To ask the First Minister how the Scottish Executive intends to address the geographical differences in educational attainment in Scotland. (S1F-212)
Official Report · Chamber
Education
First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Donald Dewar Lab 4
- Ken Macintosh Lab 2
- Nicola Sturgeon SNP 1
- Hugh Henry Lab 1
The record
8 contributionsI accept entirely Kenneth Macintosh's point: improvement in all schools must be our priority. Schools have set targets that take account of comparisons with similar schools, and the excellence fund allows local authorities to take account of local priorities in promoting improvement in their schools.
Is the First Minister aware that, on average, the life expectancy of a young man in Barrhead, an area of my constituency, can be up to 10 years lower than that of a young man in Newton Mearns or Giffnock—other parts of the constituency? Does he recognise that if we are to end the vicious and destructive cycle of low expectation and low achievement, we must deliver on all areas of policy—on jobs, crime and hospitals—as well as on schools? That way, everybody in our communities will get the chance they deserve.
I certainly accept that principle; indeed, I have referred to it on a number of occasions recently. All our constituencies can yield examples of the contrasts that we have in Scotland and of how people can have opportunities snuffed out and lose the chance to reach their potential. We have a strong and driving imperative, which I hope the whole chamber shares, to do something about that.
It is quite wrong that someone who lives a small and simple bus ride away may find themselves in a different world in terms of their personal prospects. That is what the excellence fund—£389 million over three years—is about: early intervention in schools. That is what the "Raising Standards—Setting Targets" project is about. Members are interested in that: educational opportunity and driving up standards are an essential priority in the fight to which Kenneth Macintosh referred in his question. It is clear in that project's first annual report that we are making real progress. I am pleased about that, but very conscious of how far we have to go.
It is quite wrong that someone who lives a small and simple bus ride away may find themselves in a different world in terms of their personal prospects. That is what the excellence fund—£389 million over three years—is about: early intervention in schools. That is what the "Raising Standards—Setting Targets" project is about. Members are interested in that: educational opportunity and driving up standards are an essential priority in the fight to which Kenneth Macintosh referred in his question. It is clear in that project's first annual report that we are making real progress. I am pleased about that, but very conscious of how far we have to go.
Does the First Minister think that there is any link between geographical differences in educational attainment and geographical differences in the amount of money that is spent on each child's education? In particular, will the First Minister comment on the fact that a primary school child living in Angus has—according to current Scottish Executive figures—£2,030 spent on his or her education, whereas the figure for a similar child living in South Ayrshire would be only £1,734? The South Ayrshire figure is nearly £300 less than the figure in Angus, and some £200 less than the national average.
Nicola Sturgeon raises an interesting point. As she knows, we make an indicative allocation to local authorities under the local government distribution formula. The grant-aided expenditure allocation for education this year as against last year is up by 6.2 per cent, and this year against next year there will be an increase of 4.3 per cent, which represents £126 million. She will see that the Government is doing its bit in that respect.
One must be careful about simplistic comparisons, because there will be a need to spend more—which is represented in the distribution formula—where there are small primary schools in country areas. Particular comparisons are sometimes misleading and difficult. We provide the resources and local authorities have to make their own dispositions in terms of how much they spend and how they spend it. That is the nature of local democracy—and something the SNP has strongly defended on the ground that the allocation of resources should not be directional or pre-emptive.
One must be careful about simplistic comparisons, because there will be a need to spend more—which is represented in the distribution formula—where there are small primary schools in country areas. Particular comparisons are sometimes misleading and difficult. We provide the resources and local authorities have to make their own dispositions in terms of how much they spend and how they spend it. That is the nature of local democracy—and something the SNP has strongly defended on the ground that the allocation of resources should not be directional or pre-emptive.
Does the First Minister agree that, in many cases, educational attainment and some of the other issues that have been raised have little to do with geography but everything to do with class and income, and that even in communities such as Barrhead, or Johnstone in my constituency, there are huge differentials in the same towns—and sometimes in the same villages—caused by social status?
Of course there are enormously important environmental influences, such as the area in which one lives, the traditions of that area, the pressures of unemployment and the problems of social deprivation. There are many reasons why children do not always realise their potential. Encouragement in the home and the ambition of parents are potent forces in the prospects of success. We have to do what we can to unlock the door of opportunity for children, whatever their background. We do that through our social inclusion policy and our education decisions, and we will continue to do that. I hope that we will see results over the next year or two.
In this meeting
Everything on 16 Mar 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 16 March 2000 Debate · 1
- Register of Interests (Members' Staff) Debate · 36
- Health Boards and NHS Trusts (Public Consultation) Debate · 34
- Business Motion Business motions · 43
- Parliamentary Bureau and SPCB Motions Business motions · 308
- Presiding Officer's Ruling Procedure · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 312
- Rail Travel for the Blind Debate · 12
- Local Government Finance Questions · 8
- Organic Agriculture Questions · 6
- Rural Housing Questions · 8
- Meat Safety Questions · 4
- Scottish Qualifications Authority (Meetings) Questions · 7
- Enterprise Questions · 6
- National Health Service Questions · 10
- Roads (Rural Areas) Questions · 10
- Countryside Access Questions · 5
- Coastal Bombing (Cape Wrath) Questions · 6
- Scottish Consolidated Fund Questions · 9
- School Playing Fields Questions · 6
- Public Health Questions · 6
- General Teaching Council Questions · 4
- Credit Unions Questions · 7
- Ministerial Responsibilities First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Education First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Council Tax First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Inward Investment First Minister’s Questions · 12
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.