Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Pupil Attainment

Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE

Thursday 17 May 2001 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 10 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Mary Mulligan Lab Linlithgow
link
To ask the Scottish Executive whether any research exists to suggest that pupil attainment has increased since 1997. (S1O-3451)

Jack McConnell Lab The Minister for Education, Europe and External Affairs · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
There is evidence of significant gains in pupil attainment since 1997 from the Scottish Qualifications Authority examination statistics, the national five-to-14 attainment survey, the assessment of achievement programme and Her Majesty's inspectors of schools' reports on the early stages, which demonstrate gains at all stages of schooling. For example, the national five-to-14 attainment survey, which compares performances in 1999 and 2000, shows that performance in reading, writing and mathematics has improved at almost all stages.

Mary Mulligan Lab Linlithgow
link
I am sure that all members will wish well the students who are this week starting their standard grade and higher examinations. I am especially concerned—as was Kate MacLean in her earlier question—that those who started at a disadvantage should improve their attainment through education. Would the improvement that has been identified continue if Scotland were to take its share of the £20 billion cuts that are proposed by the Tories?

Jack McConnell Lab The Minister for Education, Europe and External Affairs · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
The significant reductions in budgets that are proposed by at least one political party honestly—and perhaps by others by stealth—would have a drastic effect on Scottish education. The improvements that have been made in Scottish education have not happened by accident. The early intervention programme, the out-of-school-hours activities, the investment in new community schools, the investment in new technology and the investment in books, equipment and school repairs have resulted from deliberate decisions and a stable economy that can finance them, to the benefit of every pupil in Scotland now and in the future. It would be a disaster for Scottish education if those benefits were withdrawn as a result of cuts that may be proposed by the Conservative party, should it ever win a general election.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link
Is the minister aware of research, especially that from the student:teacher achievement ratio project—the STAR project—that has established a positive relationship between reduced class sizes and improved pupil performance? Does he concur with the findings of that project, which confirm that the benefits are most evident during the first three years of formal schooling and when class sizes fall to 18 pupils or fewer—which he will recognise is SNP policy? Further, will he concede that tinkering at the margins, by reducing class sizes from 33 to 25, which is a target that is still not being achieved by new Labour after four years, makes little material difference in matters of pupil attainment?

Jack McConnell Lab The Minister for Education, Europe and External Affairs · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
The target was to reduce class sizes to a maximum of 30 and that is being achieved.

Since the teachers' pay and conditions agreement was reached back in January, we have listened month after month to the Scottish National Party saying that we cannot recruit the teachers we need to achieve that target and the other targets for primary and secondary schooling. For SNP members now to claim that we could recruit a further 2,500 teachers to reduce class sizes to 18 is a piece of nonsense and a deception of the Scottish people. We should get on with improving Scottish education and not make up such nonsense, which simply deceives voters and pupils.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link
I shall restrict my response to a verbal punch. The Conservatives in Scotland spent more on education than the Executive—a painful fact for the minister to acknowledge. Is the minister satisfied not only that pupil attainment is increasing, but with what pupils are attaining? Is he satisfied that that matches the needs of the outside world?

Jack McConnell Lab The Minister for Education, Europe and External Affairs · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
As I have said before, one of the tragedies of last year's examinations chaos was the fact that the new national qualifications were perhaps discredited. In rebuilding confidence in the education system, we must say that although internal assessment arrangements perhaps need to be improved, those new qualifications are good for Scottish education, good for Scottish business and good for the future employment and skills of the young people of Scotland.

As Mary Mulligan said, this summer's diet of examinations started this week and we should wish the young people who are involved all the best for their exams and continue to strive to deliver their certificates accurately and on time. I hope that, as we rebuild confidence in the examinations, we can rebuild confidence in the qualifications as well. Those qualifications are already being copied elsewhere in the world, because the system is right even if the arrangements last year let many people down.

Donald Gorrie LD Central Scotland
link
As a constructive contribution to the debate that follows on from last year's fiasco arising from the exam structure, would the minister consider setting up an authoritative and neutral study of the quality of attainment by our pupils and students through the exam system? There is a sort of middle-aged view that exams are constantly getting easier and I think that it would be helpful if that were studied scientifically and either proved or disproved.

Jack McConnell Lab The Minister for Education, Europe and External Affairs · Motherwell and Wishaw
link
There have been such studies. The HMI, which is now an independent agency that works completely separately from the department, although it follows a clear annual agreement, will help provide the kind of independent and objective assessment that Mr Gorrie calls for.

It is important that we remember that the Scottish examination system is a good examination system. It has a proud tradition that is copied elsewhere in the world. We should not talk the system and the qualifications down simply because we have a new set of courses that involve far too much assessment and with which last summer's certification process could not cope. If we get those two elements right, those qualifications will have the reputation that they should always have had.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 17 May 2001 Debate · 1
  2. Special Educational Needs Debate · 42
  3. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 6
  4. Business Motion Business motions · 38
  5. SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
  6. Primary Schools (Early Intervention Programme) Questions · 4
  7. Employment (Over-50s) Questions · 12
  8. Drug Misuse Questions · 8
  9. Police (Race Relations) Questions · 4
  10. International Student Advisory Council (OSPREY) Questions · 4
  11. Pupil Attainment Questions · 10
  12. Non-departmental Public Bodies Questions · 6
  13. Scottish Executive Consultation Exercises Questions · 4
  14. Integrated Administration and Control System Questions · 6
  15. Foot-and-mouth Disease (Tourism Businesses) Questions · 8
  16. Myalgic Encephalomyelitis Questions · 6
  17. Quarrying Industry Questions · 6
  18. Health Improvement Fund Questions · 4
  19. British Sign Language Questions · 7
  20. Scottish Enterprise Borders (Meetings) Questions · 6
  21. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  22. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  23. Social Justice Objectives First Minister’s Questions · 9
  24. Governance First Minister’s Questions · 6
  25. Scottish Local Authorities (Tendering) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 71
  26. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 5
  27. Motion Without Notice Business motions · 6
  28. Decision Time Decision time · 22
  29. National Breastfeeding Awareness Week Members’ business · 15

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.