Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Action Points

Wednesday 27 October 1999 Social Inclusion, Housing and Voluntary Sector Committee Committee business 47 contributions · 8 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

47 contributions
Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

I begin with action points from our previous meeting. I will work my way through them, and members can indicate to me whether they have comments.I understand, Keith, that the issues that you were due to raise at the meeting of the European Committee on 19 October were not discussed.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I attended the meeting, but it largely tackled the objective 2 structural funds map and the Highlands and Islands. Because the objective 3 papers had not arrived in time, the topic was not covered. We are not the only committee that seems to get papers from the Executive at the last minute. The matter was not covered, but it is on the table and it will be addressed.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

Will you attend the meeting when the matter is addressed?

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I have asked the clerk of the European Committee to keep in touch with us and let us know, so that we can attend. I tried to e-mail Alex Neil, but I think that he was away in sunnier climes.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

Set the record straight, Alex.May I assume that the clerks will ensure that you are properly informed of those meetings and that you will inform us when they are to take place?

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

The issue of Scottish Criminal Record Office checks will be returned to. It connects with the next point, which is that Karen Whitefield was appointed as the committee's reporter on voluntary sector issues. Karen will make a brief statement on her progress.

Karen Whitefield Lab Airdrie and Shotts
link

I was appointed to the role of reporter only at the previous meeting, and we did not clarify my role and responsibilities. I do not want to go off and do my own thing without consulting committee members.During the recess, I attended a Scottish Council for Voluntary Organisations conference and spoke about the work of the committee. I had a follow-up meeting with the SCVO, and it has given us permission to access its database of community groups and organisations. I am happy to meet some of the key players in the voluntary sector, but I am keen that we meet many smaller community groups as well. There is no way that any of us has the time to meet them all individually, so I suggest that over the next week to 10 days I draft a letter and questionnaire to be sent out to organisations across Scotland. Before the letter is sent out, I will bring it to the committee for members' comments. The questionnaire will allow us to draw up our agenda on matters relating to the voluntary sector. The SCVO made a number of suggestions about how we should take forward the agenda, but to do it properly, we need to consult the entire voluntary sector.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

Thank you. Does anyone have any points to raise?

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

I do not wish to prolong discussion of the matter, but how will the system of reporters work? How structured will the system be? I know that other committees have set up formal sub-working groups, chaired by reporters. That is the way in which reporters are keeping in touch with committee members. How will we operate? Do we have any clear guidelines?

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

No, we do not. I do not know whether the Parliament has clear guidelines. The guidelines are evolving through the work of the committees. I prefer that, so that the role of reporters fits our needs, rather than vice versa.It was agreed previously that at the end of each committee meeting I would summarise the work that we were doing. I was going to make one or two points about our expectations of what reporters will do. That does not prevent us from addressing the issue at various times, for example, if we do not feel that the work is appropriate, or if we wish to change the role or the person, but our discussions now are simply to get us started. A process of regular reports and consultation with all members of the committee seems to be the working method towards which we are feeling our way. My view is not to take firm decisions until we are more confident about what we expect of reporters. We will return to the issue when I summarise our plans and when we are more sure of our work.

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

An outstanding action item from a previous meeting was to find out when the report on charity reform by the University of Abertay, Dundee would be available. It is a central issue for all voluntary organisations, so Karen Whitefield and the clerks should try to find out when the report will be available.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

Part of the remit of the reporters will be to ensure that decisions that are made by the committee are addressed and that appropriate recommendations emerge. I ask reporters to trawl through the records to ensure that business is completed. The work programme will be updated for the next meeting. We will return to that issue.It was decided that I would liaise with Roseanna Cunningham, the convener of the Justice and Home Affairs Committee, on the Abolition of Poindings and Warrant Sales Bill. I will talk about the issue in greater depth later, because it is important for our work. Roseanna and I have failed to make contact on a number of occasions.

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

Apparently the Local Government Committee wants some input as well.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Roseanna attended the Parliamentary Bureau yesterday to discuss the backlog of bills in the Justice and Home Affairs Committee. It was made clear that the Local Government Committee wants an input. It is all getting quite complex.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

I was told only two hours before the meeting of the Parliamentary Bureau that the matter would be raised. I have registered that we need to have more warning in future. It is likely that we will negotiate with the convener of the Justice and Home Affairs Committee and will share evidence equally with that committee.

Many organisations want to be heard, and this committee is sympathetic to that.

