Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Drug Inquiry

Wednesday 5 April 2000 Social Inclusion, Housing and Voluntary Sector Committee Evidence session 59 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

59 contributions
Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

The next item on the agenda is the logistics of our inquiry into drug misuse and deprived communities. This is an update on our on-going discussions. After discussion with our adviser, we have outlined a schedule for visits and a methodology for taking evidence. There are a few rough edges that we have to tidy up—if that is what you do with edges. For example, we have to ensure that we take evidence properly and that we use the Official Report. I am confident that we can tidy things up, after which we will come back to the committee.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

How do we decide who should go to Dublin or Grampian? Do we draw lots?

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

Okay—bids for Dublin now please.Are there any specific points that members would like to raise?

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

I would like to ask about the proposed visit on 8 May, when half of the committee will go to Edinburgh and the other half to Glasgow. As the convener knows, the social work department in Glasgow manages 12 drug addiction projects. We should visit the department and meet Iona Colvin, who is the principal officer on addictions. It may also be valuable to visit one of the projects. I know about the one in Castlemilk because it is in my constituency.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

I will ensure that those points are incorporated in our programme.

Robert Brown LD Glasgow
link

From the papers that we have, I see that we expect to receive more than 80 written responses, which is a hell of a lot. Will the Scottish Parliament information centre do any kind of analysis of those responses on our behalf?

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

Mary Dinsdale is working very hard on this. Mary is making a summary of responses and will produce a briefing for us by 26 April. I have asked that especially interesting information be selected and brought to our attention.

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

I will leave aside the controversial issue of who is going to Dublin, but should individual members advise Martin Verity of the visits that they would like to go on? If there is an imbalance, we can resolve it in committee.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

Yes, I was going to suggest that. If we feel that there is an imbalance for reasons of geography, party or interests, we could discuss that and perhaps swap some people around. When members make their requests to Martin Verity, things may resolve themselves naturally and we may not have to worry about swaps.

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

My second point is perhaps slightly more controversial, but I feel that it is relevant. In recent days, there have been clear indications from the Prime Minister, and others at UK level, of a change in thinking on certain aspects of drug policy. That may impact on any recommendations that we make. Interruption.

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

You see? I knew it was controversial.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

Yes, Mike is obviously a little anxious about this.

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

It is usually the beans you spill, Mike, not the water.I think that we need to hear from someone at UK level, for example, an official or a junior minister from the Home Office. I do not want to make this into a controversial political issue, and I certainly do not want to make it unnecessarily confrontational or party political. However, given that a change in thinking has been indicated, we should take that into account, and try to find out exactly what the change has been.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

I have always made it clear that I do not want us to get lost in issues such as the legalisation of certain drugs, because that would make us lose focus. I do not want to get sidetracked. Would it be a good idea for us to write to seek clarification on any changes in thinking?

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

Depending on the answer, we could fit any such changes into the context of our inquiry. If there has been a change, we certainly need to know.

John McAllion Lab Dundee East
link

They will definitely write back to say that there has been no change in policy.

Lloyd Quinan SNP West of Scotland
link

I would like to ask people's opinion on a slightly different issue. Our adviser, Dr Laurence Gruer, is considered one of the leading experts in the field, and he clearly is. Consequently, when incidents occur, Laurence is asked for his comments by the newspapers. He was quoted in a number of papers at the weekend. Should we say to Laurence that, yes, he should continue to offer his comments as he has done over many years, but that he should make it clear to reporters that they should make no reference to the fact that he is advising this committee? One of the papers mentioned that he was our adviser. I do not want to make a big deal of this, but when Laurence gives his views, they could be regarded as being the views of this committee.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

I take your point. I will seek clarification on the issue and bring it to Laurence's attention.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

Our taking of oral evidence will start with officials from the Executive and will continue in May. When will we be told of the people that it is recommended that we take evidence from?

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

I am glad that you have raised that point. The clerks have asked us to remit the taking of evidence from the people who were supposed to be coming on 10 May. We want to sift through written evidence and material first, and then e-mail people over the recess so that we can get them booked in.

