Item 2 is to consider two statutory instruments under the negative procedure: the Less Favoured Area Support Scheme (Scotland) Regulations 2003, and the Rural Stewardship Scheme (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2003. To assist us in our deliberations, I am pleased to welcome officials from the Scottish Executive environment and rural affairs department, who have agreed to answer members' questions on both schemes. The Rural Stewardship Scheme (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2003 came before the Subordinate Legislation Committee only today, and it has not yet had time to report on its findings, so we must defer our formal decision on the instrument until our next meeting. However, we welcome the opportunity to take evidence on the instrument in advance of our formal deliberations next week. I point out that we are obliged to decide the terms of our report on the Less Favoured Area Support Scheme (Scotland) Regulations 2003 today. I welcome Jim Wildgoose, Brian Endicott, John Hood and Bill Hepburn from SEERAD, and invite Mr Wildgoose to make an opening statement.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Less Favoured Area Support Scheme (Scotland) Regulations 2003 (SSI 2003/129)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Jim Wildgoose Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 30
- Alex Fergusson Con 21
- Fergus Ewing SNP 19
- Bill Hepburn Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 9
- Brian Endicott Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 8
- Stewart Stevenson SNP 7
- Rhoda Grant Lab 6
- Mike Rumbles LD 6
The record
106 contributionsMy opening remarks refer to some points in the Executive note. The changes were subject to detailed discussions early last year in an industry group comprising the three main bodies affected by the changes: the National Farmers Union of Scotland, the Scottish Landowners Federation and what was then the Scottish Crofters Union and is now the Scottish Crofting Foundation. Agreement was reached on the main changes in about May of last year and a consultation exercise was carried out between June and July. Agreement to the final scheme was reached late in July and the scheme was submitted to Brussels for clearance early in September, immediately following the Brussels summer break. The Commission cleared the scheme at the STAR committee—the committee on agricultural structures and rural development—on 18 November 2002. That led to the instrument today, which essentially implements the agreed scheme. I will stop there and invite comments.
Thank you. You mentioned the consultation that took place with the industry. When the details were announced, the industry generally welcomed the changes, in that they minimised the number of winners and losers that had previously been apparent. By coincidence, I was visited in my surgery last week by a farmer—not a large farmer—from the south of Scotland, who has received LFA support since the scheme was introduced. In 2001, he received just over £11,000 and, in 2002, following the alterations that took place, he received just over £12,000. However, this year, because the figures are based on 2001, and because he entered an environmentally sensitive area scheme, his support will be reduced to £6,500. The fact that he entered an ESA in the base year that has been chosen involves a 150-head reduction in his stock of ewes. The chap obviously has extenuating circumstances, so why is only one year used as the base year? Is there a way round that and what right of appeal does he have, given the rather late notification of the figures on which he could work out his LFA support—the letter only arrived at the beginning of March?
The individual circumstances of the case would need to be considered. Specifically, if he makes an application, there is a mechanism for considering whether the base year is atypical, although I cannot say, hand on heart, that a change would necessarily be made.
Has that mechanism been made widely known to farmers in explanatory notes?
Yes.
A concern about the scheme is the minimum stocking density levels, which do not take account of the souming on the land—the legal stocking density levels. On some hill farms, the legal stocking density level is a lot lower than the minimum stocking density level in the scheme. In a way, people are stuck between a rock and a hard place, as they cannot take action that would attract more finance because that would be illegal. Has any consideration been given to changing the scheme so that it uses the legal stocking density level as a minimum rather than prescribing a minimum that might not fit in with everybody?
The minimum was introduced essentially to avoid over-compensation for large estates and problems that existed with over-compensation in the earlier schemes. People who are below the minimum do not lose subsidies as such. Their area is proportioned down so that their effective stocking density becomes the minimum. That involves a reduction. The system was agreed by the group when the arrangements were set up and that is the scheme that we have.If the souming level is felt to be incorrect because it does not reflect the stock carried on the land, there is a procedure to review and change that. However, there is a minimum stocking density. Producers who are below that would have their area adjusted so that they reached that level.
