Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Lobbying

Wednesday 14 March 2001 Standards Committee Committee business 362 contributions · 20 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

362 contributions · showing 1–200
Mike Rumbles LD The Convener · West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Our main business today is our inquiry into lobbying, and this is our second oral evidence-taking session. I welcome David Bleiman, Rozanne Foyer and Tracey White from the Scottish Trades Union Congress, who are our first witnesses this morning. I invite you to make a short opening statement before we move on to questions, which, of course, is the part that we are interested in.

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

We will introduce ourselves first. I am the vice-president of the STUC—that is, I am one of the lay officers of the congress.

Tracey White Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

I am an assistant secretary with the STUC. My primary responsibilities are for policy matters in relation to the economy and employment.

Rozanne Foyer Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

I am also an assistant secretary with the STUC, involved in equality and social justice matters. I work on policy and campaigns.

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

The Scottish Trades Union Congress is the single trade union centre in Scotland. It was founded in 1897. It is not politically affiliated, although some—but not all—trade unions are affiliated politically. We represent more than 620,000 trade union members and we represent workers and their families in Scotland. We are democratically based. We make policy at an annual congress and we have a general council that meets through the year to oversee the implementation of that policy. Our membership comes from all walks of life and includes professionals and manual workers from the public sector and the private sector and from all parts of Scotland. We have 46 affiliated unions.The STUC engages in a wide spectrum of activity that might loosely be described as lobbying. That includes both responsive lobbying, such as coming to give evidence to the committee—this is only one of a number of occasions on which committees have invited us to give evidence—and more proactive lobbying, which ranges from a phone call or e-mail to an MSP on a particular issue on which we want to comment, to hosting a reception that might be associated with one of our events for quite a number of MSPs from all parties.We certainly regard the political—with a small p—lobbying role of the STUC as a distinctive service that we can offer. I hope that this does not sound pompous, but we think that we can offer that service to Scotland and to the new politics. Because the STUC represents so many workers and their families and so many different unions with their different specialist interests, the process of discussing important issues within the STUC, and all the consultation and sometimes fierce debate that we go through, can be part of consensus building within the new politics in Scotland. We see the STUC as an important social partner for the Parliament, the Executive and Scotland. We are not just another lobbying organisation.

Mike Rumbles LD The Convener · West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I would like to move to questions. Do you want to add anything to your statement first?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

I will just add that the new politics is challenging. It places significant demands on us and represents a different way of working. We are trying to respond to that challenge.

Mike Rumbles LD The Convener · West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I agree: the new politics is challenging for us all.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

I should say at the outset that I am a member of Unison.I thank the witnesses for coming along today. You did not provide a written submission, so the questions will be very important today. It seems that you are describing yourselves as loose lobbyists—if you will excuse the expression. You describe the kind of lobbying that you do as a "service". Could you expand on that? A service to whom? To your members? To parliamentarians?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

To both really. When a particular policy issue comes up, we seek to bring together the relevant affiliated unions whose members are in the sector that is involved or have an interest in the policy in question. We try to bring those groups of people together and thereby add value to what an individual trade union could do by making representations. In doing that, we also provide a service to the Parliament—I do not know whether it is right to describe what we do in that way, but it certainly assists in the consultation process if that degree of co-ordination and consultation has happened before people come along to talk to MSPs.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

What about briefings to individual members of Parliament?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

We seek to give briefings as appropriate. In the past, we were consulted much less: Westminster was much less accessible than the Scottish Parliament is. In the past, we perhaps had the luxury of engaging in oppositional politics, whereas now we are asked for constructive views. The onus is on us to ensure that what we have to say is well researched and authoritative, and that we are not simply position-mongering. That is a challenge that we hope to respond to.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

Does the STUC operate any kind of voluntary code on good practice for lobbying the Scottish Parliament?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

No, we do not. The nearest that we come to such a code is in our developing custom and practice, whereby we try to co-ordinate the affiliated unions so that, wherever possible, we adopt a group approach under the umbrella of the STUC, rather than firing off in different directions when that can be avoided.

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

At present, we have no code.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

Would there be any benefit in having a code?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

We agree with what we understand to be the basic concept in the code of conduct for MSPs. We consider the main onus to be on the MSPs, because there are many voluntary organisations, some of which have few resources and some of which are very small. It would seem impracticable to have a code that covered every organisation or individual who might lobby. The danger exists that a code might impede the access to and openness of the Parliament.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

In what ways could a code impede access and openness?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

If a small voluntary organisation such as a parent-teacher association or a tenants group wants to talk to an MSP, it might be a one-off activity and the first time that the group has done it. If those people felt that they had to follow a code of practice before they could do that—

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

I was talking about the STUC—not a small organisation—having a code of practice.

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

If it were suggested to us that we should consider a code of practice, I am sure that we would be happy to do that. We do not have a code of practice at present.

Rozanne Foyer Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

We do not have a formal code of practice, but we have standards by which we abide. Anything that we say to MSPs—whether on a cross-party basis or to people with roles on committees, for example—complies with our policies, which have been fully debated. If we are dealing with a particular issue, we try as far as possible to find people from the front line of the trade union movement to talk about the issue. We try to bring people from our grass roots to groups such as this committee. For example, for a race issue, we would try to involve members of our black workers network. On an industrial issue, we would try to find stewards with relevant experience. We try to be representative in our policies and the people who argue our case.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

Can you give me any examples of good lobbying practice?

