As the witnesses will be aware, we are conducting an inquiry into telecoms developments. As part of that, we have requested witnesses from a local government field. I welcome Councillor David Hamilton, Mary Dinsdale and Bill Hepburn, who are representing COSLA, the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities. We also have a panel from individual local authorities: Brian Kelly of Glasgow City Council, Alan Henderson of the City of Edinburgh Council and David Banford of Dumfries and Galloway Council. Bill Hepburn is also representing Highland Council.If everybody is happy, we will proceed to the first area of questioning, for COSLA, regarding parts of its submission. I invite its representatives first to make any additional comment they may have over the next few minutes. It is up to yourselves.
Official Report · Committee
Telecommunications
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Bill Hepburn Highland Council 56
- David Banford Dumfries and Galloway Council 40
- Andy Kerr Lab 37
- Councillor Hamilton 22
- Murray Tosh Con 21
- Nora Radcliffe LD 20
- Des McNulty Lab 19
- Brian Kelly Glasgow City Council 19
- Alan Henderson City of Edinburgh Council 14
- Kenny MacAskill SNP 10
- Tavish Scott LD 10
- Linda Fabiani SNP 9
- Mary Dinsdale Convention of Scottish Local Authorities 6
- Cathy Jamieson Lab 6
- Robin Harper Green 5
- Helen Eadie Lab 4
- Councillor David Hamilton Convention of Scottish Local Authorities 1
The record
302 contributions · showing 1–200Thank you, convener. I do not know if it is just me, but I do not have my glasses on and I can barely see you, let alone read MSPs' name plates.I am convener of the development services forum, Mary Dinsdale is a policy officer and Bill Hepburn is the principal for development control for Highland Council, although he will be wearing his COSLA hat for the first part of the proceedings.We welcome the opportunity to provide further evidence to this committee on telecommunications development. COSLA held a seminar last week, which some members attended. That seminar covered the statutory framework of the installation of telecommunications masts, operation perspectives, how the cell sites work, related health and safety issues, the existing national guidelines, the case for a precautionary approach to cellphone technology and the councils' response to that.COSLA represents 32 local authorities, including those of the Highlands and Islands. It is a voluntary organisation, and is paid for by membership subscription. Every single council in Scotland is involved in COSLA. Several committees make up COSLA, and the 32 local authorities are represented on the major committees and task groups. In addition, there are various sub-committees which specialise according to what part of the country their members come from. For example, a number of councillors from the north of Scotland and some parts of the central belt take a specific interest in national parks. However, every single council is represented on the development services forum, which covers economic development, transportation and planning.We are involved in a substantial number of matters, and the debates that we have been having recently cover a number of issues that we believe must be addressed differently from what has hitherto been makeshift. At present, COSLA believes that there should be full planning control for telecommunications development. In the most recent survey of councils, 23 out of 30 responses indicated full planning control over the prior approval system.The procedures for full planning permission are easy to understand, and are used by everybody: the private sector, public bodies and members of the public. The precautionary approach has been adopted—50 per cent of councils have responded, and a number of them have been monitoring emission levels. That shows a clear need for guidance, to help councils assess health issues, which can be considered in the material consideration of the planning process.As a layman, it came home to me last week that the third generation licence coming into operation will potentially increase the number of masts threefold. That causes me some concern. In our opinion, it would be a reverse position to take, so we need clear guidance on this issue as soon as possible.I believe that the committee is taking evidence in two sessions. We will answer the overall questions. As I am a politician—as members will be aware, that is a jack of all trades and master of none—I have tried to ensure that within the panel we have people who will be able to respond to the concerns that the committee and local government have.
Thank you, David. I was impressed with the seminar that COSLA held last week, which some committee members managed to attend. That was useful and well timed by COSLA in relation to the work that is going on elsewhere. You have obviously done a lot of work on this issue. Has COSLA issued formal advice to planning authorities with regard to telecoms?
There has not been any advice issued yet, because we were considering the consultation that had taken place and we were waiting for the outcome of the seminar. We will issue some advice in due course.
Have you formed a view on the siting of masts on local authority-owned property? What approach has your membership taken on that issue?
The position, because of how this has developed, is that each authority has taken on its own remit. That is why we are attempting to get some cohesion. We put a questionnaire out some time ago. The final results indicate that 23 local authorities prefer full planning permission. A number of authorities are currently working with sites on their properties. A number of those authorities have now reviewed their position. That will come through in the responses to members' questions.The vast majority of local authorities have now taken a view that they will not put masts on their own sites, unless they go through certain lines. Members will be aware that masts under 15 m do not require planning permission—that is 45 ft in the old imperial system. While 15 m does not sound so bad, 45 ft is quite a height. The approach varies from authority to authority, but we are beginning to pull together. A consensus view is developing that something must be done. If that means a change in the future for those authorities that are building on their own property, so be it.
I think that you covered this in your preamble, but perhaps you could confirm, for the record, what the problems and deficiencies are in the existing system.
The existing system is twofold. Operators operate under their licence from the Telecommunications Act 1984, so each operator has his own individual licence. Planning controls relate to whether there is a need for planning permission and whether it comes within class 67 of the Town and Country Planning (General Permitted Development) (Scotland) Order 1997. Class 67 has been widely drawn. It gives operators a lot of opportunity to erect structures, as Councillor Hamilton said, up to 15 m in height, with associated base equipment and without planning permission.I noticed an anomaly in some of the evidence given by the operators to the committee. Vodafone said that planning authorities could take enforcement action against operators that did not construct their apparatus in accordance with their licence. I think it is strange that planning authorities have to read an operator's licence and decide whether they can take action against them outwith planning legislation.As you can judge by the evidence given to the committee, it is common ground among the Scottish Executive and others—and is accepted by the operators—that the present system is inadequate and must be changed. There are inconsistencies and difficulties in interpretation. Permitted development is too wide.
The two options are prior approval and full planning control. We already know that you support full planning control. Why is that? What is lacking with prior approval?
There are different reasons for that. As far as I can gather, prior approval will be a two-tier system. Where there is a 42-day notification period, it will involve almost the same amount of administration as it would take to deal with a planning application: the application will have to be registered, its competency will have to be checked, consultation will have to be undertaken, the application will have to be advertised, a site visit will be required, and all of that will be required to be assimilated, perhaps in a committee report, before a decision can be reached. That is almost no different from the procedure for a planning application.There are differences that give rise to concern. First, prior approval does not require neighbour notification. There is a quasi-assumption that a prior approval will get consent anyway if everything is in accordance with the guidance, whatever that is. Secondly, there is no planning fee, which reflects the amount of work that may need to be done.As a practising planner, I find it difficult to see that prior approval offers any real-time advantage for operators. One of the difficulties, however, is that if a prior approval is not dealt with within 42 days, there will be a deemed approval, which potentially puts quite a lot of pressure on planning authorities. For permitted development, it also introduces the strange concept of having to give more priority to prior approval than to planning applications, for which people have paid a full fee and are going through the system. That goes for everyone in the planning system, from industrial developers to householders. It is difficult for the public to comprehend why there should be a difference.
It is also difficult for a number of people in industry. I have already received a delegation of members from Midlothian chamber of commerce. One or two employers have asked why they have to go through a certain process when other organisations do not. In my surgery, people have asked why they have not been notified about masts that have been erected in my area. If I want to hang a new door or extend my house, I have to do certain things, yet I could wake up one morning with a mast at the back of my house and would not be able to say anything about it. Practical problems arise from not having a system that applies throughout.
My next two points are related. First, is the current system flexible enough or is it lacking? It is all very well for Midlothian to do one thing, but should there be a national plan rather than individual local authority systems?Secondly, I understand that COSLA has a working group. What direction is it heading in? What view does it take of an overall national policy? What are the practical aspects?
I can comment on your first point. A series of national guidelines, called national planning policy guidelines—or NPPGs—exist for other aspects of planning, such as retailing, alternative energy, industry and so on. I see no reason why there cannot be national guidance on how planning authorities should deal with telecommunications, which is a large, dynamic and expanding industry. Part of the council's case is that there should be better guidance on good practice and policy. I cannot comment on the COSLA working group.
