Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Telecommunications Developments

Wednesday 12 September 2001 Transport and the Environment Committee Evidence session 63 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Showing Andy Kerr only · show everyone

Andy Kerr’s contributions

14 contributions
Andy Kerr Lab The Convener · East Kilbride
link

Under item 4, we will take evidence on the Scottish Executive's proposals for telecommunications developments. The aim of this session is to allow the minister to introduce those proposals. We will have the opportunity to ask questions and seek clarification of the details of the regulations in advance of our formal consideration of the regulations at next week's meeting. In line with previous practice, I invite the minister to say a few words.

Andy Kerr Lab The Convener · East Kilbride
link

As one of the survivors of the original inquiry—I think that only three committee members have started and finished the process—I recognise that we have come a long way. We have moved from the original intention, which was for prior approval, to the current situation. The committee will probably focus this morning on the exceptions, but that does not mean that we do not consider that the Executive has taken some fairly substantial steps in the direction of the committee's report. Given the fact that we carried out an investigation, took evidence from witnesses, had consultations and felt that our recommendations were appropriate, it is inevitable that we may focus on areas in which the Executive did not accept our recommendations.There is a drastic need to transfer the companies' 10 commitments from paper into action on the ground. My experience of the companies has not been too good in the past.Our concerns must also be balanced by the strategic and social role that mobile communications play in economic development and social inclusion, particularly in rural parts of Scotland. The committee's findings recognised all that and identified a system whereby we could balance those requirements. We may look at mast sharing, telecommunications planning and other areas.Fiona McLeod will open up our questioning on those matters.

Andy Kerr Lab The Convener · East Kilbride
link

Before the minister answers that question, there is an issue of retrospectivity that we must consider. The committee agreed that retrospective legislation was not appropriate—for reasons including complexity, delay and legal cases—because we wanted to progress as quickly as possible. However, our fallback position, for want of a better phrase, was telecommunications planning at local and strategic levels, whereby sites could be negotiated away, based on a projection of needs for the roll-out of third generation. Our back-up to retrospectivity was the fact that planners and the five big companies could sit down round the table and negotiate, discussing how they saw the roll-out going and how they could remove some of the more obvious difficulties that communities might have over the sites. Through that negotiation process, a lot of the heat could be taken out of the situation.The committee felt that retrospectivity would not work and would delay the whole process. We felt that there should be a back-up that would offer the chance to negotiate through a local planning process. However, the Executive has not taken up that recommendation. I wonder whether you would deal with that point when answering Fiona McLeod's point.

Andy Kerr Lab The Convener · East Kilbride
link

I, too, noticed those announcements in the media; I hope that they indicate a change in approach and culture in the big five companies. The companies need to live in the new world and stop complaining about the old world and harking back to it.Discussions about masts on buildings drove the original inquiry—certainly from my perspective, where communities in East Kilbride high-rise towers had installations of Jodrell-Bank-like proportions on their roofs. The inquiry was held because we did not know how or why masts were located. Some of those matters were discussed during our inquiry. When considering the amenity and health issues that relate to buildings, why adopt a different approach to that which was taken with ground-based masts? We want to explore further the difference in the way that those questions have been handled.

Andy Kerr Lab The Convener · East Kilbride
link

Thank you. As they say, we will watch as that one develops.

Andy Kerr Lab The Convener · East Kilbride
link

Does that mean that masts can be mounted on flats?

Andy Kerr Lab The Convener · East Kilbride
link

That is the position that we wanted to clarify.

Andy Kerr Lab The Convener · East Kilbride
link

On matters ecclesiastical, we will hear from Maureen Macmillan.

Andy Kerr Lab The Convener · East Kilbride
link

Perhaps I could come in on that point, which is an important issue for those of us who sat through many long evidence-gathering sessions. We found no conclusive evidence on the health effects. However, we concurred that the precautionary principle should be applied in the planning process. That came down to several issues relating to hierarchy of site selection, which is something that the Executive has given a nod to, although I do not know whether that has sufficient force. We did not agree with the notion of a cordon sanitaire—there was no scientific evidence to suggest that we needed to close things down. Our findings are underpinned by the fact that we constantly talk to our communities. I have stood in front of 80 to 100 people outside a high-rise block and said to them that there is no evidence to suggest a health effect. Sadly, people have lost faith in science. We need to re-establish that faith in science. Our recommendations try to restore that faith and put some local focus in the planning process.I hear what is being said about roles and responsibilities, but I should point out that we are saying not that there is a health risk, but that people think that there is and that there needs to be an on-going process that can satisfy them that there is no such risk. The irony is that, of those people standing outside that high-rise in East Kilbride, probably 95 per cent had a mobile phone. I constantly remind people of the current scientific advice, which suggests that there is no health risk but that we should adopt the precautionary approach. How have your actions tackled the issue, which is central to our findings, of convincing people on that point?

Andy Kerr Lab The Convener · East Kilbride
link

If there is any further information, just send us a note, but we are happy with what you have said on that substantive point.

Andy Kerr Lab The Convener · East Kilbride
link

I am aware of the time. I know that John Scott wants to come in, and that Fiona McLeod has a procedural question. I ask members to keep their questions short, and the minister to keep his responses tight.

Andy Kerr Lab The Convener · East Kilbride
link

I want to return to the procedure for laying statutory instruments. SSI 266 was laid on 19 July to replace SSI 244. It contained an additional provision to revoke the existing planning consents. What led to the instrument being laid later? At what point was the decision made? What was the feedback from operators and local authorities on the revocation?

Andy Kerr Lab The Convener · East Kilbride
link

Sadly, in parts of the country, the industry was laid bare in that period. In East Kilbride, a wagon turned up on the Sunday to dig a hole so that the operators could say, "We've started, so we'll finish." That was a clear abuse of the process. That did not happen throughout Scotland and not every company did that, but it happened locally and I was contacted about many such incidents throughout Scotland.That is now in the past. You spoke earlier about living with the current system and about companies now understanding where they fit into the planning process. That is a much more valuable way to proceed. I have direct experience of the situation having been abused on occasion. That was most unhelpful, as the committee is trying to balance helping the industry against community needs. Most of us agree that technology is necessary and is good, but we need to balance that against the needs of the community in relation to planning matters.

Andy Kerr Lab The Convener · East Kilbride
link

We have had a fair hit at the matter. There are no other questions. The minister has had a hard morning with us. I hope that he has enjoyed it. I found the discussion interesting and I thank the minister and his officials for coming along.Before we go into private session, I want to place on record the committee's appreciation of Shelagh McKinlay's hard work. Shelagh leaves us today to go on maternity leave.We now move into private session for the final two items. The first is consideration of the committee's draft annual report—it is usual to discuss draft reports in private. The second item is the conclusion of the contractual arrangements for the committee's adviser for its water inquiry.I thank everyone for attending.

  1. Scottish Parliament Transport and the Environment Committee Wednesday 12 September 2001 (Morning) Committee business · 3
  2. Items in Private Procedure · 1
  3. Interests Procedure · 3
  4. “Review of Strategic Planning” Committee business · 57
  5. Telecommunications Developments Evidence session · 63

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.