I certainly welcomed the alteration to the original proposal, which means that there are now three categories. I think that the alteration was welcomed in mainland areas, particularly by marginal hill farms. The alteration followed much lobbying, not just from people such as me but from the National Farmers Union of Scotland. It will help to prevent there being massive losers, certainly in the area that I represent—for example, in Strathspey.Under the LFA scheme, the lowest rate is £36.50. Who will be the most likely losers under the new scheme, taking into account that and all the other regulations, and the 50 per cent reduction?
Before I answer that question, I stress that the issue is what we compare losers with.
That is obvious. It is clear that a loser is someone who gets less income than they did before. That is not very complicated.
But compared with which year? Are we talking about 2000 or 2002? That is an important issue, because the schemes in those years were different from each other.
Yes, I know that, but perhaps you could describe both categories of losers.
So you want to know who is losing compared with 2000 and who is losing compared with 2002. The schemes that were introduced in 2001 and 2002 had a flaw—perhaps that is not the right word. We were trying to accommodate the fact that moving to a hectarage scheme meant that good producers were losing out compared with their 2000 income.The 2003 scheme tries to rectify the difficulties that we faced in 2001 and 2002 by ensuring that people who gained in 2001 and 2002 because they had large hectarage and relatively low stocking densities will lose in 2003. However, productive farmers are gaining compared with the past two years and their income will be more or less on a par with their position in 2000.
My understanding of the scheme is that it is better than the previous ones that were negotiated, particularly the first one, at the beginning of the Parliament. That scheme caused widespread concern, particularly in areas such as the Western Isles. The new scheme is to be welcomed. However, I am not clear about the answer to a simple question. Who do you expect to lose out under the new scheme? The question is not complicated. Which types of farming activity and land and which parts of Scotland will lose out?
The question is slightly more complicated than is implied, because the 2003 scheme has different elements from earlier ones. For example, there is a significant uplift effect because of the enterprise mix calculation where people have a higher proportion of cattle in their livestock than sheep. Producers get a 35 per cent increase if more than 10 per cent of their livestock units are cattle. If more than 50 per cent of their livestock are cattle, the increase is 70 per cent. I cannot give a categorical answer to the question, but when the 2003 figures are compared with previous years, I expect them to show that the categories of people who will tend to gain will be those who have cattle in or above those proportions.Other issues are involved. In 2002, a cap was imposed on payments. Indeed, one of the reasons why we had to make changes was because it was not seen as desirable for the cap to continue—the Commission was against that. Eliminating the cap and making the changes, depending on the enterprise mix of the holding, means that a holding will lose or gain compared with 2002. Quite a complex range of issues is involved in calculating who gains and who loses as a result of the changes that we have introduced.
I appreciate that the matter is complex. When one begins to examine the various formulae that are contained in the statutory instrument, one could say that it resembles more an advanced mathematics paper than a statutory instrument that farmers are supposed to be able to understand. That is why I asked a fairly simple question.As I said, I appreciate that the matter is complex. I also appreciate that the rule on cattle density means that the greater the proportion of cattle, the better off a person is. I am still not sure that we have got an answer to what was a simple question—having tried twice, perhaps I should just move on.
Could I press a small issue, which is part of that line of questioning?
Of course.
Many of the crofter organisations have voiced considerable displeasure about the financial effect that the scheme will have on some of their members. I address my question to Mr Hepburn. In general, will crofters be better off under the LFASS 2003 than they were under the previous hill livestock compensatory allowance in 2000?
There are two answers to the question. The first is that the introduction of the minimum payment of £350, which goes to all producers, has resulted in a large number of crofters being better off than they were under the old scheme. Many crofters—I am thinking of small-scale crofters with low levels of production—received payment below the HLCA level.However, when other areas are taken into consideration, our broad calculations show that the position of crofters—and indeed of the whole industry—is roughly the same as it was in 2000 in respect of the proportion of money that is spent on the different categories. In broad terms, one would expect the position of crofters to be roughly the same as it was in 2000.
