To ask the Scottish Executive why it is safe to burn cattle over five years old yet not safe to bury such cattle due to the risk of contaminating either the ground or the atmosphere with BSE. (S1O-3324)
Official Report · Chamber
BSE
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John Scott Con 2
- Ross Finnie LD 2
The record
4 contributionsThe Spongiform Encephalopathy Advisory Committee recently considered a BSE risk assessment on the burning of cattle and the risk from burying cattle. SEAC's view was that burning cattle carcases remains the preferable option, as burning can destroy as much as 90 per cent of any BSE infectivity whereas, with burial, none might be destroyed. The committee estimated that the likely BSE infectivity in cattle born before 1 August 1996 would be about 400 times higher than that in cattle born on or after that date. Based on that information, older cattle in Scotland are either rendered or burned.
The minister will be aware that BSE is almost indestructible, so the process of burning potentially BSE-infected cattle that are more than five years old must carry a risk of distributing BSE prions into the atmosphere. That could allow the prions to fall on grassland or growing vegetables, which would contaminate the human and animal food chain. In light of that fact, which the minister has not denied, would not it have been safer to render rather than burn all cattle destroyed in the foot-and-mouth outbreak? Will he undertake to have cattle that are more than five years old rendered from now on?
The answer that I gave to John Scott was that we recognise the difficulty. We rightly and properly referred the issue to SEAC, whose advice I related in my first answer. There are no risk-free options in this matter. We have had similar difficulties in taking the advice of the Scottish Environment Protection Agency and others about what we do with cattle that we are burying. In all those matters, we have the overlay of environmental considerations. There is no risk-free option, but at every stage we have taken advice from the relevant body. SEAC is charged with the responsibility for judging the risk of BSE and we have acted on its advice—it is on its advice that we have burned and incinerated animals over the relevant period.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 May 2001 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 3 May 2001 Debate · 1
- Standing Orders Debate · 8
- Genetically Modified Organisms Debate · 75
- Rural Scotland (Employment Patterns) Debate · 45
- Business Motion Business motions · 8
- Crofting Counties Roads Scheme Questions · 4
- Glasgow Housing Association Questions · 6
- Rail Links (Alloa) Questions · 8
- Prescription Charges (Exemptions) Questions · 6
- Maternity Hospitals (Nappies) Questions · 9
- Job Losses (Assistance) Questions · 10
- Ritalin Questions · 4
- visitscotland Questions · 11
- Higher and Further Education (Partnerships) Questions · 6
- BSE Questions · 4
- Criminal Justice Forum Questions · 6
- Falkirk Council (Structure Plan) Questions · 8
- Domestic Violence (Prosecution) Questions · 4
- Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (Meetings) Questions · 9
- Football (European Championship) Questions · 4
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Licensing First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Cancer Services (Funding) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Factory Closure (Kintyre) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Schools (Teaching Standards) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Child Health Debate · 54
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 6
- Decision Time Decision time · 34
- Pensions (Ardersier Employees) Members’ business · 15
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.