To ask the First Minister whether he has any plans to reshuffle his Cabinet. (S1F-1245)
Official Report · Chamber
Cabinet Reshuffle
First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David McLetchie Con 3
- Henry McLeish Lab 3
The record
6 contributionsNo.
There will be disappointment and delight in equal measure on the Labour benches at that answer. If the First Minister will not change the personnel, perhaps he might change the policies, particularly in relation to the health service.
Only this morning, we read that 40 national health service patients from Liverpool—who have waited six months for heart bypass surgery—are to be operated on at the HCI International Medical Centre in Clydebank. If what matters is what works, as the First Minister is constantly telling us, why is it that patients in Scotland have to wait 12 months before they receive similar consideration for an operation? Six months in Liverpool and 12 months in Glasgow. Is that what the First Minister means by a two-tier health service? Does he find that acceptable?
Only this morning, we read that 40 national health service patients from Liverpool—who have waited six months for heart bypass surgery—are to be operated on at the HCI International Medical Centre in Clydebank. If what matters is what works, as the First Minister is constantly telling us, why is it that patients in Scotland have to wait 12 months before they receive similar consideration for an operation? Six months in Liverpool and 12 months in Glasgow. Is that what the First Minister means by a two-tier health service? Does he find that acceptable?
First, we do not have a two-tier health service in Scotland. That was another illustration of the attempt to talk down a programme that is serving the interests of the wider public.
Although it was as if some of David McLetchie's comments this morning were a revelation, we already use private facilities, where appropriate, and will continue to do so. In that sense, David McLetchie has not thrown a bit of magic into the debate. However, we must recognise that private facilities have only limited capacity in Scotland.
Let us turn to the challenging issue of waiting times. In terms of average waiting times, Scotland compares favourably with any other part of the United Kingdom. We have an important commitment to bringing down the average waiting time to nine months and an important commitment to planning ahead. If a situation arises in which it is appropriate to use private facilities, the Minister for Health and Community Care would want to do so.
Although it was as if some of David McLetchie's comments this morning were a revelation, we already use private facilities, where appropriate, and will continue to do so. In that sense, David McLetchie has not thrown a bit of magic into the debate. However, we must recognise that private facilities have only limited capacity in Scotland.
Let us turn to the challenging issue of waiting times. In terms of average waiting times, Scotland compares favourably with any other part of the United Kingdom. We have an important commitment to bringing down the average waiting time to nine months and an important commitment to planning ahead. If a situation arises in which it is appropriate to use private facilities, the Minister for Health and Community Care would want to do so.
That is an interesting answer.
Perhaps the First Minister could tell me why it is appropriate for patients from Liverpool to get heart bypass surgery in Clydebank, but it is apparently not appropriate for patients in Glasgow—waiting for the same operation—to get the operation on their doorstep. Why is the First Minister not prepared to take the further step that has been taken down south? Why will he not enter into a proper working agreement with the independent sector in Scotland to ensure that NHS patients here get the same benefits—the results of which we now see—as those in England?
I asked the First Minister about that two weeks ago and he failed to answer. I ask him again for a clear answer. Will he kindly take off the ideological blinkers and be prepared, for the sake of patients, to consider the measure for Scotland?
Perhaps the First Minister could tell me why it is appropriate for patients from Liverpool to get heart bypass surgery in Clydebank, but it is apparently not appropriate for patients in Glasgow—waiting for the same operation—to get the operation on their doorstep. Why is the First Minister not prepared to take the further step that has been taken down south? Why will he not enter into a proper working agreement with the independent sector in Scotland to ensure that NHS patients here get the same benefits—the results of which we now see—as those in England?
I asked the First Minister about that two weeks ago and he failed to answer. I ask him again for a clear answer. Will he kindly take off the ideological blinkers and be prepared, for the sake of patients, to consider the measure for Scotland?
There is no end of ideology among the Conservatives, who argue for privatisation. The Scottish National Party argues for no private sector involvement whatever. David McLetchie quoted me last week, saying that what matters is what works. We are doing exactly that in the health service.
I am a bit vexed to have missed this morning's debate—any health debate with mention of "The Kama Sutra" or talk of clothes being stolen from a party
"after it had been stripped naked of all credibility"
must have had a bit of spice. Thank goodness, because David McLetchie's contribution to the health care debate is again singularly inappropriate. We are doing the very things that are pragmatic in Scotland. Health care matters to us. We will therefore use private facilities where appropriate. That is important, and I am sure that it is a view that the Scottish people support.
I am a bit vexed to have missed this morning's debate—any health debate with mention of "The Kama Sutra" or talk of clothes being stolen from a party
"after it had been stripped naked of all credibility"
must have had a bit of spice. Thank goodness, because David McLetchie's contribution to the health care debate is again singularly inappropriate. We are doing the very things that are pragmatic in Scotland. Health care matters to us. We will therefore use private facilities where appropriate. That is important, and I am sure that it is a view that the Scottish people support.
In this meeting
Everything on 20 Sep 2001 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 20 September 2001 Debate · 1
- Juvenile Justice Debate · 58
- Patient Care Debate · 105
- Business Motion Business motions · 39
- Croy Railway Station (Parking) Questions · 11
- Police (Funding) Questions · 9
- Scallop Industry Questions · 6
- Cities Review Questions · 12
- Autism Questions · 4
- Drugs (Methadone Programmes) Questions · 6
- Health Care Professionals (Rural Areas) Questions · 9
- Rural Development (Schools) Questions · 6
- Public Transport Questions · 6
- Health at Work Questions · 6
- Water and Sewerage Industry Questions · 6
- Women's Offending Questions · 8
- Health Service (Dental Therapists) Questions · 6
- Housebreaking Questions · 4
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet Reshuffle First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Care of the Elderly First Minister’s Questions · 6
- National Health Service (Pay and Morale) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Homeless People (Mental Health) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Air Pollution First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Schools (Assessment) Debate · 85
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 17
- Decision Time Decision time · 63
- Sighthill (Community Issues) Members’ business · 27
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.