Martin Verity Clerk Team Leader
link

We will be going through all the written evidence and, on the basis of that, we will recommend to the committee the people to call to give oral evidence. However, if we are doing that on 26 April, it does not leave much time to call the first witnesses to the first oral evidence session on 10 May. It is probably reasonable to assume that there will be some particular organisations from which the committee will want to hear evidence. The clerks are suggesting that the committee should remit to the convener the decision on who to call to give evidence at the first session on 10 May. The other witnesses would then be allocated a session on the basis of the summary of written evidence.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I am quite happy with that, as long as one or two members of the committee are consulted.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

There is no problem about consulting.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

What are the criteria for judging which witnesses are appropriate? It is unfortunate that Keith Raffan is not here, but we should know by now the sort of evidence that we want to take.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

There will be different sorts of evidence that we will want to take, as happened with our housing inquiry. I think that the people who would come here would be officers and policy makers, and perhaps deliverers of services. The people who are experiencing the problem directly—the families, the individuals, people from the communities—would be outside.There is a clear distinction. The evidence that we get in here will be the result of thorough and probing questioning; the evidence that we get outside will be more the result of listening and of gathering information. We will take evidence based on the objectives of our inquiry. We will want to consider new strategies involving through-care and follow-up, and to consider what assistance communities need. In here, we will consider professional models and policies, and the way in which they are funded and are accountable; out there, we will listen to experience.I think it would be appropriate to hear from some of the national organisations such as Scotland Against Drugs and the Scottish Drugs Forum. We could both visit them and have them visit us.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

Is what we will do on those dates set in stone? Has anything been set in motion on arranging the visits? I make no secret of the fact that I will not be able to be there, in particular on 8 May, because I have a long-standing commitment to speak at a conference on that date. I understand that such clashes are bound to happen, but if it were possible to reverse the visits on 8 and 22 May, I would appreciate that.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

Does anyone have similar points to flag up?

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

Perhaps now is the time to raise the matter of what will happen when the Parliament meets in Glasgow. Am I right in saying that there will be no committee meetings on the Wednesday mornings?

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

I think that the implication is that the Parliament will meet in the mornings.

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

But from the point of view of our committee meetings during that two or three-week period when the Parliament is in Glasgow, which I think includes the week beginning 8 May—

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

No. It is the weeks beginning 15 and 22 May.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

I have asked the clerk to incorporate that information into our programme.

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

As we are on the subject anyway, what will happen about our committee meetings while the Parliament is sitting in Glasgow?

Martin Verity Clerk Team Leader
link

The conveners liaison group has discussed the committee timetable for that period. I understand that the committees will continue to meet in Edinburgh while the Parliament is meeting in Glasgow, and that will have an impact on the timetable. There may be a difficulty with Monday 15 May; that session may be changed to Tuesday 16 May.

Martin Verity Clerk Team Leader
link

No, for a meeting of the committee.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

But that would not prohibit us from making a visit on Monday?

Martin Verity Clerk Team Leader
link

No. The visits are a separate matter.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

I am not sure what Martin is saying. Why would 15 May be affected? That is a Monday. I know from my position on the Finance Committee that the three committee sessions of Tuesday morning, Tuesday afternoon and Wednesday morning will all be concertinaed into Tuesday—there will be morning, lunchtime and afternoon meetings. Presumably, we will get one of those Tuesday slots.

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

We should not get mixed up on this. As I understand it, the Monday meetings are additional.

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

Is that not an additional meeting as well?

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

That is what I meant. I do not understand why 15 May creates a problem.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

Monday 15 May is on our programme as an oral evidence session.

Martin Verity Clerk Team Leader
link

That can be shifted to 16 May.

Mike Watson Lab Glasgow Cathcart
link

Perhaps I am missing something, but why is a Monday meeting affected by the fact that the Parliament is meeting in Glasgow that week?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

We have not had confirmation that we will not meet, for example, on Wednesday 17 May in the morning because we will be in Glasgow. Clarification of basic information such as that would be helpful.

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

Can we also have clarification that we are not meeting on 16 May in Edinburgh? In other words, is the meeting on 15 May an additional meeting on a Monday, which would have happened anyway, or is it a substitute for what would have been the Wednesday meeting on 17 May? Or are we having the special meeting on Monday 15 May—Laughter.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

You are confusing everybody, Alex. I will confer with the clerk and get the programme back out to members tomorrow. We will sort it out.

Cathie Craigie Lab Cumbernauld and Kilsyth
link

It looks as if we are not meeting at all on Wednesdays between 10 May and the end of May, and that we are substituting the Wednesday meetings for—

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

We are really short of time. I will get the information out to members tomorrow.Irrespective of the specific dates of meetings, are there any other issues on the drug misuse inquiry? It seems not. Good. We can move ahead with that.That brings the public part of the meeting to a close. We will discuss the budget process in private session.

Meeting continued in private until 12:32.

  1. Scottish Parliament Social Inclusion, Housing and Voluntary Sector Committee Wednesday 5 April 2000 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Petitions Petitions · 5
  3. Voluntary Sector Report Committee business · 50
  4. Scottish Criminal Record Office Checks Committee business · 180
  5. Drug Inquiry Evidence session · 59

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.