To ask the First Minister whether the Scottish Executive has any plans to tackle potential depopulation in parts of Scotland identified in the recent population projections released by the registrar general. (S1F-174)
Official Report · Chamber
Depopulation
First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Donald Dewar Lab 4
- David Mundell Con 2
- Alex Neil SNP 1
- Elaine Murray Lab 1
The record
8 contributionsI have a great deal of sympathy with the points that are made about depopulation. It is worth reminding David Mundell that the population movement projections since 1991 in Scottish Borders, Dumfries and Galloway, East Lothian, South Ayrshire, East Ayrshire and South Lanarkshire—all important rural areas—show an increase in population. However, that does not mean that there is room for complacency. Through extra funding for local enterprise companies and other initiatives, we are trying to ensure that food, tourism and forest products industries move to those areas. As he will know, there have recently been some important developments in forest products.
Mr Mundell may also be interested to know that Scottish Borders is one of the areas of Scotland in which the registrar general predicts a welcome increase in population during the next 20 years or so.
In conclusion—because I cannot resist offering my genuine thanks—I must thank Mr Mundell for his intervention during last week's question time, in which he suggested that I should take upon myself the role of Che Guevara. That is a creditable effort of imagination on his part.
Mr Mundell may also be interested to know that Scottish Borders is one of the areas of Scotland in which the registrar general predicts a welcome increase in population during the next 20 years or so.
In conclusion—because I cannot resist offering my genuine thanks—I must thank Mr Mundell for his intervention during last week's question time, in which he suggested that I should take upon myself the role of Che Guevara. That is a creditable effort of imagination on his part.
Not only do I want the First Minister to take on the role of Che Guevara to lead an e-revolution, I want him to take on that role in leading the revolution of the economy in South of Scotland. Despite the figures that he has quoted, he may not be aware that Dumfries and Galloway and Scottish Borders have the lowest percentage of people between the ages of 15 and 29 of any part of the United Kingdom. Does he agree that that is a cause for concern and is inextricably linked to the economic prospects of South of Scotland?
Is the First Minister aware that, only today, Seacat has announced that it is pulling out of Stranraer—with the loss of 19 direct jobs—citing lack of transport links as the reason? Will he undertake to put on the Scottish Executive's agenda those things that will genuinely improve the economic prospects of the south-west—improving the A75 and improving the timber extraction routes from the area?
Is the First Minister aware that, only today, Seacat has announced that it is pulling out of Stranraer—with the loss of 19 direct jobs—citing lack of transport links as the reason? Will he undertake to put on the Scottish Executive's agenda those things that will genuinely improve the economic prospects of the south-west—improving the A75 and improving the timber extraction routes from the area?
I understand the importance of the A75; Sarah Boyack has it very much in mind. We have to make priorities. The amount of money that is available for major road improvements is limited, but we always try to keep in mind strategic requirements and priorities. I mentioned that there have been substantial forest product developments in the south of the country—in the Dumfries and Galloway area and in the Stewartry—and I am glad of that.
Another important development, which is rather less relevant but which keys in with what Mr Mundell said, is the big investment in the harbour at Ayr, which was announced the other day. It will allow timber from the west coast to be brought into Ayr by water and to be taken on from there. We are trying to make the most of the indigenous industries of the area, but we are also working hard to ensure that new industries are brought in.
I know that David Mundell is a genuine champion of new information technology and its possibilities. It is encouraging to see new jobs being created, because of fibre-optics and broadband technology, in areas in which it would once have been inconceivable. I hope that such jobs will be created in his part of the world in the not-too-distant future.
Another important development, which is rather less relevant but which keys in with what Mr Mundell said, is the big investment in the harbour at Ayr, which was announced the other day. It will allow timber from the west coast to be brought into Ayr by water and to be taken on from there. We are trying to make the most of the indigenous industries of the area, but we are also working hard to ensure that new industries are brought in.
I know that David Mundell is a genuine champion of new information technology and its possibilities. It is encouraging to see new jobs being created, because of fibre-optics and broadband technology, in areas in which it would once have been inconceivable. I hope that such jobs will be created in his part of the world in the not-too-distant future.
Is the First Minister aware that one of the main reasons for depopulation rearing its ugly head again is the increase in net emigration from Scotland? Last year, the net civilian migration was –5.4 per cent. Many of those who leave the country are young people, whom we need for the future of Scotland—the people whom Miss Jean Brodie would call la crème de la crème. Will the First Minister take measures to encourage young people to stay in Scotland?