So what you are saying is that, although crofters might be worse off than they were in 2002, they should be about the same or slightly better off compared with the previous scheme.
Yes. That is correct.
Will you clarify what you meant by the removal of the cap?
In the 2002 scheme, a limit of £2,500 was placed on the increase in the amount of money that a recipient could receive compared with the base period. Where a freely calculated amount of money under the scheme was more than £2,500 above the amount in the base period, the amount of money that could be paid was capped at an increase of £2,500.
You said that there was pressure from the Commission to remove the cap.
Yes. The cap and the safety net beneath it were transitional measures that were agreed with the Commission; they were not part of the rural development plan as such. The Commission was looking for free-standing rates that would achieve the effect that it wanted to achieve under the rural development regulation.
It was the Executive's decision to remove the cap. The Executive was not required to do that to satisfy European Union rules.
Essentially, the answer to that question is yes. Given that we needed to make changes, the issue was how we could establish a free-standing scheme that would achieve the requirements under the rural development regulation. Decisions were taken with that in mind. It was recognised that a cap would be difficult to negotiate again. That was the position that the industry group faced. We decided that we would advance with a free-standing scheme.
It is important to bear in mind the other side of the cap, the safety net, which in the first year was 90 per cent and in the second year—2002—was 80 per cent. In the forthcoming year, the rather complicated formula, which amounted to 50 per cent and a bit, was going to be removed. The Commission insisted on the removal of the safety net. Had the scheme been left untouched, even with a cap, it would have meant a huge shift in payments and there would have been quite a number of losers, particularly among productive farms. Given that the safety net was coming to an end, we had to change the scheme anyway. In changing the scheme, the cap was lost as a matter of course.
I have two further questions, which are rather different. Looking to the future, how do you feel that the less favoured area support scheme will be affected by common agricultural policy reform—in particular, by decoupling? If decoupling goes ahead, I presume that an extremely complicated LFAS scheme such as that proposed in SSI 2003/129 would be redundant. How do you see the situation developing? Have you had any initial response from the Commission on what the future holds for farmers who rely on LFAS funding at present?
Formally, the CAP reform proposals will have no direct effect on the LFAS scheme. The scheme is funded out of the rural development, or pillar 2, end of funding. The reforms are much more directed at the pillar 1 funding—the sectoral scheme funding. In a formal sense, there is no direct link.However, in some ways, the arrangements for the LFAS scheme are quite similar to a decoupled arrangement, in that there is a base period on which sums of money are based. It is true that the enterprise mix element, in relation to which a higher payment is received for a bigger proportion of cattle in livestock units, is not decoupled, but the basic payment is. Therefore, the thinking is similar to that behind the proposals that have been made under the decoupling reforms.How those arrangements will fit together in the totality of support that goes into the LFAS scheme will depend on what comes out of the reform proposals. The firm intention is to retain the LFAS arrangements, subject to a review of how they progress and how they work in practice. There will be something similar to those arrangements from now on. I would not expect the reform proposals to make a big difference to the arrangements.
I appreciate that it is a complicated area and that we can only speculate. If decoupling had an adverse impact on the Scottish beef sector, for example, would not it have an indirect impact on the LFAS scheme, because we might lose critical mass in the beef sector?
Yes, there could be an effect there. The top-up calculations on the enterprise mix could be affected if the proportion of farmers' livestock units in cattle fell below 10 per cent or 50 per cent. I would not expect there to be a huge effect, although that would depend on the reduction in beef production that might come from decoupling. The underlying basic rates of payment would not be affected. There would be an issue about whether changes should be made to the payment rates to make up the budget. If money was not paid out under the enterprise mix calculation, it might be paid out in other ways.
I have one further question, although I do not want to hog the floor.
You were not doing that.