Rozanne Foyer Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

We see ourselves as a model of good practice, because we go to great lengths to ensure that we represent the views of our members. We would be concerned if massive amounts of access were given to people just because of the amount of money that they had or because they could buy expertise—we would have problems with such practices. We hope that the Parliament will ensure that smaller groups that lack such funds have nice, clear and open ways of accessing the Parliament.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

I think that we share your views on that.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Do you make a distinction between the small organisations that you mention in your evidence and the commercial organisations that lobby and influence for profit and have a client base?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

Yes. They are chalk and cheese. MSPs should be open to hearing the views of any organisation—whether it is like the STUC and has a large membership base, or whether it is small—and any individual. Purchasing such expertise or advocacy should not be necessary. Some professional lobbyists would argue that they do not do advocacy and that what they provide for their fee is advice on parliamentary processes. We hope that the Parliament will be sufficiently informative to allow people to find out about such matters without paying a fee.

Patricia Ferguson Lab Glasgow Maryhill
link

Before I ask a question, I should put it on record that, although I do not have a registrable interest in today's proceedings, I am—like most people around the table, I suspect—a member of a trade union. I also used to work for the STUC, although that was some years ago now.

Patricia Ferguson Lab Glasgow Maryhill
link

Yes, Frank McAveety is right that I was part of the escape committee—so it is nice to be able to grill former colleagues.I realise that this is not necessarily applicable to the STUC's situation, but I want to ask the question because you represent the wide swathe of the trade union movement. Would it be helpful to those who lobby or those of us who are lobbied if there were a register of lobbyists? We have received evidence that either a voluntary or a statutory register of lobbyists might be of use to us. As part of our deliberations, we need to decide whether we want to go down that road. Would that kind of registration be a help or a hindrance to trade unions?

Tracey White Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

Our concern is that a register might cut across the current accessibility of the Parliament. David Bleiman has already referred to the wide spectrum of organisations that legitimately want to have—and should have—access to the Parliament and to parliamentarians. It is difficult to see how a register could do anything other than cut across the Parliament's accessibility. If organisations had to go through a procedure in the first instance whenever they wanted to raise an issue with an MSP or group of MSPs, that could be problematic.In some regards, the question depends on the definition of lobbying. If I write personally—never mind in my professional capacity—to my MSP about an issue, I am, in effect, lobbying. If there were to be a register, careful thought would need to be given to the definition of lobbying and to what the appropriate level was for that register to come into play.

link

Perhaps I should say that I am a non-practising member of the Faculty of Advocates—although I do not think that it is yet a trade union.

Tracey White Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

It is not affiliated yet.

link

Could the STUC live with a registration of commercial lobbyists? Would that interfere with access in any way?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

We could certainly live with the concept that fee-based organisations that provide a professional lobbying or advocacy service should be registered or regulated in some way. I am not sure whether your use of the term "commercial lobbyists" includes small businesses and so on. We would not see that as appropriate.

link

You also mentioned that you would consider a voluntary code, if that were necessary. Is that something that, in principle, you could live with?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

Do you mean: should we as a lobbying organisation have a code for lobbyists?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

I think so. I have been deliberating over the question that Kay Ullrich asked. One of the reasons why we do not have a code at the moment is that it would not occur to us to do some of the things that might be unethical. For example, the STUC has never found it necessary to think of paying money to someone to ask a parliamentary question. At Westminster, there were always MPs who were happy to ask questions that the STUC wanted to be asked. The STUC simply does not have the resources to give excessive hospitality—Pat Ferguson will remember the STUC's financial situation, which has not got any better. We have never been in a position to consider things that large businesses might be able to afford.However—I am thinking aloud here—there would be no difficulty for us to codify our existing good practice.

link

Would it be correct to say that a voluntary code might have virtually no effect on you, because your actions would, as a matter of common sense, comply with the code in any case?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

That is right, although we have the structures to be able to deliberate on and approve a voluntary code and ensure that we implement it.On an earlier point, we concede that there could be difficulties for small organisations—such as a trade union branch of one of our affiliates—if a local issue came up and they wanted to contact their MSP. Difficulties might result from whether that branch had signed up to a code of practice. However, at the overarching STUC level, such a code would not cause us a problem.

Patricia Ferguson Lab Glasgow Maryhill
link

I was struck by something that David Bleiman said. I am not sure whether it was a deliberate use of the word, but he mentioned that the STUC was trying to rise to the "challenge" of the openness and accessibility of the new politics in Scotland. Given what he said about the STUC's financial situation, is the openness and accessibility of Parliament not just a problem but a major challenge to an organisation that, although it is not small, is not wealthy? Do you find it difficult to keep up? Do you have any comments that might help us in a wider sense?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

There is an enormous challenge. One must not underestimate the extent to which we all—especially voluntary organisations of all kinds—became trained for many decades in a form of oppositional politics in which we responded with press releases, for example, to the policies of the Government of the day. Openness to a new kind of politics, in which what we say might be listened to and might have a constructive input into legislation, involves a whole new way of working. We used to have a fairly elaborate subject committee structure, but we stripped that out to free up resources to be more responsive and proactive within the new politics. We are in the process of dealing with the new situation.Rozanne Foyer might want to say something more about the maintenance of what we describe as the equalities committees. We are aware of the need to represent the full diversity of our membership. Groups that are disadvantaged might not otherwise have a voice.