The task group produced a policy paper last year, which I can make available to the committee. Generally, we were in favour of national guidance, but the detail of a national plan will be examined further in the future.
I want to follow up Bill Hepburn's point about the similarities and differences between prior approval and full planning. As far as you understand prior approval procedures, could the time period within which a decision has to be taken be extended if an environmental impact assessment were required, which would take one beyond 42 days? Could the planning authority extend the period if it judged that the applicant, by failing to provide information or sufficient documentation, had made it impossible to determine the application? For example, one could imagine that an applicant might not give information to the authority's satisfaction in a roads construction consent case. That might lead to the process being protracted. Can you extend the 42-day period or would you lose simply because the time frame locked you out? Is there an incentive for the applicant to spin matters out as long as possible?
The question of whether the period could be extended is one for the Scottish Executive, which drafts the regulations. I understand from the evidence of John Gunstone about his discussions with COSLA last week that the answer is no. The period is set at 42 days, or 28 days for installations on buildings or other smaller-scale installations.We operate an informal system in the Highlands in which we undertake consultations on a 28-day notification. Frequently, we cannot respond in that time, for a range of factors. In practice, the operators are reluctant to jump in and accept permitted development. There may be a de facto opportunity to extend the period, but probably not in terms of the regulations. That creates an uncertainty which is unhelpful to both sides of any argument.If one seeks to extend the period, the procedure will become so close to being a planning application as will make no difference. The planning application system does not impose a deadline in quite the same way: one cannot take a deemed approval at the end of a two-month period, but one can take a deemed refusal. In practice, if there are difficulties with a planning application, one can negotiate with the developer and seek compromises that may be acceptable. If the developer does not like that, he has a pathway to a decision, as he can appeal against it.In those circumstances, I see very little advantage to having a prior notification rather than a full planning application. Planning applications have the advantage of allowing more flexibility in the system. I doubt in practice that there will be significant delays other than there might be in any case with contentious prior notification procedures.
Can you clarify what the time constraints are on a full planning application? You said that if one overruns a full planning application, there is a deemed refusal. Is that the case?
It is more accurate to say that the developer can accept a deemed refusal, but can appeal against the non-determination of a planning application. However, the onus is on him to do that, if he feels that there is an opportunity for negotiating, compromising and seeking to allay the concerns of the authority or the public. We can then proceed to determine that proposal. That might take two weeks, a month, two months, or longer, but at least a decision is reached, possibly a lot quicker than could be done for a contested prior notification.
What is the time frame for a full planning application?
A full planning application usually takes two months. If an environmental assessment is required, it will take four months. It is unlikely that any telecommunications development would require a formal environmental assessment under the environmental assessment regulations.
I will approach that subject from a slightly different angle. What percentage of planning applications are determined within two months?
The figure is approaching 80 per cent for householder applications in the Highlands. We have specific government targets. A comfortable majority of planning applications are determined in the two-month period. If they are not, there are usually good reasons: they are contentious or there are problems.
You mentioned the work that COSLA has done and the fact that a consensus is emerging. How many local authorities believe that we need full planning control and how many favour the prior approval process?
Of the 30 that responded, 23 councils indicated that they would prefer full planning control, four indicated that they would not and two indicated that they would prefer either prior approval or some form of increased control.
I want to examine sensitive areas and the precautionary approach. In the latest deliberations, did COSLA decide that sensitive areas should be introduced into the planning framework for telecommunication developments and, if so, why did it decide that?
We have not come to any conclusion. Part of the process, as you will know from the conference last week, is to come here and answer questions. The other part is that we will discuss and analyse the latest results. We consulted local authorities so that we could get the maximum amount of information for today's meeting. We will come to a conclusion soon. We can respond to your question in writing once we have done so.
In the planning process, there are difficulties in dealing with sensitive areas. Normally, the orthodox way of considering them is as a physical boundary, but I suspect that you are referring to health issues. One of the difficulties of drawing a boundary is that it is an artificial thing to do. A mast sited immediately beside a sensitive boundary could be as problematic as one sited just inside it.We can define in guidance what sensitivities might be, but it is difficult to draw hard-and-fast boundaries across a range of factors. In the Highlands, there are landscape sensitivities about masts rather than health concerns. Some areas are designated as national scenic areas, but other vast and precious areas are not. I am not convinced of the value of drawing hard physical boundaries around sensitive areas. Sensitivities are hard to define and the situation will be trickier if we include health issues.
In your submission, you said that any attempt to define sensitive areas in which the height of masts would be restricted would mean that the operators would simply have to have a greater number of masts to provide the coverage. Should issues other than the height of masts be taken into account when we consider sensitive areas? Do most local authorities have an opinion on that?
Yes. One of the issues that came up at last week's conference was the type of masts that are being developed and how they work. Rather unfairly, I think, one of the companies that was there was asked a number of direct questions on the matter. The question of why there is no multi-use of masts was asked a lot. Because of competition between the companies, there are many masts in small areas where one would have done.We saw drawings and diagrams of how masts might change. One mast was on a tree. Things are changing rapidly, but the fundamental issue is that there is no agreement between the companies to utilise effectively the resources that they have. There is a concern that the number of masts will increase. There are 2,000 masts in Scotland and 20 more are erected every month. If phase 3 comes in, the number of masts will increase substantially. Unless we can achieve some sort of cohesion across the country, we are in for a difficult time.
You use the word height in your submission. Are your authorities giving you feedback on other areas that you might want to include under the heading of sensitive? If there is no information, that is fine.
I can look through the submissions again and provide further information if some is available.
We will probably come to it later, but Bill Hepburn mentioned national scenic areas. Can you conceive of circumstances in which COSLA's policy position would be that there should be no siting of masts in sites of special scientific interest or any other nature conservation designations and you would therefore press the Scottish Executive to give the same advice?
That would be most unlikely. The difficulty with sensitivity is that it tends to be focused on one particular aspect of one particular site. If the site is in an urban area where there is a collection of fine buildings, the issue might be one of conservation. If it is a rural area, it could be a landscape issue, an SSSI, or closeness to rural housing. It is unlikely that there would be much objection to the siting of masts in many SSSIs in the Highlands, because the impact on the nature conservation interest might be relatively slight. There might be huge landscape or other issues, but that is variable.The issue cannot easily be tackled just by designating sensitive areas here and there; contentious things will always happen outside sensitive areas. Things are easier to control, however, if a planning application is required for all major telecommunications apparatus. In the determination of that application, sensitivity can be taken into account as a material consideration in a number of ways.
I would like to pursue those points. First, if we were to view health as a material consideration, are there any particular groups of individuals that we should classify for some form of additional protection within whatever regulatory system is brought in?
My council has an interim precautionary policy, pending further advice. It seeks to prevent apparatus being sited on schools or sensitive residential accommodation: people's homes, social work homes or whatever. It is a difficult issue for planning authorities and requires an overview by Government, fitting the real problem into a reasonable, scientific evidential context and deciding which, if any, precautionary distances or factors should be taken into account.The perception of health effects is a material planning consideration, but the weight that you can give that must rely on rational evidence. At this stage, on the face of it, there is not—and there may never be—a good body of conclusive evidence. In these circumstances, it will be difficult for planning authorities to deal with health issues, whether through a prior notification or a planning application procedure.
I am assuming that, to some extent, what you are saying is that it is about facts and circumstances. Is that a fair comment?
I think that it is, but, for the sake of argument, if you were to refuse an application on health grounds, it would have to be an obvious, almost extreme, circumstance that could be backed up by evidence.
My next point relates to what you said earlier about environment and landscape. We could take the view that some geographic or topographical areas should have some form of criteria for protection. Do you think that that should be the case? If so, what would be the definition and what would be the level of treatment within the policy planning system?
