Like other members, I have carefully considered the information that has come before the committee. The parliamentary clerks go about their business impartially and with integrity. They are trusted by members of all political parties and none to guide members on the matters that we must deal with, which are often complicated.In this case, I do not accept that the opinion that was given by counsel to the independent Scottish Parliamentary Standards Commissioner represents a better interpretation of the law than does the opinion that was given to Wendy Alexander by independent clerks in the Parliament. I do not accept that the counsel who gave an opinion to Mr Dyer had any more information at his disposal than did the Crown counsel or procurator fiscal.Perhaps we think that the donations that we have been considering were registrable, but is it right to go back on an opinion that was given and to change the rules without notice? I do not think so. In this case, the member acted on advice that was given to her, as I am sure other members would have done. We should judge the matter on that action and not on opinion, which is clearly divided.The advice from Parliament officials was that, as they read the law, the donations were not registrable. Crown counsel was unable to be sufficiently certain of the law to agree that the law had been broken and to bring a prosecution, as the standards commissioner's findings would have permitted. A spokesperson for the Crown Office said:"After very full and careful consideration of the report from the Scottish Parliamentary Standards Commissioner, Crown Counsel has concluded that a prosecution would not be appropriate in the full circumstances of this case. In coming to this decision, Crown Counsel had regard to the fact that: there is a degree of uncertainty surrounding the interpretation of these provisions; Miss Alexander sought the advice of the Clerk to the Standards committee in relation to this matter; a voluntary disclosure was made to the Electoral Commission",and"the issues raised by the case might more appropriately be dealt with by the Standards, Procedures and Public appointments committee",as we are doing.Mr Dyer's legal opinion said that the donations were registrable, although he states in his report that it is well established in law that when an opinion has been given,"imposition of a penalty on a person is possible only if it is imposed by clear words."I do not believe that the words were clear. However, the advice from the clerks to the member was in clear words, but the standards commissioner said:"The Clerks' advice however cannot affect my conclusion regarding a breach, which must be arrived at according to my independent judgement."That stance has amazed and troubled me. How can anyone arrive at a fair and independent judgment or conclusion when one of the main mitigating facts in a defence cannot be considered by the independent commissioner? Such a position is not acceptable and we must consider the issue further as a matter of urgency.I am sure that any fair-minded and impartial observer would agree with the decision of our Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service. As the convener announced at yesterday's meeting, the committee decided by a majority that there had been a breach of the rules. I do not agree with that decision and, having considered all the circumstances in the case, move that no sanction be imposed on the member. I support colleagues who have taken the same position.