Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Opencast Mining

Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE

Thursday 8 March 2001 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 9 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

9 contributions
Mary Mulligan Lab Linlithgow
link
To ask the Scottish Executive what plans it has for the future of opencast mining. (S1O-3071)

Allan Wilson Lab The Deputy Minister for Sport, the Arts and Culture · Cunninghame North
link
The Executive will continue to ensure that the policies in national planning policy guideline 16, "Opencast Coal and Related Minerals" are rigorously applied.

Mary Mulligan Lab Linlithgow
link
If the Executive is committed to the principles of NPPG 16, why did the development department issue a paper, on 26 January, that set out amendments to the Lothian joint structure plan and identified six further sites for opencast mining in my constituency alone?

Does that not fly in the face of NPPG 16, which asks for consultation with local communities and councils? Does it not muddy the waters at a time when local people are positively considering an opencast site at Polkemmet and facing a public inquiry over a Wester Torrance site? This puts local people—

Allan Wilson Lab The Deputy Minister for Sport, the Arts and Culture · Cunninghame North
link
Members will appreciate that while those matters are subject to appeal, it would be inappropriate for me to comment on the specifics of the modifications that have been referred to.

I assure the member and the chamber that, in general terms, the fact that broad areas of search are indicated in a structure plan does not mean that there is a predisposition to development. NPPG 16 meets a Labour party 1997 manifesto commitment of establishing a far tougher framework against which proposals would be considered. The guidance is clear that permission should generally not be granted if a proposal would cause demonstrable and material harm to either communities or the environment.

Gil Paterson SNP Central Scotland
link
Lanarkshire, Ayrshire and many communities in Scotland have been devastated by over-provision of opencast mining—the old term for it was strip mining. Is it not time that the Parliament implemented a moratorium on opencast mining?

Allan Wilson Lab The Deputy Minister for Sport, the Arts and Culture · Cunninghame North
link
It is not for this Parliament to judge the need for additional coal. That is a commercial judgment for operators. The role of the planning system is not to set limits on production levels, but to ensure that proposals are environmentally acceptable. As I said, the role of NPPG 16 is to ensure that communities and the environment are protected in that process.

John Home Robertson Lab East Lothian
link
Will the minister encourage Sam Galbraith to apply some of his well-known charm to people in his department who want the Lothian structure plan to designate a large part of East Lothian as an area of search for opencast mining? We have already had a lot of opencasting in East Lothian and the question of further sites has been flogged to death at public inquiries. Will the minister refrain from giving any encouragement to opencast operators to indulge in plans in that part of Scotland? They are not wanted in East Lothian and will not receive consent for that kind of opencasting.

Allan Wilson Lab The Deputy Minister for Sport, the Arts and Culture · Cunninghame North
link
Again, that issue is subject to the planning process and could come to ministers for a decision. As a result, it would be prejudicial to the process for me to comment on the specifics of East Lothian.

However, the whole point of NPPGs—as John Home Robertson should know, being a member of the Labour party that instituted them—is to ensure that communities' environmental concerns are respected and that no predisposition to development results from instituting searches.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 8 March 2001 Debate · 1
  2. Fishing Industry Debate · 171
  3. Crisis in Rural Scotland Debate · 77
  4. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 10
  5. Business Motion Business motions · 40
  6. Planning Appeals Questions · 4
  7. Opencast Mining Questions · 9
  8. Statistical Information Questions · 6
  9. Landfill Questions · 10
  10. Young Disabled People (Personal Care) Questions · 4
  11. Internet (Dangers to Children) Questions · 4
  12. Domestic Abuse Questions · 6
  13. Public Sector Jobs Questions · 12
  14. Hospital Services Questions · 9
  15. Fire Safety Questions · 6
  16. Waiting Times (Tayside) Questions · 7
  17. Scotland Against Drugs Questions · 6
  18. Land Reform (Scotland) Bill Questions · 8
  19. Scottish Secure Tenancy Questions · 4
  20. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  21. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  22. Fishing Industry First Minister’s Questions · 4
  23. Biodiversity First Minister’s Questions · 4
  24. Power Supplies First Minister’s Questions · 10
  25. International Development Bill Bill debate · 12
  26. Leasehold Casualties (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 12
  27. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 13
  28. Culture and Recreation Bill Bill debate · 3
  29. Decision Time Decision time · 62
  30. Points of Order Procedure · 6
  31. Less Favoured Areas Members’ business · 22
  32. Points of Order Procedure · 5

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.