To ask the Scottish Executive which hospitals' in-patient maternity units may be relocated following acute services reviews. (S1O-3397)
Official Report · Chamber
Maternity Units
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Susan Deacon Lab 4
- Brian Monteith Con 2
- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 1
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 1
The record
8 contributionsIt is not possible for me to comment on or indeed speculate about the location of hospital in-patient maternity units ahead of the completion of local acute services reviews that are currently taking place. However, I expect NHSScotland to take full account of the national framework for maternity services when considering the most appropriate configuration of maternity services to meet the needs of the local population.
I am disappointed that the minister could not give the chamber a fuller answer, as she must have the information at her disposal. She might have mentioned the proposals to move maternity services from Stirling to Falkirk, from Perth to Dundee, from Dunfermline to Kirkcaldy and so on—there is a list of 13 or more maternity units that might be moved. Perhaps the minister will place that list in the Scottish Parliament information centre some time. When she gives her strategic overview of the service, will she consider the population growth in Stirling over the past two years, which has been 10 times that in Falkirk?
Brian Monteith's representation of the issue is disingenuous, dishonest, misleading and—I must say—scaremongering, particularly as it concerns such an important and sensitive area of service provision. He is well aware that there has been full and considered local debate about the right configuration of maternity services now and in future. It is only right that local people should be properly informed about those issues and involved in the debate; they should not be misled by local politicians making a bid to score cheap political points.
The minister is well aware of the continuing public outrage at moves to downgrade maternity services at Perth royal infirmary. Will she join me in welcoming the late addition to the acute services review of another option that would retain a consultant-led maternity provision at PRI? Will she also go further and give a commitment to Scotland that she will continue to push for locally accessible services within the framework that she mentioned and confirm that there will be no orthodoxy of centralisation in Scotland's health service?
The national framework for maternity services makes it clear that there must be proper local provision not just of delivery units but of general maternity care from pregnancy through to post-natal care. Current practice—and current expectations based on modern medicine and technology—enables us to provide far more support and services to the community than was once the case. I hope that, when health boards across Scotland consider those matters, they will think and act flexibly and that they will listen and respond to the real concerns of local communities. In that light, I am pleased that Tayside Health Board has been thinking flexibly and continues to be in dialogue with the local community about its concerns.
Does the minister agree that safety must be the paramount consideration in the implementation of the maternity strategy? If we are not to demoralise Scottish midwives, will she ask her officials to ensure that the changes required in working practice to implement the team midwifery systems—which are important for pre-conception, prenatal and postnatal care—are handled carefully? Furthermore, will she ensure that her first priority in appointing additional community midwives should be understaffed areas and areas of deprivation?
I certainly endorse Richard Simpson's comments about the importance of safety as a key consideration in debates about the future of maternity services. I would add the importance of enabling women to exercise informed choice about their maternity care and, in particular, the birth of their child.
Alongside those considerations, a crucial issue is how we organise the many staff—not least midwives—around women's needs. As the national framework for maternity services sets out, we are working closely with the profession and have put in place mechanisms to ensure that, in future, the capacity and organisational training of the work force matches the needs and expectations of the women who use the service.
Alongside those considerations, a crucial issue is how we organise the many staff—not least midwives—around women's needs. As the national framework for maternity services sets out, we are working closely with the profession and have put in place mechanisms to ensure that, in future, the capacity and organisational training of the work force matches the needs and expectations of the women who use the service.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 May 2001 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 10 May 2001 Debate · 1
- Tourism Debate · 48
- Holyrood Debate · 110
- Business Motion Business motions · 38
- SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
- Devolution Questions · 4
- Foot-and-mouth Disease Questions · 8
- Social Work Questions · 6
- Litter Questions · 11
- Extradition Questions · 6
- visitscotland Questions · 8
- Lung Cancer Questions · 4
- Maternity Units Questions · 8
- Hospitals (Mixed-sex Wards) Questions · 4
- ME Awareness Week Questions · 6
- Judiciary (Training) Questions · 4
- Foot-and-mouth Disease (Dumfries and Galloway Council) Questions · 6
- Schools (Promotion of Industry) Questions · 6
- Gaelic Questions · 4
- Respite Care Questions · 4
- Tuition Fees Questions · 4
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Devolution First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Scottish Qualifications Authority First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Tartan Day First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Urban Regeneration Debate · 46
- Decision Time Decision time · 53
- Foot-and-mouth Disease (Dumfries and Galloway) Debate · 22
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.