Obviously, the regulations are extremely complicated. The formulae are incomprehensible—except perhaps to the draftsman, who I hope understands them. However, the regulations place a number of onerous obligations on farmers. For example, part II of schedule 2, entitled "Verifiable standards", contains eight specific, detailed rules. You are aware that farmers and crofters argue—quite rightly—that they are subject to a huge range of regulation.Some of the rules are quite vague. Paragraph 7 states:"Unsuitable supplementary feeding methods shall be avoided."Paragraph 8 states:"Undergrazing shall be avoided."A vague definition of undergrazing is provided.Farmers want to meet appropriate standards, to follow correct practices and to exercise good stewardship. However, do these regulations not go too far? If not, what happens if there is an infraction of any rule? Will that lead to withdrawal of LFASS money, or a proportion of it?
Good farming practice guidelines are common to a number of the schemes that we use. When undergrazing or overgrazing is first noted, we will seek to reach an agreement with the farmer on the management steps that are necessary to return the land to good agricultural condition. Once that agreement has been made, it will be monitored. Only if the farmer fails to uphold the agreement will his payment be affected. The effect may be limited to that part of the payment that refers to the area of land that is being overgrazed or undergrazed.
That procedure is not set out in the statutory instrument.
It is set out in the explanatory notes that we have issued to all producers, which indicate how issues relating to good farming practice will be handled.
Courts will examine the statutory instrument and any decision must be made on the basis of it. Does the instrument contain a specific reference to the informal procedure that you have described? I did not notice one on first reading, but perhaps I missed it.
The member is correct to say that the procedure is not set out in the SSI.
Where is it set out?
The arrangements that I have described are set out in the explanatory notes that we provide. Those indicate how we put good farming practice guidelines into practice.
As you know, I have made detailed representations on behalf of crofters and farmers in my constituency who have broken the rules unintentionally, usually by failing to fill in their integrated administration and control system forms properly. As a result of a clerical error, some of them have lost a whole year's income. If I robbed a bank, mugged someone or shot someone, I might not get such a large fine.I raised this issue in the Parliament and received an assurance from Ross Finnie that he would take the matter to Europe and would get Europe to agree to introduce a better system. I know that there is an appeals structure, but that is not relevant because it does not change the rules at all—it means only that someone else interprets them. What progress has Mr Finnie made on winning a fairer system that would not treat farmers and crofters like criminals?
Unfortunately, the person who deals with this area of work is not here today. However, because I was responsible for it until eight or nine months ago, I can tell the member that on several occasions we have asked the Commission to address simplification. As part of the mid-term review, the Commission is considering proposals to simplify arrangements, particularly under the rural development regulation.It has been singularly difficult to convince the Commission of the need to simplify the system. There is a feeling that the rules must be obeyed to the letter and it has been extremely difficult even to engage the Commission in the kind of discussion that you mention. The Commission does not recognise the category of obvious error or unintentional error. It recognises a category where someone has perhaps summed up a row of figures incorrectly, but not another error that might look like an obvious error. It has been extremely difficult to move the Commission away from that position. I am not up to date with the very latest up to date position, but that is certainly the ethos that existed in the time that I was responsible for that.
I take it that you are saying that the Scottish Executive view is that there should be a fairer system that would allow errors that could be demonstrated to be innocent rather than fraudulent to be treated in a mild and appropriate way through a written warning rather than financial loss. Does the Executive share my view that that should be the approach?
Yes. That is the position. In the past, we suggested a yellow card, red card procedure for those kinds of errors, but to no avail.
I have had occasion to write on this many times in the South of Scotland, which I represent, as has Fergus Ewing in his area. It has become apparent to me, as I am sure it has to all committee members, that the lack of flexibility allowed in the European regulations has forced us to a position where we are penalised every bit as severely for a genuine and honest mistake as we would have been if we had filled in a form fraudulently. In any true justice system, that seems to me to be beyond the pale. Although everybody's desire is for further flexibility, will you assure us that such cases are prosecuted with every bit as much inflexibility in other European states as they are in the United Kingdom?
