To ask the Scottish Executive what plans it has in place for the maintenance of trunk roads from April 2001. (S1O-2876)
Official Report · Chamber
Trunk Roads (Maintenance)
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Sarah Boyack Lab 5
- John Home Robertson Lab 2
- Sir David Steel 2
- Bruce Crawford SNP 1
- Murray Tosh Con 1
- Mr John Munro Ross, Skye and Inverness West) (LD 1
- Mr Munro 1
The record
13 contributionsI announced the successful bidders to the tendering process last week and I made it clear in the debate in the chamber last Thursday that, before awarding the contracts for the work, Scottish ministers would consider the audit report that I commissioned last week in response to the widespread concerns that had been raised. I expect to receive the audit report shortly.
I am sure that we all want to achieve the best possible value for taxpayers' money, but does Sarah Boyack accept that there are extremely serious doubts as to whether her officials have made fair comparisons in their assessment of those tenders? [Applause.] Does she accept that the review that she has rightly initiated must take account of all relevant factors, including the experience of rural areas such as East Lothian and the issue of responsibility for local roads? Will the Executive accept the unanimous view of the Parliament, which was made abundantly clear last Thursday? I remind the minister that she is not under any legal obligation to accept any of the tenders that have been tabled. [Applause.]
I reiterate once again how disappointed I am, particularly as a Labour minister, that there was such a huge gap between the winning and losing bids. I am fully aware of the implications of that for local authorities and I note that there are many local authority representatives in the public gallery this afternoon, who have been meeting members. As Minister for Transport, I have the responsibility to ensure that all the tenderers are treated fairly and properly. We have audited the majority of the process that we have been through thus far and, before we move forward to contracts, we will look at the last part of the audit, which I spoke about in the chamber last week.
The process has been thoroughly scrutinised, and I expect further scrutiny in the weeks ahead. We are where we are and the existing contracts expire on 31 March. Extension is not an option and we now have to take the process forward within the law. [Interruption.]
The process has been thoroughly scrutinised, and I expect further scrutiny in the weeks ahead. We are where we are and the existing contracts expire on 31 March. Extension is not an option and we now have to take the process forward within the law. [Interruption.]
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
Order. Before I call any more members to ask questions, I remind people in the public gallery that, although they are welcome to be here, they may not express approval or disapproval. I call Bruce Crawford.
I thank councillors and council leaders from all over Scotland for being here today to lobby the Parliament. Last week, during the SNP-initiated debate, Sarah Boyack said that it would be a breach of European Union rules for the tendering process to be suspended. Will she tell us why her view is superior to that of local authority solicitors, who are absolutely clear in their opinion that there is no such requirement? Does not the minister agree that her legal reasons are just an excuse for the lack of political will to ensure that justice and fairness are brought to the flawed tendering process? Even at this late hour, will not she see sense and stop the signing of the contracts pending the outcome of the Transport and the Environment Committee inquiry? This is this lady's chance to show that she is for turning.
As a minister, I have to receive and consider the legal advice that I get and I then have to act within it, as do all Scottish ministers.
After audit, if the contracts are placed with the contractors who have, provisionally, been successful, does the Executive intend to share the savings that it believes can be made with local authorities through a resource transfer? That would allow those authorities to be compensated for any consequent redundancy payments, for the costs of redundant or superfluous vehicles, equipment and plant, and for the additional operating costs of providing maintenance, particularly winter maintenance, on those stretches of road that hitherto have been maintained on an integrated basis. It would also ensure that local authorities can continue to provide services economically in the future.
I point out to Murray Tosh that this year's local government settlement included an additional £70 million for local authority roads and maintenance, in particular for roads and bridges. Local authority direct labour organisations will also be able to tender for work worth £150,000 or more. On his substantive point, any money that we are able to release through the process will be invested in vital services across Scotland.
Mr John Munro
Ross, Skye and Inverness West) (LD
link
I am sure that the minister is well aware of the anxiety that has been expressed throughout Scotland by people who fear losing their jobs because of the recent decision. My area of the Highlands is geographically equivalent to Wales. If she were to suggest that a private contractor could look after every piece of road in Wales, people would tell her that her suggestion was absurd. The suggestion that has been made about the roads in Scotland is equally absurd.
I would like to pose a question—
I would like to pose a question—
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
I would like you to pose one, too.
Mr Munro
link
I understand that the cost of the Caledonian Roads north-west bid for the five-year period has been reduced by some £7 million to approximately £90 million. Is the minister prepared to reveal the true cost of the preferred bidder and will it provide best value for the Highland public?
I am keen that we should be able to give as much information to members as possible. When the process comes to a conclusion, that is exactly what I intend to do. We are looking to see how much information can be revealed about each bidder, within the commercial confidence procedures that we operate, so that the maximum amount of information is available to members.
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Feb 2001 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 1 February 2001 Debate · 1
- “Working together for Scotland: A Programme for Government” Debate · 169
- Business Motion Business motions · 56
- Lockerbie Debate · 24
- Children's Diet (Fruit) Questions · 9
- Schools (Violence) Questions · 6
- East of Scotland Water Questions · 8
- Drug Misuse Questions · 8
- Sustainable Development (Ministerial Meetings) Questions · 4
- Waste Water Treatment Questions · 4
- Railways Questions · 6
- Scottish Prison Service (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Abercorn Primary School Questions · 7
- Chhokar Inquiries Questions · 4
- Trunk Roads (Maintenance) Questions · 13
- Class Sizes (Primary Schools) Questions · 6
- People's Juries Questions · 6
- Rough Sleepers Initiative Questions · 4
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Domestic Violence First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Less Favoured Areas First Minister’s Questions · 18
- Strategy for Enterprise Debate · 79
- Decision Time Decision time · 37
- Acute Services Review (Tayside) Members’ business · 53
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.