Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Railways

Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE

Thursday 5 April 2001 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 8 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Scott Barrie Lab Dunfermline West
link
To ask the Scottish Executive what progress is being made on the Stirling-Alloa-Dunfermline rail link. (S1O-3264)

Sarah Boyack Lab The Minister for Transport and Planning · Edinburgh Central
link
My department is in close contact with Clackmannanshire Council and Railtrack about progress with the project. I have called for an urgent report from the council on potential cost increases.

Scott Barrie Lab Dunfermline West
link
The minister will be well aware of the importance of that project to relieve the freight pressure on the Forth bridge, the east coast main line and the Fife circle. Can she confirm what the current gap in the financing of the project is? Can she cast any light on whether the increased gap is caused by Railtrack's tightening of the line and signal specifications or by deficiencies in the original report prepared by Clackmannanshire Council?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Minister for Transport and Planning · Edinburgh Central
link
Until I have the urgent report that I have asked for, I will not be able to answer those questions in detail. That is why we need that urgent report. Members will recall that, in 1999, I deferred Clackmannanshire Council's application for further work, although we gave it clearance last year. I am very concerned about the potential cost increase in the project, but more background work is required to find out from all the parties involved exactly what the nature of those increases is before we can make statements about the future of the project. The gap is significant and we will need to consider the issue very carefully.

Dr Richard Simpson Lab Ochil
link
When she is reviewing the situation with her officials, will the minister ensure that she examines the figures that I have received, which show that the passenger element of the bid was wrong by a factor differing from £2.2 million to £9.9 million? Will she investigate what the official submission was and how on earth the bid could ever have been approved in the first place if those figures are indeed correct? Furthermore, will she agree to hold an urgent meeting involving Scott Barrie, Sylvia Jackson and me, and Clackmannanshire Council, Stirling Council and Railtrack, to review what appears to be a disastrous bid so that we can endeavour to resolve the problem in the interests of all our constituents?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Minister for Transport and Planning · Edinburgh Central
link
It is fair to say that there has already been a meeting with some of the key players who would be involved in delivering the project. I take the matter very seriously and, in issuing the next public transport fund circular for information, I am certainly minded to ensure that the authorities provide us with more information than they have hitherto been required to provide. It is up to local authorities that are submitting bids to the Executive to ensure that the whole package is in place and has been properly and robustly evaluated. That is why I need an urgent report and why we cannot take the matter any further forward in the chamber today. Nevertheless, I am happy to talk to Richard Simpson and Scott Barrie about the matter.

Bruce Crawford SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link
Does the minister agree that that rail line has regional significance and that Clackmannanshire Council has put a tremendous amount of effort into trying to secure it? How much has this matter really got to do with Railtrack holding the Government to ransom over the £1.5 billion that will be allocated over the next few years to bail Railtrack out of the problems arising from the Hatfield derailment? Is not that the real reason for the costs escalating?

Sarah Boyack Lab The Minister for Transport and Planning · Edinburgh Central
link
Just as I was not prepared to speculate to Labour back benchers, I am certainly not prepared to speculate to an SNP back bencher. I am just being consistent to all members in the chamber. We need to get the facts on this matter. It disturbs me greatly that there has been such a huge increase in costs and I am not prepared to lay blame without having the full facts in front of me and without being able to analyse the problems. We need to get more information. These issues have come to light very recently. Before members make speculations, we need to have the evidence in front of us.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 5 April 2001 Debate · 1
  2. Structural Funds Debate · 120
  3. Foot-and-mouth Disease Statement · 42
  4. Business Motion Business motions · 22
  5. SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE Questions · 1
  6. Health Spending Questions · 8
  7. Workplace Standards Questions · 8
  8. Urban Regeneration (Dundee) Questions · 9
  9. Fireworks Questions · 6
  10. Homelessness Questions · 10
  11. Further Education Questions · 8
  12. Community Care Questions · 6
  13. Social Workers Questions · 6
  14. Ferry Services Questions · 4
  15. Health Boards (Capital Projects) Questions · 12
  16. Tenant Participation Questions · 9
  17. Post Offices Questions · 9
  18. Railways Questions · 8
  19. Tourism Questions · 4
  20. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
  21. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
  22. National Health Service First Minister’s Questions · 8
  23. European Police Force First Minister’s Questions · 4
  24. Examination Diet 2001 Statement · 41
  25. Tourism Debate · 39
  26. Decision Time Decision time · 13
  27. Railways (Airdrie to Bathgate Line) Members’ business · 21

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.