Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Mainstreaming Equality

Tuesday 10 February 2004 Standards Committee Committee business 15 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

15 contributions
Brian Adam SNP The Convener · Aberdeen North
link

We move to agenda item 5, for which members have briefing papers. The committee is invited to decide how it will implement the Parliament's mainstreaming equality agenda in its work. Do members have questions or comments on the papers? My recollection is that we are asked in particular to address recommendations 2, 5 and 7 of the previous Equal Opportunities Committee's first report of 2003.If no one else has a comment, my only one is that, so far, the Conveners Group has not endorsed recommendation 7. That is largely because highlighting the mainstreaming of equality in a committee's annual report would run counter to the whole idea of mainstreaming; it would put it into a little ghetto if it were part of an annual report. I do not know how other members feel about that point. However, if the committee agrees, I am happy to make that point to the Equal Opportunities Committee and to agree that we will do our level best to adhere to recommendations 2 and 5.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

The recommendations are intended to guide us and ensure that there is a mechanism for automatically reminding ourselves of the need to mainstream equalities issues. Whether or not we think that recommendation 7 is the most important one, the idea is that we should formally scrutinise our work once a year and ask ourselves if we have been consciously implementing our mainstreaming equality policy. Whether mainstreaming equality has a space in our annual report or not, it is important to have the item formally on an agenda because that will allow us to scrutinise our thoughts and workings on equalities issues. Perhaps there will be nothing to report on that, but it is always worth reminding ourselves that mainstreaming equalities issues is part of the committee's duties.

Karen Whitefield Lab Airdrie and Shotts
link

The clerks have made a helpful suggestion in paragraph 10 of the briefing paper, although it probably means further work for them if we accept it. They suggest that we prepare "alternative formats" for the code of conduct, which members of the public would be able to access. That would ensure that anybody who wants to find out more about the workings of the Parliament and our code of conduct would be able to do so with no great difficulty.

Brian Adam SNP The Convener · Aberdeen North
link

On that specific suggestion, are the committee agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Brian Adam SNP The Convener · Aberdeen North
link

Does the committee have a strong view one way or the other on recommendation 7?

Brian Adam SNP The Convener · Aberdeen North
link

So is the committee content to agree to all the recommendations? Or does the committee share the Conveners Group's reservations about recommendation 7?

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

I share the reservations because there is the possibility of inverted discrimination if we take recommendation 7 in a certain direction. We should avoid that possibility. The point is that either we mainstream equality or we do not. If we are mainstreaming, I share the Conveners Group's reservations about singling out equality issues. The point is that we want to mainstream them.

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I take the convener's and Alex Neil's points, but we could say that the mainstreaming of equality is at an interim stage. If we are trying to mainstream, we might as well assess for the first year or so whether we have been successful. I know that that sounds contradictory. However, if we simply mainstreamed an equality issue and then sat back while the practice failed to match the agreed principle, the principle would not be worth the paper on which it had been written. Therefore, it is important to assess how the principle, which we may or may not agree on, is getting on and whether it is being acted on. I know that my point seems contradictory, but I think that it is logical.

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

I would not go to the barricades on the issue. I am happy to follow recommendation 7 for a couple of years, then drop it if we are satisfied that everything is hunky-dory.

Brian Adam SNP The Convener · Aberdeen North
link

Can I take it that Mr Butler's recommendation is agreed, that the committee accepts recommendations 2, 5 and 7 and that the committee will revisit the mainstreaming issue in general after we have produced two annual reports?

Bill Butler Lab Glasgow Anniesland
link

I hope that the suggested procedure will fall naturally into abeyance.

Brian Adam SNP The Convener · Aberdeen North
link

I seek specific guidance for the clerks, so that they know exactly what is required of them. Do members agree to the points to which I referred?Members indicated agreement.

Brian Adam SNP The Convener · Aberdeen North
link

I will now formally draw the meeting to a close, but I would like members to stay behind for a couple of seconds.

Meeting closed at 11:41.

  1. Scottish Parliament Standards Committee Tuesday 10 February 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 1
  2. Cross-party Groups Committee business · 31
  3. Standards of Conduct Committee (National Assembly for Wales) Committee business · 5
  4. Members' Interests Order Committee business · 34
  5. Mainstreaming Equality Committee business · 15

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.