Item 5 is the draft Air Quality (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2002. I welcome Ross Finnie to the meeting to speak to the regulations, which are subject to the affirmative procedure. I should point out for the record that the minister has other engagements and has to leave by 12.50. As we have to get through this and two other agenda items, I ask members and the minister to be as concise as possible in their questions and answers.A note on the regulations has been circulated to members. Following the usual procedure, I will give members the opportunity to put questions to the minister and the officials before we have a substantive policy debate on the regulations. The minister will then move a motion asking us to approve the regulations. However, before I invite members to ask their questions, I give the minister an opportunity to make his opening remarks.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Air Quality (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2002 (Draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ross Finnie LD 7
- Bristow Muldoon Lab 3
- Antje Branding Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 3
- John Scott Con 3
- Robin Harper Green 2
- Nora Radcliffe LD 2
- Maureen Macmillan Lab 2
The record
25 contributionsThank you very much. I am pleased to speak to the regulations, which set tough new limits for three pollutants: benzene, carbon monoxide and particles. I want to stress that air quality in Scotland is generally good. However, evidence from our health experts shows that we cannot afford to be complacent. Indeed, the Committee on the Medical Effects of Air Pollutants reported last year that the health effects of long-term particle air pollution might be at least 10 times greater than the short-term effect of day-to-day changes in particle levels that was reported in 1998. The committee concluded that cutting particulate air pollution is likely to be much more beneficial to health than we had previously thought. That message is important.As a result, the requirement for local authorities to undertake a review and assessment of air quality in their areas is at the core of the air quality strategy. We must ensure that most local authorities are able to meet all the objectives by the required dates. That leaves only the hotspots in our city centres in Aberdeen, Edinburgh and Glasgow where air quality management areas have been declared on the basis of transport-related nitrogen dioxide emissions.The current objectives for benzene, carbon monoxide and particles are likely to be met by the prescribed dates. In the case of benzene and particles, the policy aim of the new regulations is to give local authorities additional long-term targets to move towards. However, the progress that has been made towards meeting the current limits for carbon monoxide means that it can be directly replaced by a more stringent objective.A new, long-term annual target is proposed for benzene, and is to be met by the end of 2010. It is based on the recommendation of the expert panel on air quality standards and supplements the current objective. A tougher objective for carbon monoxide replaces the current one, but has the same target date of the end of 2003. That is based on the limit value in the second European Union air quality daughter directive. New, long-term 24-hour and annual objectives for particles are being introduced, which are to be met by the end of 2010 and will supplement the current objectives that are to be met by the end of 2004.Last year, we completed a range of reviews that we have used to inform our proposals, which will set tough, long-term objectives for particles. As the research and modelling work showed that we could set tougher targets, we have decided to adopt that approach. The new objective will be more than 50 per cent lower than the current one. The fact that it will also be tougher than the objectives proposed for the rest of the UK and for London reflects the high standard of air quality that we already enjoy in Scotland.Furthermore, we will be reducing the number of exceedences allowed of the 24-hour mean particles objective from 35 per year to seven. That will make the 24-hour objective at least as tough as the one in the original 1997 strategy. The new objective will be challenging, but our modelling work suggests that it will be no more so than the less stringent objectives elsewhere in the UK. That will be the first departure from a UK-wide approach to the strategy. Due to the trans-boundary nature of our air pollutants, it is appropriate to have an air quality strategy presented in a document covering all parts. Nonetheless, our air quality is a fully devolved issue and we feel that we are free to advance policies that reflect our own specific circumstances, which are reflected in the new regulations.
Thank you for those comments, minister. Robin Harper has the first question.
We were told last week that the long-term objective for traffic control, rather than traffic reduction, was to achieve traffic levels in 2020 that are limited more or less to the present traffic levels. If controlling traffic levels, rather than reducing traffic, is the sole overall objective in Scotland, how can that feed into achieving the reductions in air pollution and the targets that you are now setting for 2010?