That is quite a big question, which refers not just to telecommunications. We already have a system of landscape environmental designations—national scenic areas, sites of special scientific interest and so on—which are for different things. The argument could be made that any further controls could be helpful. My view is that it is not that simple in practice. A non-designated area on the edge of a town can be much more sensitive than a site within a national scenic area, because of its particular circumstances. It would not be an easy way forward simply to designate sites all over the place—for example, using article 4 directions, which the planning authority is empowered to do. Those directions have their own problems, because operators can feasibly seek compensation for development that would otherwise have been permitted. It is a clumsy, piecemeal approach. It would be better to go back to first principles and ask which developments deserve planning permission and then feed in one's sensitivities, based on the merits of the site.
I am not quite sure about the balance. You talked about health being a consideration but not as something that might determine a decision. I am not sure where that fits with the balance of material matters and environmental sensitivity that you were talking about.
The planning system is designed to deal with orthodox environmental concerns and material matters: siting design, external appearance and impact on amenity—for the most part, it is a visual and physical thing. Health concerns arise quite frequently in relation to waste tips, emissions from incinerators and so on. Case law has accepted that public perception of a health concern can be a material consideration. In some cases, a very acute perception would influence the planning authority in taking a decision or locating a development.The difficulty with telecommunications apparatus is that the health effects are ill defined, if at all. It will be some years before that research is conclusive, if ever. At the moment, there is no evidence that would allow the planning authority to base a refusal on health grounds. Telecommunications apparatus is ubiquitous. Preventing the siting of apparatus at a school, for example, may not prevent health effects were the apparatus to be sited across the road, where we might have no control. Furthermore, the industry would argue that there might be no health effect, or that there might be less of an effect, if the apparatus were sited on the building rather than across the road. It is difficult to deal with that in the planning process. We need the Government to take a lead, to view the evidence and to say—in whatever precautionary terms it chooses—what planning authorities should do, so that there is a level playing field.
The industry is keen to assure us that the masts have no health impact. Two possible issues arise, even if one accepts that assurance. First, the extent of the use of telecommunications or the technological changes associated with the industry might be such that what is a low-level risk at the moment might become a higher-level risk in the future. I take it that there is nothing in planning law to deal with that eventuality. I assume that you have influence only over where something is sited.Secondly, if permission was granted to site one type of mast, and in 10 years' time the company wished to replace the mast with a new form of technology, would there be a requirement for a repeat planning application that could take account of health considerations? Once planning permission had been granted, could a company put whatever it wanted on a particular site?
On Des McNulty's first question, on the extent of technological changes, on what might become a higher-level risk and on the influence of planning, I think that I can refer back to my previous answer: without firm guidance from those who are statutory advisers to the Government, including the National Radiological Protection Board and the Health and Safety Executive, planning authorities cannot, in my view, be expected to make decisions themselves about the level of risk. I now come to Des's second question. Once permission is granted, inertia sets in. Replacements of masts of the same height or additional apparatus on a mast installation do not usually require planning permission, or at least they are at the lower end of permitted development and are not considered significant—in Highland, we would not normally contest such replacements.
At present, we are talking about the visual impact of masts and about competition. From a local government perspective, those factors are easy to measure. Members will appreciate the difficulty that local government has. I represent the second smallest local authority in Scotland. There are very few people in that council with the expertise required to judge whether there is a health and safety issue. The City of Edinburgh Council and Glasgow City Council are represented here today, and members will be asking them specific questions. Being much larger authorities, they might have a deeper understanding in their departments. It comes down to the statutory bodies making a determination on health and safety issues. I watched a television programme about beef on the bone last night. You have a great challenge to resolve that one, because you will get every opinion under the sun: the companies will argue one way, and the environmentalists another. You have to make a judgment. That judgment can be made only at the centre, because local government does not have the resources to make it. Aspects such as visual impact should be dealt with by the appropriate planning authorities. There is a fundamental flaw in the system. Firms, owners, employers and the general population are saying, "Something is wrong. We have to do this, but they can do that." It is as simple as that. Members might wish to discuss the more detailed questions among themselves.
I do not want to oversimplify matters, but am I right in saying that COSLA wishes a national plan to be introduced but that, within that, full planning approval would provide the regulatory framework that you require, and that that would give you sufficient room to manoeuvre, depending on circumstances? Is there something more than that, or does that cover the national plan and full planning approval in a nutshell?
There should be national guidance and full planning approval for major structures, certainly. I am not trying to argue—certainly not on the part of my council—that planning permission is necessary for every last piece of telecommunications development. That would be impossible. There are many levels of permitted development now which are very minor in orthodox planning terms. As the industry evolves, that is becoming more and more prevalent. Burglar-alarm-type antennae can now be sited on buildings: we would not normally consider that to require planning permission. It is not even a matter of permitted development. The term de minimis comes to mind: such devices are so small as to be insignificant. With regard to health issues, it makes something of a mockery to try to control the major structures when all those minor structures can be erected with no planning control.
To follow up Kenny MacAskill's point about a national plan, the logic of Councillor Hamilton's points is that health considerations have to be at the centre. There are such big implications that much research and careful thinking are required. COSLA and the local authorities would be looking for advice from the centre, in other words, from the Executive. They would argue that local government bodies are too small to make such decisions on the health implications of planning applications because of the shortage of resources that has just been described.
There are 32 local authorities. I do not know how many thousands of councillors and officers that represents. Within those 32 local authorities, groupings will determine how they deal with their issues. The responses that we received, to which Mary Dinsdale referred, showed the diversity of opinion, although the vast majority were of one mind about planning applications.I am sure that, in Edinburgh and Glasgow, there has been far more detailed debate on health and safety issues than in Midlothian, Clackmannan or the Highlands and Islands, as those local authorities have neither the number of officers that we have to support us—and it should be remembered that councillors are, by and large, part-timers—nor the level of expertise that exists within our divisions. I mean no disrespect to the smaller councils, but they cannot afford that level of expertise. I imagine—although I cannot be sure—that major authorities such as Glasgow City Council, City of Edinburgh Council and Dundee City Council might have more available resources to get hold of that information. That is a personal opinion, but I believe that it would reflect that of the politicians and COSLA. We hope that the Scottish Government, along with the national Government, will consider the best way in which to deal with that situation. We can contribute to the debate, but I do not think that that responsibility should be with local government.
Do you think that there is a danger of effecting a two-tier structure? My own council is Shetland Islands Council, on which I served as a councillor on a planning authority. In one case, an electrical substation was sited right next to somebody's house. The council officials there—you are right about the need for advice—did not have the resources.
I am not saying that there will be a two-tier structure. City of Edinburgh Council and Glasgow City Council might disagree. They receive advice and deal with it in the way that is deemed appropriate for each authority. Although they are large authorities, they might disagree on the best way to proceed. A much bigger debate must take place, which we will take part in. That is the way in which the matter must be dealt with.
The danger is that there might not be clear guidance on how to deal with the health issues in the different circumstances that might arise. With a prior notification procedure or a planning application procedure, there will be great variation in the decisions that are taken by different local authorities, which might weigh those factors differently.
If the focus is on health considerations, and if planning legislation allows you to deal with the physical aspects of the structure only when the structure is being put in place for the first time, is planning legislation the most effective means of dealing with the health or broader environmental impacts? To take another environmental/health issue, air pollution is not dealt with by planning; it is dealt with through other forms of legislation. Do local authorities have a view about balancing planning controls with other mechanisms?
I do not disagree with what you are saying. The planning application process at least allows a broad community view of the acceptability of development. We can feed into that the expertise of other regulatory authorities—on water and sewerage, for example, or the expertise of the Health and Safety Executive—which might be able to comment at the time of the planning application on what the implications will be. However, the planning application procedure is not suitable for making individual decisions unless there is clear guidance on health concerns such as individual telecommunications apparatus.
Another, more general, issue is connected with that. If you want to take community planning forward—I know that COSLA is particularly interested in it—you might need to consider community planning not in the context of planning legislation alone, but in combination with other forms of legislation. A community planning framework might involve a comprehensive, joined-up look at a whole series of issues that impact on a locality. This issue might fit into that framework.