Rozanne Foyer Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

David Bleiman said everything that is necessary on that subject. On the sheer level of access, we are almost victims of our own success. I think that every organisation in Scotland that deals with Parliament would echo our welcome of the access that we have. However, the sheer number of consultation documents, opportunities to give evidence and cross-party groups in which we have an interest sometimes makes it difficult to respond and to do the homework that we would wish to. We struggle with that resource issue daily. We see our job as primarily to represent to Parliament the views of working people in Scotland.

Tracey White Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

I am sure that we are not the first organisation to talk to the committee about time scales within which Parliament looks for a response to consultation. The consultation on which the committee is engaged at the moment has a reasonable response period, but not all committee inquiries have the luxury of sufficient time for responses. The parliamentary committees should perhaps look more generally at that.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

On much the same point, I think that David Bleiman said that it is up to MSPs to regulate the behaviour of lobbyists, but he also suggested that we could take some positive action to ensure access for smaller groups. That might be a productive step. This might be asking a bit much today, but would you go beyond that and say what steps we could take to encourage access? Bigger, professional or commercial lobbying organisations have the resources to be able to put together a case and present it through lectures, for example. Smaller groups find that difficult. Are there constructive steps that we could take to make it easier for smaller groups to reach us?

Rozanne Foyer Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

When the Parliament was established, there was a lot of talk about committees going out to communities and about how the mechanics of that might work. Some disadvantaged groups in Scotland simply will not make it along to the Parliament. Given the way in which the format has developed, those groups are not up for giving evidence to committees or for writing lots of letters and following the traditional forms of lobbying by answering consultation documents, for example. They are not even up for submitting petitions to the Public Petitions Committee. There is room for the Parliament to be a bit more proactive and to consider conducting the sort of research in which members could go out and talk to people where they live. For example, there is room for the reporters who examine different issues for the Equal Opportunities Committee to conduct some proactive research by going out and getting people's views. On the key principles of regulation, we believe that the Parliament needs to ensure that organisations do not have to have the money to hire people in order to lobby successfully. We at the STUC are struggling—and lobbying is our job—and other groups will have a much harder time than us, even though they might be representative and have valid points to make. If the Parliament is to come up with a code, it must consider those issues. It must also examine how to enforce equality of access across Scotland.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I do not want to put words in your mouth, but you seem to be saying that, although we might find it difficult to find an acceptable form of regulation or registration—and you seem to be arguing that such regulation or registration would be a hurdle at whatever level it might be set—it is more important to be proactive in ensuring access for less affluent groups.

Rozanne Foyer Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

Yes.

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

Yes.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

What has been said might explain why an organisation such as the STUC finds it difficult to keep pace. A lobbying company might say, "We'll fill this space", whereas other organisations—even the STUC, with all its experience—do not have the resources to do that. That is an interesting point.The STUC had a critical role in shaping and developing the debate about the Parliament. I have noticed that many other organisations may not have always been as committed to the Parliament as the STUC has been. In a sense, those organisations are cautious about their relationship with the Parliament and about how they lobby and try to influence members. The real debate is about the code of conduct for MSPs, which we are considering from the point of view of organisations. Having read the code of conduct—if you have been sad enough to do so—do you think that we should beef up its provisions or enhance its standards, in order to make it more transparent, given that the public believe that transparency is important?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

I will respond to that question, although my colleagues may have something to add. Broadly speaking, I believe that the code of conduct looked fine. I was struck—this is my view, not the STUC's—by where the line is drawn in relation to what constitutes incidental or insignificant hospitality. Although the STUC does not have huge resources, we occasionally hold receptions at which we may provide sandwiches or a glass of wine. That creates an environment in which we can talk to MSPs, although we do not use those occasions to purchase anything with sandwiches or a glass of wine. If you have been to an STUC reception, you will appreciate that point. The code does not make it clear where the level has been set. Perhaps the onus is on the MSP to judge what constitutes incidental hospitality, which is okay, and what constitutes bribery and corruption. We are looking for realism in the way in which people within Scotland relate to one another, as that will enable us to facilitate dialogue.

Mike Rumbles LD The Convener · West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Just before I bring Frank McAveety back in, I should point out that the code of conduct limits declarable interests to £250 for MSPs—that is a lot of sandwiches.

Tracey White Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

If I may, I would like to add to David Bleiman's answer, although I am reluctant to admit to having read the code of conduct, now that Frank McAveety has said that I am sad for doing so. What has been put down on paper makes sense, but it does not address the other side of the coin, which we discussed earlier. The question is about barriers to access. It is not about how MSPs should be proactive in engaging with the wider community, rather than with only those people who approach them in the first instance. That is crucial to properly informed public policy making, and perhaps the code should outline some principles at the beginning of the section that deals with lobbying to address those issues.

Mike Rumbles LD The Convener · West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Frank, do you want to come back in?

Mike Rumbles LD The Convener · West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Do members have any other questions?

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

The STUC might be skint, but individual trade unions are very good with their expense accounts.

