We asked the Executive several questions about the implementation of the public participation directive and members will have seen the response. On the questions that we asked about implementation of the PPD, the delay in commencing consultation and the transposition note, are members content to report that information was sought from the Executive and to pass that on?
Official Report · Committee
Executive Responses
Environmental Impact Assessment (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2006 (SSI 2006/614)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Dr Sylvia Jackson Lab 10
- Stewart Maxwell SNP 7
- Ken Macintosh Lab 3
- Mairi Gibson Legal Adviser 2
The record
22 contributionsYes.
The most serious point is on implementation, in paragraph 5 on page 2 of the supplementary legal brief, which says:"The arguments advanced are capable of enabling compliance with the Directive (although without extensive consideration of the relevant legislative regimes it is not possible to be conclusive). In the circumstances, the Committee may wish to report to the lead committee that information was sought from the Executive and has been received."The point is about the amount of searching that would be involved. As I said, extensive consideration would be required to be conclusive about the implementation. The best that we can say is that the provision seems okay.
What a ringing endorsement.
I know. Do you want to read paragraph 5, which forms the crux of the argument?
I read the paragraph before the meeting and I reread it just now. In many ways, it is damning. If our advisers have such difficulty, what chance does anybody else have? The problem is not necessarily that the provision is wrong—it may well be fine; I do not particularly doubt that—but that proving whether the provision is correct involves much difficulty.
Do members mind if I ask Mairi Gibson to explain in more detail? What she has just said sounded more convincing than what I said.
The directive allows member states discretion as to how to implement its provisions on consulting the public. The regulations take a slightly different approach according to the subject. However, we cannot extrapolate that a different approach means incompatibility for subjects for which some provisions do not exist—more expertise in the general subject is required. I concluded that I did not feel able to go as far as saying that doubt exists about whether the directive has been implemented adequately. That is why I thought that I could go as far as to say that information had been sought and received. A difference exists according to the subject, but we cannot conclude incompatibility from that.
That is fundamentally what the convener said. The problem is that, without that expertise, we cannot be—
Conclusive.
Yes. That leaves us in a slightly difficult position, but we can do nothing other than accept what our advisers and the Executive have said.
Do members have other points?
I am not sure why we are making such a huge issue of the matter. The directive is about compliance with public participation measures and ensuring that people in other member states know about projects that we are implementing and which may affect them. Is that right?
Yes.
The directive is also about ensuring that people here are aware of projects in other member states that may affect them. My reading is that the Executive says that it is relying on other member states to ensure that the public are fully informed. Am I oversimplifying the matter?
I am not sure whether the explanation that the Executive gave covered how the Scottish public would be consulted about a project in another member state. Provision is made for some subjects but not others and the Executive response did not quite explain that. However, I did not feel able to extrapolate any other conclusion from that; the difference might have a policy justification.
I do not think that we are making a big issue of the matter. We are just pointing out the slight difficulty.
That is all that we are doing. We are pointing out that the legal advisers tell us that considerable effort would be needed to consider all the various elements in order to be conclusive.
Yes.
Paragraphs 12 to 14 of the supplementary legal brief concern the other point. Paragraph 14 gives a summary:"Taking into account primarily the legal effect created by section 101 of the Scotland Act, but also that other corresponding UK provision will be made, we do not consider that reporting the instrument to the lead committee as potentially raising a devolution issue is warranted in this case".Obviously, that is for us to decide on. We can flag that up.
I do not think that that is a problem.
Are members content to report that there has been a failure to follow proper drafting procedure?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 23 Jan 2007 →- Scottish Parliament Subordinate Legislation Committee Tuesday 23 January 2007 Subordinate legislation · 1
- Executive Responses Committee business · 9
- Executive Responses Committee business · 22
- Executive Responses Committee business · 5
- Instrument Subject to Approval Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instruments Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instruments Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instruments Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instruments Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instruments Not Laid Before the Parliament Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instruments Not Laid Before the Parliament Subordinate legislation · 9
- Transposition and Implementation of European Directives Inquiry Committee business · 43
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.