To ask the Scottish Executive what representations it has made to the UK Government or public bodies about the proposals by Babcock Ltd to store radioactive waste from HMS Renown at Rosyth. (S1O-1853)
Official Report · Chamber
Radioactive Waste
Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Sarah Boyack Lab 4
- Bruce Crawford SNP 2
- Scott Barrie Lab 1
- Nick Johnston Con 1
The record
8 contributionsI understand that Babcock Rosyth Defence Ltd has yet to bring forward detailed proposals regarding its pilot project to store on land the components of the reactor compartment from HMS Renown.
We have been involved by the Ministry of Defence in the preliminary consultation on this proposal and have stressed the need to involve the local community. We note that the proposal would not result in any increase in radioactive material stored at Rosyth. Independent regulators will be involved as the project progresses.
We have been involved by the Ministry of Defence in the preliminary consultation on this proposal and have stressed the need to involve the local community. We note that the proposal would not result in any increase in radioactive material stored at Rosyth. Independent regulators will be involved as the project progresses.
I hope that the minister will agree that it is hardly surprising that the people of Fife are a bit concerned about the continuing storage of intermediate nuclear waste at Rosyth, and that that concern reached new levels as a result of Babcock's proposals. Will the minister make it clear to those who will be responsible for carrying out the environmental assessment that it would be unacceptable for radioactive components to be removed from submarines until the UK finally has its own fully operational long-term storage site for intermediate waste? Will she also recognise that we cannot allow there to be the perception in Fife that Devonport got the jobs and Rosyth gets the waste?
It is important that we understand that this is a pilot project to deal with one submarine's nuclear waste. We are all aware that, in the long run, we as a society have to deal with that nuclear waste. It is important to get across the point that there will be strong local consultation. Any moves to discuss this further would require an environmental impact assessment, which would be consulted on at a local level. Representations have already been made to local councillors and to MSPs. It is important that people do not hype up this issue, that they treat it seriously and look at the details carefully and that none of us falls into the trap of exaggerating what is being proposed. It is important that we have the discussion in the open, and that we have it without going for headlines.
Does the minister agree that nuclear submarines that need to be dealt with are currently being stored at Rosyth? Does she also agree that the current proposal by Babcock will isolate the spent reactors and allow the remaining hulks to be scrapped, and that the Ministry of Defence is actively looking for alternative sites outwith the Rosyth base to store the radioactive waste?
I am happy to confirm that. It is important that we understand that this project is at the feasibility stage. However, I understand that existing float storage capacity is finite, so there is a need for us to look at this issue. I hope that the consultation will fully involve local members and the council, so that local communities can see exactly what is being proposed and, before a second stage of the project can be pursued, that there is a commitment that the independent regulators have to be completely satisfied that a case has been made for progressing safely.
Does the minister agree that a major reason why Rosyth has survived as a dockyard is the expertise that was attained from the maintenance of the nuclear submarine fleet? To what extent will that expertise be put to good use with respect to the storage of radioactive waste at Rosyth?
I appreciate that the issue of expertise is a critical one. In pursuing the discussions on this project, that expertise and confidence will be vital. In persuading the regulators and making the safety case to them, it is important that that expertise is used to the full.
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Jun 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 1 June 2000 Debate · 1
- Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
- Civic Participation Statement · 19
- Borders Rail Link Debate · 76
- Business Motion Business motions · 37
- Bell Baxter High School Members’ business · 18
- Local Authority Boundaries Questions · 10
- Education Questions · 6
- Genetically Modified Organisms Questions · 15
- National Health Service Questions · 4
- Highlands and Islands Transport Authority Questions · 8
- Housing (Glasgow) Questions · 7
- Depression Questions · 6
- Radioactive Waste Questions · 8
- Prisons Questions · 8
- Asylum Seekers (Health Care) Questions · 4
- Ministry of Defence (Housing) Questions · 6
- Schools (Security) Questions · 6
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Joint Ministerial Committees First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Volunteers Week First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Museums First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Local Government Finance First Minister’s Questions · 6
- New Community Schools First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Rough Sleeping Debate · 99
- Insolvency Bill Bill debate · 3
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 6
- Decision Time Decision time · 33
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.