We like to think that we are moving towards that. We have a local planning section in Highland Council that is called community planning and economic development. It is an attempt to bring together all the interests of the public, public bodies and industry—the community generally—in forming a plan. Telecommunications would certainly be part of that.
I have some detailed questions, but I would like to pursue the big issue of precautionary principles. We interviewed the National Radiological Protection Board a couple of weeks ago. Its judgment was that it could detect no health issues, but that it was happy that Government should tell it that a precautionary principle was none the less justified.This morning, Bill Hepburn has also said that he does not see a role for planning because it is a health issue on which there is no evidence. However, in COSLA's written submission, it said that until such time as conclusive evidence was available—which might be never—it wanted to adopt the precautionary principle. How does COSLA justify that if it does not feel that the issue is relevant in planning terms? Are you simply saying that you know that there is a risk, that you would be grateful if the Government took the decision for you, and that you would implement it?
The concern raised in that point has been reflected by the number of councils that have adopted the precautionary principle on their own premises. Until there is guidance, councils will have problems justifying or explaining decisions to the public—so there is a need for some central guidance.
So, although you are sceptical about the evidence, you are fully signed up to the principle of a precautionary approach. Is there no ambiguity about that? I thought that Bill Hepburn's view on the health issue—expressed quite trenchantly—was that he was unimpressed by the argument. Notwithstanding that, are you firm that you want a precautionary principle?
Perhaps I should clarify my position. I am not "unimpressed" by the view that health might be an issue, and I am not decrying the view that health might be an issue; I am simply saying that it is an issue that it is difficult for the planning process, as framed, to take into account. I fully agree with COSLA's evidence to you that the Government should take it into account. It is an up-front public issue just now. Indeed, the Government is taking it into account in so far as the House of Commons Select Committee on Science and Technology recently issued a report on it.Because it is difficult for the planning process to take the health issue into account, we need clear Government guidance on how planning authorities should deal with it.
If we agree that we are considering the principle of taking a precautionary approach on the siting of major telecommunications apparatus, and bearing in mind the fact that you do not want full planning control over the more minor installations, do you feel that the same precautionary approach ought to apply to the siting of the lesser fixed telecommunications equipment—such as micromasts and cells—as applies for major apparatus?
I am no health expert. Again, I cannot alight on a linear or vertical distance that would be safe in the circumstances. From what has been said on health, and from what I have read in the literature, it is my interpretation that the health effects are probably quite localised.However, it is impossible for local authorities to take their own clear, conclusive, individual views on that. In those circumstances, it is for the Government to take the lead and to give local authorities and the industry guidance on the level of precaution that is justified.
You are making the point that I made earlier. We are getting responses about visual appearance and about the physical apparatus that is causing concern. A debate is taking place, but there is a perception that there is a health and safety issue. The representatives of the larger councils might give members more specific information on that later. We need a more cohesive debate on a wider basis.As a layman, I can tell you that 150 people attended last week's seminar. We had to turn people away. For the first time, COSLA had to move the venue because of the volume of the response, and we still had to turn people away. The people who attended came from all walks of life. As chairman of that seminar, I was taken aback by the number of people who were there. Some people were there for personal reasons; others were representing public organisations or the private sector.As an official, Bill Hepburn takes the view that there is no point in a council rejecting an application if it will end up in court several months later because it cannot sustain its objections. We have major difficulties in deciding how to proceed. We are trying to get some semblance of order across Scotland, so that we can work in unison. It may be that that leads to oversimplification, but we need some guidance.Small changes do not need planning applications. If someone wants to build a massive extension on their house, they must go through the planning process, but if they want to change a door, they do not need a planning application. If a company wants to build a 100 ft mast, it will have to apply for planning permission, but if the mast is less than 15 m, it does not need planning permission—although it would still be a massive structure.At the moment, different local authorities have different policies, which is not helpful. We need consistency across Scotland.
I want to move on to the way in which the precautionary principle might operate. It is all very well to ask for guidance, but the implementation of a planning policy on a local basis would require definitions and operational standards to tackle the issue of proximity. In asking the Scottish Executive for national guidelines, how would COSLA want the definition of closeness to be established? What role should the local authority have in such decisions, and to what extent would other bodies, such as health boards and the national advice agencies, feed into that process? If we wanted to build in any degree of local consideration and influence, surely there would be a problem in seeking the consistency across the country that David Hamilton has just mentioned.I do not think that COSLA can dissociate itself from the issues of definition, even if there were central guidance, because there are implementation and operational considerations. How do you see that working?
I do not think that I can adequately answer that question. Perhaps some of my colleagues from the other local authorities, who are more involved in health issues, can comment on that later.My reading of the situation is that all the authorities and operators are complying fully with current guidance. Without any scientific reasons for doing so, the guidance might be lowered fivefold to give comfort to the public and to bring it in line with other European and international guidance. As far as I am concerned, that is a question for experts. Given the degree of public concern, scientists will be required to give advice to Government on suitable precautionary distances or circumstances. It is not a question that we, on behalf of COSLA, can easily answer.
It will be difficult for us to produce a report that may well ask the Scottish Executive to establish a precautionary principle and to take account of all the public concerns that David Hamilton mentioned, but which does not offer any guidance on what constitutes "close" and on what would be reasonable central guidance for the Executive to issue to local authorities. We—and COSLA—have a responsibility to give some indication of what we are looking for. If COSLA wants to be able to operate that guidance on the ground, it will need an idea of what it means in practice. One of the first questions that the Scottish Executive will ask is what exactly COSLA wants.
Instead of pushing for an answer that COSLA cannot give at the moment, we should flag up those areas with the organisation and follow up the points on the back of its conference and further consultations with member authorities. However, Murray Tosh is fundamentally right. Although we are discussing the general issue, we will try to address some specifics in our report, which will have a wide-ranging impact on how the matter develops.
We will give a written response to that matter.The committee has an overview. I understand that this is its third meeting on the issue and that it has taken evidence from witnesses from different parts of the country, from different areas of expertise and with different opinions. When COSLA discusses the issue, it will take into account evidence from the seminar, the deliberations at this meeting and a review of papers up to now. I take Bill Hepburn's point that local authorities will answer your specific questions in the second part of the session. COSLA will give a rounded view and submit a written response.
We are trying to establish COSLA's view and to open the matter up for wider discussion.
A related question has come up in previous sessions. When the precautionary principle has been discussed, the question has been raised about which buildings and uses should be covered. There is a view that residential property should be subject to a different spatial protection from that for buildings with less intensive occupation, such as office and commercial buildings. If COSLA has opinions on that, we would like to hear them now; if not, we would like the organisation to express them soon, as central Government guidance to local authorities is bound to contain its own views on the subject.Furthermore, if consents are given to telecommunications installations in relation to existing neighbouring uses, presumably the guidance given would require rigorous scrutiny of any further planning applications within the cordon that might impact on the telecommunications use.Do you have any immediate reactions to the different types of use or building, or are you still considering the issue?
I can see the problem. My answer returns to David's earlier answer. COSLA is an association of 32 local authorities that have neither the detailed expertise nor the time required to tackle the issue. As COSLA has only recently held its seminar on the issues, perhaps there has not been time to put any meat on them. In practice, given the existing spread of the telecommunications industry in rural and urban areas, it is a difficult issue.
I am not sure that I will get very far with my questions as you are obviously developing your thoughts on the subject. We have considered evidence for a blanket approach to not siting masts close to buildings. Do you have a view on that? Perhaps you will consider it in the written evidence that you will provide. For example, can masts be sited in school grounds as long as they are not close to, or on, schools? There are practical issues for you to think about. What is your view on the difference between taking a precautionary approach for individual buildings and taking such an approach for sensitive areas?
