PE508 is on the implementation of environmental impact assessments, about which we took evidence from the Deputy Minister for Social Justice two weeks ago.I look to members for guidance on how they wish the committee to deal with the petition. We could decide to conclude our consideration of the petition by noting the Executive's willingness to consider undertaking research into environmental impact assessments. Obviously, that research would also consider whether consultation with communities should be beefed up. It would then be open to the committee to decide whether it was satisfied with the outcome and conclusions of the Executive's research.Another option would be to make a firm recommendation that such research be carried out and to draw to the Executive's attention specific areas that we think should fall within the remit of the research. What are members' views on how we should conclude our consideration of the petition?
Official Report · Committee
Petitions
Planning Process (PE508)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Bristow Muldoon Lab 5
- John Scott Con 3
- Robin Harper Green 2
- Bruce Crawford SNP 2
- Nora Radcliffe LD 2
- Maureen Macmillan Lab 1
The record
17 contributionsI agree with the recommendation that is given and I agree with everything that the convener has said. Further research should be carried out, particularly on whether there are conflicts of interest. If independent research could determine whether the problem was real or imagined, that would put minds at rest.
I would like to see further research not only on terrestrial EIAs, but on EIAs for aquaculture. There is a crying need for a review of the way in which such EIAs are implemented.
For a second, I thought that Robin Harper was about to ask for research into extra-terrestrial EIAs.
Given this morning's announcement of the discovery of 120 soundings from extra-terrestrial bodies, perhaps Robin Harper is closer to the reality than we expected.
That probably falls outwith our brief.
Yes. It probably comes under culture, as you cannot get hold of it.I think that we should perhaps go a bit further than asking for more research. Before we heard evidence from the minister and his officials on future strategic planning issues, we discussed whether it might be wise to ask the Executive to respond to the issues that the petition raises by including the whole area of environmental assessments in its review of strategic planning. We should go that step further by saying that we expect environmental assessments to be part of that wider strategic review. So far, the Executive has not said that it would do that. When and if a bill or new regulations are placed in front of us, we would then have research material and could get witnesses round the table to discuss the issue.
I would not want us to give the impression that EIAs are necessarily flawed because they are conducted by the person who wants the development. Robin Harper mentioned aquaculture. I have seen the EIAs that the fish farming firms have done—those assessments are detailed and extremely thick and I have no doubt that they are done well. I do not want us to give the impression that we think that there is some sort of sleight of hand. There might be problems occasionally, of course.
We are being asked what issues the research should address. People might think the process more transparent if the planning authority commissioned the EIA and charged the developer to recover costs. That would not cost anyone any more money, but it might give people more confidence in the system.
Just as we expect to deal with a nature conservation bill in the next session of Parliament, we may want to deal with environmental assessments through the new planning bill that whoever forms the Government after the election will introduce in the next session. We should ask the Executive to deal with the matter in that way.
On the concerns of the petitioner, we should ask for the research to be carried out with a view to revising planning advice note 58. That should address some of the petitioner's concerns.
If we said that there should be a revision before we have carried out the research, we would be in danger of making decisions before analysing the evidence.I am picking up that members support research into EIAs and want to recommend that the Executive conduct such research. We seem to feel that that research should consider statutory requirement for public consultation in advance of the production of an EIA, the weight that is given to evidence produced by SNH and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency and the role that the EIA has in influencing the decisions of planning committees. We could also mention Bruce Crawford's comment about including EIAs in the strategic review.
We should add the issue of whether the body that commissions the EIA should be the planning authority or the developer.
That can be added. Do members agree to write to the Executive making those points and to conclude consideration of the petition, writing to the petitioner to advise him of the recommendations that we are making?Members indicated agreement.
Before we begin the next item on our agenda, we will suspend the meeting to allow the minister and his officials to take their seats.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 18 Mar 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Transport and the Environment Committee Tuesday 18 March 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 2
- Items in Private Procedure · 1
- Petitions Petitions · 15
- Petitions Petitions · 17
- Railways and Transport Safety Bill Bill debate · 18
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.