The purpose of item 2 is to take oral evidence on an objection in the Scottish Rugby Union's name. We could not take the evidence last week because of time constraints. Having just administered a public admonition to the promoter, in the spirit of reconciliation, I now thank the promoter, the objector and all their witnesses for their help in ensuring that this meeting to take rescheduled evidence could proceed. Their co-operation is greatly appreciated.Last week, I set out fully the format for the meeting; I do not intend to repeat all that. Suffice it to say that, as I am sure everyone understands by now, we are at the consideration stage. It is the committee's role to decide on each outstanding objection, so to allow the committee to do that, we require absolutely clarity about what the unresolved issues are and about what the committee is expected to do to resolve them.We move on to the evidence on the Scottish Rugby Union's objection. The witnesses for the promoter are Gavin Murray, Aileen Grant and Jim Harries, whom I invite to the table. They are required to take the oath or make a solemn affirmation.Gavin Murray took the oath.Aileen Grant and Jim Harries made a solemn affirmation.
Official Report · Committee
Consideration Stage
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Dr Sales 76
- Gavin Murray Transport Initiatives Edinburgh Ltd 51
- Malcolm Thomson 27
- Bill Aitken Con 21
- Aileen Grant City of Edinburgh Council 17
- Graham Ireland Scottish Rugby Union plc 13
- Mark Fisher Carl Bro Ltd 10
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 2
- Malcolm Thomson QC Counsel for the Promoter 1
- Dr Martin Sales 1
The record
222 contributions · showing 1–200Although he requires no introduction, I introduce Malcolm Thomson QC, who will be questioning the witnesses on behalf of the promoter, and Dr Martin Sales, who will be questioning the witnesses on behalf of the objector. Before we hear evidence from the first witness, I want to set the scene by outlining what I consider to be the outstanding issues between the two parties, having read the witness statements and rebuttals.It appears to me that there is willingness on both sides to co-operate in order to resolve problems, which is appreciated. Having read the objector's rebuttal, I summarise the outstanding issues as being: confirmation of the design approach from Network Rail; land in the east-west spectator link; involvement of the SRU in the design, development, use, relocation and temporary loss of the pitch area; and operation and safety issues. Can we get broad agreement that those are the outstanding issues in order to give some focus to the meeting? Obviously, if progress has been made on any matter, we can pick that up in questioning.
I agree that those are the areas of dispute between the parties. However, I hesitate to use the word "dispute". Perhaps it would be more accurate to describe them as areas in which full agreement has not yet been reached. From my perspective, there is willingness to agree on all those matters.
I agree that those are the areas that are still in dispute or that still require resolution. If I misheard you, I apologise, but I think that you referred to a pitch, which would be the inner stadium. In fact, we are concerned about what we refer to as the back pitches.
That is correct. Mr Thomson, do you have any questions for Mr Murray?
Mr Murray, will you give us a brief update on events since the date of your latest rebuttal and statement?
Since I put my latest rebuttal together, we have focused on the outstanding issues. We have had on-going consultation with the SRU and have had discussions with the City of Edinburgh Council's safety officer in relation to how the construction process will work and how it is likely to affect use of the SRU's premises. As the committee will acknowledge, the area between the railway line and the southern end of Murrayfield stadium is tight. There is a significant area within the turnstiles in which people can move readily but, outwith that area, there is a need for spectators and others to get from the parking area in the back pitches around to the turnstiles and vice versa. The area is complex and we have aimed to work with the SRU to work out problems relating to how the construction work would proceed. In particular, we have examined in detail the limit of land that is to be acquired or used, and we have defined it in different ways. That is covered in my rebuttal and in the document of which we sent the committee a draft and which we have since updated with further input. There have been significant discussions between the parties on a range of issues that have been outlined. We have talked with Network Rail about getting its approval for our proposals for construction of the tram route through the area and it has been able to give us verbal confirmation that it sees no major problems with what we propose. However, it has not yet been able to put that verbal confirmation in writing for the SRU, which was the SRU's request. We cannot say that the verbal confirmation necessarily resolves the SRU's issue, but we believe that the general principle is agreed. The construction proposal is similar to others that have been used and approved by Network Rail, which has given us verbal confirmation that it understands the proposal and does not see any major problems with it. That covers the major elements of the progress that has been made subsequent to the rebuttal.
If Network Rail gives its approval, will that remove the east-west spectator link issue?
