To ask the Scottish Executive what representations it has received concerning the reorganisation of the health service in Glasgow. (S1O-2760)
Official Report · Chamber
NHS (Glasgow)
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Susan Deacon Lab 4
- Sandra White SNP 2
- Bill Aitken Con 1
- Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP 1
The record
8 contributionsThe Executive has received approximately 690 letters about the review of acute services in Glasgow. We have of course copied the letters to Greater Glasgow Health Board as part of the response to the board's public consultation on the review.
The minister says that she has copied the letters to Greater Glasgow Health Board, but I wonder whether she has replied to each letter individually and how long that took her. If the minister has received 690 responses, she will realise that people in the north and west of the city are very concerned about the closure of the Western infirmary, which would leave that end of the city without an accident and emergency department. What are the minister's concerns on the high cost of private finance initiatives, which many believe will lead to the further decline of the national health service, not only in Glasgow, but throughout Scotland?
As I said in response to earlier questions on the subject, points of detail about local service reviews are important, but they should be considered through the proper process at a local level. The big picture—which is what the Executive is interested in—shows that record investment is going into the NHS, which will lever in the kind of change that must take place to ensure that the people of Glasgow have the services that they need and deserve. Our health plan for Scotland set out the extent of our ambition and vision for the health service in Scotland. I wish that the SNP would start demonstrating a wee bit of ambition and vision for our country, as we have done.
Is the minister aware of the considerable concerns of Glasgow citizens, particularly those in the west and south sides of the city, who see the health board's consultation process as a complete sham? What process will she put in place in order to allay those concerns?
I do not think that the consultation that has been carried out in the Glasgow area can, by any measure, be described as a sham. I believe that there is always room for improvement in consultation processes. Since devolution, a great deal of attention has been paid to ensuring that the methods used by public bodies—national and local—to take on board the public's views are more imaginative than they have been previously.
I have been watching developments in Glasgow carefully. I expect local concerns to be taken on board. However, I also hope that local members will engage fully in the local discussions that need to take place in order to move forward, modernise and change facilities and provide people with modern health services. Sadly, too many of those services do not meet current or future needs.
I have been watching developments in Glasgow carefully. I expect local concerns to be taken on board. However, I also hope that local members will engage fully in the local discussions that need to take place in order to move forward, modernise and change facilities and provide people with modern health services. Sadly, too many of those services do not meet current or future needs.
I can assure the minister that the consultation process is a fake and that the people of Glasgow are extremely angry. The health board has merely presented its plans for what it will do to the public—and the public do not like it. I draw the minister's attention to the desire of the people of Glasgow to retain local hospitals. They do not want the creation of a monstrously large hospital at the Southern general. They most certainly desire the retention of the Royal hospital for sick children and the Queen Mother's maternity hospital on their site at Yorkhill.
With the greatest respect, none of us as individual politicians can say so simply that we know for sure the public's views. It is for the health board to ensure that it reaches out, gets as good a picture of the public's views as possible and takes them on board in relation to service changes. Striking the right balance between local provision and specialist facilities is one of the key issues that the NHS across Scotland, and particularly in Glasgow, must address. It is important that people have access to the quality of services that they need and deserve. Sometimes that requires greater specialisation.
The investment that we are putting in can, with modern medicine and modern technology, also provide many other services outside the hospital environment and in communities. That balance is what we are seeking to achieve for the NHS in Scotland. That is the vision that we have set out, and that is what is being developed in the NHS locally. It is a pity when local politicians focus on the points of disagreement rather than on the positive changes that are taking place for the future.
The investment that we are putting in can, with modern medicine and modern technology, also provide many other services outside the hospital environment and in communities. That balance is what we are seeking to achieve for the NHS in Scotland. That is the vision that we have set out, and that is what is being developed in the NHS locally. It is a pity when local politicians focus on the points of disagreement rather than on the positive changes that are taking place for the future.
In this meeting
Everything on 11 Jan 2001 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 11 January 2001 Debate · 1
- Salmon Conservation (Scotland) Bill: Timetable Bill debate · 8
- Careers Service Review Statement · 29
- Salmon Conservation (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 158
- Salmon Conservation (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 50
- Business Motion Business motions · 15
- Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration Questions · 4
- Housing (Scotland) Bill Questions · 8
- Residential Nursing Care Questions · 9
- Number Plates Questions · 10
- Crown Estate Questions · 4
- Edinburgh Royal Infirmary Questions · 6
- Contaminated Land Questions · 6
- Acute Services Review (Glasgow) Questions · 7
- Policing (North Lanarkshire) Questions · 8
- Central Heating Initiative (Aberdeen) Questions · 16
- Primary School Teachers Questions · 6
- Tourism (Highlands) Questions · 10
- NHS (Glasgow) Questions · 8
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Farmed Salmon First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Transport (Travel Information) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Points of Order Procedure · 11
- Stalking and Harassment Debate · 24
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 28
- Autistic Spectrum Disorder Members’ business · 40
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.