To ask the First Minister when he next plans to visit the Westminster Parliament. (S1F72) The First Minister (Donald Dewar): I was there on 12 January 2000 and, sadly, it turned out to be a one-line whip. However, I am going again on 9 February and, of course, visit Westminster regularly.
Official Report · Chamber
Westminster (Visits)
SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 4
- Donald Dewar Lab 3
The record
7 contributionsI am sure that, like me, the First Minister likes to welcome distinguished visitors to the Parliament. This morning, I was delighted to meet and welcome Mr Tom Conti when he visited the Parliament as a guest of Colin Campbell.
When the First Minister next goes to the Westminster Parliament, will he take the opportunity to talk to the Prime Minister about the press report in The Scotsman last Friday, which announced the Prime Minister's visit to Scotland under the headline:
"Blair visit to ‘reassure' Scots over devolution
Labour turmoil continues as Dewar is forced to defend another aide"?
The article argued the line from Labour sources that the Prime Minister's visit to Scotland was to shore up the First Minister's incompetent Administration. Is that the reason for the visit, or are London spin doctors as out of control as the ones in Edinburgh?
When the First Minister next goes to the Westminster Parliament, will he take the opportunity to talk to the Prime Minister about the press report in The Scotsman last Friday, which announced the Prime Minister's visit to Scotland under the headline:
"Blair visit to ‘reassure' Scots over devolution
Labour turmoil continues as Dewar is forced to defend another aide"?
The article argued the line from Labour sources that the Prime Minister's visit to Scotland was to shore up the First Minister's incompetent Administration. Is that the reason for the visit, or are London spin doctors as out of control as the ones in Edinburgh?
I should make an important announcement—I have no one to welcome in the gallery today, although all who are here are of course very welcome. As for Tom Conti, I was also delighted to meet his wife, Kara Wilson, who was at university with me and who gave me a very pleasant kiss. Sir David, may I say, without sounding pathetic, that that is not something that happens to me every day. [Laughter.]
As for the report in The Scotsman, I hope that the Prime Minister will be able to say a few words of welcome to the Parliament. The chamber will remember that, for very good reasons, he was unfortunately unable to be at the official opening ceremonies. He will be in Scotland for a very simple purpose: to address the annual conference of the Scottish Labour party. If he were not coming for that purpose, I cannot think of all the ingenious words that would be used to suggest that that was a snub, a disaster and a repudiation of Scotland.
As for the report in The Scotsman, I hope that the Prime Minister will be able to say a few words of welcome to the Parliament. The chamber will remember that, for very good reasons, he was unfortunately unable to be at the official opening ceremonies. He will be in Scotland for a very simple purpose: to address the annual conference of the Scottish Labour party. If he were not coming for that purpose, I cannot think of all the ingenious words that would be used to suggest that that was a snub, a disaster and a repudiation of Scotland.
On the subject of snubs, I am sure
that Mr George Foulkes is recovering from not being welcomed by the First Minister.
I want to return to the report in The Scotsman, which quotes senior Labour sources in London as saying:
"[Mr Dewar's administration] were meant to be the best and brightest that Scottish Labour had to offer, but they have displayed a naivete and incompetence that is quite extraordinary. People are appalled by the sheer naked incompetence of it."
If we leave to one side the "naked" bit, are not people right to be appalled by the Executive's incompetence, just as they should be appalled at the arrogance of London spin doctors who say that all that is required to sort everything out is a visit from the Prime Minister?
that Mr George Foulkes is recovering from not being welcomed by the First Minister.
I want to return to the report in The Scotsman, which quotes senior Labour sources in London as saying:
"[Mr Dewar's administration] were meant to be the best and brightest that Scottish Labour had to offer, but they have displayed a naivete and incompetence that is quite extraordinary. People are appalled by the sheer naked incompetence of it."
If we leave to one side the "naked" bit, are not people right to be appalled by the Executive's incompetence, just as they should be appalled at the arrogance of London spin doctors who say that all that is required to sort everything out is a visit from the Prime Minister?