I will answer the first part, and Bill Hepburn can address the detailed point. The responses that we have received show that some authorities have taken a precautionary approach where sites for masts are close to buildings. Those authorities are reviewing that position as research and opinion develop. Some authorities took a decision early on, but are now reviewing their position and taking different decisions on new structures. A local authority might determine that it will not build on its own premises, but a mast can be sited on private land across the road. We have to deal with that problem.
I am not sure that I can answer your second question on the difference between the precautionary approach for individual buildings and that for sensitive areas. I explained the difficulty that will exist because, clearly, microcell developments will not require planning permission, but other telecommunications developments will. There will be no point in having a policy that is based on health issues for larger structures that could not control smaller ones.Local authorities will find it difficult to deal with these issues, unless there is clear guidance from Government on what the level of risk is and consequently what, in the interest of the public, the level of precaution should be. Ideally, the system will work much better if the Government issues clear guidelines so that every local authority and operator thinks in the same way about things.
Can you clarify whether the wider economic issues in network provision are material planning considerations? There are arguments about how wide the network provision should be. There are areas, especially rural areas, that would not have coverage if there were strict national guidelines. Also, how would you take account of the desire of society to have adequate network provision in densely populated areas?
I do not understand why national guidance would eliminate coverage in certain parts of Scotland.
If there were a national plan that had a presumption against development in certain areas, such as sites of special scientific interest, tracts of the country would be ruled out from coverage and people in those areas would not have facilities to use mobile phones.
BBC masts cover the whole of Scotland.
I assure you that they do not. Many parts of Scotland are not covered.
In any case, as Bill Hepburn said, there are not many areas in northern Scotland where a mast would not be put up, so I do not think that that issue would arise. Surely guidance would not presume against development.
That is interesting.
I have a question arising from something that Bill Hepburn said about microcell development. When we spoke to the operators, it bothered me that there is no compulsory system for labelling where microcells are placed. Do you see any value in a central register for each local authority plotting each location where there is any such equipment, and in a labelling system at those sites?
I do not see much value in a labelling system from a planning point of view, except that it would lead to general recognition when work is going on in buildings. I am pretty sure that the roads authorities would want installations labelled so that they knew what allowances they would need to make during maintenance or renewal work. Widening the question out from microcells, it would be valuable to have a proper register of all installations in open countryside and in urban areas, so that everyone knows where they are and operators can be directed towards them.
Time is limited, so I ask members to keep their questions as short as possible.
I would like some specific information about material planning considerations. What process is used for setting the parameters of what constitutes a material planning consideration, and who determines what is considered material?
That is a good question. Material planning considerations are defined to some extent in national guidance, but there are no absolutes, and material considerations can be framed widely in the particular circumstances of any case. If one considers health, case law shows that the perception of health effects can be considered material. If one considers the broad process of planning assessment in relation to materiality, decisions are made on giving weightings to the different material factors. There must be reasonable evidence as to what the effects might be in terms of the amount of traffic, the emissions from a chimney, or some other measurable, quantifiable effect that could be substantiated in the courts if necessary.
Does your answer imply that different criteria are being employed by different authorities to determine materiality and that, even within authorities, different weightings may be given to different cases?
I cannot answer for different authorities or speculate on inconsistencies within authorities. However, in my experience, the materiality of any facet of a planning application is a matter of careful judgment and there is scope for variations in judgment.
If health were to be a consideration, would it be unusual for the councillors making a judgment or the planning officers advising them to have relevant expertise in health?
Yes, it would.
Suppose health were to be a material consideration. Would you seek an alternative source of advice, such as the NRPB?
The current guidance on telecommunications is that planning authorities may consider the perception of a health effect material, but the innuendo is that it should not be taken into consideration in any planning decision. The NRPB advises that health issues are matters for the Health and Safety Executive and Government.
If health is not dealt with as a material planning consideration, is it reasonable for us to consider introducing a precautionary approach at national level with health as a major factor?
It is reasonable for the Government to recognise public concern and to seek proper advice. As that public concern is manifested in planning decisions, the Government should be giving planning authorities proper advice based on the expertise that is available.
What about other forms of applications, ones where there is no adopted local plan or a local plan is out of date? How would the operation of material planning considerations relating to telecommunications developments be dealt with?
It would not be dealt with differently, except that the status of land would become more of a material consideration. Development should be considered in the context of the development plan unless other material considerations indicate otherwise. However, the situation would not be greatly different. Planning applications often raise health effects and authorities might require advice from health boards and other such bodies. Mostly, authorities are not in a position to make judgments about the technicalities of health.
In your submission, you suggest that adequate publicity and consultation is required. Who should generate that information, who should be consulted and how might you determine what would constitute an adequate level?
Consultation normally takes two forms. We consult regulatory or other bodies that might have an interest and we consult the public. I do not see that process changing. It would not be normal for planning authorities to consult the health authority. In this instance, I suspect that we would not get clear answers if we did, given the current state of research. On behalf of my council, rather than COSLA, I suggest that we need clearer Government guidance on the issue.
On any planning committee, there are several key people, one of whom is the representative of the legal department. He sits and does not say much during the process but kicks in when the committee decides to go against a planning application and informs us what would happen if we did so.The local planning area structure plans that we are involved in are extremely helpful for all the planning authorities. The City of Edinburgh Council, West Lothian Council, East Lothian Council and Midlothian Council are working to our structure plan. We then work within our local plans. We try to work cohesively throughout the area—Edinburgh can have an opinion on what happens in Midlothian and so on. If a local authority decided not to agree to the siting of certain masts, it would be told by the legal department that doing so without an expert legal opinion on the matter might result in the authority being taken to court.There are concerns about many issues. Therefore, the quicker that we can get to a position where we can develop a comprehensible strategy, the better it will be.
It is not entirely clear whether we are going down the correct routes in the context of weaknesses in the planning structure.
Our submission makes our opinion clear. Certain factors—the visibility of masts and so on—are measurable. The difficulty starts when we consider health aspects. Research is still on-going in that area and the position is different now from the situation a year ago.On the planning issue, not the health and safety part, a judgment should be made that we treat like with like, depending on what authority we are dealing with. An area relating to that can be seen to be cohesive throughout Scotland, health and safety notwithstanding.We will give a written submission detailing how each of the authorities are dealing with the health and safety issue. However, the fact that we are dealing with 32 local authorities means that different opinions will be expressed.
That is my concern. In a sense, what you are saying is that you advocate a precautionary principle, but that the mechanism for enforcing that is inappropriate. Is that a fair comment?
We do advocate a precautionary principle, but I will let Bill answer.
That is all the more reason why Government should take over.
Government and other agencies perhaps?
Yes. The Government in association with the statutory agencies.
I want to go back to Des McNulty's question about health being made a material planning consideration for telecommunications. Is COSLA concerned that if we did that for telecommunications, there might be a lot of other areas of land use and practice where health would become a consideration? Are we opening up a major issue, or can telecommunications be treated in isolation?
Health issues are material considerations if there is evidence that they should be. My view, as I have said this morning, is that there is uncertainty. No conclusions have been drawn and none may be for some time. In those circumstances, rather than letting individual planning authorities reach separate judgments about how much weight health should be given, it would be helpful for local authorities—and perhaps for industry, although I cannot speak for it—if Government stepped in to give an overview of whether and to what extent a precautionary principle should apply.
Which factors should be taken into account in deciding the other environmental impacts of masts, particularly in urban areas?
I have not dealt with a great many masts in urban areas. In the Highlands, those we have dealt with have tended to be in open countryside. The issues are orthodox: the visual impact, the impact on the landscape, whether access can be gained to the site, whether the site needs separate access and whether power can be supplied to the site. In urban areas, controversy has usually been caused by a combination of the appearance of the mast—which inevitably is very utilitarian, although that is slowly improving in some cases—and whether there is a health issue. Are any families living in accommodation close by being affected?
Another area that merits a bit more discussion is the distinction between what is covered by planning legislation and what is covered by licensing. Will you say a bit more about that?
