The final item is the work programme. In large measure, the programme results from discussions that the committee had at its away day, when we tried to anticipate and fit together matters such as subordinate legislation and the requirements of the Executive. The work programme document has been produced by the clerks in the light of those discussions. Perhaps Martin Verity will update us on one point. In paragraph 5, the document refers to the civic participation event that the committee is keen to organise, particularly in the light of the sensitive draft Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Robert Brown only · show everyone- Robert Brown LD 12
- Martin Verity 4
- Fiona Hyslop SNP 3
- Elaine Murray Lab 2
- Ken Macintosh Lab 2
- Rosemary Byrne SSP 1
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 1
Robert Brown’s contributions
12 contributionsWe are trying to resolve technical difficulties, but the committee is keen to organise the event in reasonable time so that we can make use of it in the context of considering the bill.Is there any disagreement with the content of the paper? Have you any thoughts about it, Rosemary? I am conscious that you were not at the away day.
It is a big issue upon which the committee touched in its discussions at the away day. We were of the view that, at a suitable point, we would want to consider how successful McCrone is and whether there are any problems to address. We do not know whether this is the right time to do that. You mentioned the link to the bill. I would appreciate other thoughts about that. We have problems with doing anything lengthy at this point.
My only slight concern about that is whether a brief report—or even a lengthy report—would be suitable for the subject. Elements of assessment, where we are going and what problems are emerging would be involved. I wonder whether we could get all that together readily at this point.
It might be sensible to ask the Executive at official level what it is doing to monitor and assess McCrone and to respond to that at a future meeting, with a view to examining the matter later in more detail.
That is right; the committee took the view that we should take a dual-track approach to all of that. Perhaps the report of the meeting could take that on board.When I was looking at the timetable, one thing that struck me was that although the bill is not coming out until the end of October or thereabouts, we are a little bit thin on the number of detailed meetings we can have about it between now and then. There are things that we have to do over the forthcoming weeks and there must be committee meetings to accommodate them. For various reasons to do with budget timetables we cannot readily squash all those meetings into one. However, there might be scope for one of the September meetings to include an evidence-hearing session of some other kind.I am quite anxious to give a bit of attention to the young people agenda. I wonder whether members might be interested in doing a panel session to get thoughts and contributions from uniformed organisations and the informal youth sector about their approach, their problems, their contribution and how they relate to mainstream education. It would not be intended as an inquiry, but would be intended to give the committee a bit of information on, and flavour of, those aspects. I am quite keen on that idea. There might be other suggestions but we could probably slot in an hour and a half or a couple of hours on a session of that sort. That would not commit us to a longer-term inquiry at this point.
School discipline is referred to in paragraph 11 of the work programme paper and we are writing to the minister on that. I suspect that it might not fit into the time we have available before the autumn recess. We have a limited number of meetings before the break. I am not sure how quickly the Executive will be able to reply to that letter, but I assume it will take two or three weeks. I am not sure that it would fit into the timetable but I am not averse to the idea.Do we have reasonable agreement on the immediate format of the timetable? I should add that we are trying to fix up some visits. What date did we decide?
That will be at the time that the committee would normally meet.
That is the point that I was just about to make. I thought that we were going to visit several schools.
As it happens, I am not available on that day, so there will be six of you. That might give a reasonable division of three members visiting each of the two schools. That is the kind of format we have in mind. Again, I am relying on my experience on the Social Justice Committee, but that format worked very well for that committee and allowed us to go on a wider range of visits.
I had the wrong numbers.Are there any other points on the work programme? Do the clerks need any other formal decisions?
Yes, with the addition of our suggestions.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Sep 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Education Committee Wednesday 3 September 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 2
- Draft Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 87
- Petition Petitions · 11
- School Transport Guidelines Committee business · 12
- Work Programme Procedure · 26
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.