Mike Rumbles LD The Convener · West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Do you think that there remains a perception among the public that commercial lobbying companies have privileged access to MSPs?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

That is not the STUC's perception. We are aware that we do not need to use lobbying companies—

Mike Rumbles LD The Convener · West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

So, as far as you are concerned, that perception does not exist.

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

Members of the public who pick up their perceptions of the Scottish Parliament from the media might have a different view but, as a result of our experience, which informs our view, we do not have that perception.

Tracey White Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

The issue that the Parliament must address is whether people who can afford to pay professional lobbyists have enhanced access, rather than whether the lobbyists themselves have enhanced access.

link

My question is simple. Is it correct to say that you are lobbyists, although you are not commercial lobbyists?

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

Yes, that is reasonable.

Tracey White Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

You could say the same about anyone who telephones or e-mails their MSP.

David Bleiman Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

In order to be helpful, I would like to go back to an earlier question. I have been reflecting on the point about whether there should be a register of lobbying organisations. For example, when committees consult groups—of course, that is a different way of looking at the issue—we would like the STUC always to be on the list of consultees. On the other hand, coming to the Parliament to lobby MSPs should not be restricted to people who are on an approved list. The STUC has been engaged in lobbying politicians for the past 100 years and will be engaged in that activity for the next 100 years. However, we are aware that ad hoc, unofficial groups spring up and, although we do not want them to be treated as the official representatives of the Scottish labour movement, for example, politicians must listen to them, bearing in mind the fact that those groups may not be representative or that they may represent only an ad hoc, unofficial campaign. It would be a big mistake to say that MSPs should not listen to those people because they are not on a list of approved lobbyists.

Rozanne Foyer Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

On your previous question, convener, I work with many people who are not active or senior in the trade union movement, because I work within the equalities structures in the STUC. It would be fair to say that, among those people, there is a perception that those with expertise, such as professional lobbyists, gain more access to the Parliament. The STUC could be used as a tool, in partnership with the Parliament, to give greater access to people at grass-roots level. For example, on several occasions, cross-party groups of MSPs—perhaps representing different committees—have attended equality conferences. People have been able to question those MSPs face to face and to lobby them. The STUC can be used as a tool to facilitate access to a wide range of people and to allow a wide body of people to give their views.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

I will make a quick comment that Rozanne Foyer might find helpful. I am a member of the Equal Opportunities Committee, which has been going out to areas. One of our problems is that the people whom we go out to see want to give us hospitality—it is almost embarrassing. The boot is on the other foot—they feel that they must provide us with food and sustenance when we visit them. I think that that is just good Scottish manners.

Rozanne Foyer Scottish Trades Union Congress
link

Absolutely.

Mike Rumbles LD The Convener · West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

As there are no further questions, I thank the witnesses for giving evidence to the committee. They are more than welcome to stay to listen to the other evidence that we will hear this morning. I adjourn the meeting for a few minutes.

Meeting adjourned.

On resuming—

Mike Rumbles LD The Convener · West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I welcome Angela Casey and Alan Boyd, who are here to represent the Association for Scottish Public Affairs. Before I throw open the meeting to questions from committee members, I invite Angela Casey to make a short opening statement.

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

I am the convener of the Association for Scottish Public Affairs, which, you will be pleased to know, we call ASPA for short. I am also the managing director of the public relations company Countrywide Porter Novelli. Before I began working in Edinburgh, I was a professional PR and public affairs consultant at Westminster and in Brussels.By my side is Alan Boyd, who is the former convener of ASPA and a director of the legal firm McGrigor Donald. He is director of McGrigor Donald Public Policy and a past president of the Law Society of Scotland.ASPA represents the interests and regulates the advocacy or lobbying activity of public affairs professionals in Scotland. We are the only solely Scotland-based body and have 50 members from in-house public affairs departments, trade unions, professional public affairs consultants, the voluntary and charitable sector, legal companies that give public policy advice, information companies, trade associations and public sector communications departments.ASPA believes that the industry can regulate itself. Our code of conduct was drawn up for that purpose. The code is relevant to anyone from the above organisations who might have dealings with Parliament. Its basis is openness, honesty and integrity.We would like to reaffirm what the committee has already recognised and what the Committee on Standards in Public Life has also said: that the democratic right to make representations to Government is fundamental to the proper conduct of public policy.We welcome the inquiry and debate. It is only right that the committee should have as much information as possible before it decides a way forward for public policy representation in Scotland.ASPA believes in openness and co-operation. We will continue to work with the Parliament and the committee whatever decision they take. We also have close working relationships with the Association of Professional Political Consultants in Scotland, the Institute of Public Relations and the Scottish Public Relations Consultants Association. We will continue to communicate with them on our voluntary codes and a way forward for the industry.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

You said in your submission that you have over 50 members from the various organisations that you outlined. In the evidence that the Stirling media research institute gave us at our previous meeting, they said that you have 25 members. Have you been on a membership drive since then or do you indeed have 50 members?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

We are renewing our membership this month, so the actual figures will be available after that. When we first started, we had 50 members signed up and there were probably more than 50 who were interested. I cannot give you an exact figure.

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

It will be somewhere in between.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

How many public affairs companies or organisations do you think there are in Scotland?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

What do you mean by public affairs companies? Are you talking about organisations that are operate exclusively in that area of work or about other professional providers?

