To ask the acting First Minister whether the Scottish budget will fall as a share of the UK budget in the next four years. (S1F-469)
Official Report · Chamber
Budget
First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jim Wallace LD 6
- Andrew Wilson SNP 4
- Michael Russell SNP 2
- Sir David Steel 2
- Cathie Craigie Lab 1
- David Davidson Con 1
The record
16 contributionsThe total Scottish Executive budget for the next three years will be known after the chancellor has announced the conclusion of the 2000 spending review. Per head of population, Scotland will benefit pound for pound the same as the rest of the UK.
I think that it would be of interest to acknowledge that, like Alex Salmond's question, that question was not answered. I point out that the answer that the acting First Minister gave to Alex Salmond's question contradicted what the Minister for Finance said yesterday. Is the acting First Minister aware that, according to page 92 of the Treasury red book, health spending in the UK will rise next year by 7.4 per cent, whereas, according to Susan Deacon, health spending in Scotland will rise this year by 4.3 per cent? That to me is a fall, relative to the UK figure. Does he agree with me on that and will he confirm it?
Andrew Wilson is suffering the same confusion as Alex Salmond. The 4.3 per cent—
It is in the written answer.
I have a copy of that written answer here.
Is it right?
The 4.3 per cent real-terms increase to which Mr Wilson refers is the planned expenditure for this year over the expected outturn expenditure for last year; 7.3 per cent is the planned increase this year as against last year's planned health service spending. Mr Wilson is not being wise if he is trying to fudge that. He ought to accept that, pound for pound, health spending in Scotland will increase by the same amount as it will south of the border and that we in Scotland already start with higher spending on health per head of population than is the case south of the border.
Does the acting First Minister agree that not only does Scotland receive, as he put it, a pound-for-pound share of total UK spending through the Barnett formula, which the SNP would jeopardise, but that this year Scotland has received much more money through the budget than we would have received through the nationalists' rejected penny for Scotland tax?
As I indicated last week, the Barnett formula, on which we—including the SNP—agreed and campaigned in the referendum, brings stability to the funding of the Scottish Parliament. I also confirmed last week that the expenditure that has come through as consequentials is more than would have been produced by the penny on income tax, which Mr McLetchie now seems to be advocating.
Will the acting First Minister confirm the Executive's continuing support for the Barnett formula and that the important issue is the maintenance of the current per capita spending in Scotland, regardless of spending in the rest of the United Kingdom?
As I have indicated, the Barnett formula allows us to plan each year, because it automatically allocates the amount of money that the Scottish Parliament and Scottish Executive receive. It would be a recipe for disaster, especially in these early days of the Parliament, if we had to have an annual haggle with Westminster. We want the Parliament to work; we want a stable Scottish Parliament within a stable United Kingdom. That formula, which we all supported in the referendum—with the exception of Mr Davidson's party—is one that provides that.
On a point of order, Presiding Officer. Rule 15.3 of the standing orders allows the Parliament to regulate who enters the chamber. A subordinate regulation limits the number of advisers who may enter the chamber. I know that it is clear from this afternoon's performance that the acting First Minister needs all the help that he can get, but the Executive has today breached that rule and exceeded the number of advisers. Will you please look into that?
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
I can assure Michael Russell that I gave permission for an increased number of advisers. If there is a request for an increased number from Opposition parties, I will also give permission for that.
Now that we know that such a facility exists, I am sure that we will not require it, but the Executive will need more and more advisers.
Sir David Steel
The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
I do not think that that is really a point of order.
In this meeting
Everything on 29 Jun 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 29 June 2000 Debate · 1
- Economic Development Statement · 16
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 6
- Education and Training (Scotland) Bill: Timetable Bill debate · 15
- Education and Training (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 121
- Education and Training (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 16
- Active Communities Initiative Statement · 26
- Business Motion Business motions · 9
- Fife Schools Questions · 7
- Fraserburgh Harbour Commissioners Questions · 6
- Crime Questions · 8
- National Lottery Funding Questions · 6
- Opencast Mining Questions · 8
- Civil Liberties Questions · 6
- Countryside Premium Questions · 6
- Gaelic Questions · 11
- Children's Health Questions · 16
- National Health Service Questions · 13
- Road Traffic Accidents Questions · 6
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Local Government First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Scottish Parliament (Anniversary) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Budget First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Agriculture Strategy Debate · 48
- Decision Time Decision time · 26
- Emergency Calls Members’ business · 15
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.