Welcome to this meeting of the Standards, Procedures and Public Appointments Committee. Under item 1, the committee is asked to agree to re-establish four session 2 cross-party groups. Members will be aware that, in considering whether to approve proposed cross-party groups, we should take account of a range of matters, such as the group's purpose, as well as whether the group is being formed on the basis of public interest. The first proposed cross-party group that we are considering today is the proposed cross-party group on sexual health. I welcome Patrick Harvie to the committee. Patrick, would you like to make any comments?
No. The remit has not changed significantly since the group operated in the previous session. The only reason why we are being treated as making a new registration is that we did not quite get our act in gear in time to meet the 90-day deadline. However, the group is essentially the same as the one that existed in the previous session.
The second proposed cross-party group that we are considering today is the cross-party group on learning disability. I welcome Jackie Baillie and Pauline McNeill to the committee. Jackie Baillie is the group's convener. Do you have any comments that you wish to make, Jackie?
The third group seeking our approval today is the proposed cross-party group on Palestine. I welcome Pauline McNeill, the group's convener, to the meeting.As members will be aware, this proposed group has requested a waiver of rule 2 of section 6.3 of the code of conduct. That rule requires that each cross-party group should have a minimum of five MSP members and that each party that is represented on the Parliamentary Bureau should be represented in the group's membership.A note from Pauline McNeill that sets out the steps that have been taken to attract a Conservative MSP to the group's membership has been circulated to members. Pauline, would you like to comment?
The group began in 1999 or thereabouts, and I took over as convener in 2001. We have periodically had problems in getting members of all the main parties to sign up to what is an important group—certainly, despite my best efforts, I cannot persuade members of the Conservative party to join us this year. Members will see from the remit that, essentially, we have been raising awareness and, in particular, making links with regard to devolved issues—it is quite a specific remit. We have a fair representation from other parties, and I ask the committee to note that, of the two vice-conveners, one is from the Green party and the other is Margo MacDonald, the only independent member in the Parliament. Unfortunately, I am unable to get anyone from one of the main parties, the Conservative party, to sign up, but I have virtually everybody else signed up to the group and I hope that the committee will take that into consideration.
Thank you. Before we take questions, will you tell us the purpose of the £1 membership subscription? That is a question that has come up with other groups as well.
We decided to introduce that subscription in this session—we had not done it in previous sessions. It is mainly because we wanted to make it clear who was able to vote should a dispute ever arise, which it never has—there has only been one argument, which was with a member who joined but did not really sign up to the aims of the cross-party group. The subscription is a way to ensure that everyone who joins clearly understands the aims of the cross-party group—when they make the commitment to join, they pay a nominal fee of £1 and that entitles them to vote on any matters that arise.
I thank Pauline McNeill for the detail that she has given us on the matter. Again, I declare an interest, as my name appears on the group's membership list. Are we setting a precedent by allowing a group to be set up that does not meet the rule to which you referred?
You are not setting a precedent—each case is dealt with individually on its own merits. I understand that there was at least one occasion in session 2 on which a cross-party group that did not have members from each of the parties represented on the Parliamentary Bureau was approved.
MSPs from all parties except one have indicated an interest in forming the group, which has very laudable aims. I propose that, in this case, we grant approval to the establishment of the cross-party group on Palestine.
I was going to say the same thing. There is coverage across all parties, apart from the Conservative party, and the independent member is involved too. That shows that there is good cross-party support for the group within the Parliament.
I express my agreement as well, and I declare an interest, as I am a member of the group. I also apologise for not declaring that I am a member of the first cross-party group that we discussed. I second Cathie Craigie's proposal.
If there are no other comments from members, are we agreed that the cross-party group be established and that we waive the rule in question?Members indicated agreement.
I will not say a great deal. The cross-party group on visual impairment is another group that has existed since the early years of the first session of Parliament. It represents a broad range of interests in the area and has done so throughout the period. I have been a member on and off before becoming convener in this session. We have a good turnout, with regular attendance at meetings.
Yes. RNIB Scotland, which is one of the main supporters of the cross-party group, has, since the early years of the Parliament, received a donation from the education fund of Eli Lilly and Company. RNIB Scotland administers that donation, so it is not a direct grant to the cross-party group but it pays for the group's routine running expenses—sandwiches and things at lunch time, and so on. Importantly, it pays the travel expenses of blind and visually impaired people who attend the group, as there are different challenges in that regard.I gather that the whole £4,000 has not usually been required. The money is part of the funds that RNIB Scotland raises. Probably only £1,000 a year has been spent on the group in any one year. It depends on what the demands are. We do not have control of the money; in effect, RNIB Scotland pays for the administrative costs of the group with the money. Nonetheless, it was thought right to declare the money—both the amount and where it comes from—for the sake of openness.
I have not been involved with the money directly before, but I understand that a similar donation has been made every year since the beginning of the Parliament. RNIB Scotland has a large fundraising potential, and the money is part of the funding that goes to the organisation. Its initial purpose is to support the cross-party group. It cannot be guaranteed indefinitely, however. Such funding is often made available for a certain period and another funding source has to be found later on but, so far, the cross-party group has been funded in that way.
I do not think so. In a sense, it is at one remove from the cross-party group because it is a grant to RNIB Scotland rather than to the group. It is to be used for broad educational purposes. I understand that it was requested specifically to support the cross-party group, but there has usually been money left over that goes towards RNIB Scotland's more general purposes. Some of the funds that it receives are restricted in their use, but I do not think that this donation is.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.