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I will rephrase the question. How many companies do you think there are that are engaged by clients, who pay money to them, for their services to lobby, advise or influence the Scottish Parliament?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

There is probably a handful of companies that exist solely for that purpose. If you mean companies whose work might include an element of advice, briefing or research on public policy issues, there are probably an awful lot more.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

How many more? Are we talking about 100, 200 or more?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

No. There might be another 20.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

There are possibly several dozen. We must accept that most of the major legal practices in Scotland advise clients on aspects of Parliament-related work.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

So you think that there are about 40 companies in Scotland that operate in such a way, but you have 50 members from that sector and others. Does your organisation represent 100 per cent of the sector?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

ASPA is a broad church, to put it another way. Our members comprise not only professional public affairs consultants but individuals, public sector representatives and voluntary representatives. ASPA's 40 or 50 members cut across the range of interests that the Scottish Parliament might become involved with. The reason for setting up ASPA was to avoid any suggestion of exclusivity. That is why we started by organising public meetings in the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities headquarters, the first of which was attended by almost 100 people who represented all interests. Some of those people are now MSPs, incidentally.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I will rephrase the question as I want to try to tie you down. What percentage of the organisations in Scotland that are engaged by clients to lobby and influence the Scottish Parliament are part of your organisation?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

I am not seeking to avoid the question, but I honestly do not know how many organisations or individuals seek to lobby, influence or brief members of Parliament. However, in the Scottish context, it would be fair to say that the 40 or 50 ASPA members are a relatively small percentage of the people who are concerned with the business of the Parliament.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I was trying to establish how representative you are of the commercial lobbying organisations. That leads me to my next question, which concerns the voluntary code of practice that you suggest is the way forward. A voluntary code of practice is useful only if the vast majority of relevant organisations sign up to it. There must be many companies, however, who work as individual organisations and simply do not sign up to any code of practice.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

That must be correct.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

You say that the ASPA approach to the code of practice is to name and shame companies that do not meet your standards. Since your organisation was set up in August 1998, have you named and shamed anyone?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

No. We have had no need to.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

How do you monitor the organisations that are signed up to ASPA? How do you ensure that their actions conform to the code of conduct?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

We would never seek to interfere in the day-to-day business of our members. Bearing in mind that some of them are in the public sector, there is no way that we could do so, even if we wanted to. The code is voluntary. People who apply for membership of ASPA agree, when submitting their membership application, to be bound by the rules and constitution of ASPA. We rely on our members to keep us advised of breaches of the code of conduct. As the code and the constitution of the organisation are publicly available, it would be right and proper for MSPs, officials and members of the Scottish Executive who felt that there had been breaches to report them to us. The philosophy behind ASPA is one of openness and transparency.

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

We like to think that, just as we are aware of the MSPs' code of conduct, MSPs are aware of ours. Indeed, on occasion, staff of MSPs have contacted us to talk about whether there was a breach of the code or simply to discuss matters arising from a meeting. The Standards Committee could aid the efficacy of the code of conduct by encouraging communication between us and the Scottish Parliament.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

When members of MSPs' staff contacted you with concerns about a meeting, did you hold an investigation into whether the company had breached the voluntary code?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

If someone alerted us to something that was happening or informed us of their concerns about a meeting, we would investigate the meeting.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

You said that MSPs' staff had contacted you. I want to know what action you took.

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

In those instances, we contacted people involved in the meetings to find out what the situation was.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Did you hold an independent investigation?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

We talked to people. We have not yet had to set up a formal investigation as there has not yet been a breach of the code.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

How could someone be named and shamed if there is no proper inquiry mechanism in place?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

I said that, in the instances that we are talking about, we did not need to have a proper inquiry.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

In the Scottish Parliament, we have a code of conduct and a Standards Committee. People are well aware of the code of conduct and a few complaints about MSPs' conduct have been investigated. I want to know what your investigatory process is. Has it ever been enacted? Certainly, you have never named and shamed anybody.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

As we have received no complaints about breaches of the code of conduct or a lack of propriety on the part of ASPA members, we have never had to conduct an inquiry. However, ASPA's constitution, which all members have signed, makes it clear that the committee has the power to expel members who do not act in the interests of the association. If the undertaking to abide by the code of conduct were breached, that would be seen as a failure to act in the interests of the association.A mechanism is in place, but we have not had to use it because we have had no complaints. Long may that continue.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Derek Draper, the former lobbyist who was involved in the so-called cash for access affair at Westminster, gave evidence to the Neill committee. He said:"The truth is that you are not going to get companies that are incredibly competitive and ridden with personal difficulties to regulate themselves properly."

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

My answer to that is that I would not want to be guided by Derek Draper on any question of propriety.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Is it possible for companies that are in competition with one other to regulate themselves properly?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

That would be a matter for the Scottish Parliament to judge.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I am asking for your opinion on whether it is possible for companies in an incredibly competitive industry to regulate themselves properly.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

It should be possible, provided that there are adequate sanctions. Regulation without sanctions does not work. Membership of other, more traditional professions, such as the legal and medical professions, is covered by statute or by other regulations and those professional bodies have the power to expel members and to prevent people from continuing in their profession. As we are dealing with a looser grouping, the situation is different.

Mike Rumbles LD The Convener · West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

If someone has a complaint against an ASPA member, who should they complain to? Your voluntary code does not make that clear.