We have not carried out a specific study of exactly how penalties are imposed in other member states. I know that the Commission makes draconian audit visits to member states, including visits to Scotland. It imposes disallowance on member states that do not abide by the rules. I cannot say whether the same stringency is used in other member states, but the Commission penalises heavily those that do not abide by the regulations, particularly in relation to errors in forms. It takes samples of forms and follows the audit trail of what has happened when figures are changed. A draconian procedure is used for audit trail purposes.
Can you give us a time scale for when a yellow card, red card procedure might be looked at?
The simple answer is that I cannot. If the reforms proceed in the way that is proposed, the arrangements will be different. We will not be counting animals or areas and there will be a different system. We are keen to see a much simpler system with the new arrangements—that was one of our key negotiating points. One of the issues that could be difficult is good farming practice, to which Fergus Ewing referred. The measures in schedule 2 are the kind of thing that will be required for receipt of the decoupled payment. There is a question about how that will be controlled and how draconian or detailed the controls will have to be. Those issues will be addressed within the discussions on CAP reform.
You mentioned continuing monitoring of LFASS as it will apply from 2003. What procedures are in place to review it, and in what time scale might that happen?
We will look specifically at the payment arrangements and outturn for LFASS 2003; we will check certain features and see how things are working. Though a date has not yet been set, the industry group will meet again in the middle of the year for review, and to decide whether changes need to be made: to rates, for example. That programme of work is on-going. It is hoped that the scheme will not require fundamental change until the end of 2006, when the plan ends. However, from there we will certainly review how things are working every year.
Might that review include retrospective payments to farmers who have genuinely been caught out in an anomalous situation by the introduction of LFASS 2003? If not, would you expect that to be addressed by the appeals procedure?
I expect that to be addressed through the appeals procedure. Any concerns or anomalies relating to the scheme in question would be covered by it. If slightly different provisions apply in the following year, those would then cover applicants under that scheme. In other words, jurisdiction is kept within the scheme year.
As regards undergrazing, I am concerned about how the scheme sits with environmental protection. The way in which the scheme is written encourages maximum stocking, so that the maximum acreage is taken into account. Discouragement of undergrazing is also written into the scheme. How does that sit alongside policies of reduced stocking levels to protect the environment?
The minimum stocking density is designed to reach a balance between avoiding overgrazing and avoiding undergrazing. I sense that you want to avoid undergrazing. In fact, overgrazing is more of an issue if there is more stock on the land.
Overgrazing is obviously a huge environmental issue, but I cannot understand why the scheme discourages undergrazing, which would allow more habitats to be left intact. The scheme seems to push farmers and crofters up to the maximum grazing available from their land. It does not seem to be aligned with other environmental schemes, which require lower stocking for environmental benefit.
The stocking density of 0.12 is relatively low, and is the minimum level that we would pay on. Clearly, good farming practice in the terms that we just discussed will stop the occurrence of undergrazing. Research has shown that if there are too few animals on land, it will revert to bracken and shrub and result in a monoculture. For that reason, a balance between over and undergrazing is necessary. Therefore, while it introduces a minimum stocking density, the scheme will ensure that there is stock. Too few animals also represent an environmental impact.
It has been explained that for those farms with a souming level below the minimum stocking density, the area of land is reduced until the minimum is reached. Surely that encourages farmer-crofters to reach their maximum stocking density, even up to the maximum that the land can bear? There is no encouragement to reduce stocking levels for environmental benefit.
There are separate schemes to deal with environmental issues. This scheme is designed to support agriculture, so one would expect producers to have a reasonable number of stock on their land and that is what the scheme is designed to encourage. If there is overgrazing, the good farming practice provisions would kick in so that that would be stopped. Equally, if producers have too little stock on their land, the undergrazing provisions would kick in.
