Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Work Programme

Speakers

Showing Patrick Harvie only · show everyone

Patrick Harvie’s contributions

12 contributions
Patrick Harvie Green The Convener · Glasgow
link

Agenda item 3 is on our work programme. Members recently had the opportunity to suggest issues to add to our work programme for the coming months. Paper TIC/S3/08/1/2 lists the various suggestions that members have come up with, which I will run through quickly. The suggested issues are the costs of public transport, in light of recent increases; the development of air routes to and from Scotland; the role, responsibility and performance of Highlands and Islands Airports Ltd; school travel plan co-ordinators; the rail service from Glasgow and Edinburgh to Inverness; the development of high-speed rail links to England; and options for introducing direct rail links to Europe via the Channel tunnel.I will kick off with my views and then open out the discussion. The final two issues, on rail links to England and the continent, are hugely important, but they are potentially bigger issues than we will have time to consider in the gap in our work programme that we want to fill. Although I advocate strongly that the Scottish Parliament should have a role in developing the case for such rail links in the longer term, there is no clear, simple and specific piece of work that we can do on that in the short term.We recently considered the development of air routes in our examination of the Government's budget and we will have further opportunity to debate the issue in the Parliament, so I am not sure that a specific, discrete inquiry by the committee would add anything. My preference is to consider either school travel plan co-ordinators or public transport costs, given the recent increases. I am sure that members from other parts of the country will have similar experiences but, in the peak period, Glasgow to Edinburgh commuters are now asked to pay getting on for £18. A case can be made for examining the impact of rail and bus fares on the Government's aspiration to get meaningful modal shift.Those are my initial thoughts. I open up the discussion to members.

Patrick Harvie Green The Convener · Glasgow
link

To answer your first point, paragraph 1 in the paper states that we have an opportunity to do a piece of work that covers two or three evidence sessions and to produce a report with recommendations.

Patrick Harvie Green The Convener · Glasgow
link

If we were to consider those issues, I would be entirely supportive of considering the whole country. I gave the one example of a journey earlier only because it was the one that I have made most recently.

Patrick Harvie Green The Convener · Glasgow
link

Are you suggesting that as something more substantial for us to do in next year's work programme?

Patrick Harvie Green The Convener · Glasgow
link

I certainly agree with your point about the comparative cost of different modes of transport. If we are looking to understand why people make certain decisions and what their incentives are, we need to make that comparison. Again, though, that reinforces the point that that is probably a more major piece of work.There seems to be a lot of open-mindedness to the idea of a more substantial piece of work on public transport, including the future generally for rail travel in Scotland, bearing in mind the need to consider all parts of Scotland and not just the areas that are already well served. However, perhaps that is something more substantial for next year's work programme.If we are thinking about doing something short—however dirty or otherwise it might be, Charlie—we are probably talking about having two or three meetings to consider something much more discrete. Several members have mentioned the school travel plan co-ordinators. Is there anything else from the list in the committee paper that people would prefer us to take as our topic?

Patrick Harvie Green The Convener · Glasgow
link

I suggested that we consider that issue because, although there are elements of the costs of all the different modes of transport that the Scottish Parliament and the Scottish Government can do nothing about, there are elements of them that we can do something about. I was interested in discussing the balance that can be struck and which of those mechanisms we are using.

Patrick Harvie Green The Convener · Glasgow
link

Two topics seem to be getting support. It is suggested that we do something short and focused on rail travel in general or on the prices of public transport in general—I am not sure which of those members support. The other topic concerns school travel. Can I see a show of hands? Who supports a discussion of school travel? Thank you. Who supports a discussion of rail/public transport? Thank you. We are probably going to have to thrash out a fairly specific remit for our consideration of the issues based on the discussion that we have had. Steve Farrell suggests that we give a nod towards either something aspirational or something that is about costs. It seems to me that a proper examination of the costs of public transport is hugely important but probably requires a lot more work than we are going to have time for. Is that agreed?

Patrick Harvie Green The Convener · Glasgow
link

Okay. Is that enough to be going on with?

Patrick Harvie Green The Convener · Glasgow
link

I think that we have enough to be going on with. I thank members for their attendance. Does the committee agree to delegate to me and to the clerks the tasks of identifying relevant witnesses and of updating the committee's work programme on the website to take account of our discussion?Members indicated agreement.

  1. Scottish Parliament Transport, Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee Tuesday 15 January 2008 Committee business · 1
  2. Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 5
  3. Forth Crossing Committee business · 140
  4. Work Programme Procedure · 29

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.