The first item on the agenda is the committee's forward work programme. Members will have received the initial papers and will see that a substantial amount of issues require our attention. We need to agree on how to organise our work to address all those major issues. Members have said several times that completing the draft code of conduct is a priority. There is also an urgent need to put in place a complaints procedure and to consider, as it is appropriate to our remit, the issue of lobbying.Do members reaffirm that the draft code is our priority? Members indicated agreement.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Mike Rumbles only · show everyone- Mike Rumbles LD 15
- Karen Gillon Lab 9
- Des McNulty Lab 7
- Tricia Marwick SNP 4
- Lord James Douglas-Hamilton Con 3
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 3
- Adam Ingram SNP 1
Mike Rumbles’s contributions
15 contributionsI agree that the draft code of conduct should include a complaints procedure and an enforcement procedure, and that we must complete it as quickly as possible. I suggest that the draft code of conduct, including, as Des McNulty said, the interim complaints procedure, be the main item on the agenda of the meeting on 24 November.It will help our deliberations if we set a target date for completion of the draft code. I know that that is difficult, but it is important to give a steer to what we do. We should make progress by Christmas, with a view to having the draft available by January. Can we agree to that time scale, with the meetings on 24 November and 8 December devoted to that item? We might need additional meetings to meet the January deadline, but we will address that closer to the time.
I take that point on board.
I have already asked whether we can meet weekly, but parliamentary staff have told me that it is difficult to arrange the facilities for that. I asked whether we could meet next week, but that has proved impossible.
We have meetings on 24 November and 8 December. The clerks tell me that they will do all the preparation to allow us to complete our work by then. I am suggesting a January deadline, because 8 December might be too tight. The legal advice that we received was that the draft code could not be checked before then. I acknowledge what you say. We will have to review the situation after each meeting.
I confirm to members that, prior to this meeting, I requested a meeting for 17 November—this time next week—because I felt that we should be meeting not fortnightly, but weekly. The advice that I am giving you now is advice that I received from the committee clerks, who said that that was not possible. However, I hear what members are saying and take the same view. We should go back to parliamentary staff and say that we want to meet on 17 November to progress the issue.
I was given to understand that the clerks could make the drafts available to us reasonably quickly, so that we could deal with them at our meetings on 24 November and 8 December. It was made clear by the legal staff at the pre-meeting briefing that because of pressure of work they could not agree to give the necessary legal advice on the draft code of conduct this side of Christmas.
If other committee members agree, I will write to the Presiding Officer to draw his attention to the fact that the establishment and presentation to Parliament of a draft code of conduct is our No 1 priority. I will mention that the advice that we have received today indicates that those resources will not be available to allow us to do so before Christmas.
Let me get this absolutely clear. My intention as convener was to try to get the committee to agree to complete a draft code of conduct by the end of this parliamentary term. I said at the start of the debate that my advice indicated that that might not be physically possible—we might have to stray into January. I understand that that is not acceptable to members and that members feel that we must complete the task before the Christmas recess.I am happy to take that to the Presiding Officer, to ensure that we can make available a draft code of conduct to the Parliament by the end of this parliamentary term.Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.
Before we move on, I would like to say that I am concerned that we might be diverted from our timetable if we are required to deal with individual cases.
I think that we decided that any letters of complaint would be handed to the clerks in the first instance. The point of asking for a temporary adviser is to deal with the initial sifting of complaints.
Are there any other views?
I think that the general view of the majority of the committee is that we should leave the issue until a later date. Is that right?Members indicated agreement.
Thank you. We shall move on to—
Des is suggesting that, and I think that we should move on.
In this meeting
Everything on 10 Nov 1999 →- Scottish Parliament Standards Committee Wednesday 10 November 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 2
- Work Programme Procedure · 42
- Cross-party Groups Committee business · 17
- Lobbying Committee business · 28
- Complaint Committee business · 22
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.