Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Petitions

Ferry Service (Gourock to Dunoon) (PE1035)

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

11 contributions
Patrick Harvie Green The Convener · Glasgow
link

The next petition is PE1035, by John Rose, which calls on the Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to withdraw direct and indirect support for CalMac Ferries on the Dunoon to Gourock ferry service and to ensure full transparency of Government subsidy of ferry services. The issue clearly relates not only to our current work but to on-going matters in Europe. Do members have any comments?

David Stewart Lab Highlands and Islands
link

You have predicted what I was about to say, convener. The fact is that we are carrying out a comprehensive inquiry into ferry services throughout Scotland. Some work has been done on the Gourock to Dunoon service. Shirley-Anne Somerville, the clerk and I were also present at a meeting at which we met the boards of CalMac Ferries and Western Ferries.The petition raises a specialist issue. As members will be aware, there is a long history behind the service, which I am not—you will be pleased to hear—going to rehearse. A Dunoon constituent said to me that it is like the Schleswig-Holstein question: only three people have ever understood it, and one of them is dead, one is mad and the last one has forgotten it.I am very reluctant to arbitrate in a debate over whether public is bad and private is good: we have to take a more sophisticated approach. I have asked a number of parliamentary questions on issues such as frequency restriction which, as we know, applies to CalMac and which the Government has said it has no plans to change. I have also asked about European state aid issues, but it appears that nothing is going to happen in that respect until the European Commission investigation into ferry services is concluded.We should put ourselves in the shoes of people who live in Gourock and Dunoon. I appreciate that members have other views on the matter, but my feeling is that many people in the area want a good service with good frequency and prices. In other words, they want two services. It will not help for us to make a particular judgment on the petition. Instead, we should note the specific requests but cover in our inquiry the issues that are raised in the petition and that we are currently investigating. The issue might well arise in any chamber debate that we might secure.As we have not examined all the details, it is not really fair for us to carry out a complete analysis of the matter. Equally, given that we do not have all the evidence, it would be a mistake to make a hard and fast ruling on the petition. In any case, the petition raises a much wider question that requires much more debate, not least with the European Commission, whose response will not be known for another 18 months.

Alex Johnstone Con North East Scotland
link

I start from a slightly different position but come to a similar conclusion. People may be aware that my opinion—some might say my prejudices—tend to take me with the petitioner. However, it would be inappropriate for us to prejudge the position that we will take in our inquiry. Although I agree with the vast majority of the points that the petitioner makes, I do not support the suggestion that we should urge the Scottish Executive to withdraw direct funding from the service at this time.

Cathy Peattie Lab Falkirk East
link

I would not urge the Scottish Executive to withdraw funding from the service at all—I take the opposite view. It is scary to see that my notes on the petition are almost identical to those of Neil Kay. I have real problems with some of the information that the petitioner has submitted. We will await the conclusion of our ferry inquiry, but I am concerned that a private company has submitted a petition to the committee. What is to stop private bus companies submitting petitions against Lothian Buses, or other private sector operators submitting petitions against local authorities in relation to service bids? I have a problem with the nature of the petition but, like other members, I am prepared to await the outcome of our inquiry and the Commission's investigation.

Patrick Harvie Green The Convener · Glasgow
link

Members do not seem inclined to agree to the terms of the petition; at the present time, I do not agree to them, either. We may want to explore the issues that it raises with the Minister for Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change. Some may arise in the normal course of our ferries inquiry, but there may be issues that we have not explored in great detail. It is reasonable for us to seek from the Scottish Government information on the timetable for the Government's work on the matter and on the European Commission process. Do members agree?Members indicated agreement.

Patrick Harvie Green The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do members want to keep the petition open and to return to it in the future, after we have received information in response to our letter to the minister?

Charlie Gordon Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

We should close the petition formally but treat it as evidence in our broader ferries inquiry.

Patrick Harvie Green The Convener · Glasgow
link

Do members agree to close the petition and to consider it as evidence during our ferries inquiry?Members indicated agreement.

Patrick Harvie Green The Convener · Glasgow
link

We will write to the minister in the terms that I have suggested.

  1. Scottish Parliament Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee Tuesday 27 May 2008 Committee business · 1
  2. Budget Adviser Committee business · 8
  3. Petitions Petitions · 10
  4. Petitions Petitions · 11
  5. Work Programme Procedure · 43
  6. Annual Report Committee business · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.