Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Draft Instruments Subject to Approval

Members of the Parole Board (Removal Tribunal) Regulations 2003 (draft)

Tuesday 4 February 2003 Subordinate Legislation Committee Subordinate legislation 31 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

31 contributions
Margo MacDonald Ind The Convener · Lothians
link

The committee might ask the Executive to explain the legal basis of regulation 5(3). Paragraph 3B of schedule 2 to the Prisoners and Criminal Proceedings (Scotland) Act 1993 provides that: "The tribunal shall consist of the following three members, who shall be appointed by the Lord President of the Court of Session–(a) either a Senator of the College of Justice or a sheriff principal (who shall preside);(b) a person who is, and has been for at least ten years, legally qualified; and(c) one other person who shall not be legally qualified."That implies no variation. The regulations would introduce the possibility of variation. If one member of the tribunal were unable to participate in an investigation, the Lord President could decide that the tribunal might proceed with only some of the three prescribed members.

Margo MacDonald Ind The Convener · Lothians
link

The enabling power, which is paragraph 3D of schedule 2 to the 1993 act, states that: "The regulations made by the Scottish ministers-(a) may make provision enabling the tribunal, at any time during an investigation, to suspend a member from office and providing as to the effect and duration of such suspension; and(b) shall make such further provision as respects the tribunal as the Scottish Ministers consider necessary or expedient, including provision for the procedure to be followed by and before it."

Gordon Jackson Lab Glasgow Govan
link

I suppose that that might apply to a situation in which the work was almost finished.

Margo MacDonald Ind The Convener · Lothians
link

I hate to say this, my learned friend, but for nit-pickers it does not matter whether work is starting, is in progress or has finished. An investigation either can or cannot take place, and according to the 1993 act, it cannot.

Gordon Jackson Lab Glasgow Govan
link

If a tribunal with three members has not started its proceedings and one of its members dies, that person is replaced by another person of that category. However, when the hearing is almost finished, all the evidence has been heard and everything has been done, it might be obvious to everybody that all three tribunal members agree, and the person who is under investigation might know that they agree, because people get vibes. If one tribunal member died just 10 minutes before the tribunal was to issue its final determination—I am being facetious, but only a little—what would be the sense in appointing a replacement? What would be done? Would that person restart proceedings and hear all the evidence again?

Margo MacDonald Ind The Convener · Lothians
link

That is entirely reasonable if all three members agree and the outcome is obvious to the person who is under investigation. However, what happens if all three members do not agree and the outcome is not obvious to the person who is under investigation?

Gordon Jackson Lab Glasgow Govan
link

The replacement is made only if the person who is under investigation wants the missing member to be replaced. The person who is under investigation can always insist on a third person's appointment.

Gordon Jackson Lab Glasgow Govan
link

If the person who is under investigation says, "I am content for the determination to be issued in the names of the two remaining members of the tribunal," why should a third member be appointed? What is that person to do? Should the tribunal start again and hear the case again? What role can that third person play in proceedings?

Margo MacDonald Ind The Convener · Lothians
link

Nobody disagrees with you, because that is common sense. However, the enabling act does not allow for that. We are saying that the act does not allow for such a situation and that a change needs to be made to allow for that.

Gordon Jackson Lab Glasgow Govan
link

I do not understand. Perhaps I am just being stupid.

Margo MacDonald Ind The Convener · Lothians
link

No. The act does not allow for the variation in the regulations. I do not argue that it is not a good idea to have the variation in the regulations. I argue that, legally, that variation is not permitted under the act, so a change will have to be made.

Ian Jenkins LD Tweeddale, Ettrick and Lauderdale
link

Could we draw the matter to the Executive's attention?

Gordon Jackson Lab Glasgow Govan
link

The convener says that, under schedule 2 to the 1993 act, a tribunal must have three members.

Margo MacDonald Ind The Convener · Lothians
link

That is correct, because the act uses the word "shall".

Gordon Jackson Lab Glasgow Govan
link

Therefore, the fact that the regulations say that the third member does not have to be reappointed is—

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

The position is contradictory. Perhaps we could ask the Executive for clarification.

Margo MacDonald Ind The Convener · Lothians
link

We can draw the matter to the Executive's attention, because we are probably right. The Executive can fix it.

Gordon Jackson Lab Glasgow Govan
link

It does not make sense to appoint a third person with five minutes to go.

Margo MacDonald Ind The Convener · Lothians
link

We are not talking sense; we are talking subordinate legislation and powers.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I think that everybody agrees with Gordon Jackson.

Margo MacDonald Ind The Convener · Lothians
link

Nobody disagrees with him, but the act does not provide such a power. We think that that power should be available, because it makes sense. It is up to the Executive to find out how to obtain that power.

Ian Jenkins LD Tweeddale, Ettrick and Lauderdale
link

Substitutes in extra time have been known to score winning goals and change the situation.

Margo MacDonald Ind The Convener · Lothians
link

I am sorry, gentlemen—we are arguing policy. We do not talk policy.

Gordon Jackson Lab Glasgow Govan
link

I can see why, if the person who is under investigation says that they want the tribunal member to be replaced, they can have that member replaced, but the replacement should be made only with the consent of the person who is under investigation. However, perhaps doing so would still be illegal.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I am sure that the Executive will clear up the matter for us before our argument resembles that in the letters between the Marx brothers and the brothers Warner.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

That is life-affirming procedure.

  1. Scottish Parliament Subordinate Legislation Committee Tuesday 4 February 2003 (Morning) Subordinate legislation · 3
  2. Delegated Powers Scrutiny Committee business · 6
  3. Delegated Powers Scrutiny Committee business · 4
  4. Delegated Powers Scrutiny Committee business · 10
  5. Executive Responses Committee business · 1
  6. Draft Instruments Subject to Approval Subordinate legislation · 1
  7. Draft Instruments Subject to Approval Subordinate legislation · 9
  8. Draft Instruments Subject to Approval Subordinate legislation · 1
  9. Draft Instruments Subject to Approval Subordinate legislation · 1
  10. Draft Instruments Subject to Approval Subordinate legislation · 2
  11. Draft Instruments Subject to Approval Subordinate legislation · 31
  12. Instruments Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 2
  13. Instruments Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 3
  14. Instruments Not Laid Before the Parliament Subordinate legislation · 9

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.