Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Cabinet (Meetings)

First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE

Thursday 30 March 2000 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 8 contributions · 2 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

8 contributions
Alex Salmond SNP Banff and Buchan
link
To ask the First Minister what issues were discussed at the most recent meeting of the Scottish Executive's Cabinet. (S1F-239)

Donald Dewar Lab The First Minister · Glasgow Anniesland
link
Mr Salmond should not be surprised to learn that we discussed several matters of significance to the Executive and the people of Scotland. Lest he be disappointed, I should mention that his name cropped up once, in passing.

Alex Salmond SNP Banff and Buchan
link
Only the once?

What should have been discussed at that meeting is the increased cost of the Holyrood project. Will the First Minister explain paragraph 4.3.4 of John Spencely's report, which has been made available to members today? That paragraph highlights the fact that, on four separate occasions last year, up to £27 million of additional costs had been identified but were not reported to the Parliament. Will the First Minister tell us whether, at any stage, the project team that he appointed made him or any member of his Administration aware of those possible additional costs? Does he accept that, for whatever reason, when the Parliament decided last June to go ahead with Holyrood, the chamber was seriously misled about the true costs?

Donald Dewar Lab The First Minister · Glasgow Anniesland
link
No, I do not accept that Parliament was misled, and I give Mr Salmond a categorical assurance that I would not be party to misleading Parliament and have no intention of doing so.

The figures supplied to me were £62 million for construction costs and a total of £109 million. I reported that in good faith and believe it to be correct. That total included £6 million for construction contingency costs. The figure of £89 million is of course important, and I understand that it is built on the inclusion of a number of elements including £16 million for design risks. Those figures were not firm costs and as such were not supplied to me, or to the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body. I gave an honest estimate based on expert advice. My officials have advised me that they deliberately excluded those figures because they saw it as part of the task of the design and project teams to manage the risks out. In their view, it would have been contrary to good practice to add them in, as it would have effectively removed the pressure on the design team to prevent the costs from rising.

My officials further point out that the process of setting and working within the overall budget must be seen as a whole. Although some extra risks might materialise, further savings can often be made. For example, the value engineering exercise that they planned turned out to offer savings of around £20 million. The design risk figures that were not included must be considered in that context.

I should add that I would expect the Auditor General's forthcoming study to examine my officials' judgment on this matter, and I imagine that many members will be interested in the results of that inquiry. Mr Salmond will notice that paragraph 4.3.4 of the Spencely report says that the additional £27 million

"were not identified in cost terms in the report to the Client"—

the client being the SPCB. However, the same holds for me as well.

Alex Salmond SNP Banff and Buchan
link
Given that the project team is not noted for managing costs out but for managing them up, might it not have been a good idea for the client to have been told about the £27 million that had been identified on four separate occasions in four separate cost assessments?

Is not it the case that the Parliament was entitled to have that information when it made its vital decision last year? Furthermore, given that we did not have that information, does the First Minister agree with the statement that the £109 million figure that he reported to this Parliament was wrong and not the whole story?

Donald Dewar Lab The First Minister · Glasgow Anniesland
link
No, I would not agree with that, for the reasons that I have given at some length. I do not believe that Parliament was misled and I gave an account of the situation based upon my knowledge and the information available to me. Furthermore, the SPCB made its decision on that information and those figures. Mr Salmond will remember that paragraph 11 of its report, which was published this morning, says:

"It may well have been possible for the project as it then stood to have been completed for a figure in the region of £109m. At the time we accepted the £62m construction component of this as a challenging budget. But clearly it assumed very limited design changes and no delays."

For reasons that the SPCB goes on to explain very fairly in its report, the pressures for increased accommodation from the parliamentary family and the spread of interests in the Parliament meant that there were very substantial increases in space demands that had to be built into the design. That greatly affected the cost profile. At the time, the figures that I gave were accepted by the SPCB as challenging but possible. It was certainly on that basis that they were put forward.

Alex Salmond SNP Banff and Buchan
link
When I said that the figures were wrong and not the whole story, I was quoting John Spencely directly. Given that information, will the First Minister now say that his officials were wrong not to tell him about the £27 million costs? Will he retract the statement he made, quite incredibly, at a press conference this morning, that it was perfectly proper for him not to be told about the figures? If he was not told about the figures, how on earth was the Parliament expected to reach a rational decision? Given that the officials concerned were appointed by the First Minister when he was Secretary of State for Scotland, will he now accept his personal responsibility for the contribution he has made to the unacceptable and escalating costs of the Holyrood project?

Donald Dewar Lab The First Minister · Glasgow Anniesland
link
No. I do not accept that charge. I certainly accept that I am responsible for the project in the same way as a minister is responsible for anything that occurs within his bailiwick or area of responsibility. I sometimes think that I take that more seriously than others have in the past.

I take some consolation from a large number of John Spencely's findings. It is important to recognise, for example, that he endorsed the construction methods, which were much criticised. I note the evidence in his and the SPCB's report that many of the cost features were very competitive when compared with Portcullis House, the new Parliament building in London. I know for a fact, despite many of the rumours that have been put about, that the demands made by the Executive for additional space were less than 5 per cent of the total increase that occurred. I certainly believe that the decision to go to the Holyrood site, which was made as a result of investigation and advice from men of skill and experience, was the right one. I hold to that decision and will continue to defend it.

  1. Scottish Parliament Thursday 30 March 2000 Debate · 1
  2. Scottish Service Tax Debate · 77
  3. Housing Energy Efficiency Debate · 46
  4. Business Motion Business motions · 5
  5. Spending Allocations 2000-01 Statement · 28
  6. Mental Welfare Commission Report Debate · 6
  7. Royal Hospital for Sick Children Questions · 6
  8. Coastal Erosion Questions · 4
  9. Football Clubs (Supporter Involvement) Questions · 8
  10. Health Promotion Questions · 6
  11. Rural Housing Questions · 6
  12. Railways (Electrification) Questions · 8
  13. National Health Service Questions · 6
  14. Lip-reading Tutors Questions · 8
  15. District Courts Questions · 4
  16. Planning Questions · 8
  17. Tax-varying Powers Questions · 4
  18. Assisted Areas Questions · 5
  19. Local Government (Electoral Reform) Questions · 10
  20. Railways (Electrification) Questions · 6
  21. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  22. Joint Ministerial Committees First Minister’s Questions · 8
  23. New Deal First Minister’s Questions · 6
  24. Higher Education Funding First Minister’s Questions · 8
  25. Mental Welfare Commission Report Statement · 16
  26. Public Appointments Debate · 22
  27. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 8
  28. Decision Time Decision time · 44
  29. Health and Safety at Work Members’ business · 17

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.