That is right. If Network Rail gives its approval, construction of the tramline will be almost wholly on Network Rail property; therefore, it will not impact on the east-west spectator link. That still leaves us with issues concerning the construction period, although we are dealing with those according to the code of construction practice and, more specifically, the local construction plan. We have provided an early draft of that plan.
Is the promoter prepared to liaise with the SRU on future and finer design matters?
Absolutely. As I said, we have had meetings with the SRU throughout the process, which have ramped up considerably through the witness statement and rebuttal period. It is vital to the requirements of the tramline and the SRU that we have close liaison to ensure that the design takes on board the SRU's issues. Safety is paramount for the promoter and the SRU, and the only way to achieve that is to involve all the parties in development of the design. The SRU has vast experience of organising and managing events at its venue, and the City of Edinburgh Council's safety officer has considerable knowledge of that from signing off the certification and so on for those events. It is vital to the promoter that all that information be encapsulated in the design and brought to bear on the construction and operation of the line.
Is the promoter willing to liaise, as far as possible, with the SRU to achieve meshing of construction activities and events?
Yes. Again, that is vital to how things will go. It will be important for the promoter to work on that in the forthcoming period and to ensure that such action is written into the contractual requirements when the contract goes out to tender, and in the subsequent construction period.
Is it envisaged that there will be a formal written agreement between the promoter and the SRU on such arrangements?
Yes, definitely. I believe that it is vital that such agreement be reached. That is in everyone's interests and it is what we are working towards. It would have been nice if we could have achieved that already.
Finally, everybody is aware that the back pitches will have to be moved as a result of the tramline proposals. The SRU is concerned that that work should be done, as far as possible, outside the rugby season. Has any progress been made on sorting that out?
Yes, significant progress has been made. We have identified the exact requirements of the SRU to ensure that the pitches are the required size and have the relevant run-off areas so that there can be safe play as well as safe spectating. We have identified those requirements on the plan that goes with the local construction plan, and we have laid out six full pitches. One pitch overlays the flood elements; however, if those are taken out, there is space for six full pitches.The next stage is to define the exact requirements for floodlighting, irrigation, drainage and reinforcement so that they can be used for parking. That will be undertaken shortly, then the construction strategy will be drawn up. It is feasible to achieve that outwith the main event season, such that adequate parking can be provided for minor events. We will work closely with the SRU on use of the pitches to ensure that they can be regenerated within appropriate timescales so that the SRU has them for the peak periods. We will minimise the impact of their being used.
Thinking first about the safety issue, which is one of the five areas of potential difference between the SRU and the promoter that the convener outlined, is the code of construction practice sufficient to ensure that safety problems will not arise?
The code of construction practice that has been developed is a generic document for the whole scheme. I would not say that it is relevant to the achievement of safe working practices for the specific location that we are discussing. From that perspective, it has always been the promoter's intention to develop local construction practices and plans. We have begun work to encapsulate the specific local requirements.
I think that that more specific document is called the local plan for Murrayfield. As I understand it, the committee has a version of that document. Does that draft document contain sufficient detail comfortably to address all the SRU's concerns?
I believe that the final version will do that. I am not convinced that we have achieved that yet, but we are working towards it.
Do you know when the final version is likely to be forthcoming?
I cannot say for certain. It depends on the process and on how well we progress it. I would like to think that the document will be available relatively soon.
The version that is before the committee contains a number of options with regard to both the permanent works and the location of different sections of the permanent works along the northern line of the railway. Is that correct?
That is correct.
Section 1.3 of the document contains a number of options, including the construction of a retaining wall instead of an elevated structure. Is that correct?
Yes. That was introduced into the current version in relation to the western edge along the back pitches. It was never intended that that element should impact on the east-west spectator link.
Is it your position that there will be no need for a retaining wall or similar structure in the area of the east-west spectator link?
It is.
Can you reassure the committee that the final design will not involve that sort of supporting structure?
It is fair to say that in the current position there is no intention to have a retaining wall. The outline design that we have developed, which was included with the SRU's objection, identifies a scheme that we believe would be the appropriate one for that section.
That is an elevated tramway section.
That is correct.
You are aware that there is a safety plan for the stadium.
Yes.
That document is before the committee in the form of appendix 3 to Mr Fisher's statement.
Yes.
Have you seen that document?
Yes.
Do you know that it is based on a risk assessment of the factors that have to be taken into account with regard to safe operation of the stadium and the safety of people coming to and leaving the stadium?
Yes—I understand that.
Does the promoter understand that taking more land at the southern end of the stadium area would give rise to a need to change the safety plan?
Yes, we understand that.