Licences under the Telecommunications Act 1984 for individual operators are very large—as big as several telephone books. They cover a number of operating factors that have nothing to do with planning permission or control, although all of them put some onus on the operator to respect the environment and to seek to minimise the impact of their installations. It is a dual system, which the Government presumably will insist continues to operate, and which will operate as we enter the third wave of telecommunications that we all expect.
You mentioned the need for a clear complaints procedure. It would be useful if you would expand on that. What would it involve? How would the procedure work?
My view is that there are two levels of complaints: complaints about the way in which a planning situation has been dealt with and complaints about the appearance of apparatus on the ground. There are tried-and-tested methods of dealing with the matter. That can involve going through a system of planning permission, for example, prior notification if it is introduced, and if people are not satisfied with it, they have recourse to the courts or to a local government ombudsman.I am not qualified to speak on the other method, which concerns the licensing side of things and whether an operator is fulfilling all the terms of its licence. I am not aware if there is a telecommunications ombudsman who might deal with that issue, but I am sure that there must be some procedure in the licensing regime by which the matter may be addressed.
So there is a clear complaints procedure as far as local authorities are concerned.
Yes. If you look at it across the board, local authorities have a wider interest than just that of a planning authority. They may have an interest as a land owner, as protective environmental health authorities, or a number of different interests, which mean that they may wish to take action against operators, not through the planning system but through the licence itself.
If we had the system that is referred to in your document, who would arbitrate? Who would be the decision maker? How would it fit with the planning appeals procedure that was mentioned?
As is the case in other spheres, I imagine that the answers to those questions easily could be set out in guidance. A distinction could be made in any guidance between what the planning system and the other regulations that are involved could do, and if people are dissatisfied for any reason they can go either to an ombudsman or to the particular Government department that regulates telecommunications.
So the complaints procedure will relate to the licensing element, not to the planning element?
In my understanding, the complaints procedure will relate principally to the licensing element, and there are other procedures that already are established within the planning regime with which people can take up their grievances.
I do not think that there is anything at the present time. Currently, if someone takes a complaint through local government to the ombudsman, it goes through a number of mechanisms. The ombudsman does not just look at the issue, but at how the council responded to the issue, how each of the appropriate departments dealt with it, and whether it was dealt with in an effective way. We do not have an established system. It would be difficult for an ombudsman, or any independent authority, to make a judgment. That issue may need to be clarified as matters progress.
Paragraph 3(b) of your submission states:"The extent of local authorities' control must be defined, eg what control authorities have in the event of an operator ignoring advice; also, the responsibilities of other agencies who have control of non land use aspects, such as the role of the NRPB and House . . . and of telecommunications companies themselves."What is your view on the appropriate extent of control by local authorities? What are your views on the responsibilities of the other agencies that were mentioned, and how they would fit into the whole process?
With regard to the first part of your question, our view on what should be the extent of control is simple: there should be planning permission for major structures. That would bring into line a lot of the issues regarding telecommunications and would let them be dealt with in a normal way. The difficulty with the present system, and perhaps with the prior notification procedure, is the extent of local authorities' ability to control different aspects of development. Almost by definition, a prior notification procedure makes the assumption, "This is really permitted development. It must be approved, unless there is some out-of-the-way reason that the authority has to take into account." Whatever happens, Government has to provide clear definitions in the new guidance. It is a possibility that if they bring larger telecommunications developments into planning control, they can define the main materialities that were mentioned earlier this morning and define what should be taken into account by local authorities and what may, in some circumstances, receive less weight.
Will you expand on how the NRPB and HSE feed into that?
The main way that they feed into it is not through the planning process, but through the operators having to observe the current guidance and regulations from HSE, as advised by the NRPB.
Is that outside the planning system?
Yes.
Would that not be brought into the planning system by requiring them to make a planning application?
It would only be brought in to the extent that if there was any doubt about an installation, we would ask to be assured that the installation complied with all relevant HSE guidance.
Would that happen under prior notification as well?
Yes, there is no reason why that should not happen under prior notification.
What guidance do you think the NRPB should issue to take a sufficiently precautionary approach. We have heard a lot over the past few weeks about where local authorities are at the moment. What specific advice should be given?
That comes back again to what is considered a safe distance for masts to be located from buildings.
Do you think that Government advice on telecommunications developments would be best provided through the national planning policy guidelines or the planning advice notes or national guidance of a different form that would be regularly updated? What should that guidance address?
It would be helpful to have national guidance. That would be consistent with the guidance on other planning factors. When a national planning policy guideline appears, it is usually accompanied by a planning advice note, which relates to good practice, and a circular on the degree of interpretation that the Scottish Executive thinks might be put on the NPPG. All three types of guidance could be appropriate.
You have already touched on my next question. How do you see the planning and development of telecommunications infrastructure fitting in with the concept of community planning?
One of the difficulties is that, as recent experience in the Highlands shows, this is a dynamic industry. It produces a lot of proposals and it is difficult to fit that in within the time scales of the community planning process—by which I assume that you mean the production of structure and local plans. It is not impossible; it can be helpful to take telecommunication developments into account in the community planning process.
For example, in Highland, various meetings are held prior to local plans appearing, in the planning for real process. That is an opportunity to let the public air their views and to be advised of impending developments in their area. It could be taken into account but it may need careful handling in relation to the rate of roll-out of operators' network programmes and the planning process as a whole.
As there are no other questions, I thank the COSLA witnesses for coming along. I know that you are going to sit through the next session.We will now have a short comfort break.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
I welcome members to the resumed meeting of the Transport and the Environment Committee. There are certain areas from our discussion earlier this morning that we wish to follow up in writing with COSLA. Councillor David Hamilton indicated that there would be no problem with that, which we welcome. This next part of the meeting will be difficult, because of the number of witnesses. None the less, we would like to get some more detail about the issues that we are investigating, particularly from an individual local authority perspective. I formally invite David Banford, Alan Henderson, Brian Kelly and Bill Hepburn to participate in this session—other inputs would also be welcome. I want the witnesses to focus on how individual local authorities deal with the issues. I begin by asking how local authorities' precautionary policies on the siting of telecommunications developments relate to councils' role as the planning authority. That issue has been raised on a number of occasions.
The position in Glasgow is best described as bitty—it is all over the place because different committees consider the issue. I know that this committee's main concern today is planning, but other issues arise in our economic and physical regeneration committee—a difficult one to remember. Other issues also arise on the planning and development control front and in environmental services, where I report back on our findings. Although I say that the policy is bitty, it is, nevertheless, developing. We have not yet got a document that we can refer to and say, "This is Glasgow's position." The policy affects, and surfaces in, the areas of different committees.
From Edinburgh's point of view, the ownership side of considering these installations is dealt with separately from the planning process—it is dealt with through a separate range of committees. In view of public concerns about the risks associated with this equipment, the council undertakes a formal consultation process with the local community before it comes to a decision on installing masts on its premises.
It is the same in Dumfries and Galloway—we have no set policy on the precautionary principles. This is a relatively new, evolving concept; it is clear from the evidence that the committee heard this morning, and from the debate at last week's conference, that there is a serious lack of evidence on which to base a tangible policy. The authorities look to Government for that guidance.
We are particularly interested in the policy in relation to property owned by the authorities. Have the authorities faced any contradictions or difficulties?
Glasgow currently has more than 70 masts, aerials and antennae—call them what you will—on top of multi-storey blocks. The interpretation has been given that that might be better than placing them on top of schools, for example. Nevertheless, we have to examine the history, which, I am told, goes right back to the 1960s, when developments started for different forms of communication. We are addressing a new issue in the context of a long history. It will be all the more difficult to take a new position for that reason—we cannot turn the clock back.
The issue of income has been raised at a couple of this committee's meetings and in some media reports. What income do you expect from the operators from siting masts on council property?
Personally, I have always regarded it as a low blow when that matter comes up in the media. Clearly, the council is not placing masts on its property with the intention of gaining income. The fact that we get income for it is another issue; it is not a matter that I ever bring before committee or on which I have been questioned. From the perspective of public health, the advice that I have offered has been taken. In my council, as far as I am aware, there has never been a question that income is a motive—quite the contrary. That has been said in the press but, as I said, such a claim is a low blow.