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

They would complain to the ASPA committee, which would investigate the matter.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

Are the organisations that can afford to pay for the services of commercial lobbyists likely to have more influence in the decision-making process?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

I would not say that they would have more influence. Some of the organisations that—perhaps quite rightly—have the greatest influence with Parliament are COSLA and the STUC. Furthermore, some charities and other voluntary bodies have huge influence and tremendous lobbying potential—and I need mention only Greenpeace, animal rights organisations and campaigning organisations such as Oxfam in Scotland. Professional lobbyists can help clients—and perhaps commercial clients—to focus their arguments better for Parliament and its members. I do not think that money necessarily gets access for clients, but it can buy them focused professional advice that enables them to bring the issues into sharper focus, which can only help everyone in the policy process.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

I am a bit bewildered. You seem to be saying that it is not worth employing a commercial lobbyist because all the organisations that you have trotted out have much more influence. If that is so, would it not be better to pay Greenpeace or the STUC to do your lobbying?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

Well, you might be better off paying Greenpeace if you want to hijack an oil rig.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

I am only taking Greenpeace as an example because you used its name.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

People who instruct public affairs consultants typically feel that they have concerns or issues that they want to bring to the attention of MSPs. Such concerns or issues might relate to legislation before the Parliament or to consultative documents where the Parliament is actively seeking the views of the public and business on particular matters. All I am saying is that, as in any other sphere, if people do not have the adequate in-house resources, buying in professional advice must help. It will not give clients any greater access, but it will help them to focus their arguments and enable them to brief MSPs better.

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

Are your customers aware that they are not paying money for you to lobby Parliament, but for the other services that you have mentioned?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

Clients of professional firms generally pay for advice—

Kay Ullrich SNP West of Scotland
link

So they do not hire you to lobby Parliament.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

Certainly not.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

Our submission—and this discussion—makes it clear that we have accepted a somewhat wider definition of lobbying than direct one-to-one relationships between the lobbyist and the member of the Parliament or the parliamentary official involved. My understanding is that the definition of lobbying includes the general provision of advice relating to political policy formation.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

One of the key objectives of any lobbying or advocacy company is to get its message across, and so far I am quite confused about what your message is. Both of you have made potentially contradictory statements. It was said that complaints or issues about conduct were raised which you sort of examined. However, you also said that there have been no complaints. Could you help me with the distinction between the two statements?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

The incidents that you refer to were not complaints, as I said. People rang me up to talk about a meeting or meetings that were taking place just to clarify who was meeting and why. They would have become complaints if the initial inquiry had brought to light anything wrong.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Do you provide people who call you up to express such concerns with a copy of the complaints procedure?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

No, because at that point it is purely an inquiry, not a complaint.

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

It would become a complaint if the initial inquiry made it clear that something wrong was happening.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Have any organisations that are ASPA members been complained about in the recent past?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

No.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Were any organisations involved in the most recent celebrated cases ever members of your organisation?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

Beattie Media was involved with us during the formative stages, if that is what is in the back of your mind. However, that particular division of Beattie Media—and we must point out that it was a separate division of Beattie Media—wound itself up pretty shortly after anything happened, by which time the company was no longer a member of ASPA anyway.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Could Beattie Media have become a member of another organisation?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

I do not know.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

It could have, but I would suggest that if it had wound up its public affairs division, there would be no point in its being a member of a public affairs organisation.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

What is the difference between ASPA and other organisations such as APPCS?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

If you examine the submissions of the two organisations, you will find that they are very different. ASPA was set up solely in Scotland for people from different organisations and backgrounds who were going to deal with the Parliament in any way. You will need to ask the APPC about its set-up and background; however, it represents purely public affairs consultancies, whereas our membership includes members of charities and public bodies such as COSLA.

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

Our voluntary code extends beyond lobbyists and indeed covers all bodies that wish to sign up.

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

That is something for the Parliament to decide. However, if I were asked for my opinion, I would say that a voluntary code or code of any sort should cover anyone who deals with the Parliament. We are talking not just about consultancies, but about organisations that are pulled together purely to lobby on one issue and which are, in that sense, professional consultants.

link

But do you not accept that charities and voluntary organisations are a rather different category from very much larger bodies?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

I have a little difficulty with that idea, because those organisations are as capable as anyone else of influencing the policy process.

link

From everything that you have said and written, am I right in thinking that you have no difficulty with the principle of registration and are quite happy for it to be introduced?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

Two weeks ago, the Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations made a couple of valid points suggesting that registration might stop some smaller organisations and even individuals in their sector from approaching Parliament. That would be a bad thing.

Patricia Ferguson Lab Glasgow Maryhill
link

I am sorry to go back to a question that was almost asked by a colleague earlier. However, I am sure that you appreciate that the event was very significant and has influenced all of us on this topic. You were asked earlier about Beattie Media's possible membership of your association. Was Beattie Media a member of ASPA at the time of the events that we later investigated, bearing in mind the fact that they happened some time before that investigation? Furthermore, was the company still a member at the outset of the investigation?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

From memory, I think that the answer is yes, it was a member at the start, but by the end it was not, for the reasons that I explained to Mr McAveety. Apart from anything else, it no longer existed as a public affairs organisation.