Is the promoter also the certifying authority for the safety plan?
Certainly, the promoter is the City of Edinburgh Council, and I understand that an element of the council signs off the plan.
Is it appropriate for the promoter to be entrusted with the task of providing any new certificate that may be required in relation to safe operation of the stadium?
It is outwith my ability to answer that, but the assumption seems reasonable to me.
Can you help us at all in respect of the promoter's position on indemnity for the SRU against risks that arise from the proximity of the construction works to an area in which a large number of people will circulate on event days?
My understanding is that the process will be similar to the present process, in that any event would need to receive sign-off to ensure that a safe event can be held.
Can you help us with the indemnity element?
I cannot speak about indemnity in my capacity as technical adviser.
I turn to the issue of the outstanding approval that is required from Network Rail. Is it correct to say that the limits of deviation for the section of the tramline that we are considering include both the northern rail embankment and part of the east-west spectator link?
That is correct.
So, whether approval is forthcoming from Network Rail in due course, at least part of the east-west spectator link will be consumed by the permanent works.
If the outline solution that my colleagues have worked up were adopted, the permanent works would oversail the east-west spectator link and not utilise it.
Is it correct to say that, because the rail embankment is a structure, Network Rail's approval is required if it is to be used for the infrastructure for tramline 2 at Murrayfield?
That is correct.
Does the promoter have a fallback position—if we may describe it as such—in case Network Rail's approval to use the rail embankment is not forthcoming?
The fallback position would have to be a design along the lines of the retaining wall solution at the back pitches, which we mentioned earlier. For that, there would be a need to use the area within the east-west spectator link, which would require a considerable rejig of the whole area to the south of Murrayfield stadium. I understand that the SRU has said that it would be willing to consider such a proposal if we were to work it up. To date, we have not undertaken that work, on the basis that Network Rail has considered our proposals and is generally happy with them. The construction that we propose has been used in a number of similar situations, so we believe that it should not be a problem.
To be clear, the position appears to be that Network Rail's position is not known and may not be known for some time. Ultimately, if Network Rail declines to approve a piled structure that contains an elevated tramway, you would have to fall back to a retaining-wall-type structure, which in turn would necessitate reconfiguration of the south end of the stadium area.
The type of structure could still be a piled open structure, but its columns would need to be sited at the edge of the Network Rail land rather than within its safety zone. We would have to fall back to a position that is slightly further north. I think that that is the point on which clarification was sought.
Do you have information regarding how long it might take for Network Rail's definitive approval to be secured?
I am afraid that I cannot give you any direct information on that.
Are we talking weeks, months or maybe longer?
I think that we are looking at months and not weeks, but I am afraid that I say that without any certainty.
We have at present what might be called a free-flow area at the south end of the stadium, but do you agree that construction of large columns or pillars for the elevated section of the tramway will create a hazard as far as safety is concerned? I am thinking of circulation of pedestrians in the area.
If the pillars had to be brought into the east-west spectator link, I agree that they would cause a hazard and that it would be necessary to reconfigure the area to ensure that we got back to a free-flow situation.
Is it your evidence that the pillars or columns will positively not have to encroach on the east-west spectator link area?
Our position is that the way in which we have designed the structure at the moment means that the pillars will be within the Network Rail land.
Turning to the back pitches, I think that it is common ground between us that the SRU seeks restoration of the relocation pitches to an appropriate technical specification. Would that be right?
I understand that that is the case.
Just to be clear, I understand that the need to relocate the pitches arises from the requirements of both the permanent land and the LLAU—the limit of land to be acquired or used—for construction works. Is that correct?
Yes. That is correct.
Are you aware that the pitches are subject not only to direction by the SRU but that they are also under contract to tenant clubs?
Yes. We are aware of that.
Are you also aware that the removal or relocation of the pitches is not just a simple matter of putting white lines or other lines on a different location and moving the posts?
I think I said that earlier when I mentioned the issues of drainage, floodlighting and so forth.
There are also the matters of reinstating turf, relocating drainage, rejigging irrigation, moving floodlighting and so on.
Yes.
Are you aware that the pitches are currently subject to a legal obligation that they be used from time to time for ad hoc parking arrangements during special events?
Yes. I am aware of that.
Are you also aware that their surface is reinforced to accommodate vehicle parking.
Right.
Do you know the rough extent of the relocation in terms of distance?
I do not have that detail to hand, but it is in our documentation. Although I have not been involved in working up the relocation, I believe that it is in the order of 15m to 20m to the north.
