clear. It was described by the previous First Minister, Donald Dewar, when he said:
"The evidence is that the private sector can deliver prison services competently and competitively, and I have no problem in principle with that".
That was the position then and it is the position now. The purpose of the estates review is to come to a clear, transparent, open-minded decision about how, over the next 10 to 15 years, we put in place a prison service that serves Scotland.
"The evidence is that the private sector can deliver prison services competently and competitively, and I have no problem in principle with that".
That was the position then and it is the position now. The purpose of the estates review is to come to a clear, transparent, open-minded decision about how, over the next 10 to 15 years, we put in place a prison service that serves Scotland.
The minister will be aware that three potential sites in the Rutherglen and Cambuslang areas in my constituency are being considered as part of the prison estates review. Will he confirm that the views of local residents will be considered and that full consultation will take place before any decisions are reached about the siting of prisons?
I can, of course, confirm that. The opening or building of a new prison is subject to the full planning process. A result of that—and of the fact that that is an unusual and particularly complex project—is that the process may be long and extended. It is quite proper that consideration is given to the possibilities while we await the final figures in the estates review—and what those figures might tell us—and the outcome of the public consultation.
Is the minister aware of the recently published report on the past year of the chief inspector of prisons? Is he aware that 50 per cent of the items of good practice that the report identified were drawn from Kilmarnock prison? Does he agree that all is not bad with private sector prisons—just as all is not perfect. Does he also agree that the Scottish Prison Service provides an equally good service in many ways?
I am aware of the report of the chief inspector of prisons, and that 12 examples of good practice were drawn from Kilmarnock prison. In his report, the chief inspector pointed out that the examples of good practice tended to be drawn from those prisons where there had been a recent full inspection. In this case, those included Kilmarnock and Cornton Vale.
Mr Gallie's later point echoes the comments of Mr Fairweather, who stated:
"I have always said that there are good things at Kilmarnock, just as there are good things in the public sector. Both need to learn from those examples."—[Official Report, Justice 1 Committee, 11 September 2001; c 2639.]
That is a good example of the sort of open-mindedness that sets dogma to one side. I hope that we will bring that to bear in the important debate that we will require once the options stemming from the estates review are before us.
Mr Gallie's later point echoes the comments of Mr Fairweather, who stated:
"I have always said that there are good things at Kilmarnock, just as there are good things in the public sector. Both need to learn from those examples."—[Official Report, Justice 1 Committee, 11 September 2001; c 2639.]
That is a good example of the sort of open-mindedness that sets dogma to one side. I hope that we will bring that to bear in the important debate that we will require once the options stemming from the estates review are before us.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Sep 2001 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 27 September 2001 Debate · 2
- Care of the Elderly Debate · 50
- Public Resources Debate · 129
- Business Motion Business motions · 28
- Scottish Transport Group Pension Schemes Questions · 8
- Water Authority Questions · 9
- Telecommunications Masts Questions · 6
- Prisons (Private) Questions · 8
- Schools (Exclusions) Questions · 6
- Scottish Prison Service (Slopping Out) Questions · 6
- Central Heating Questions · 8
- Home Energy Conservation Act Questions · 7
- Hospital-acquired Infections Questions · 19
- Waste Water Treatment Questions · 5
- Lung Diseases Questions · 6
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Economy (Impact of Terrorist Attacks) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Social Justice Objectives First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Meat and Livestock (Export Ban) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Common Fisheries Policy Debate · 20
- Police and Fire Services (Finance) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 27
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 13
- Decision Time Decision time · 39
- “Value Nurses” Campaign Members’ business · 32
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.