To ask the First Minister whether he has any plans to reshuffle his Cabinet. (S1F-292)
Official Report · Chamber
Cabinet Reshuffle
First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- David McLetchie Con 3
- Donald Dewar Lab 3
The record
6 contributionsNo.
A predictable, if regrettable, answer.
On the subject of ministerial portfolios, it is unfortunate that the First Minister appears to be unwilling to spare even one of his many ministers to take responsibility for the Holyrood project by participating in the progressing group. According to one newspaper, they are allegedly too busy. After all, compared with the situation three years ago, we now have four times as many ministers and a building that is costing five times the initial estimate. Will the First Minister finally get a grip on the project by ensuring that there is direct ministerial responsibility within the group for building the new Parliament on time and within the revised budget?
On the subject of ministerial portfolios, it is unfortunate that the First Minister appears to be unwilling to spare even one of his many ministers to take responsibility for the Holyrood project by participating in the progressing group. According to one newspaper, they are allegedly too busy. After all, compared with the situation three years ago, we now have four times as many ministers and a building that is costing five times the initial estimate. Will the First Minister finally get a grip on the project by ensuring that there is direct ministerial responsibility within the group for building the new Parliament on time and within the revised budget?
Although I do not want to trouble the chamber with a history lesson—or a constitutional lesson—I am genuinely astonished at Mr McLetchie's comments. He has constantly said that there should be a rebalancing of power and responsibility between the Executive and the legislature, and has always held himself up as being particularly proud of Parliament's rights. He must recognise that the building has by law been passed to Parliament and away from the Executive, and is now a matter for the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body and the progressing committee to which the SPCB wishes to delegate some activities. If I were to insist or suggest that the committee should include ministers from the Executive, we would be invading the space dedicated to the Parliament in a way for which various MSPs heavily criticised us when the suggestion was first made a few months ago.
I want the progressing committee to be set up. However, I am well aware that, despite great efforts by our representatives, it seems almost impossible to get agreement on the committee's composition. Instead of sniping and hopelessly confusing the roles of the Executive and the legislature, Mr McLetchie should concentrate on helping to get the committee up and running; by doing so, he would be doing more for the dignity of Parliament and the effective policing of the project than he has so far achieved.
I want the progressing committee to be set up. However, I am well aware that, despite great efforts by our representatives, it seems almost impossible to get agreement on the committee's composition. Instead of sniping and hopelessly confusing the roles of the Executive and the legislature, Mr McLetchie should concentrate on helping to get the committee up and running; by doing so, he would be doing more for the dignity of Parliament and the effective policing of the project than he has so far achieved.
If the First Minister had acknowledged that there was an interest in how £200 million of public money would be spent, the whole project might have been better handled from the outset.
It would be much easier to judge whether the First Minister's Cabinet was as busy as it is claimed if we knew what it was doing half the time. Will the First Minister follow the example of his Labour counterpart in Wales, the First Secretary Mr Rhodri Morgan, and publish the minutes of Cabinet meetings, or will he leave that to his acting deputy to introduce, when he is in what I hope will be very temporary charge of proceedings?
It would be much easier to judge whether the First Minister's Cabinet was as busy as it is claimed if we knew what it was doing half the time. Will the First Minister follow the example of his Labour counterpart in Wales, the First Secretary Mr Rhodri Morgan, and publish the minutes of Cabinet meetings, or will he leave that to his acting deputy to introduce, when he is in what I hope will be very temporary charge of proceedings?
What a very pleasant end to that question. The answer to the main point is that we have no such plans, but I confess that I, too, have been reading the questions that are advanced in the press. I notice that in referring to Jim Wallace, Mr McLetchie described him as a wee, pretending First Minister. It looks as if Mr McLetchie is determined to get back to the nursery and to march forward bravely to his second childhood.
In this meeting
Everything on 4 May 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 4 May 2000 Debate · 1
- Discipline in Schools Debate · 53
- Elderly and Disabled People Debate · 68
- Business Motion Business motions · 12
- National Health Service (Asylum Seekers) Questions · 9
- Special Needs Education (Sport) Questions · 6
- Lifelong Learning Questions · 6
- Local Government Finance Questions · 8
- Scottish Health Technology Assessment Centre Questions · 12
- Caesarean Births Questions · 13
- Multiple Sclerosis Questions · 4
- Childminders (Registration) Questions · 4
- Debt Recovery Law Questions · 10
- Glasgow Housing Association Questions · 4
- M77 Questions · 6
- Modern Apprenticeships Questions · 8
- Tweed Industry Questions · 6
- Scottish Executive Priorities First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet Reshuffle First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Scottish Parliamentary Elections (Anniversary) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Water Charges First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Flooding First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Sport Debate · 62
- Commonwealth Parliamentary Association Debate · 3
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 7
- Decision Time Decision time · 59
- Glenrinnes School Members’ business · 31
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.