I turn to construction issues. I understand that there is a requirement that work at Murrayfield has to be carried out at times when no trains are running on the adjacent railway line. Based on the works that are planned, can you say what will be the timescale for construction works at Murrayfield?
Not all works require to be undertaken when no trains are running on the adjacent track. Certainly, elements of the work need to be undertaken in that way, so a detailed programming exercise will be required. Disruptive possessions, as they are termed—the railway is closed to train use—are difficult to achieve. A considerable lead-in time is required to achieve them. We have not done a detailed programme of works as yet; that is one of our upcoming activities.
We are talking about works adjacent to the blue-ribbon line in Scotland—the east-west link between Edinburgh and Glasgow and vice versa. In your view, are we talking about months or years for the construction programme?
I would say yes—we are talking months to years.
Months or years?
I would say months to years.
So you would perhaps not see it going beyond a year into a second or third year?
It could go into a second year, but I do not like to think that it would need to go into a third. If the tramline is to achieve the construction period that has been defined, the work would need to be dealt with in that period.
That is a long period of time, is it not, for an organisation having to forward plan major international events?
Absolutely.
Thank you.
There are no questions from the committee, so we move to re-examination.
I will address the point about disruptive possession. I presume that when the train has to stop functioning so that new work can be carried out by the promoter, that does not happen at 8 o'clock on a Monday morning.
No; such work is generally undertaken between late Saturday night and early Sunday morning—that is, until about 6 o'clock on Sunday morning.
Is the idea that you book a long time in advance to have a disruptive possession slot?
That is correct.
And the slot is likely to be a few hours in the middle of the night between Saturday and Sunday.
That is correct.
That is why a longer than expected period of time may be required to enable the number of those six-hour sessions to build up.
That is correct.
But the long lead-in time means that the promoter knows about, and can plan, those sessions a long time in advance.
Very much so.
So there is certainly an opportunity to mesh the sessions with fixture dates.
Yes.
Thank you very much.
I thank Mr Murray.The room is very hot and if any witness or counsel wishes to remove his jacket, he is perfectly at liberty to do so.Aileen Grant will address section 50, in relation to car parking and prior approval issues in relation to structures.
Are there any matters on which you would like to update us since the date of the rebuttal and your witness statement?
Yes. Since the statements were drafted, there have been two reports to the planning committee. The first report on 26 May made reference to the section 50 agreement. It drew the planning committee's attention to the probable need to vary that legal agreement and indicated generally how that might be done. It asked the planning committee to note the position and to write to TIE to seek its views on what the issues would be for that section 50 agreement. That letter has gone to TIE and we are awaiting further details.The second report to the planning committee was on 16 June, when we presented a mark 2 version of the tram design manual. That is a further draft version of the design manual, which the planning committee has agreed can now go out for public consultation. The planning committee agreed that some tidying up needed to be done—for example, adding page numbers to the document. That is just being completed with a view, we hope, to sending out the design manual this week. We are putting together our consultation list. The SRU will, of course, be on that list, as will all the objectors to the tram proposals.Those are the main things that have happened since the statements were prepared.
So far as the section 50 agreement is concerned, would the simplest solution perhaps be for the council, as the planning authority, to give a letter to the SRU undertaking not to take any action in respect of any breach of the section 50 agreement that is occasioned by the tram works?
What we need to be clear about is what the full implications are of the works in Murrayfield that impinge on that legal agreement. We have asked for a formal response from TIE on whether there will be any permanent infringements of the agreement or only temporary effects. The suggestion is that the impacts will be only temporary. Once we see the response, we intend to write to the SRU. The terms of the section 50 agreement are such that both parties must agree how the legal agreement might be varied. We think that it might not need to be formally varied and that a temporary suspension could be achieved through an exchange of letters.
Thank you.
Good afternoon, Ms Grant.In section 4.1 of your original witness statement, you say that the impact that tramline 2 would have on the SRU's interests would be marginal. Do you stand by that judgment?
Yes. The impact would be marginal on the SRU's overall landholding, on which there would be a minor incursion. That is what the statement meant.
Do you agree that it is equally possible to say that tramline 2 will have an extensive impact on the SRU's interests, in so far as there will be a requirement to accommodate the stacking area for the trams, and the impacts of oversailing will have to be taken into account? There are the significant effects that I have discussed at length with Mr Murray on what is currently a free-flow area in the east-west spectator link and there is the need, which you have just mentioned, to deal with aspects of the pitches under the section 50 agreement. There is also the matter of the relocation of pitches and the fact that we are still awaiting a fallback position, if that is needed, in respect of the Network Rail position. Taken together, do those factors lead to the possibility that there will be an extensive impact rather than a marginal impact?