Let me add to that. It is true that one could argue that a farm or croft with a stocking density of 0.08, which is below the minimum stocking density of 0.12, has an incentive under the scheme to increase the stock level such that it comes up to the 0.12 level. However, in point of fact, if the 0.08 level is the level that is sustainable and consistent with the souming, that 0.08 level would be seen as the level that was consistent with good farming practice, which would mean that it abides by another element of the scheme. Strictly speaking, therefore, a producer in that situation should not extend the stocking density to go beyond what is required by the good farming practice provisions under the scheme.
To get the maximum benefit from the scheme, producers would be not only encouraged, but required to maintain that 0.08 stocking density level, if that is the maximum that they can have. However, if 0.08 is the maximum level that the land can sustain, might not that cause environmental problems? Surely it would be better to allow the producer to maintain a level slightly below that for environmental benefit.
If the sustainable level of stocking is 0.08, that is the level that is consistent with good farming practice. Having half as much stock again—which is what would be required to get from 0.08 to 0.12—would not be consistent with good farming practice. In that instance, there would be a question mark over whether the scheme's provisions were being complied with.
Do you understand where I am coming from? The scheme seems to run against other Executive support schemes and there seems to be no policy that runs through all the schemes. One can see why farmers might get a little confused, when one scheme asks them to do this and another scheme asks them to do that. Sometimes the schemes seem to contradict one another.
That rather takes me back to where I began. As the farmer to whom I referred had entered an environmentally sensitive area, his stocking density had dropped to a lower category, which in effect halved the amount of subsidy that he could receive. I think that we are coming from the same angle.
I was under the impression that the appeals process was to help farmers who had made innocent errors in the completion of their paperwork, such as failing to fill in forms correctly. However, the answer given to Fergus Ewing's question seemed to indicate that that was not the case. What is the appeals process for?
I must distinguish between two kinds of appeals.Under the standard IACS appeals arrangements, which were set up about two or three years ago, the essential question that is asked is whether the rules have been applied properly. Clearly, there is some discretion in the application of rules and in the decisions that department officials might need to take in particular cases. The producer might say that the decision on a particular application was unfair or unreasonable or whatever. That appeals mechanism is designed to check whether the rules have been applied properly. For cases in which an error has been made on a form, the Commission has set down detailed rules and procedures as to whether a change can be made to correct the error. For example, if someone has put down 10 as opposed to 100, there are rules that need to be applied for that kind of error. As I said earlier, a number of those rules are particularly difficult and are not subject to the appeals mechanism as such. We have tried to seek change on that from the Commission, but we have not been successful. That is the ordinary appeals mechanism, which concerns the application of the rules as they exist within the legislation.The other element of appeal, which is specifically referred to in the case that you mention, concerns the atypical base period that might be used for this scheme. If 2001 is atypical because a family problem, for example, has led to a reduction in production or whatever, a mechanism would allow that to be looked at to see whether the grazing category that has been allocated is incorrect and should be changed. Therefore there are two elements to the appeals process.
Say, for example, that I am a farmer. I understand the rules, and I fill in my forms and send them off to you. However, when I have sent them off I think, "Crikey, I have made a mistake." If I did not quite understand the rules, or I thought that you were misapplying them, I could appeal. However, because I have made a mistake there is no appeals mechanism for me. You will just make the decision and say that the form is wrong, and I do not get what I am applying for.
It is perhaps not as black and white as that. However, the rules are fairly strict and are in the legislation—indeed, even in the EU legislation. The Commission considers those issues when it conducts an audit. Therefore we must take them seriously. We have looked at trying to make changes, such as the yellow card, red card arrangements that I talked about earlier. However, we have not made headway with the Commission, which has been pretty clear about its views.
I would like to make sure that I have this right. A farmer can use the appeals mechanism if he feels that you are misapplying the rules, but he cannot use it if he thinks that you are applying the rules, whether or not there has been an error. In other words, even if he admits that there is an error and you agree, there is no third party to whom he can say, "The Executive is being too heavy handed because it knows that I have made a mistake, and I know that I have made a mistake, but there is no leeway." Are you saying that there is no other appeals mechanism? If not, do you not think that there should be?
