Good afternoon. Thank you for inviting us to give evidence and for doing the introductions for me.I have been the non-executive chairman of the David MacBrayne group since 2006, having previously been a non-executive director of Caledonian MacBrayne since 2000 and of both NorthLink companies since 2002. I have lived on the isle of Bute for the past 27 years.The committee has heard and received considerable evidence to date and has received documentation from us, so I shall confine my remarks to three topics.First, although Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd now has responsibility for the Clyde and Hebrides ships, piers and terminals, we still have most of the staff for and all the experience of looking after and operating the services.Many people offer the view that the shortest distance between an island and the mainland, together with the fastest vessel, offers the shortest journey time, greatest frequency and most capacity. However, that ignores the cost of implementing such an upheaval in terms of the 30-plus-year service life of the existing fleet, together with the present ports and mainland infrastructure.We operate all year round in some of the most severe weather in Europe. Our vessels are designed for that and are custom built, mostly with shallow draughts and narrow beams to fit the limited access at many of the ports that we serve. Of course, we do not sail when conditions are so bad that they are unsafe, yet many passengers nowadays expect us to operate whatever the weather.It has been suggested that instead of replacing vessels like for like, we should be innovative and replace one large monohull with two smaller and faster catamarans. We have commissioned an independent study of the advantages and disadvantages of operating a catamaran compared with a conventional ferry on the Uig–Lochmaddy–Tarbert routes. That study might be available before the committee reaches its conclusions, and we would be happy to provide you with a summary of the outcomes.The whole of the west coast United Kingdom ferry industry is hugely interested to see how the Pentalina B operates in bad weather when it comes into service on the Pentland Firth later this summer. It is rarely noted that we already operate a small catamaran between Gourock and Dunoon and all our experience, and that of some Irish Sea operators, is that a monohull will continue to run in bad weather when a catamaran has long been tied up due to Maritime and Coastguard Agency wave height restrictions.Secondly, both NorthLink and CalMac engage with and consult communities, hauliers, and ferry users and will continue to do so. Both companies and the then Scottish Executive undertook significant consultation to take account of community views before publishing the detailed tender specifications.Speaking personally, I regret that the shipping services advisory committees have been discontinued, because they gave us and our customers a formal opportunity twice a year in which to discuss collectively the very issues about which you have heard complaints. Now we engage directly with each community separately, and in some cases with more than one group with differing views within the same community. In the past 12 months, some of our directors and managers have visited virtually every one of our destinations and consulted community representatives and business sectors formally and informally.I will point out some of the differences between the two companies. CalMac operates about 30 ships on 24 routes, whereas NorthLink operates five ships on three routes. We operate about 350 services a day in the west, but there are just about 10 a day to the northern isles. Each year, about 5 million passengers use the Clyde and Hebrides services; NorthLink carries little more than 300,000. CalMac's vessel turnaround times between sailings are generally short. It can take 20 minutes to disembark up to 1,000 passengers and embark another 1,000, which makes flexibility somewhat difficult. In contrast, NorthLink's turnarounds are long, which makes flexibility somewhat easier for it.We both provide some services that operate at or near vessel capacity in summer, yet in winter we might have to sail with just a handful of passengers. You have heard evidence about the competing needs of different sections of communities, the perishable nature of island produce and the wishes of the retail trade for fresh product to be delivered early. In some cases, there is only a limited opportunity for visitors and residents to spend time at opposite ends of the same route; in others, there is a need to cater for sporting interests and other socioeconomic needs.With such a wide variety of user needs and volumes, we appreciate that we are not going to be able to please everyone all of the time, but we are certainly trying to do so. We are much more proactive with our customers today, partly through innovative marketing, including award-winning website activity and television advertising. Incidentally, there will be a CalMac advert at half-time during the UEFA cup final. We are setting new, higher standards for our publications. We are helping to market some destinations to fill a gap that is not serviced by communities or local businesses. We use independent surveys to monitor service quality and to arbitrate on local issues, for example on Bute and Mull. We give significant support to community and cultural events. We are committed to the national plan for Gaelic. We also have much closer relationships now with other public bodies such as the National Trust for Scotland, Historic Scotland, VisitScotland and Highlands and Islands Enterprise.NorthLink's customer care programmes benefited from a new company ethos from the very start, but it is taking a while longer to implement such programmes in CalMac, where attitudes that have been developed over decades are being overcome. I would be the first to agree that we could improve still further, and there is evidence to support the view that our performance is often better than it is portrayed. You will have heard it said that CalMac has a take-it-or-leave-it attitude, that it is unhelpful, that it will not listen or that it operates to the benefit of its crews rather than its customers. Those views are often a result of our inability to meet the service improvement or ticket price demands of some, which might be due to hours-of-work restrictions, to vessel or port unavailability, or simply to affordability factors.Thirdly, our public service contracts are prescriptive. They specify which vessels to use on which routes, the precise timetables to operate and the prices to charge. They include a performance regime that requires services to arrive within a specified time, and there are heavy financial penalties for service failures, although a number of relief events are detailed to provide for matters outside our control, such as having to wait for delayed public transport or essential lifeline produce.We are expected to innovate whenever possible, and we are keen to do so. However, in order to adjust any aspect of our services—except to reduce fares at our risk—we must initially consult interested parties in the community involved to procure their broad agreement, and then we must seek the approval of the Scottish ministers to vary the contract. That is relatively straightforward if there are no extra costs, but it is much more complex when additional costs are incurred, particularly in the context of the recent spending review.We understand the wish of communities for more frequent or earlier or later sailings, or for other service improvements, and we acknowledge that the cost of ferry travel represents a barrier to economic welfare. However, those are ultimately matters of policy for the Scottish Government. We discussed fares reviews with previous Administrations, but we were told that the level of grant could not change under the circumstances. With that restriction, any fare reductions would have been accompanied by corresponding fare increases elsewhere. Understandably, ministers were not keen to proceed. In that context, the road equivalent tariff study is to be welcomed, although its impact on demand and capacity will not be clear until it has operated for some years. I hope that you find my remarks helpful.