From what I have heard today, significant impacts are certainly involved, but the planning authority's position is that we must wait for TIE to complete its technical discussions and its detailed design to a certain stage before we comment on the matter. The planning authority has not yet been asked to comment on the details that are emerging from the process.It is clear that a number of significant impacts are involved, but it appears that some of them may be resolved. The planning authority will become formally involved only at the prior approval stage—which is after this stage—so we are not fully party to the discussions that have taken place.
Another potential long-term impact, which might be marginal or more extensive, is the design and the quality of the design of the tramway in the vicinity of the stadium, on which you have given evidence-in-chief through your statements. Given that Murrayfield is the national stadium, do you agree that the location is important for the SRU?
Yes.
Do you also agree that the stadium is a national asset that attracts world focus to the part of Edinburgh in which it is situated?
It is an important asset to the city.
For that reason if for no other reason, do you agree that the SRU should be given a formal consultation role in the design process?
I am not sure how formal "formal" is, but we certainly think that the SRU should work with us in devising a set of design objectives for the structure at Murrayfield. We put a reference to that in the revised version of the tram design manual, accepting that for each structure there are different circumstances or different localised contexts. Although the initial version of the design manual suggested a rather standardised approach to all structures, in reviewing the tram design manual, we felt that we needed to pay much more regard to the local context. In that document, we suggest some kind of consultation with various stakeholders over major structures or alterations to major structures along the tramline. We will invite comment on that, along with all the other aspects, during the forthcoming public consultation. If you consider that to be formal involvement in the process, I agree with you.
The difficulty is that my clients would not regard that as sufficiently formal or enough of an involvement. You used the phrases "some kind of consultation" and "invite comment". Given the importance of this to the SRU, I repeat my question: do you not think that there should be a formal place for something more than comment—something akin to real consultation?
We could explore that during the current consultation on the draft design manual. I would welcome suggestions from the SRU for a formal process, and we would be happy to respond to those. We want to ensure that the design of the structures in Murrayfield and in other prominent, important locations meets aesthetic and visual amenity criteria. We want the structures to be designed in a holistic way so that they fit with the context; that is where the planning authority is coming from on this.
As matters stand, the only reliance that the SRU can place on the formal procedures is on the operation of the prior approval process to which you refer in your witness statement. You mention the provisions of class 29 of part 11 of schedule 1 to the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (Scotland) Order 1992. Do you regard that safeguard as giving sufficient comfort to the SRU?
The comfort of the prior approval process?
Yes.
There are restrictions inherent in that process, which have been set out in various committee reports. The planning authority will not have the same full powers for considering prior approvals that it has for considering planning applications. There is a greater restriction. We have introduced the tram design manual as a way of ensuring that, at the outset, the design addresses the key planning and design considerations, so that we should have design solutions that fit more closely with the various planning policies.
Dr Sales, may I interrupt you for a second? I am a little bit concerned that we may be entering the realm of situations that may or may not occur after the committee has done its work. The subsequent approval process is not really a matter of concern to us.
I understand that. I am trying to explore with Ms Grant the extent to which all those who are concerned at this part of the process may put reliance on the later part of the process to give comfort on an important matter for the SRU—the ultimate approval of the design.
I hear what you are saying, but I would like you to bring this line of questioning to a reasonably quick conclusion.
I will do my best, sir.In that regard, Ms Grant, do you agree that there are limiting conditions within that class, which may mean that the prior approval process is not the ultimate long stop or backstop on design approval?
It will be the long stop on design approval, as far as my role in the planning authority is concerned. That is the channel for a sign-off by us as the regulatory authority as far as planning is concerned. The inherent restrictions to safeguard the aesthetics have limitations, but we have tried to explain that, under the process that we have sketched out, the design manual has a key role. If the structures that are designed at Murrayfield fit the planning principles in the tram design manual, we as the planning authority will be likely to approve them.
I will keep my question as short as possible. Do you accept that, if that class applies, its application to the circumstances at Murrayfield has limitations?
There is no doubt that the proposed structure at Murrayfield will require consent under the prior approval procedure. I am not sure whether that is what your question probes. As it is a structure in the nature of a bridge, our interpretation is that it will require prior approval under class 29. I am not sure whether you suggest some ambiguity about the application of class 29 to the structure design.
