To ask the First Minister what representations the Scottish Executive is planning to make to the BBC in connection with the BBC's previously announced May 2000 review of the need for a Scottish edited and controlled 6 o'clock news programme. (S1F-44)
Official Report · Chamber
BBC News
First Minister's Question Time SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Michael Russell SNP 2
- Donald Dewar Lab 2
The record
4 contributionsThe last thing that an Executive or an Administration should do is to try to dictate to the broadcasters. It is not for me to prescribe—[Laughter.] Ladies and gentlemen on the SNP benches may laugh at me, but I can assure the chamber that an Administration or Government that tried to bully or to over-influence the broadcasting process would be open to very considerable criticism. I do not think that I want to indulge in such a practice.
I welcome the fact that, as a result of the last round of talks in 1998, a further £10 million was given to BBC Scotland—that is probably another 50 or so skilled jobs. The test must be that we should have fair, balanced and accurate coverage in news reporting, that we should have world news, national news and Scottish news, that such reporting should be inclusive and certainly not insular and that the standards and professionalism should be of the highest order. We want to maintain the true traditions of public service broadcasting.
Some might argue, although I do not think that Michael Russell would, that, if we did have a "Scottish Six", politicians from this chamber would appear rather more commonly in the living rooms of the nation. I leave it to other people to decide whether that is an argument for or against.
I welcome the fact that, as a result of the last round of talks in 1998, a further £10 million was given to BBC Scotland—that is probably another 50 or so skilled jobs. The test must be that we should have fair, balanced and accurate coverage in news reporting, that we should have world news, national news and Scottish news, that such reporting should be inclusive and certainly not insular and that the standards and professionalism should be of the highest order. We want to maintain the true traditions of public service broadcasting.
Some might argue, although I do not think that Michael Russell would, that, if we did have a "Scottish Six", politicians from this chamber would appear rather more commonly in the living rooms of the nation. I leave it to other people to decide whether that is an argument for or against.
The First Minister has the virtue of consistency, at least. He has taken a supine position on the matter since it was first raised.
However, in the light of that position, perhaps it would be advisable for the First Minister to tell the First Secretary in Wales about it. In the excitement of his election on 12 May 1999, the First Secretary said in the Welsh Assembly chamber, during his acceptance speech:
"The BBC was right to decline to break up the six o'clock news."—[Official Record, National Assembly for Wales; 15 May 1999.]
In the circumstances, there is no consistency in new Labour's position and there has been bullying and interference.
I hoped that the First Minister and his Administration might address the potential of Scottish broadcasting and help it to develop, first of all in the BBC and, in the emerging crisis, in Scottish Television, as that would be welcome. I hope that the First Minister will be active in the matter.
However, in the light of that position, perhaps it would be advisable for the First Minister to tell the First Secretary in Wales about it. In the excitement of his election on 12 May 1999, the First Secretary said in the Welsh Assembly chamber, during his acceptance speech:
"The BBC was right to decline to break up the six o'clock news."—[Official Record, National Assembly for Wales; 15 May 1999.]
In the circumstances, there is no consistency in new Labour's position and there has been bullying and interference.
I hoped that the First Minister and his Administration might address the potential of Scottish broadcasting and help it to develop, first of all in the BBC and, in the emerging crisis, in Scottish Television, as that would be welcome. I hope that the First Minister will be active in the matter.
I hope that I am not supine in these matters although I certainly do not believe that, as a Government, we should be trying to prescribe to the broadcasting authorities. If Michael Russell were to think about going down that road, he would see the dangers of it.
I am not responsible for what happens in Wales. If I understand what Michael Russell said—I may have got it wrong—he invited me to endorse something that was said in Wales, which he would then be able to attack with great ferocity. I am sorry to disappoint him, but I have no intention of taking his rather contradictory advice.
However, in my initial reply, I made the point that
I totally join Michael Russell in urging upon the BBC the need to maintain the standards of public service broadcasting and to serve Scotland, not in the narrow sense, but in the broad, internationalist sense, to which I think we would all want to pay tribute.
I am not responsible for what happens in Wales. If I understand what Michael Russell said—I may have got it wrong—he invited me to endorse something that was said in Wales, which he would then be able to attack with great ferocity. I am sorry to disappoint him, but I have no intention of taking his rather contradictory advice.
However, in my initial reply, I made the point that
I totally join Michael Russell in urging upon the BBC the need to maintain the standards of public service broadcasting and to serve Scotland, not in the narrow sense, but in the broad, internationalist sense, to which I think we would all want to pay tribute.
In this meeting
Everything on 20 Jan 2000 →- Scottish Parliament Thursday 20 January 2000 Statement · 9
- Family Law Debate · 32
- Drug Misuse Debate · 105
- Business Motion Business motions · 13
- Census (Scotland) Order 2000 Debate · 2
- Meeting of the Parliament (Glasgow) Debate · 5
- West of Scotland Water Questions · 5
- NHS Pay Review Questions · 5
- Public Finances Questions · 6
- Rural Schools Questions · 5
- Rail Transport Questions · 7
- Tourist Boards Questions · 5
- NHS Dental Services Questions · 4
- Economic Development Services Questions · 5
- Drugs Education Questions · 4
- Influenza Immunisation Questions · 7
- Vulnerable Witnesses Questions · 6
- Breast Screening Questions · 6
- Cancer Questions · 7
- Domestic Abuse Questions · 4
- Scallop Industry Questions · 5
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meeting) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Prime Minister (Meeting) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- School Standards First Minister’s Questions · 5
- BBC News First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Water Charges First Minister’s Questions · 3
- Drug Misuse Debate · 44
- Standing Orders (Definition of Budget Bill) Bill debate · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 31
- Civil Service Jobs (Dispersal) Members’ business · 21
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.