Patricia Ferguson Lab Glasgow Maryhill
link

Did your organisation consider action against that company in the light of the circumstances that were uncovered?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

No complaint had been made against the company. At the same time, we were aware that parliamentary investigations were being carried out. It would have been wrong to run a parallel investigation when the Parliament was carrying out its investigation.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

The answer is perfectly straightforward: anyone who has a ground for complaint, be it a member of the Parliament, an official, a clerk, or a member of the Scottish Executive. If there is any question of misconduct, the complaint should be made and it should be investigated.

Patricia Ferguson Lab Glasgow Maryhill
link

This brings us back to one of the difficulties that we have in coming to our conclusions about this inquiry, which is that, as you have said, very often the companies that are part of your organisation are acting on behalf of someone else. We do not always have contact with members of your organisation. We may have contact with the people that they are being paid to represent, which is what happens more often than not, but they are acting on advice that is given by people who are members of your organisation, so it might be difficult for us to know that there are grounds for a complaint against one of your members. How would you make your procedure more open and transparent?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

Most members of our association are charity and public sector people and in-house public affairs professionals, who obviously will be very open and clear about who they are. In the unlikely event that one of the few consultancies that are members of ASPA approached the Parliament, it is highly unlikely that they would do so on behalf of a third party and either not declare that that was what they were doing, or do it without that person being with them.You as MSPs will know that the incidence of a public affairs consultant, or a professional lobbyist in your definition, approaching a member of Parliament in any legislature and saying that they are representing a third party is very rare these days. What tends to happen much more is that consultancies are employed to give advice to clients about how they themselves can do the lobbying. You will find that in most cases it is the client who is the lobbyist, not the consultancy.

Patricia Ferguson Lab Glasgow Maryhill
link

With respect, that is my point: how would we know that the advice that they have been given by people in your organisation gave us grounds for complaint, because we would not be dealing directly with them?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

That opens up yet another complex area, because in our democratic society, anyone has the right to take advice from a professional person, and they need not disclose that they have taken that advice. Indeed, that is one of the fundamental bases on which the legal profession operates. Someone is quite entitled to consult me as a lawyer, get advice and apply that advice. Of course, the person who is at the receiving end at the end of the day has no recourse against my acting as a lawyer. That raises difficult questions, because in matters of public policy, people equally have a right to take professional advice and guidance, which brings us to an area that has not been considered by the committee, at least not in the evidence that I have read.How does the right to take advice and its impact sit with certain aspects of the Human Rights Act 1998? That is an important question, because, for example, article 8 of the European convention on human rights states:"Everyone has the right to respect for his private and family life, his home and his correspondence."The court has held that that right extends to business property and correspondence. You can see immediately how that could relate to the considerations that are before the committee.There are other articles that are probably relevant in this context. Article 10 of the convention, on the freedom of expression, includes the"freedom to hold opinions and to receive and impart information and ideas without interference by public authority and regardless of frontiers."Article 11 deals with the freedom of assembly and association and article 17 is a prohibition of abuse of rights, which effectively prevents public authorities from otherwise restricting any of the rights that are available under the convention. Those articles appear to sit beside some of the issues that the committee is considering and require to be taken into account in examining the registration and regulation of lobbyists.I apologise for the fact that that answer was rather long-winded. In response to Patricia Ferguson's point, I have to say that people are entitled to take professional advice. If that advice is of a poor quality, negligent or recommends a wrong course of action, the recourse lies with the client who has been badly advised to take a wrong course of conduct.

Mike Rumbles LD The Convener · West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Let us return to a point that I would like you to clarify for the record, following Patricia Ferguson's line of questioning. How do you publish your membership list? How would anyone know that an organisation such as Beattie Media was a member of ASPA? How would they know to complain to your organisation?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

Members of ASPA are expected to declare that they are members of ASPA. We often ask them to use our logo on their letterhead or to make it obvious that they are members. We would be quite happy—at a later date, when we have records of our recent membership details—to publish a list of our members if that would be of use.

Mike Rumbles LD The Convener · West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

So there is no formal mechanism.

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

Not at the moment. However, we are not hiding our membership. It is generally assumed that members will declare their membership and talk about it.

Mike Rumbles LD The Convener · West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I am conscious that I put Patricia Ferguson off. Do you want to continue your questioning, Patricia?

Patricia Ferguson Lab Glasgow Maryhill
link

No. Mr Boyd explained very well the difficulties that we face.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Do you have a copy of your complaints procedure?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

We have a copy of our constitution, which contains the relevant paragraph. I would be happy to leave a copy with you.

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

We did not submit our constitution, but we submitted our code of conduct.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

I would be happy to leave a copy of our constitution for the committee.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

If a member of the public wanted to make a complaint about one of your members, how would they find out about your membership? Every other public body has to have open and transparent complaints procedures.

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

From the outset, ASPA has never tried to hide anything. We are not about any kind of subterfuge or not telling anyone what we are doing. We set up our organisation in a spirit of complete openness, and we have never tried to hide who our members are. The point of someone's being a member of ASPA is that they are public about the way in which they behave.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

We have a modest budget. Part of the reason for that is that we want to encourage the spirit of openness and broad membership. We have to keep the subscription low because, although we operate differential subscriptions, certain individuals and charitable bodies can afford to pay only a modest amount. In a perfect world, we would have a website and our membership would be displayed there.