As someone who has not left Scotland—a feature that I share with Alex Neil—I am not sure that I want to assume that the crème de la crème are those who are not with us, but no doubt that is a matter of opinion.
I want not so much to hold people as to offer them the attractive jobs that will tempt them to stay. We are all united on that. I like to think that the present healthy state of the Scottish economy—with the lowest unemployment claimant count for 24 years and pressure on the jobs market in some parts of Scotland—will create opportunities for people to return. I would like that. An economy that is in good nick, as it is at present, is the best way in which to encourage such a trend.
I do not want, in anything that I have said, to underestimate or talk down the problem of population loss. In reply to David Mundell, I was simply trying to make the point that if one looks at the figures for, for example, Scottish Borders and Dumfries and Galloway over the past eight or nine years, there has been a population build-up. It is a modest one, but it is an increase. That does not mean that we should not take seriously the population profile. Nor does it mean that we should stop the efforts to make things better.
I want not so much to hold people as to offer them the attractive jobs that will tempt them to stay. We are all united on that. I like to think that the present healthy state of the Scottish economy—with the lowest unemployment claimant count for 24 years and pressure on the jobs market in some parts of Scotland—will create opportunities for people to return. I would like that. An economy that is in good nick, as it is at present, is the best way in which to encourage such a trend.
I do not want, in anything that I have said, to underestimate or talk down the problem of population loss. In reply to David Mundell, I was simply trying to make the point that if one looks at the figures for, for example, Scottish Borders and Dumfries and Galloway over the past eight or nine years, there has been a population build-up. It is a modest one, but it is an increase. That does not mean that we should not take seriously the population profile. Nor does it mean that we should stop the efforts to make things better.
Does the First Minister agree that the figures released by the registrar general are for a worst-case scenario, because they do not take into account issues such as the opportunities that are presented by the manufacturing strategy, which we discussed this morning? In Dumfries and Galloway's case, no account was taken of such issues as the development of the Crichton university site and the possibilities that arise from the world-class new technology that is being installed there. Indeed, many of us here hope that the Scottish university for industry will be based at that site. The registrar general's figures give us a baseline above which we have to perform. Instead of being pessimistic about the opportunities for areas such as Dumfries and Galloway, we should be moving ahead optimistically and making the most of all the new opportunities that exist in those areas.
Elaine Murray has made an important point, which I should have stressed. Most of my colleagues will recognise the point. The figures from the registrar general that I have been quoting are projections on the present population line, assuming that no further action is taken. I hope that we will be able to do better. I am delighted that she mentioned the Crichton site; I know it well.
The co-operation between Bell College of Technology, the University of Glasgow and the University of Paisley has opened some extraordinarily exciting gateways. It was great to be on the campus and talking to students who have been attracted there from other parts of Scotland and, indeed, other parts of the United Kingdom. It is bound to be a growth point. If it does as well as the sponsoring organisations believe it can, it will, I hope, have a considerable impact on the population projections.
The co-operation between Bell College of Technology, the University of Glasgow and the University of Paisley has opened some extraordinarily exciting gateways. It was great to be on the campus and talking to students who have been attracted there from other parts of Scotland and, indeed, other parts of the United Kingdom. It is bound to be a growth point. If it does as well as the sponsoring organisations believe it can, it will, I hope, have a considerable impact on the population projections.
In this meeting
Everything on 9 Mar 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 9 March 2000 Debate · 1
- Manufacturing Debate · 129
- Business Motion Business motions · 45
- Health Service (Lanarkshire) Questions · 5
- Anti-social Behaviour Orders Questions · 4
- Business Innovation Questions · 4
- Forth Crossing Questions · 8
- Care of the Elderly Questions · 7
- Standards in Scotland's Schools etc Bill Questions · 6
- Planning Legislation Questions · 8
- Student Finance Questions · 4
- Capital Projects (Costs) Questions · 8
- Roads (Child Fatalities) Questions · 6
- Business Competitiveness Questions · 6
- Inverness College Questions · 6
- Health Service (Tayside) Questions · 18
- Education (Violent Incidents) Questions · 8
- Volvo Questions · 9
- National Cultural Strategy Questions · 7
- Scottish Executive Cabinet (Meeting) First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Labour MPs (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Drugs First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Depopulation First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Climate Change Statement · 26
- Census (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 29
- Census (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 2
- Scotland Act 1998 (Cross-Border Public Authorities) (Forestry Commissioners) Order 2000 Debate · 2
- Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Bill Bill debate · 7
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 29
- Peterhead Prison Members’ business · 19
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.