Usually those kinds of problems will appear through the ordinary appeals mechanism. It is not usually quite as straightforward as is being outlined. If the error is one that falls within the legislation as being unacceptable, the appeals route will decide what view will be taken and will say that that will be the decision. If it is something further than that, such as a problem with how the rules have been applied, the appeal then moves through. There have been cases in which appellants have been successful.
We accept that the penalties can be very severe, and to that extent, over the autumn and winter, we issued a booklet that explains the penalties in detail, giving examples of how they are calculated. The booklet also gives handy hints about how penalties can be avoided.Taking Mr Rumbles's example, part of that booklet also explains that if a farmer completes and submits his form, then realises that he has made an error, a facility that was introduced under the latest IACS regulations allows him to withdraw that claim without penalty and put himself back into the position that he would have been in had that claim never existed. He can avoid penalties in that way.
Are we perhaps dancing on the head of a pin here? Is it a problem or not? As far as you are aware, are people being penalised because they make errors in their applications?
They are being penalised. For example, part of my job is to sit on the appeals panel at stage 1. We come across cases of people forgetting to put in a form. The form arrives—there is no debate about that—it gets put on one side, other things intervene and the scheme closure date comes and goes. In such cases, the panel tries to seek out information that might identify whether the applicant has suffered what the regulations call "force majeure"—an unexpected event that has prevented them from filling out the form. If we can find evidence of such a situation, the appeal might be accepted. If we cannot, the regulations say that late claims will not be admissible. It is as stark as that. We do not have any discretion in such a situation.
In effect, you are saying that the lateness of a claim is the issue. If a claim that is wrong comes in, it can be sent back and the applicant can resubmit it. The fact that time has run out is what matters.
That would be one example. Another might be someone who forgets to enter a certain number of animals on a particular claim or who overdeclares or underdeclares the amount of land that they have. People suffer a penalty for many reasons.
I understand the time limit issue. Your hands are tied in such cases. Putting that to one side, you are saying that if someone makes an error in an application, the appeals people will look at it and will say that it can be withdrawn and a proper application submitted. Apart from the time issue, are there any other reasons why farmers should be penalised if they have inadvertently put forward the wrong information?
There might be situations in which farmers had failed to maintain adequate flock or herd records or in which there had been a failure in the tagging of particular animals, for example.
I am glad that the officials acknowledge the severity of the situation. They seem to accept that the penalties are very severe. I could answer Mike Rumbles by saying that my experience over the past three and a half years is that if someone has made a mistake, even if it is an honest and genuine mistake, there is an appeals procedure, but an appeal is very unlikely to be successful. The rules are incredibly tight. I can only hope that efforts to find some flexibility or a warning-card system will be pursued with the utmost vigour. Fairness dictates that that should be the case. An honest mistake should not be penalised in the same way as a fraudulent claim. That is what happens at the moment.
We are not finished with the subject yet. The penalties on farmers for errors that are essentially administrative are draconian. The Executive has applied to Europe to introduce something more sensible. We are not getting what we need. Whose desk is the issue sitting on? Is it sitting on Franz Fischler's desk or on someone else's?
The issue has certainly been raised at working-group level and at higher level. I could not say that it sits on Franz Fischler's desk at the moment, although he is the commissioner responsible for such issues.
I am asking whether we should be encouraging the eight Scottish members of the European Parliament to start raising the issue on a political level in Europe. I do not think that there would be any political division on that suggestion. Would that lubricate the decision-making processes? I recognise that, as officials, you do not necessarily have to comment on that. However, it might be useful to ask whether, in your experience, the application of the rules in other countries is as rigorous and as onerous as it is here.
I just asked that.
Did you? In that case, we do not need to pursue it. I must have nodded off.
Should I answer that?
Please do. I am hurt that a member could nod off while I was speaking.
I would like to add that, from time to time, we have sought to get the Commission to agree to recognise the term, "genuine error". It does not recognise that term. It recognises the term, "obvious error". Such an error would be numbers on a form being summed up to something different from the subtotal. It is extremely difficult to move beyond that.