Bill Aitken Con Glasgow
link

We might hear evidence, then the other committee might hear the same evidence. We must not allow that to happen, particularly as the clock starts ticking as soon as the bill has been introduced. Something must happen within three months, otherwise the whole thing falls.It would be unfortunate if a bill should be lost because we are unable to organise the committee's timetable to accommodate the time scale involved.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

From what Ken Hughes told me yesterday evening, I understand that the bill will not necessarily have to keep to that three-month deadline. I will recommend that we pursue it immediately as there is a substantial amount of evidence to be heard, but the bill is not as hide-bound as other bills are because of the financial resolution.

Bill Aitken Con Glasgow
link

Essentially, it is the Executive's bills that must be progressed within the three-month period. As I understand it, that is because they require a financial memorandum. Contrary to the advice that the sponsors of the bill were given, private bills, which, by definition, have no financial implications for the public purse, do not require a financial memorandum.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

There is obviously some debate about that. I informed the committee of the most recent advice that I received.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

I will attend the next meeting of the Parliamentary Bureau to make sure that we are clear about the timetable.

Robert Brown LD Glasgow
link

There is potential for different aspects of the bill to be dealt with by different committees—I assume that the Local Government Committee is concerned about the effects on the recovery of council tax. We must keep a balanced view when questioning witnesses and ensure that only the aspects connected with our committee are reflected in the questions that we put. We must also ensure that the committees do not speak to the same witnesses.

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Roseanna Cunningham said that she and the clerk of the Justice and Home Affairs Committee had drawn up a list of people from whom evidence would be taken. It is important that the committees take evidence from those who are for and those who are against the bill.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

I have had discussions about that. I have a list of people, and we can talk about it later. We should take a balanced approach and share the responsibility with the Justice and Home Affairs Committee. The social inclusion sub-group will recommend that we tackle the bill in the context of debt and credit, as we would consider those issues anyway.I recommend that we read through the list of agencies that want to submit evidence. I will liaise with the ad hoc social inclusion group, the Justice and Home Affairs Committee and the Local Government Committee. I think that it will be possible for us to come to a working agreement among the committees. The Parliamentary Bureau will tell us when we should report to the Justice and Home Affairs Committee.

Robert Brown LD Glasgow
link

We should seek out organisations that we might want to hear from but which have not contacted us.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

We have the right to do that. The Justice and Home Affairs Committee has advertised for organisations to give evidence, and the social inclusion group will probably do the same.I will return to the issue of meeting in private. Do we all receive copies of press releases relevant to the work of the committee?

Bill Aitken Con Glasgow
link

There has been a plethora in the past few days.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

We will be hoist by our own petard on that.

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

On that point, have we had any response to the previous letters that we sent to the Executive?

Fiona Hyslop SNP Lothians
link

I understand that four of the social inclusion network reports are due for press release next week. It is essential that the committee receives them.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

I received a letter at my constituency office and forwarded it to Martin Verity to circulate to the committee. Do you have the letter, Martin?

Martin Verity Committee Clerk
link

I have a copy of the letter here, and I can circulate it to the committee.

Robert Brown LD Glasgow
link

Have we had anything on the domestic violence announcement that was made earlier this week?

Martin Verity Committee Clerk
link

I do not think so.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

That might go to the Equal Opportunities Committee. We need to seek clarification on that. Can we move on?

Keith Raffan LD Mid Scotland and Fife
link

You whizzed quickly through bullet point 2 on the Scottish Criminal Record Office checks.

The review committee is being set up, but it would be useful if we had a session on that soon.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

I rushed through it because I expect that Karen will tell us when we can have the session. The reporters need to think that through. I ask Karen to remind us about that.

Alex Neil SNP Central Scotland
link

An outstanding item from a previous meeting is that we were to receive—from the Scottish Parliament information centre, I think—some sort of mapping exercise of all the social inclusion work that is going on among the public sector agencies in Scotland. We asked for it about three or four months ago and there does not seem to have been any progress.

Margaret Curran Lab The Convener · Glasgow Baillieston
link

May I check that and get back to you?

  1. Scottish Parliament Social Inclusion, Housing and Voluntary Sector Committee Wednesday 27 October 1999 (Morning) Committee business · 4
  2. Action Points Committee business · 47
  3. Social Inclusion Committee business · 17
  4. Scottish Homes Committee business · 132
  5. Housing Committee business · 50
  6. Meetings Committee business · 13
  7. Timetable Committee business · 2
  8. Correspondence Committee business · 4

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.