Let us be grateful for the fact that these are draft regulations, because we must raise eight points on them with the Executive. The regulations are very odd. I will pick out a couple of points. Clarification is required on the matter of complaints, because there seems to be a difference in the draft regulations between a "relevant complaint" and a "complaint". It is not clear when a complaint is relevant; neither is it clear who can deal with the complaint. The regulations seem to make it possible for the convener alone to determine a case. In addition, the convener appears to be the only person to whom an appeal can be made about the tribunal's decision. That does not seem a clever way of drafting the regulations.
Official Report · Committee
Draft Instruments Subject to Approval
Bus User Complaints Tribunal Regulations 2002 (draft)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Margo MacDonald SNP 10
- Ian Jenkins LD 5
- Bristow Muldoon Lab 5
The record
20 contributionsAs you say, there are two connected matters, but we can think of them separately. The first is that if a tribunal rules against someone, an appeal can be made only to the tribunal's convener, who would have been involved in the original decision. That procedure seems odd and might be against the provisions of the European convention on human rights, because the convener would have a vested interest in the decision.
He might be a perfectly nice convener.
Absolutely.
But that provision is just a bit on the cosy side.
It just does not feel right. The second matter concerns drawing relevant complaints to the tribunal's attention. There appears to be no compulsion for the bus companies to make those relevant complaints available to the tribunal. Is that right?
I think so. That is what I thought.
I agree with the point about the independence of an appeal. However, is it not the case that, other than on points of law, the procedure under the regulations is not dissimilar to that of an industrial tribunal? In an industrial tribunal, when someone disputes the interpretation of facts, is not that referred to the tribunal for potential review, as opposed to being referred to an independent appeal? My point is that I suspect that the cases with which an industrial tribunal deals are generally more serious than those with which a bus user complaints tribunal would deal.I am not overly concerned about the matter, but I agree with the point that it would be better to have an independent appeal system.
I do not think that the committee should determine whether more weight should be given to a bus user's complaint than to an employee appealing against something in their employment contract. We cannot make that sort of decision, but we can decide whether the regulations' provisions are reasonable. Judicial review would be available, but the committee's attitude is that that is not satisfactory because one can appeal only on a point of law.
I am comfortable with the general point that an independent appeals process would be better—all I am saying is that similar examples exist.
In a way, you are betwixt and between on the issue. You said that there might be a parallel with industrial tribunals. What does the convener of an industrial tribunal do if an appeal is made against his tribunal's decision?
My understanding is that members of the tribunal may review the evidence, rather than the convener on his own. I think that the three members of the tribunal would review the evidence.
We spoke about the issue and thought it a bit cosy that the draft regulations say that the tribunal will have three members, but do not say that two or so members must make a decision. It could be argued that one member—the convener—could make a decision and that an appeal could be made only to the convener. We think that that is a flaw and would like the Executive to reconsider the matter. An industrial tribunal is not the same—as you say, an appeal is made to members of the tribunal rather than to the convener.
I think that it is up to the convener to accept a case for review.
That might be true, but that is different. The legal briefing mentions the possibility that an appeal can be made only to the person who may have made the decision.
I do not disagree with the general point.
I am glad about that. I was worried—I thought that there would be a vote. I hoped not—that would have been vulgar.
In line with the legal advice, we should refer the matter back to the Executive for its comments.
We will ask the Executive how it envisages the regulations working. We were confused—or rather, intrigued—by them.
These are draft regulations and there is an opportunity for the Executive to clarify matters and explain things to us.
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Mar 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Subordinate Legislation Committee Tuesday 5 March 2002 (Morning) Subordinate legislation · 1
- Delegated Powers Scrutiny Committee business · 10
- Executive Responses Committee business · 1
- Executive Responses Committee business · 1
- Executive Responses Committee business · 3
- Draft Instruments Subject to Approval Subordinate legislation · 20
- Draft Instruments Subject to Approval Subordinate legislation · 4
- Draft Instruments Subject to Approval Subordinate legislation · 3
- Instruments Subject to Approval Subordinate legislation · 1
- Instruments Subject to Annulment Subordinate legislation · 5
- Instruments Not Subject to Parliamentary Control Subordinate legislation · 2
- Instruments Not Laid Before the Parliament Subordinate legislation · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.