Item 2 is consideration of an affirmative instrument. Members will have received a covering note on the regulations. They are laid under affirmative procedure, which means that Parliament must approve them before their provisions come into force. With that in mind, the sponsoring minister, Iain Gray, has lodged a motion that asks the Transport and the Environment Committee to recommend approval of the regulations. Margaret Curran is a supporter of the motion and is here to speak to it.The Subordinate Legislation Committee considered the regulations at its meeting on 29 January and determined that the attention of Parliament need not be drawn to them. As we are required to report on the regulations by 9 March, we will follow the usual procedure for handling affirmative instruments. First, I will give members the opportunity to ask the minister and her official any questions that they might have about the regulations. I should point out that the questions should be genuine questions of clarification and should not stray into a substantive debate about policy.After we have done that, I will ask the minister to move the motion. Other members will then have the opportunity to contribute to a formal debate on the motion, which must last no longer than 90 minutes. As Mr Scott—the Executive official, not the MSP—will not be able to participate at that stage, I ask members to raise any questions that he could assist with during the question-and-answer session.I believe that John Scott seeks some clarification.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Town and Country Planning (Fees for Applications and Deemed Applications) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2002
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Bristow Muldoon Lab 7
- Margaret Curran Lab 6
- Mike Scott Scottish Executive Development Department 3
- Robin Harper Green 3
- Des McNulty Lab 2
- John Scott Con 1
The record
25 contributionsThat is right. Actually, I have already intimated my question to the minister. Are the size of the fee increases outlined in the regulations in line with inflation and the retail price index? Furthermore, when were the fees last reviewed? That information would give us some indication of whether the increases are in line with inflation.
I am sorry, minister. I meant to give you the chance to say a few brief words about the regulations before we started. I now invite you to make some introductory remarks. Perhaps you could also take Mr Scott's question into account, if you feel that that would be appropriate.
Thank you very much. I am very pleased to be here this morning. This is my first appearance before the Transport and the Environment Committee, and I am sure that I will be back for more. Depending on how I get on today, I might or might not be looking forward to that prospect.The regulations introduce new levels of planning fees which, if approved by the committee, will come into effect on 1 April 2002. I should make it clear that fees are not intended to address the full costs of development control as such costs include pre-application discussions, appeals and other non-qualifying activities. They are designed to cover only the costs of processing planning applications.The Scottish ministers consider that the increase strikes the right balance between full recovery and the likely impact on the potential developer. Fees remain a very small part—considerably less than 1 per cent—of developers' costs and there is no evidence that they act as a deterrent to development. At the domestic property end of the scale, very few householders pay any fee at all as most minor development in this area does not require a planning application.I want to highlight some indicative figures. The minimum fee for a factory or office development would rise from the current level of £210 to £220 on 1 April while the maximum for the same categories would increase by £500 to £11,000 for a building of 3,750 sq m or more. An application to build a new house will attract a fee of £220, whereas substantial alterations to a domestic property would be charged at £110.The Scottish ministers believe that users and potential beneficiaries of the development control system should meet the costs incurred in determining planning applications which otherwise would fall to be met by payers of council tax and business rates generally. Even after taking into account the increase in fees proposed in the regulations, I feel that planning application fee levels continue to be modest and represent a very small proportion of developers' overall costs.On John Scott's specific questions, planning fees were previously increased in June 2000. Local authorities have provided financial data which, when adjusted to remove inadmissible costs, demonstrate that recovery stands at 95 per cent against the policy target of full recovery. Although I acknowledge John Scott's point that that figure is slightly above the level of inflation, we must remember that fee levels were previously reviewed more than 18 months ago. Furthermore, the information on which the calculations are founded is based on data that relate to local authorities' past performances uprated to reflect current trends. As a result, it has been clearly demonstrated that we need to bridge a gap between actual and target objectives. The increase in fees not only addresses the recognised shortfall, but takes into account an element for inflation.
Thank you. Do any other members have questions?
I want to ask the minister about the maximums that local authorities are allowed to charge in relation to planning applications. For example, in the Milngavie area, a large and very controversial application has been submitted for a water treatment plant, which will cover a substantial amount of land. The cost to the local authority of processing that application will vastly exceed the maximum that the authority can charge the applicant.When major public investments raise a series of planning issues on which the local authority is more or less forced to seek and pay for expert advice, is it reasonable that there should be a flat maximum charge of the kind that exists at present? Should the legislation be amended to allow for special circumstances—such as the nature of the application or the degree of controversy over it—that involve local authorities in costs that are in excess of those in other circumstances?