The two conditions in the application of that class are that the design and appearance would harm the neighbourhood's amenity and that that harm could be avoided through reasonable modifications. If those conditions do not apply, the class as a whole does not apply.
Those conditions are standard. The planning authority, not the promoter, must be satisfied about them, which is where the design manual kicks in, as it sets out the principles that would be interpreted in making that determination.
Of course, given that a fallback position may be the construction of a retaining wall and a solid structure, we do not know whether we are dealing with a bridge and whether class 29 of part 11 will apply, do we?
That is true.
Thank you. I have no further questions.
The SRU has expressed concerns about the section 50 agreement. Will you clarify the timescales, which the evidence that we have heard suggests could be substantial? Is obtaining authorisation from the planning committee likely to be an issue?
We are concerned to know what the length of time is, if we can be more specific than Mr Murray has been, and what the implications are for the loss of green space, playing pitches and overflow car parking. Once a bit more flesh has been put on the implications, we will explore them with the SRU.We will ask TIE whether alternative arrangements could be made for replacement overflow car parking or replacement of pitches. At this stage, we cannot say what will happen. We do not know how much of an issue the loss of those two aspects is for efficient operation at Murrayfield. Several issues must be explored.
Convener, can the committee be kept up to date on that?
Yes.
I do not know what the mechanism is, but we are happy to keep the committee up to date with developments.
That would be appreciated.
I have only one matter to ask about. Ms Grant, you were asked about the significant impacts of the tram proposals on Murrayfield and the stadium there. From a planning point of view, would there be any significant positive impacts of having a tram in such proximity to the stadium?
From our point of view, there would be significant positive impacts in having the tram stop close to, and serve, Murrayfield. We would certainly consider how to ensure that there is easy access from the tram stop to the main entrance at Murrayfield stadium. There would also be positive impacts from the additional transport connection that the tram would provide into town or, potentially, to the airport and to the railway station at Haymarket, for example. I do not know the details, but there are a lot of significant positive aspects.
Thank you.
I thank Ms Grant for her evidence.Jim Harries, who is the final witness on behalf of the promoter, will address the issues of maintenance, access, operational agreements and crowd control.
I have no introductory questions and I assume that there will be no cross-examination of Mr Harries either.
That is fine.Dr Sales, do you have any input at this stage?
I believe that we are not entitled to any and I have none.
As none of the committee members has any questions, Mr Harries has not had too much of an ordeal. I thank him for attending in any event.That concludes the oral evidence from the promoter in respect of the SRU. We now turn to the objector's witnesses, Graham Ireland and Mark Fisher.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
Before we commence evidence taking, Mr Ireland and Mr Fisher will be required to take the oath or make an affirmation.Graham Ireland made a solemn affirmation.Mark Fisher took the oath.
Mr Ireland, I think that you have been keeping yourself abreast of negotiations with TIE to meet the Scottish Rugby Union's concerns. Where are we in relation to those negotiations?
We have been discussing an agreement with the promoter for possibly two years. Within the past four weeks or so—probably as a result of these hearings—the pace has picked up considerably and we are, apparently, making some progress. However, we are not there yet and we still have a number of issues to resolve, as outlined earlier.
Would it have been necessary for the SRU to appear here today, having been carried over from the programme that was scheduled last week, if matters had been moved on more swiftly by TIE?
I would have hoped that we could have progressed to an agreement by this stage. Sadly, we have not got there. There are a number of key issues that we have to explore and this is our chance to put them before the committee.
In relation to design matters, Mr Murray says, in paragraph 3.1 of his rebuttal of your evidence, that "the design issues will be agreed with the SRU."Have those issues been agreed?
It is quite clear, from what we have heard today, that the design issues have still got a fair way to go. At the present stage, I am not entirely clear whether we are talking about a structure on stilts, a retaining wall with the tram on top of it or something else. From what has been said, it is clear that both parties recognise that Murrayfield is a national asset that attracts thousands of visitors each year. What has not been brought out to date is the fact that the proposed tram goes right across the front door of Murrayfield. I think that committee members had the opportunity to walk into Murrayfield through our main entrance but I do not know whether they realised that that main entrance will have a tram going over the top of it. We are acutely concerned that we are going to end up with some form of concrete monstrosity curving across our front door. The committee might have seen the artist's impression of that, which reinforced our view. That is the reason why we have come before the committee, as we want the committee to help us, along with the promoter, to ensure that Murrayfield has an appropriate entrance and that visitors' lasting impression of their trip to Scotland is not of some hideous concrete structure going across our front door.
