Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Executive Responses

National Health Service (Travelling Expenses and Remission of Charges) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2007 (SSI 2007/225)

Tuesday 27 March 2007 Subordinate Legislation Committee Committee business 15 contributions · 4 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

15 contributions
Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab The Convener · Stirling
link

We asked the Executive to explain the vires for regulation 2, which gives another provision retrospective effect. We have dealt with the issue before. As I understand it, the Executive is arguing that it has taken the approach based on the idea of fairness. However, as members will see, the legal brief states that that argument does not really apply, as there should be a power in the original act if a provision is to apply retrospectively. What are members' thoughts?

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I do not think that any member will disagree that we want to be fair to students throughout Scotland, particularly to those from more deprived backgrounds. There is no lack of sympathy for the policy intention. However, as a committee, we should address our concern about the use of retrospective powers that are not expressly provided for.Our legal advisers make a strong argument, but I thought that perhaps the most worrying comment was towards the end of the brief, where they point out that there have been four such examples in recent years—civil legal aid regulations account for the other three—which may amount to a trend.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

In months—sorry. That trend is what is particularly worrying about the idea of justifying retrospective legislation in this manner, which is effectively what the Executive is doing.

Stewart Maxwell SNP West of Scotland
link

I agree with Ken. There are a couple of issues.First, despite the fact that I agree with the fairness argument—in this case, in the effect on students—we can never claim that when we are being fair to somebody we are not being unfair to somebody else. I am not sure that the Executive's argument holds water. In the previous cases, with civil legal aid regulations, the argument was about fees. At the end of the day, it was the taxpayer who had to fund those fees, so were we being unfair to the taxpayer when we were being fair to those involved? It is not logical to say that the fairness argument holds. It may be that nobody will challenge it legally, but I believe that there is a difficulty in the logic of the Executive's argument.My second point is that, even if we accept that the Executive is trying to do the right thing, once it brings about uncertainty in the law it creates difficulty. People should be able to expect that the law will be certain at any one time, and we should be cautious about the idea that the Executive can come along later and introduce retrospective legislation when nothing in the original act provides that it can do so. If there is such a provision, that is fair enough—people will expect it to happen. However, when there is no such provision, they would not expect it to happen. An Executive taking a power to apply retrospectively something that is not in the original act is a dangerous road to go down. It opens up all sorts of possibilities. Even if we agree with the policy intention in the four cases so far, I am concerned that we will end up in a situation in which the procedure has become the norm and that future Executives could say that there is precedent. My concern is general; it is not about the policy intention, but about using the powers in that way.

Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab The Convener · Stirling
link

What do members think about paragraph 29 of the legal brief, which mentions the Joint Committee on Statutory Instruments at Westminster?

Murray Tosh Con West of Scotland
link

It is an interesting comment, and the conclusion is clearly that the Executive should amend primary legislation rather than tinker with secondary legislation, draw inferences and go beyond its powers.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

The Parliament has the power to apply retrospective legislation. However, in this case, although I suppose that we are being consulted, the Parliament is not really being consulted or giving its approval in an appropriate manner for such a major digression from accepted practice. We should flag up our concerns.

Murray Tosh Con West of Scotland
link

We have not really been consulted—we have just noticed that it is happening on the way past. If we had been consulted and somebody could have said whether it is good practice, that might have been a better position for the Executive to find itself in. However, it is clearly just winging it.

Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab The Convener · Stirling
link

Okay. We will bring two points to the attention of the lead committee. First, regulation 2 appears to give regulation 3(2)(c) retrospective effect, but the parent act contains no authority to do that. Secondly, because of that, there are doubts about the vires of regulation 2.

Stewart Maxwell SNP West of Scotland
link

Will the Local Government and Transport Committee consider the regulations this afternoon?

Stewart Maxwell SNP West of Scotland
link

Will we be able to get our arguments to the committee before it meets this afternoon?

Stewart Maxwell SNP West of Scotland
link

I know that they are fantastic. I just wanted to check.

  1. Scottish Parliament Subordinate Legislation Committee Tuesday 27 March 2007 Subordinate legislation · 1
  2. Executive Responses Committee business · 3
  3. Executive Responses Committee business · 3
  4. Executive Responses Committee business · 5
  5. Executive Responses Committee business · 5
  6. Executive Responses Committee business · 15
  7. Instrument Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 1
  8. Instruments Not Laid Before the Parliament Subordinate legislation · 1
  9. Instruments Not Laid Before the Parliament Subordinate legislation · 9
  10. Legacy Paper Committee business · 23

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.