Frank McAveety Lab Glasgow Shettleston
link

Or even a piece of A4 paper. I do not buy the line that advertising your membership is too costly. It could be included on a piece of A4 paper at the end of your membership application form, or the information could be made available every time you lobby.

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

We produced a newsletter, a while ago, in which our membership was published. We have not, at any point, tried not to tell people about our membership.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Four of the committee members were involved in the lobbygate inquiry, but none of us knew that Beattie Media was a member of ASPA. That bears out the point that Patricia Ferguson was trying to make. We simply did not know that Beattie Media was a member of your organisation. I would have thought that that information would have percolated down to us.ASPA was formed in 1998, following discussions with various people. It was set up in the wake of all the sleaze allegations at Westminster and elsewhere, to self-regulate, to operate a voluntary code of conduct and to see off any future regulation that the Scottish Parliament might introduce.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

I would couch that in different terms. When ASPA was set up, we were aware of the background at Westminster. We were equally aware of the culture surrounding the establishment of the Scottish Parliament—the open, transparent and participative nature of the Parliament. Quite simply, ASPA was an attempt to replicate that culture among those who would be interested in influencing, lobbying and canvassing the Parliament. ASPA intended to ensure that its members, at least, subscribed to those important and basic principles in undertaking that work.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Yet, within months of the Scottish Parliament's opening, a member of your organisation was involved in the first serious inquiry of the Standards Committee.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

Yes.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

So you patently failed to achieve what you tried to achieve.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

No, we did not fail. No complaint was made. Although there was an inquiry, it found no specific matter of misconduct. You may correct me if I am wrong, but I was not aware that the inquiry covered that ground.The important point is that the constitution and the code of conduct existed, had a complaint been made. If a finding of misconduct had been established against Beattie Media, and had the company been a member, we would have taken action of our own accord. There was no question of our not doing that.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Two of the people who were involved with Beattie Media gave evidence to the Standards Committee that they acted foolishly and as they should not have done. There was evidence from their own mouths that they suggested that they could do things that they could not.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

That may be true. However, as I advised the committee earlier, by the time that the Parliament's investigation had run its course, Beattie Media was no longer a member of ASPA. We therefore had no jurisdiction to intervene in the matter. We certainly would not have interfered while the Parliament was running its investigation—that would have been quite wrong.

Tricia Marwick SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Did your voluntary code pick up any concerns over Beattie Media before the inquiry took place?

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

No.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I have a practical question. If we were to introduce a registration or regulation scheme, we would have to establish a threshold for commercial or professional payments. If we set a threshold at a company spending £5,000 on lobbying activity, would that affect all your members in all their work?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

Do you mean in-house departments, charities, trade unions—

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

It is difficult to determine how much someone is spending on lobbying, if it is an in-house department.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

If we start a registration scheme for any organisation that spends more than a set threshold of, say, £5,000 on lobbying the Scottish Parliament, would that affect all your members or only a few? Would it affect the charities?

Angela Casey Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

It would affect very few organisations.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

It would depend on how lobbying was defined. If you are talking about a £5,000 payment to a lobbyist to go and actively lobby on behalf of a client, Angela is right to say that very few, if any, organisations would be affected. On the other hand, if you are talking about the £5,000 being spent on general professional advice on public policy matters, a lot of organisations would be affected. Every major public limited company based in Scotland will have a public affairs department, which will require resources. A major part of the work of that department will be to brief the organisation, its board and its management on matters of political policy that impact on the plc.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I will give you a rough idea of how I think this might work. If an independent company bought the services of a professional consultancy and the bill came to more than £5,000, that would have to be declared. If the company had an in-house public relations facility or if it employed a parliamentary officer, and if salaries came to more than £5,000, that would have to be declared. If the company employed a PR officer who did not spend all their time but perhaps half their time at the Parliament, and if their salary was more than £10,000, that would have to be declared. It would be possible to work out the resources going into that activity, and I am trying to find out whom that would affect.I do not think that it would affect any of the small charitable organisations. All those organisations, tenants' groups and so on, would not even come close to that figure of £5,000 and would not be bothered by it. However, I imagine that anyone with a commercial interest would be affected and would have to declare their spending. It would then be out in the open. Even an organisation such as the STUC would have to declare that it employed a staff of perhaps six, three of whom spent a great deal of their time lobbying the Scottish Parliament. I would like to know how you feel about that, what you feel about the figure of £5,000 for a threshold, and how that would impact on your members.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

The system that you have just described would inevitably catch—if that is the right word—a lot of people and organisations. Following the argument through, however, I have difficulty in understanding how the system would be monitored and enforced. Notwithstanding the human rights implications that I mentioned earlier, I have difficulty in seeing how theory would be translated into practice and how that practice would be enforced.

Ken Macintosh Lab Eastwood
link

I am trying to get a definition of commercial or professional activity as opposed to all the voluntary and individual access to Parliament. We do not want to discourage any type of activity, professional or otherwise, but we want to identify activity that is commercial and professional and that, therefore, may be more influential in some ways.

Alan Boyd Association for Scottish Public Affairs
link

I hope that it would not be.

  1. Scottish Parliament Standards Committee Wednesday 14 March 2001 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Lobbying Committee business · 362

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.