Earlier, Miss Grant told us that she thinks that the prior approval mechanism that is operated by the promoter wearing its planning authority hat should satisfy the SRU's concerns in that regard, together with the provisions of the design manual. Do either or both of those factors satisfy the SRU?
I think not. To be cynical, the promoter could put together a concrete structure that would be perfectly adequate to carry a tram, but which might not be what we would want to have in front of our national stadium. I do not think that we can rely on the City of Edinburgh Council's planning process to produce an appropriate solution. The proposal might be technically okay, but it would not necessarily be one that we would want.
On matters relating to construction, from the information that has been provided to date by the promoter, do you know how long it will take to complete the permanent works in particular?
That is one of the key problems. At the moment, particularly because of the Network Rail concerns, no one is sure how long the process will take. I am not a technical expert but, from our experience in Murrayfield in the 1990s, I know that such circumstances make it difficult to run events. If, as has been suggested, the process will run for months or years, it will be almost impossible to run the stadium. A great deal of management will be required by both sides, which is why we are seeking certainty over the period as a priority.
When you had the builders in before, did the SRU have control over the building contracts?
Yes, the building contracts were largely under our control because we were doing the works at Murrayfield, which meant that we could specify when the contractor had to cease work because we were having events. If a third party is doing the work on site—with a long lead period in which Network Rail will be involved—it will be difficult to do that. The event that is taking place next week provides a useful example. We have been landed with a concert at Murrayfield at short notice. As things stand, I fail to see how the promoter would deal with such a situation in relation to clearing the east-west spectator link. We cannot escape the fact that such events come up; as a business and sporting organisation we need protection in the process.
Mr Murray thought that considerable progress had been made in discussions with the SRU about safety during the construction process. Is that your impression?
I speak as the director who is responsible for the stadium and we have had no substantive engagement on the issue. We understand that the promoter met the local authority safety team during the past two weeks, but no tripartite meetings have been held to discuss the matter, to my knowledge. That concerns us. If we work together, we can reach a satisfactory solution, particularly if the issues to do with the east-west spectator link can be resolved. However, we have no assurance that the problems will be resolved, primarily because we do not know where the columns will be. We do not know whether Network Rail will permit them to be sited entirely on its land or whether they will have to encroach on our land. Until such matters are resolved, there can be no assurance on safety. I am sure that the committee appreciates that safety issues will ultimately fall back not on the promoter or the council's safety team, but on the SRU, which is unsatisfactory. We have had discussions with the promoter and we have looked to the promoter for assurances that it will take some responsibility if the worst happens, but we have received no such assurances.
Would there be financial consequences for the SRU should safety considerations not be adequately and properly dealt with through sufficient forward planning?
There are two or three key issues. On one occasion during the construction of the Murrayfield stadium in the 1990s, we were within an inch of losing a major international match the evening before it was due to take place, because a site compound had not been tidied up and a number of safety issues had not been resolved. Such considerations come up before every match, because the safety team must walk round and ensure that all issues are resolved. It might be possible to resolve matters to a degree, but there might be a requirement to reduce the capacity of the stadium. It is difficult, on a Friday night on the eve of a Scotland-England game, to reduce the capacity of the south stand, for example, to accommodate safety concerns.Such issues can be resolved if there is adequate planning and much detailed knowledge before the event. I do not want to detract from the work that has been done so far, but there are currently big gaps in our knowledge. Those gaps can be filled with a bit of extra work, but we have not yet reached that stage.
Let us think about the higher considerations. Am I right in thinking that the SRU fully supports the tram proposals?
We are very supportive of the tram proposals. The tramline will help to provide transport solutions for Murrayfield and we regard the proposals positively. We want the line to be constructed, but we need to find the right solution to the safety considerations and operational aspects of the scheme.
I take it from your answer that the SRU fully recognises the improved access to Murrayfield, particularly on match days, that would flow from the construction of the tramline.
We do.
Am I right in thinking that the stacking provision is tailor made to accommodate the requirements of the SRU and the stadium's operations?
The proposed stacking area will help to disperse crowds at the end of games.
Against that background, if the worst were to happen and for some reason Network Rail went back on the indications that it has given about its approval of the promoter's current proposed design, with the result that something akin to an embankment solution was required, which resulted in some incursion into SRU land immediately to the south of the stadium, would the SRU look favourably at what have been described as rejigging arrangements, to enable space for an adequate, safe, east-west pedestrian route to be created?
