To ask the First Minister whether he has any plans to reshuffle his Cabinet. (S1F-500)
Official Report · Chamber
Scottish Cabinet
First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David McLetchie Con 3
- Donald Dewar Lab 3
- Frank McAveety Lab 1
The record
7 contributionsNo.
You're no getting in, David.
I can assure Mr McAveety that it would be a substantial improvement if I did.
Many candidates come to mind for a change of a position and Mr Galbraith is obviously among them, given the evidence of the past day or two.
I wish to pick up on a couple of the points that were raised initially by Mr Salmond, in particular the business about dissembling or misleading Parliament. Yesterday, Mr Galbraith was asked by Mrs Smith about his powers in relation to the Scottish Qualifications Authority. In answering, he omitted to mention that he has wide-ranging powers of direction, which are of a
"general or specific character with regard to the discharge"
of the functions of the SQA.
I put it to the First Minister that such convenient paraphrasing was misleading to Parliament and that that should be corrected by the Minister for Children and Education. The minister should stop hiding behind semantic distinctions between an instruction on the one hand and a wide-ranging power of direction on the other.
Many candidates come to mind for a change of a position and Mr Galbraith is obviously among them, given the evidence of the past day or two.
I wish to pick up on a couple of the points that were raised initially by Mr Salmond, in particular the business about dissembling or misleading Parliament. Yesterday, Mr Galbraith was asked by Mrs Smith about his powers in relation to the Scottish Qualifications Authority. In answering, he omitted to mention that he has wide-ranging powers of direction, which are of a
"general or specific character with regard to the discharge"
of the functions of the SQA.
I put it to the First Minister that such convenient paraphrasing was misleading to Parliament and that that should be corrected by the Minister for Children and Education. The minister should stop hiding behind semantic distinctions between an instruction on the one hand and a wide-ranging power of direction on the other.
That is not the information and advice that I have been given. I put it in those terms because I do not pretend to be a constitutional lawyer.
I repeat to Mr McLetchie the point that I made to him earlier: that there is clearly a power to lay down in statute the aims, objectives and remit of the SQA. The point of the authority is that it is an arm's-length organisation. That is the point of a non-departmental public body, as distinct from a public body that has some sort of remit that lies within the Executive itself, or a next-steps agency. There is a gradation and the authority is, as a non-departmental public body, at the far edge of it.
I know that it is convenient to argue—I understand this—that we could just ignore the statutory basis of the organisation and that we could ignore the rules. However, if we had done so, we would have been in considerable difficulties, and I hope that Mr McLetchie will consider that carefully. It is an interesting area that will have to be considered by Mr McLeish and Mr Galbraith—no doubt many other people will want to help them—when they examine the review of the relationships between the Executive and that non-departmental public body.
It is a serious issue, because there have always been seen to be real advantages in independence of action and impartiality and in removing relevant matters from direct political control. I do not think that Mr McLetchie in particular—if I may say so, given the political traditions from which he comes—should simply ignore that and sweep the matter to one side.
I repeat to Mr McLetchie the point that I made to him earlier: that there is clearly a power to lay down in statute the aims, objectives and remit of the SQA. The point of the authority is that it is an arm's-length organisation. That is the point of a non-departmental public body, as distinct from a public body that has some sort of remit that lies within the Executive itself, or a next-steps agency. There is a gradation and the authority is, as a non-departmental public body, at the far edge of it.
I know that it is convenient to argue—I understand this—that we could just ignore the statutory basis of the organisation and that we could ignore the rules. However, if we had done so, we would have been in considerable difficulties, and I hope that Mr McLetchie will consider that carefully. It is an interesting area that will have to be considered by Mr McLeish and Mr Galbraith—no doubt many other people will want to help them—when they examine the review of the relationships between the Executive and that non-departmental public body.
It is a serious issue, because there have always been seen to be real advantages in independence of action and impartiality and in removing relevant matters from direct political control. I do not think that Mr McLetchie in particular—if I may say so, given the political traditions from which he comes—should simply ignore that and sweep the matter to one side.
It is not a question of ignoring the matter; it is a question of interpretation of the powers that are available to ministers. I think that the First Minister will acknowledge that I would never endorse breaking of the law by any representative of the Scottish Executive in his or her ministerial capacity.
Will the First Minister confirm for the record that no action could have been taken by the Scottish ministers in exercising their powers under section 9 of the Education (Scotland) Act 1996 which would have corrected the situation that existed until 13 August? Will he confirm that there is no action that could have been taken by Scottish ministers in exercising their statutory powers that Mr Galbraith omitted to take?
Will the First Minister confirm for the record that no action could have been taken by the Scottish ministers in exercising their powers under section 9 of the Education (Scotland) Act 1996 which would have corrected the situation that existed until 13 August? Will he confirm that there is no action that could have been taken by Scottish ministers in exercising their statutory powers that Mr Galbraith omitted to take?
If Mr McLetchie follows closely—as I am sure he will—the investigations of the committee of inquiry, he will discover that a great deal of action was taken in terms of the advice that was offered, continuous contact and the efforts that were made to unscramble an increasingly difficult situation. It would be sensible to wait until the story has been told—until it has unfolded and has been investigated with, I hope, the kind of impartiality that the chamber expects.
I hope also that Mr McLetchie will take pleasure—as I do—in the figures that Sam Galbraith announced yesterday, which show that 23,694 Scottish students have definitely been allocated university places. That is 2.6 per cent more than had been accepted at the same stage in the process last year, and the figure is well above the much smaller increase in the number of English acceptances.
I hope also that Mr McLetchie will take pleasure—as I do—in the figures that Sam Galbraith announced yesterday, which show that 23,694 Scottish students have definitely been allocated university places. That is 2.6 per cent more than had been accepted at the same stage in the process last year, and the figure is well above the much smaller increase in the number of English acceptances.
In this meeting
Everything on 7 Sep 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 7 September 2000 Debate · 1
- Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Scotland) Bill: Timetable Bill debate · 4
- Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 222
- Ferry Services Questions · 8
- Creative Industries Questions · 4
- Dental Services Questions · 9
- National Health Service Questions · 8
- Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 Questions · 4
- Sutherland Report Questions · 8
- Genetically Modified Organisms Questions · 10
- Liquid Petroleum Gas (Conversion Grants) Questions · 7
- Water (Fluoridation) Questions · 8
- National Health Service Questions · 6
- Roads (A96) Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Scottish Cabinet First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Drugs First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Less Favoured Areas Scheme First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Local Government (Pay) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Regulation of Investigatory Powers (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 20
- Decision Time Decision time · 3
- Scots and Gaelic Members’ business · 46
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.