As you said, that is the only published standard that we have set at the moment. I have made it clear in all the contributions and discussions on setting targets and indicators that it is an evolving process. A range of measurements are used to measure the effects of pollution but not to show the impact from some of the sources of pollution. Governments throughout Europe have acknowledged that we need measures not only of the level of pollution, but also of the sources of pollution and their contribution to the overall targets. We believe that setting standards for air quality measurement and testing for benzene and carbon monoxide particles as outlined in the strategy can be achieved within the current programmes. I whole-heartedly agree with Robin Harper that there is a lot more to be done on measuring pollution produced by road traffic, and the overall aim of stabilising car use is but part of that. However, the air quality strategy puts greater impositions on the regulations for traffic in towns and on local authority controls of heavy vehicle emissions. The strategy places an obligation on local authorities to take action against those over whom they currently have control and to exercise that control more strictly. If local authorities do not do that, they will be in breach of the regulations.
I have a rough figure that shows that about 80 per cent of pollution comes from 20 per cent of vehicles, which consistently break emissions regulations through poorly maintained engines. Has there been any discussion about how to address that problem?
I am aware that the imposition of the regulations has certainly opened up discussion as to how that can be achieved. As I said, that will not only create a much heavier obligation to test for emissions, but will create a fallback position in which a failure to reduce emissions will constitute a failure to impose the regulations, as set out in the EU directive. In a sense, the stick that has been absent will come into play with the coming into force of the regulations.
We are talking about PM10s, referring to the size of the particulate matter. I believe that there is evidence that smaller particles are actually more hazardous. Is any work being done to investigate whether we should be considering smaller particulate matter in tightening up the regulations as we progress towards better air quality?
You are right to say that medical evidence has emerged recently to show that it is particulate matter smaller than 2.5 micromillimetres that causes the worst health effects. The expert panel on air quality standards looked into the matter of whether the measurement based on PM10s—particles slightly bigger than PM2.5s—would still be adequate to protect human health. After considering all the evidence, the expert panel concluded that a particles objective based on the PM10 measurement would be the best standard. Although the health effects of PM2.5s are recognised, there are also the effects of those particles in the range between PM2.5 and PM10. By setting the standard at PM10, all those particle sizes can be encompassed and better protection of human health can be achieved. The expert panel on air quality standards will keep the matter under review as new evidence is produced.
Thank you. That is helpful.
Most of the policy measures to reduce particle emissions are targeting the small fraction of PM2.5s. It is that fraction that will be reduced.
Are these particles emitted from the internal combustion engine, or are you talking about pollution more generally?
They are particles emitted from vehicles and industrial processes. Particles are also re-suspended from the roads while vehicles are passing, by the rub of the tyres. We are targeting all those particles.
Minister, You said that most local authorities would be able to deal with the emissions. You then said that city centres were exceptions and would be exempted from air quality management areas. Is that right? I am not quite sure what you were describing, minister.
I do not think that we are exempting such areas. We have had to change the compliance dates for city centres, as they are hotspots. We have declared them air quality management areas to bring them up to speed. Regrettably, we may have to extend some of the deadlines, but we have not lost sight of the imperative to control pollution or the need to designate air quality management areas. Over a period, we have not been meeting the targets, but we are determined that we will establish the conditions in which we can meet the targets. That is why we have established these air quality management areas.
I am interested in the pollution from benzene that is given off from petrol. I understand that a new type of petrol pump is being introduced to address that problem, which will incur a considerable cost to filling stations. Will you do anything to help more remote, rural filling stations to meet the costs that the new standards will incur, or is that not part of the regulations?
There is nothing in the regulations that requires Scottish ministers to provide subsidies to the international oil companies.
With respect, I am not talking about the oil companies. I am talking about the operators of small, rural garages.
Yes, but who imposes a price for general consumption?
The Government.
Well, is it? We are now talking about something slightly different. Taxation is not within my remit. My purpose in introducing the regulations is to set standards. I hope that all producers of materials that emit particles during their use will have regard to the need to meet those standards. If someone engages in the provision of materials that cause emissions, they must have regard to the impact on the economy of unnecessarily imposing additional cost. I will have to look at the details. You refer to the possible cost, but I will have to investigate the matter before I can give a definitive answer on it.
As members have no other questions, I ask the minister to move motion S1M-2984.
Motion moved,
That the Transport and the Environment Committee recommends that the draft Air Quality (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2002 be approved.—Ross Finnie.
Motion agreed to.
In this meeting
Everything on 8 May 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Transport and the Environment Committee Wednesday 8 May 2002 (Morning) Committee business · 3
- Petitions Petitions · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 25
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 33
- Petition Petitions · 37
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.