PE1064 is on the replacement Forth crossing. We have discussed the Forth crossing at previous meetings in several different contexts, but the petition is specifically on the proposal that there should be a replacement or new crossing.The clerk's paper invites us to: note the Government's decision to proceed with a replacement crossing; note the response from the Forth Estuary Transport Authority; and consider whether, in light of the Government's decision, the objectives of the petition remain realistic and, if not, whether the petition should be closed.From the Public Petitions Committee's consideration of the petition, the petitioner might reasonably have expected that the petition would receive some further level of scrutiny. The strong impression was given that our committee was looking into the issue, whereas we were considering only the issue of tolls on the existing road bridge. That was the nature of our visit to the bridge, but people might not have drawn that impression from the comments that were made at the Public Petitions Committee. Referring to our committee, the convener of that committee agreed that"the debate needs to be aired clearly at that committee".—Official Report, Public Petitions Committee, 23 October 2007; c 215.Some members—including those who know him—might feel that the convener of the Public Petitions Committee made a bit of a presumption about the work of our committee, but the petitioner was clearly given that expectation.Finally, given recent public comments in the media to the effect that the First Minister has given a commitment to the Road Haulage Association that the existing bridge will not be closed to heavy goods vehicles on the date previously suggested, some questions remain open that we could explore in considering the petition.Do members have any comments?
I take the point that has been made, but I am reluctant to agree that we should deal with the petition in a particular way because of a miscommunication on the part of the Public Petitions Committee. The convener has clarified that we did not visit the bridge to discuss the replacement crossing so I think that we can put that aspect to bed.We had a full statement in the chamber on the replacement crossing so, although the committee has not discussed the issue, the Parliament has discussed it at length. I appreciate that the Government's decision did not win unanimous support among all parties, but it was well supported by most parties in the Parliament. I think that the issue has had a sufficiently detailed airing to have allowed all the parties to put their points, so I am not sure that much more remains to be said. The repair work is perhaps a separate issue, on which it might be interesting to be kept up to date. I think that we decided on that when we visited FETA, which said that it would keep us abreast of what was happening. I am reluctant to take the petition further on the basis that we have not had enough debate on the issue, given that it has been considered in the chamber.
I agree. The Parliament has already agreed—albeit not unanimously—on the need for a new crossing. We will continue to need to consider issues such as access for heavy good vehicles, but we should not confuse that with the issue of the replacement crossing. We should close the petition because, in a sense, things have moved on.
Members will not be surprised to learn that my preference is for us to write to the Government in light of the First Minister's recent reported comments, which appeared subsequent to the ministerial statement and which throw a different light on the issue. Is there any support for that view?
I find myself in a minority on this. It seems to me that the mood of the committee is to close the petition, so we will close it.That was the final item of business, so I close the meeting but ask members to stay on for a brief moment.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.