In my tax return two years ago—when I was leaving my previous employment and taking up employment here—I had share options to deal with. They came under four different headings, because they were part of four different schemes. The bank failed to draw to my attention in a letter the fact that one option differed from the other three in its terms of approval, and all the options went in under one heading in my tax return. A year later, it transpired that one of the options had to be treated differently in tax terms and that more tax was due. The penalty that fell upon me was the interest on the sum that I had not paid in tax, which was £685. That was a perfectly fair penalty. Do you think that the type of penalty that is imposed on farmers when they have made an obvious mistake—the withdrawal of all their income—would be deemed under international law to be cruel and unusual punishment?
I feel that the penalties are draconian in some areas. It does not seem reasonable for someone to lose all their income for what seems a fairly trivial error. There have been test cases against such penalties, but nothing has been upheld. On the late penalties, the legislation says that for every day after the day by which the form has to be in, there will be a 1 per cent reduction in the money, and after 25 days there will be no money at all.
Given that, in other countries, there appears to be flair and imagination in the way that things are implemented, would it be possible for farmers to deliver their forms to an intermediate body that would check them for correctness and obvious errors and return them to the farmer, before they reached SEERAD? Such a body could take a bond or negotiate insurance to cover any liabilities that it might end up with if such checking proved to be incomplete. When the forms reached SEERAD, they would be correct, because they would have been verified by an independent public body or by a body established by the industry. Would that proffer a possible way forward to reduce the impact on farmers?
Yes indeed, and I think that such a method is used to some extent now, as private advisers check forms. We are developing electronic means of submitting forms, which would offer major advantages. When applicants input their information electronically, it can be checked at that point, because the machine will not accept certain errors. A range of things could be done. Unfortunately, it is difficult to get a high uptake of electronic form submission, but we are progressing with that as quickly as we can.
I suspect that if farmers became aware that draconian penalties would cease to fall upon them if they used electronic form submission, the uptake might rise sharply. If SEERAD requires additional resources to improve the quality of such systems, we would like to know, to ensure that the resources are made available.
Much as I welcome increased use of electronic methods of applying for various schemes, I hope that it is not too much of a generalisation to suggest that experience dictates that the farmers who find themselves in difficulties because of a genuine mistake are probably the least likely to join electronic schemes.
Sure.
I also have slight difficulty in understanding why an official who will determine what is under or over-stocking, or indeed what is good or bad agricultural practice, cannot also be allowed to determine what is a genuine and honest mistake. In my farming days, the officials knew one's farming practices and probably had a fair idea whether they were good or bad. I find that a difficult equation to get to grips with. I hope that it might be addressed in the future if a more reasonable method comes to light.You say that negotiations are taking place and that discussions are being held—with whom?
On the simplification of forms—
And flexibility in the determination of errors.
I would not like to mislead the committee and say that a working group is considering that as we speak, but at various points we have raised the issue of simplification. Indeed, I think that there is a committee considering it now. The issue is to the fore at working level in Brussels and it is raised from time to time at more senior level. Much attention at present in Brussels is on the common agricultural policy reforms, which will change the nature of the provisions and rules, and the kind of penalties that might apply.
Is any working committee that is dealing with this to be found in Brussels?
Yes.
If you are lucky enough to find it.
Can we be told, by note from officials, who sits on the committee and which senior official has blocked this and been so intransigent? If there is more than one official, can we have their names? You have levelled quite serious charges, with which we would agree, at these people. We need to know who they are, if any progress is to be made. Can we have that information please?
Yes, we can look at producing something.
If that could be sent to the clerks, that would be very useful. Thank you.
In this meeting
Everything on 18 Mar 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Rural Development Committee Tuesday 18 March 2003 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
- Item in Private Procedure · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 106
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 33
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 12
- Petition Petitions · 13
- Legacy Paper Committee business · 26
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.