I have noticed a rather depressing tendency for Alex Salmond to reduce everything to arguments ad hominem. If he wants to judge this Parliament and this Administration, perhaps he should consider some of the achievements and policies that we have pursued. I am unashamedly proud of the fact that we were able to announce a settlement for student finance, which is very distinctly built for Scotland and will put £50 million gross into student support. The settlement was described by the spokesman for the Committee of Scottish Higher Education Principals as a new and better ball game compared with the old system.
I am proud of the fact that, since March 1998, waiting lists in the health service have fallen by more than 15 per cent. I am proud of the fact that we have the lowest unemployment claimant count for 24 years. I am certainly proud of the fact that we have the biggest building programme for Scottish schools that we have ever seen.
I am proud of the fact that, since March 1998, waiting lists in the health service have fallen by more than 15 per cent. I am proud of the fact that we have the lowest unemployment claimant count for 24 years. I am certainly proud of the fact that we have the biggest building programme for Scottish schools that we have ever seen.
How interesting. The same source said in The Scotsman that there were concerns about
"the fallout south of the Border over student tuition fees"
and the Administration in Scotland.
The First Minister says that he knows the reason for the Prime Minister's visit. Are we expected to believe that the fact that the last prime ministerial visit to Scotland took place during the Hamilton by- election and that the next will take place a week before the Ayr by-election is mere coincidence? Or are people in Scotland entitled to be appalled by the Administration's incompetence, by the effrontery of the Labour spin doctors in London and by the gall of a Prime Minister who wants to treat this Parliament as a political plaything a week before a by-election? [Applause.]
"the fallout south of the Border over student tuition fees"
and the Administration in Scotland.
The First Minister says that he knows the reason for the Prime Minister's visit. Are we expected to believe that the fact that the last prime ministerial visit to Scotland took place during the Hamilton by- election and that the next will take place a week before the Ayr by-election is mere coincidence? Or are people in Scotland entitled to be appalled by the Administration's incompetence, by the effrontery of the Labour spin doctors in London and by the gall of a Prime Minister who wants to treat this Parliament as a political plaything a week before a by-election? [Applause.]
The noise of the chief whip's clapping shows a certain loyalty.
I very much hope that Alex Salmond will listen with courtesy to what the Prime Minister has to say. I hope that Alex Salmond will not tailor his response to the visit to whether the Prime Minister goes to the Ayr by-election, but I rather fear that that is what will happen.
I say to Mr Salmond that, occasionally, people come to my surgeries clutching newspaper cuttings and boring me with them—[Interruption.] I regard them with some suspicion.
I very much hope that Alex Salmond will listen with courtesy to what the Prime Minister has to say. I hope that Alex Salmond will not tailor his response to the visit to whether the Prime Minister goes to the Ayr by-election, but I rather fear that that is what will happen.
I say to Mr Salmond that, occasionally, people come to my surgeries clutching newspaper cuttings and boring me with them—[Interruption.] I regard them with some suspicion.
In this meeting
Everything on 3 Feb 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 3 February 2000 Debate · 2
- National Health Service Debate · 106
- Air Transport Debate · 101
- Business Motion Business motions · 7
- Coalfields Regeneration Trust Questions · 5
- National Lottery Questions · 5
- Roads (A77) Questions · 10
- Temporary Sheriffs Questions · 3
- Irish League of Credit Unions (Meeting) Questions · 3
- Local Produce (Retail Outlets) Questions · 9
- Drug Misuse Questions · 7
- Domestic Sprinklers national health service. (S1O-1061) Questions · 5
- Radioactive Waste Questions · 3
- Roads (A74) Questions · 4
- Prisoner Release Questions · 3
- NHS Dental Services Questions · 5
- Dirt Bikes Questions · 3
- Local Authority Pay Awards Questions · 9
- Nephrops Industries Questions · 7
- Health Boards (Meetings) Questions · 8
- Westminster (Visits) Questions · 7
- Scottish Executive Questions · 9
- Local Government Act 1986 Questions · 7
- Convention of the Highlands and Islands Questions · 9
- Sustainable Development Debate · 34
- Decision Time Decision time · 51
- Rights of the Child Members’ business · 19
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.