To ask the Scottish Executive what the changes in manufacturing output and Scottish gross domestic product were in the most recent quarter for which official figures are available. (S1O-2218)
Official Report · Chamber
Manufacturing
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Henry McLeish Lab 7
- Sir David Steel 4
- Tricia Marwick SNP 3
- Andrew Wilson SNP 2
- John Swinney SNP 1
- Dorothy-Grace Elder SNP 1
The record
19 contributionsIn the first quarter of 2000, Scottish manufacturing output fell by 1.7 per cent compared with the previous quarter. Over the same period, Scottish GDP fell by 0.2 per cent.
Does the minister remember that, in February 2000, he told the Parliament:
"output in the Scottish economy continues to expand"?—[Official Report, 12 February 2000; Vol 4, c 917.]
The minister made that remark when the figures that he had just announced showed that the Scottish economy had entered an official recession for the first time since the early years of Mrs Thatcher's time in office.
Why was that recession notified only through a leak to The Times during the summer? When will Labour ministers begin to admit that there is a problem, recognise their responsibility and act on it, rather than hide behind fiddle and spin?
"output in the Scottish economy continues to expand"?—[Official Report, 12 February 2000; Vol 4, c 917.]
The minister made that remark when the figures that he had just announced showed that the Scottish economy had entered an official recession for the first time since the early years of Mrs Thatcher's time in office.
Why was that recession notified only through a leak to The Times during the summer? When will Labour ministers begin to admit that there is a problem, recognise their responsibility and act on it, rather than hide behind fiddle and spin?
That was really pathetic, even by the SNP's usual standards of intervention in economic debates. The SNP is a party that has no economic strategy and that will talk down Scotland on every occasion. [Members: "Answer the question."]
Scotland is rejoicing in the fact that, under a United Kingdom Labour Government and a Labour-Liberal Democrat partnership in Scotland, unemployment is at its lowest point for 24 years, employment is at its highest point for 34 years, youth unemployment is at its lowest point ever, long-term unemployment is at its lowest point ever, GDP is up by 2.2 per cent over the year to quarter 1 of 2000 and, in manufacturing, output is up as well. [Members: "Speech."] We have low interest rates, low inflation rates and stable public finances. The SNP is able to talk only about something that is theological in the calculation of the index for GDP.
I will conclude by explaining that theology in simple terms. [Members: "Answer the question."] If members would be quiet for a minute, they might understand my point.
Scotland is rejoicing in the fact that, under a United Kingdom Labour Government and a Labour-Liberal Democrat partnership in Scotland, unemployment is at its lowest point for 24 years, employment is at its highest point for 34 years, youth unemployment is at its lowest point ever, long-term unemployment is at its lowest point ever, GDP is up by 2.2 per cent over the year to quarter 1 of 2000 and, in manufacturing, output is up as well. [Members: "Speech."] We have low interest rates, low inflation rates and stable public finances. The SNP is able to talk only about something that is theological in the calculation of the index for GDP.
I will conclude by explaining that theology in simple terms. [Members: "Answer the question."] If members would be quiet for a minute, they might understand my point.
On a point of order.
The GDP index was published on 2 August and showed that quarter 4 of 1999 remained unchanged and that there was a slight reduction in quarter 1 of 2000.
On a point of order.
When the figures between the two quarters are calculated—
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
There is a point of order.
Because those figures are unrounded, one ends up with 0.1 and 0.2.
Quite simply—
Quite simply—
Members
link
There is a point of order.
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
Order. There is a point of order.
The SNP has no policy other than to seek mischief while Scotland enjoys substantial economic success. [Interruption.]
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
Order. A point of order may take time away from the supplementary question that I was going to call.
I hope that my point of order does not take time away from a supplementary question, Presiding Officer, as the minister has singularly failed to answer the original question. On a point of order—
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
No. I am sorry, but the content of answers is not a matter on which points of order can be raised.
link
Perhaps, in his long ramble, the minister might have liked to admit the fact that GDP output in Scotland declined for two quarters in a row—the classic definition of a recession. Why cannot the minister answer a straight question with a straight answer?
I understand that the Scottish Executive cannot produce statistics to cope with SNP holidays. This matter was debated in Scotland on 2 August. Four weeks later, the possible leader of the SNP enters the fray, and two weeks later, Mr Wilson enters it.
At the risk of boring MSPs who are concerned about real-world issues, I repeat that the published GDP index showed no change in quarter 4 of 1999 and a slight fall in quarter 1 of 2000.
The way in which the figures are calculated—not rounding them up to decimal points—shows the different figures. Both pieces of information are in the public arena—there was no attempt to hide them. The SNP wishes to make a song and dance about this technical issue only because that party is bereft of an economic policy that is in the interests of Scotland.
At the risk of boring MSPs who are concerned about real-world issues, I repeat that the published GDP index showed no change in quarter 4 of 1999 and a slight fall in quarter 1 of 2000.
The way in which the figures are calculated—not rounding them up to decimal points—shows the different figures. Both pieces of information are in the public arena—there was no attempt to hide them. The SNP wishes to make a song and dance about this technical issue only because that party is bereft of an economic policy that is in the interests of Scotland.
On a point of order. The minister makes speeches to cover up the fact that he has no answers.
In this meeting
Everything on 14 Sep 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 14 September 2000 Debate · 1
- Family Law Statement · 30
- Transport (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 105
- Transport (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 7
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 7
- Decision Time Decision time · 36
- Prostate Cancer Members’ business · 23
- Fuel Situation Statement · 42
- School Buildings (Funding) Questions · 8
- Health Services (Tayside) Questions · 8
- Unison (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Dental Services Questions · 6
- South of Scotland University Questions · 4
- Landfill Questions · 6
- Local Government Questions · 8
- Digital Hearing Aids Questions · 6
- St Abbs Harbour Questions · 4
- Social Inclusion Partnerships Questions · 4
- Aggregates Tax Questions · 6
- Manufacturing Questions · 19
- COSLA (Meeting) Questions · 8
- Housing Bill Questions · 5
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Pensioner Poverty First Minister’s Questions · 10
- National Health Service (Funding) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Scottish Executive's Programme Statement · 153
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.