The section that deals with lobbying says: "The Committee published its report on lobbying on 8 February 2002. The Committee is awaiting a response from the Executive".Is there a time scale within which the Executive has to respond to reports? I thought that there was a maximum period of about three months. I am conscious that we are still waiting for some sort of response.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Tricia Marwick only · show everyone- Mike Rumbles LD 10
- Tricia Marwick SNP 4
- Ken Macintosh Lab 3
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 2
- Sam Jones Clerk 1
Tricia Marwick’s contributions
4 contributionsI am sure that members of the Executive—the civil servants, at least—will read the Official Report, but I am extremely disappointed that, having spent a long time carrying out an investigation into lobbying, we are still waiting for a response from the Executive. I have sympathy with the view that, at the next meeting of the CLG, we should try to get a slot for a debate in the chamber. If the Executive has replied by that point, that is good, but if it has not, we can point out during the debate that the Executive has been tardy in its response to a report by a committee of the Parliament and that that is unacceptable. We should not delay; we should fix the date as quickly as possible, so that members of the Scottish Parliament can have a debate. If the Executive wants to contribute to that by providing its response in advance, that is fine. We should not wait any longer for the response before we seek a slot.
My concern is that we published our report on 8 February 2002. We were seeking to establish a statutory registration scheme. I felt that we took a long time to carry out our lobbying inquiry. I was clear in my mind that we were looking for a statutory registration scheme by May 2003. The longer the Executive delays—or the longer we delay the debate that needs to take place in the Parliament—the less chance we have of getting that statutory registration scheme in place by May 2003. That would be most unfortunate.We started our lobbying inquiry in October or November 1999. It would be unacceptable to me if we have not come to a resolution of the matter in the form of a statutory registration scheme by May 2003. No obstacles should stand in the way of achieving that goal. It is important to kick the matter on as quickly as possible, so that we can do the kind of work that we set out to do.
I acknowledge what the convener has said about the committee's work load. It is true that we have done a lot and that a lot more must be done before May 2003.In many ways, the Standards Committee has been unfortunate, in that some of the rules and regulations that were drawn up by those who helped to set up the Parliament took little cognisance of the fact that we would be a working Parliament. That has meant that we have been left with a lot to deal with, such as the members' interests order, the registration scheme for lobbyists and the Scottish Parliamentary Standards Commissioner Bill. All those things are worthy in their own right and need to be done. However, I am keen to ensure that the completely different Standards Committee that will be set up in May 2003 does not need to tie up loose ends. If it wishes, that new Standards Committee will be able to have another inquiry into lobbying, but we need to ensure that that committee can have a fresh start.
In this meeting
Everything on 26 Jun 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Standards Committee Wednesday 26 June 2002 (Morning) Committee business · 2
- Item in Private Procedure · 4
- Cross-party Group Committee business · 14
- Cross-party Groups Review Committee business · 13
- Work Programme Procedure · 20
- Annual Report Committee business · 1
- Members' Interests Order Committee business · 83
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.