Does anyone else wish to comment on that? It is a widely held view.
I am curious to know the ballpark figure. I appreciate that you might think that that is a low blow but, if local authorities have to site these things, it seems perfectly legitimate and reasonable for them to charge for it. Is there a pattern of charges? Are some local authorities perhaps undercharging?
To try to help you, I can tell you that I have seen written evidence that the figure for Glasgow is in excess of £500,000 per annum. I have compiled the data and seen the figure in reports.
Is there a methodology for how charges are levied? Should there be?
I reiterate that I am not involved in that, so I do not know how a figure is set or derived. It is not something that I have ever been party to. I know that there is a charge, but I have no way of assessing what a reasonable charge should be.
Would other council representatives care to comment on how they have derived their respective charges?
I am speaking from a planning viewpoint. I do not know the details of ownership and income.
I would not like to see a Dutch auction in which, for example, Midlothian undercuts the City of Edinburgh and somebody sites a telecommunications mast 100 m from the boundary. From a planning perspective, could you see the advantage of a national tariff as opposed to a locally operated rate? If there is national planning, is a set tariff laid down, as may be the case for other installations on local authority property?
It struck me earlier in the meeting that there could be some difficulty between local authorities if, for example, Glasgow had a policy of not wanting a mast and an adjoining authority was happy to have one 50 m from the boundary. How would Glasgow react to Renfrewshire in such a case, or vice versa? I suspect that tensions will arise between authorities, irrespective of the financial aspect, as a result of policy differences.
I do not think that such matters can be taken into account when dealing with the individual planning applications. If they were, developers might be accused of buying planning permission. We make a strong point of divorcing any consideration of a lease arrangement from planning considerations.
This money must go into a black hole in the authority, as I have never heard of it before.Has any authority considered hypothecating income from the siting of a telecommunications mast for those elements in the community that might be immediately affected? For example, if the mast was put on the top of a tower block, the money might be used to improve the amenities within that tower block.
That is certainly not the case, to my knowledge.
That might be a mechanism for allowing people to make a decision for themselves about the cost benefits of an installation.
I understand that, if someone owns a private home in a high-rise flat, they will receive a share of the rental income. Council tenants get nothing, but private householders get their divvy-up of the rental money. I have heard that from several residents.
Am I allowed to speak in this part of the meeting?
Yes, you are entitled to speak.
If a mast is built on a community centre—and I know of such examples—the money goes directly to the community centre. That is hypothecation, if you like. As in the case of developers who want to build houses in a council area, the potential contribution has to be considered. I do not know Glasgow's budget, but I would have thought that £500,000 is not even a ripple—it is nothing in comparison to the size of that council's budget. As an elected member, I think that the really important thing is to ensure at all times that any request for an installation is separated from the financial benefit that the local authority may or may not get. I would be extremely concerned if the financial consideration was prioritised to the detriment of either the visual or the health issue, which are the most important considerations. I cannot answer in any specific terms. There would be no competition between Edinburgh and Midlothian. Midlothian won Ikea—Edinburgh is extremely arrogant about that. At the end of the day, such competition causes ructions. There are examples all over the place of one council making a decision that means that operators find it easier to go to another council. Standardisation will help to alleviate that problem.
I want to ask about the application process. Is it easier for local authorities to put masts on the roof of high-rise flats than it is for a private landowner? Is the process the same?
As I understand it, the operator, not the local authority, would be the applicant. If it were the local authority, there would be a different planning procedure.
However, if the council has an interest, as it is the owner of the property, is the process just the same?
If the council has an interest in the siting of the mast, a decision must be made whether the case is referrable to the Scottish ministers for approval.
I want to ask about what the current framework does and does not achieve, in addressing the needs of telecommunications development. How does that advice come to sit with you?
Could you clarify what you mean?
I mean the current framework—the one that is operating now, the status quo provision of advice and so on.
The current system?
Yes.
The current system is completely inadequate. The limit is 15 m for permitted development. That is the measurement that the industry uses: it builds right up to the 15 m limit. Some of the structures are fairly inconsequential, in that they are slim monopoles that may have two aerials fitted at the top. However, much more substantial steel gantry tripod structures can also be built pretty much at will by the operators if they are permitted development. The planning authorities have no effective mechanism to deal with any objection that they might have to those structures.The public feel at a loss, aggrieved and almost abandoned by the system when they see 15 m gantries being erected in close proximity to houses, with no redress. That has a major effect, but the industry carries on regardless. I know that the licensing system obliges companies to have regard for environmental considerations, but it is very difficult for the planning authorities to make headway in relation to that legislation. That raises the question who should police the licence. That is not the responsibility of the planning authority. The public perception is that the licences are not policed and that the whole system is inadequate.
City of Edinburgh Council has experience of operating under three different procedures. First, the permitted development rights mean that we have little control and that fairly large installations can go ahead without people living nearby knowing anything about it. The public cannot believe that such large structures can be erected without people receiving neighbour notifications or being allowed to contribute to the process.Secondly, in conservation areas, we have to be notified of installations and we can say whether we think that they would adversely affect the character and appearance of the conservation area. Nevertheless, that is not a complete planning process—it is done outside the public arena and is not open to public scrutiny. That causes us concern.Thirdly, several conservation areas in the built-up areas of the city have article 4 directions—approved by the Scottish Office five years ago—which remove permitted development rights for several use classes, including the class that applies to telecommunications developments. In those areas, we have experience of operating a system in which the operators must submit a planning application. We have found that very helpful because it gets the community involved. We have also found that the operators respond positively to that approach—they know that we have put that direction in place in areas where the environment is particularly sensitive. They usually want to put their installations on top of tall buildings, which are often listed. They know that unless they address the concerns, they will not receive planning permission. They work with us to the extent of erecting mock-ups of the installations during the consultation period, to allow the public and amenity groups to see what the apparatus looks like. That experience has led the City of Edinburgh Council to believe that such powers should be applied to all proposals; we support COSLA's approach to that.
I am not a planner, so I could not add to what has been said.
I want to pick up on the point about enforcement. Are those policy areas where detailed planning is required effectively policed or do you find that you have difficulties with the operators? Do the operators change the specifications or fail to comply with conditions? There are always practical difficulties in enforcing planning conditions. It would be useful to know whether the practice of planning is proving effective right through to the final development. That would give us a steer as to whether a further range of applications would be helpful.
My experience from the few cases that I have dealt with that required a planning application is that they complied with the terms of the permission. To date, I have had no cause for concern with any of the sites. Generally, the industry acts responsibly when planning permission is required for installations.
I am sympathetic to the idea that we should consider generalising planning requirements, particularly for neighbour notification schemes, so that people know what is going to be built in their locality and have an opportunity to make their views known. Is there an opportunity for the planning or licensing authority, as part of its dialogue with the operator, to discuss alternative sites that may be more environmentally suitable, either because they are further from housing or are in a less intrusive setting? I know about one example of an operator putting up a mast overnight without notifying the neighbours. In my view, abundant alternatives were available nearby. In addition to considering neighbour notification as a planning requirement, do we need to consider the terms under which an authority can refuse an application—for example, because a better or more suitable site is available in the immediate vicinity?
In my experience, if the planning authority finds a proposal unacceptable, one of its first responses will be to ask the operator to site the mast elsewhere. A dialogue begins, which is a fairly normal process. If something is wrong with any planning application, it is not usually rejected out of hand; a remedy is sought. With masts, that may mean investigating alternative sites. If agreement is reached, the outcome will be an alternative site. The process can also be reversed. It is quite common for applicants to engage in a dialogue before lodging an application. That is a beneficial process, as it allows the key points to be highlighted and discussed so that an effective solution can be agreed on before the application lands on the officer's desk. Dialogue is all-important. We would seek alternative sites if we felt that there was something wrong with the original proposal. Inevitably, there will be circumstances in which the operator says that the technicalities of the installation are such that it must go in a certain place. Those circumstances can be difficult to deal with, but they are part of our daily diet.
