Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Genetically Modified Organisms

Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE

Thursday 25 May 2000 Meeting of the Parliament Questions 11 contributions · 6 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

11 contributions
Kenny MacAskill SNP Lothians
link
To ask the Scottish Executive whether it has any plans to review the guidelines for genetically modified crop trial sites and in particular the exclusion distance between genetically modified and conventional crops. (S1O-1774)

Ross Finnie LD The Minister for Rural Affairs · West of Scotland
link
Separation distances are designed to minimise the extent of cross-pollination and are kept under continuous review to take account of the best available scientific evidence. If the information that the rural affairs department is seeking on the precise circumstances of the contamination that arose in Canada provides new evidence, that will be reflected in revised guidelines.

Kenny MacAskill SNP Lothians
link
Would the minister care to comment on where the power seems to lie with regard to the recent scandal involving Advanta? It would appear that the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food was told about the contamination on 17 April, but that information was not transmitted to the Minister for Rural Affairs until 15 May. When did the Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food find out from Advanta, when did he tell the Minister for Rural Affairs and when were the rest of the members of the Scottish Parliament advised?

Is it not the case that, in areas in which power is devolved, this Parliament should know contemporaneously with Westminster, and that it is not up to the Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food south of the border to decide when, on a whim of fancy, he will tell us?

Sir David Steel The Presiding Officer · Lothians
link
Order. Questions must not contain statements of opinion. They are meant to be questions to the minister.

Ross Finnie LD The Minister for Rural Affairs · West of Scotland
link
Advanta was aware of the contamination on 3 April. That information became known to the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food on 17 April. The Scottish Executive became aware of the problem on 15 May, as did other offices such as the Wales Office.

I want to make clear two points in relation to this matter. First, the fact that Advanta knew about the contamination on 3 April, before the Scottish sowing season had started, but did not release that information is a matter that we are examining with law officers. Secondly, I make no attempt to hide my deep anger and annoyance at the failure to transmit that information to us and to other agriculture departments. That is not acceptable.

My priority has been to try to establish the facts so that we can give advice on aspects of human health, the impact on the food chain, the risks to the environment and on the question of compensation to our farmers, who would have expected to receive recompense in relation to integrated administration and control systems claims and for the sale of the crop. We are trying to establish those facts as quickly as possible in order to give proper advice.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link
On a very practical point, if alternative advice is received on minimum separation distances and if farmers who fall within the new minimum separation distances for the crop trials being conducted in Scotland are affected, will the Executive be able to compensate them in any way?

Ross Finnie LD The Minister for Rural Affairs · West of Scotland
link
That question would arise if the issue of compensation actually arose. If the evidence in relation to the current incident shows that there is a need for new guidelines, we will introduce them. The implications for crop trials would be a separate matter. Since they are trials, the question of commercial return on them is difficult and I do not want to anticipate the issue of compensation. However, I want to make clear that if the evidence calls for new buffer zones, we will implement such zones.

Robin Harper Green Lothians
link
In view of the procrastination by Westminster that has been revealed by the minister, will he insist that immediate compensation to farmers to enable them to take up and destroy the planted Advanta seed in Scotland comes out of the Westminster budget, and as soon as possible?

Ross Finnie LD The Minister for Rural Affairs · West of Scotland
link
I have indicated my serious concerns about the way that MAFF has handled the matter, but it would be a mistake for us simply to exonerate Advanta. That seems to me an extraordinary proposition. It was Advanta that became aware of the problem on 3 April; it was Advanta that failed to notify those to whom it had distributed the seed; and it was Advanta that permitted farmers in Scotland to sow the crops without reviewing that information. I am not about to give that kind of advice to farmers until we are in possession of all the facts.

Nora Radcliffe LD Gordon
link
The crop trial on oil-seed rape in Scotland is in my constituency. Can the minister confirm whether, as part of that crop trial, pollination distances are being measured and that that will be a useful addition to the knowledge of that aspect of genetically modified crops?

Ross Finnie LD The Minister for Rural Affairs · West of Scotland
link
That takes me back to my earlier answer. I am very concerned that the current advice from the Advisory Committee on Releases to the Environment gives us certain assurances on seed purity and that, as a consequence of that, it sets the perimeters for the buffer zones. At first sight the information from Canada suggests that they will have to be reviewed. I repeat the undertaking that if that scientific advice shows that the buffer zones need to be reviewed, the Scottish Executive will act immediately.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 25 May 2000 Debate · 1
  2. Race Relations Debate · 41
  3. “Rural Scotland: A New Approach” Debate · 118
  4. Business Motion Business motions · 38
  5. Modernising Government Fund (Bids) Questions · 4
  6. Councils for Voluntary Service Questions · 7
  7. Education Questions · 8
  8. Roads (A76) Questions · 6
  9. Regional Selective Assistance Questions · 4
  10. Genetically Modified Organisms Questions · 11
  11. Social Inclusion Partnerships Questions · 6
  12. Modernising Government Questions · 11
  13. Draft Transport Bill Questions · 8
  14. Glencoe Visitor Centre Questions · 6
  15. Fishing (Fleet Reduction) Questions · 8
  16. Roads (A1 and A720) Questions · 4
  17. Health Department Questions · 4
  18. Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Questions · 6
  19. United Kingdom Parliament (Visits) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  20. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  21. Genetically Modified Organisms First Minister’s Questions · 6
  22. Age Discrimination (Guidance) First Minister’s Questions · 9
  23. Digital Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 4
  24. Caledonian MacBrayne Debate · 12
  25. Points of Order Procedure · 4
  26. Education and Training (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 51
  27. Education and Training (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 4
  28. Decision Time Decision time · 32
  29. Dyspraxia Members’ business · 16

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.