Many serious points about the way in which the planning system works were embedded in Des McNulty's question. We will give serious consideration to the matter in terms of his constituency interests and other related interests. I will let Mike Scott come in on some of the specific issues. The Scottish Executive development department has given considerable consideration to the operation of planning instruments and to the levers that we might use to address some of the serious issues that Des McNulty mentioned.Broadly speaking, it is appropriate to keep the fee system as straightforward as possible and not to overcomplicate matters, which might happen if we had to vary the system according to local circumstances or to individual planning applications. I am sure that some people and local authorities would suggest that special circumstances pertained to all applications, which would lead to a complex and over-bureaucratic system of fees for applications. The development department has considered the matter. Mike Scott might want to colour in the details.
It must be remembered that the planning fee system is a balancing act. The policy objective of 100 per cent recovery of costs applies Scotland-wide, not to each of the 32 councils. Under the regulations, the type of application that Mr McNulty mentioned will cost £11,000, which will probably be balanced out over the piece by other applications that do not take up the full fee.
As it happens, East Dunbartonshire Council is faced with two similar major applications: the prospective £80 million to £100 million water treatment plant in Milngavie and the substantial application for the extension of the quarry at Douglas Muir, which is in my constituency. Those applications will cost East Dunbartonshire Council considerably more than £11,000. There are time implications for the planning staff and the cost of meetings, getting advice and support and producing maps. I have no idea what the total cost will be, but I am certain that it will be well in excess of £11,000 for each of the applications.In that context, it seems unreasonable that a local authority should suddenly have to find substantial additional resources for its planning budget because of applications. With substantial planning matters, there should be an exceptionality provision under which the applicant would have to make a contribution that is more than the £11,000 fee. That cut-off point is not reasonable when in some cases the costs of processing applications are substantially higher. I understand that it is difficult to define exceptionality, but I want to highlight the issue.
We are straying towards a debate on that issue. I think that the minister understands the point.
I will try not to debate the issue. I take on board what Des McNulty says—it has a clear logic. Our minds are never closed to examining and trying to improve the system so that it works more effectively and in the interests of local people and local authorities. We have not received representation from local authorities on those points. If the occurrence of serious incidents throughout Scotland was making the system too onerous on local authorities, we would certainly look at the situation, but we have not yet received evidence to that effect. Our minds are not closed to the points that Des McNulty raised, but I reassure him that we will continue to consider the issue.
I have a genuine question.
I suspect that this will be hard to answer.
My question concerns the difference between paragraphs 3 and 4 of the schedule. The charges for glasshouses seem to be quite punitive in comparison to those for other buildings. What is the explanation for that?
I will refer that to the official.
The higher charges stem from legislation that was introduced in 1995, when there was a tremendous influx in the number of agricultural tenants switching to using glasshouses for production. That is the reason for the punitive charge, as you called it. However, such glasshouses can cover a tremendous area of ground. The charges reflect the basic tenet behind the planning fees, which is that the charges are based on the area of ground that will be taken up by the development.
The fees are not based on the expense of processing the planning application?
The two things are tied together. One needs a measurable and identifiable basis on which to base a planning application fee. For a housing development, it is easy to say that the maximum should be based on the number of houses but, for every other development, the fee must be based on the land that will be occupied by the development. Depending on the application type, the unit of measurement is either 0.1 hectare or 75 sq m.
As members have no other questions, the minister may move the motion.
Motion moved,
That the Transport and the Environment Committee recommends that the draft Town and Country Planning (Fees for Applications and Deemed Applications) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2002 be approved.—Ms Margaret Curran.
As no members wish to speak to the motion, does the minister wish to waive her right to respond?
I am happy to do so.
Motion agreed to.
I thank the minister and her officials for their attendance.
In this meeting
Everything on 27 Feb 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Transport and the Environment Committee Wednesday 27 February 2002 (Morning) Committee business · 2
- Items in Private Procedure · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 25
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 20
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Finance Committee Inquiry (PFI/PPP) Committee business · 12
- Petition Petitions · 37
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.