Dialogue is important and does take place. In the absence of national planning guidelines, the Lothian structure plan includes a policy that sets out the sorts of issues that we expect operators to address. One of those is the fact that they must consider alternative locations and demonstrate the operational reasons for choosing a particular location. Applications in conservation areas are subject to the non-statutory development control guidelines on telecommunication masts—such guidelines exist on a number of issues. The guidelines include a list of points that we expect operators to consider—for example, the need to negotiate with owners of buildings of less architectural significance if we are concerned about the impact of the equipment on a particular building. Operators would need to consider other locations where the infrastructure could be more easily camouflaged and have less of an impact. Although dialogue is important, it is equally important to set out the ground rules and expectations in advance.
First, I want to pursue the issue of conservation areas, where you have changed the scope of the planning system. Has that had a significant effect on telecommunications development in those areas?Secondly, what are your performance criteria for processing such applications? Are they processed in the same way as other applications, or is the process slower? Telecommunications is an interesting area, because it is a living example of full planning powers.
Edinburgh is traditionally the slowest authority in terms of the number of applications that it determines in two months—about half of all types of applications are determined in that period. That is because of the large number of conservation areas involved and the environmental issues that we have to deal with and consult the public on. Our experience is that telecommunications applications have not been handled any more slowly than those for other types of development. If telecommunications applications take longer than two months, that is because we are discussing a more acceptable alternative location with the applicants. The alternative is that the applicants get their decision quickly, but that that decision is a refusal. We find that they—like other developers and operators—would rather continue negotiation and discussion to find an acceptable solution. There is not a dramatic difference in performance in the way in which such proposals are dealt with.
Has that stopped the roll-out of any developments? Is Edinburgh an area in which mobile phones do not work? I suspect that that is not the case.
I am sure that the operators would tell us if we were holding up developments. I think that the operators have accepted, in Edinburgh, the environmental constraints of a world heritage site and have been willing to look at alternative solutions. That has been a positive reaction from them.
I want to conclude an earlier answer. The Glasgow experience has been that many developments have been moved to alternative locations because of the pressure; equally, a number of applications have been withdrawn for the same reason.Further to the point that Alan Henderson just made, Glasgow development control committee's performance is monitored, as the performances of all such committees are. Our performance, too, is lower than expected; at the last time of checking, it stood at around 59 per cent, while the Accounts Commission expects us to deal with applications at a hit level of around 80 per cent. We are already under severe pressure. As you know, the committee in Glasgow meets weekly, so it is very resource intensive. If we took new issues such as this on board, the pressures would become worse and, in some respects, other applications would suffer. Indeed, all applications would suffer some sort of punishment and the performance might go down.
We seem to be moving the debate towards procedures and performance. At a previous meeting, Mr Nick Greer gave evidence on behalf of one of the operators. He said that the industry liked the concept of permitted development because it created a favourable environment for the operators—an environment that removed them from public debate. He promoted the argument that an adverse environment would be created if the operators had to go through the proper planning process. The reason for his view was that most cases—under the prior notification scheme—would be dealt with under delegated powers, whereas under the planning application system, cases would be moved away from planning officers towards politicians. He saw that as a retrograde step.What Mr Greer fails to understand is that in the vast majority of Scottish authorities, most applications are dealt with by delegation to planning officers. About 80 per cent of applications to my authority are dealt with by officers at my level. It is only when something goes wrong—where there is a conflict with policy or when somebody lodges an objection—that the application moves to a committee. Once it is in committee, the matter is debated in an open forum.The industry does not understand properly how planning authorities work and it is high time that it did. I hope that if we engage in dialogue, we can make clear our procedures to the industry. If we had a system that required planning permission for the largest structures, an application would come to the authority in the usual way and officers would examine it. If they were content with that application and there were no objections to it, it would be approved as a delegated item. That would be no different from prior approval; it is only when there is a problem that an application goes before a committee.
Thank you for clarifying that.
I note the points that were made about the effectiveness of the current framework, and the number of applications that are approved because they are delegated to officers. I would like to explore the effectiveness of the prior approval system. A number of interesting points were made about that by previous witnesses to the committee, particularly by those from the Royal Town Planning Institute in Scotland.As an example of a situation in which prior approval may not have worked for agricultural buildings, the RTPI said in its written submission that"planning authorities . . . are only too well aware that the imposition of improved standards for such buildings at this stage is likely to have little impact on a landscape already extensively blighted by poorly sited and inappropriately designed farm buildings."Planning authorities presumably seek to maintain and enhance the environment, whatever its current state. Do you think that that is fair comment? Does prior approval fail to work because of the attitude and approach of planning authorities?
Generally, that is fair comment. An important element of the prior approval system is that development remains permitted development, so that the planning authority is starting on its back foot in trying to improve environmental standards. My experience of the prior approval system for agricultural and forestry buildings is that our powers are restricted by development orders. The range of considerations that we can apply is restricted because the legislation says that those structures effectively have outline approval. We are not allowed to challenge the principle of erection of an agricultural building; all that we can do is consider its siting and appearance. With that system our powers are limited by statute. With the planning application system, however, we have a greater ability to seek environmental quality.
Therefore, there is a clear precedent in such cases. How does the prior approval system differ from the Executive's telecommunications proposals?
I have still to see the Executive's published proposal. If that is constructed in a similar vein, I would expect there still to be a restriction on planning authorities' ability to deal effectively with the environmental consequences of telecommunications proposals. One system is inherently restrictive to planning authorities and the other is not.
I have questions about the Executive's proposals for telecommunications developments. Can you describe the Executive proposal and what it entails?
The Executive proposes a two-tier system—a 28-day period for prior approval for structures on buildings, and a 42-day period for free-standing structures. That reflects the English and Welsh system, which is up and running.The first stage is an application being lodged with the authority. The authority must then decide whether prior approval is necessary and must investigate the application in sufficient depth to make that judgment. If it is content that there is no problem with the scheme, the usual permitted development provisos will simply take effect.If the council takes the view that there is a difficulty and, therefore, that prior approval is necessary, the procedure moves to the second stage and an advertisement is published. The Executive is suggesting that neighbour notification should take place. If neighbour notification does not happen, the current situation will be weakened vis-à-vis planning applications.Phase 2 takes one into the 42-day period. As Bill Hepburn said, if an authority misses that deadline, it is deemed that permission has been granted and the authority loses the opportunity to modify the application. If an authority decides that there is a problem and does not find a proposal acceptable, the application must, presumably, go to committee with the report that sets out why the council finds the application unacceptable. That mirrors exactly what happens with planning applications. A decision by the committee that there should not be prior approval is equivalent to a refusal of planning permission. In difficult cases, therefore, prior approval does not achieve anything that the planning permission procedure could not.
What about public notification and consultation?
I understand that there is no neighbour notification—that is a defect. A public advertisement is required—if members of the public see that advertisement and respond timeously to it they can participate in the debate. If they miss that chance they cannot.
Can you confirm that there would be one public advertisement?
Yes.
Are there issues about the complexity of the suggested process?
There are various types of prior notification system. The system in the proposed legislation is inherently more complex than the comparative simplicity of a planning application. When the existing legislation was drawn up, it was done so in the context of deregulation—allowing industry to do things more quickly and simply—but the statutory structure that has been created to facilitate that is complicated and difficult for practitioners to work with. It is possibly far more complicated for the public to understand. We often have to try to explain why some things need planning permission and others do not, and the public are bemused by our answers. I think that the planning application system is simpler than the prior notification system. If the planning application were used, everybody would know where they stood and we could get on with the business and reach the correct decisions.
In this meeting
Everything on 1 Dec 1999 →- Scottish Parliament Transport and the Environment Committee Wednesday 1 December 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 2
- Telecommunications Committee business · 302
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.