That highlights the current problem. We have been working with the promoter on the issue for the best part of three years. It is easy to say that, with a little rejigging at the southern end of the stadium, everything can be accommodated. Those who know the site, however, know that it is quite tight at the southern boundary. I do not know how many committee members have been round the southern part of the stadium on match days, but if they have they will know that it is extremely tight and congested. We are happy to continue to work with the promoter to try to reach an appropriate solution. How easy that will be I do not know. The easiest solution would be if Network Rail were to give permission for the pillar that will support the tramway to oversail the east-west spectator link to allow a free flow of pedestrians, as is currently required under the safety certificate. However, if there are other options, I am happy to look at them.The difficulty for us, as I understand the situation, is that this is the last chance for the SRU to make representations on the bill as it goes through its process. Therefore, we are looking at proposals that might help to resolve our problems in the future. If we had the opportunity to come back to the committee in two or three months and say, "We have worked through the issues and there have been proposals from the promoter that are acceptable to us," I would welcome that. Until we are at that stage, however, we will be forced to continue with our objection to highlight our concerns.
As a general proposition and against a background of the benefits that will accrue to the SRU from the tram proposal, is there a continuing willingness on the part of the SRU to work with the promoter to try to find solutions to problems as and when they arise?
As I said, we are keen for that work to take place. We will continue to engage with the promoter to try to resolve the problems. We want to be positive about the process and we will continue to be so.
As there are no further questions from the committee and no re-examination by Dr Sales, I thank Mr Ireland.Mark Fisher will now address the issues of stadium operation, Network Rail safety, flood prevention and disruption.
I would like to look at some of the issues that are still in dispute according to the rebuttal of your witness statement by Mr Murray. Let us think first about the main points of objection as referred to in that rebuttal statement on page 2. Your concern was that the LOD and LLAU proposals would remove SRU control over a strategic part of Murrayfield stadium. In response, it was said that the general LLAU and LOD area has been reduced. Is that your experience of where the negotiations have led us?
We have had a number of detailed discussions in the past three or four weeks, which have provided some of the backdrop to this committee's work. We have, in a number of different plans and proposals, reviewed the use of the LLAU, but not the LOD so much, in the southern part of the stadium. That has allowed the SRU to gain some comfort that, with the operation of the proposed tram, it would still be able to control that part of the stadium. There are, however, other issues that relate to the construction and permanent works aspects.
In relation to the thorny issue of whether Network Rail's approval will be forthcoming, how confident are you today that that approval will materialise?
My general view about Network Rail approval is that it involves a fairly difficult and tortuous process. I have added to my rebuttal statement in an appendix a definition of the rail support zone. I have experience in the rail environment and understand the associated issues. It will take some time to gain Network Rail approval for the proposals. At this stage, the designer who represents TIE will not be carrying on with the formal design works of the proposed permanent works; TIE will employ another party to do that. TIE has had no discussions with Network Rail at the present time.
Considering where things stand today, will you hazard a guess as to how soon such approval may be forthcoming?
I guess that it will take a number of months.
In your view, if approval for use of the heavy rail embankment is not forthcoming for whatever reason, what consequences will that have?
Obviously, we have discussed that point in general. If the approval was not forthcoming, the limits of deviation that are highlighted in the bill would become the edge of the proposed permanent works and consideration would be given to using alternative forms of construction such as a retaining wall structure. Such a structure would reduce the width of the east-west spectator link and would mean that the south part of the stadium would need to be reconfigured. My witness statement and rebuttal promote the view, which we have promoted for the past 12 to 14 months, that that position needs to be reviewed.
I will move on to another aspect of your evidence. If an overhead structure such as a flyover or bridge was not possible for whatever reason, would that have any consequences for flooding issues?
As the information that is before the committee indicates, the limits of deviation for the back pitches need to comply with flood prevention legislation, given the proposed construction of a flood wall in the zone that is highlighted. If the tramline was constructed on the limits of deviation for the tram scheme, that would mean that the flood wall would need to move outwith the limits of deviation for the tram scheme. In other words, the flood wall scheme that is before the Scottish Executive would need to change.
So the question of Network Rail approval is critical from a number of points of view, as it affects more than just the location of the permanent and temporary works that are proposed in the bill.
Indeed.
In this meeting
Everything on 28 Jun 2005 →- Scottish Parliament Edinburgh Tram (Line Two) Bill Committee Tuesday 28 June 2005 Bill debate · 1
- Proposed Route Changes Committee business · 1
- Consideration Stage Committee business · 222
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.