It has been a constant refrain of mine that we should have an expert adviser for this inquiry, so I am surprised that there is no such proposal in the briefing paper. I have done some digging into how the Treasury Select Committee went about its inquiry into UK financial services and have found that it was supported by a couple of expert advisers who would typically brief the committee before each evidence-taking session to ensure that members obtained maximum value from the sessions.It seems to me that we need an adviser who can support us in two very different areas of expertise. For our generic look at employment levels in the financial services industry and Scotland's reputation as a financial centre, we need an academic such as Sheila Dow at the University of Stirling, who has been an expert on Scottish banking and finance for a long time now. I wonder whether Chris Harvie knows anyone else, but we should be thinking of someone of that ilk.On the other hand, very topical matters such as the availability and cost of credit, the practicalities of restructuring and the impact of decisions that are being taken on small to medium-sized enterprise are really about the blood and guts of the behaviour of what are essentially two nationalised institutions. After all, in the past 24 hours alone, we have heard about remuneration packages for bank chairmen, the role of UK Trade & Investment and so on.I just think that it is better to ask fewer and better questions with support from the right expert adviser than it is to ask a lot of questions blind and perhaps not get to the meat of the issue. The Treasury Select Committee had a lot of support which, although not necessarily visible, made it more effective and helped it to do a good job. We should consider the same approach instead of stumbling into this inquiry with a lot of anecdotal evidence from organisations such as chambers of commerce. I have spent a lot of time talking to the chamber of commerce in my area, and its view is that people are very anxious not to prejudice in any way their relationship with their present bank—or, indeed, any other bank that they might use in the future. As a result, any evidence that we will receive will largely come from anonymous sources. In our attempts to pursue issues, we will simply not have in front of us those who are at the raw end of the market.We have not only to persuade those on the supply side—in other words, those who work in the banking industry—to be transparent about their current lending practices, but to persuade executives to be candid about their restructuring plans. It seems that there has been no public transparency about such matters, and I feel that they will be very reluctant to expose themselves in that way.In summary, it would also be valuable if we had a couple of insiders to help us with our task, and I am happy to leave it to the convener, the deputy convener and the clerks to consider the matter over the summer. All I will say is that, otherwise, the committee will risk being compared very unfavourably with colleagues in another place, who undertook a not-dissimilar task less than 12 months ago.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Wendy Alexander only · show everyone- Iain Smith LD 10
- Wendy Alexander Lab 6
- Lewis Macdonald Lab 2
- Stephen Imrie Clerk 2
- Christopher Harvie SNP 1
- Rob Gibson SNP 1
Wendy Alexander’s contributions
6 contributionsI think we are looking for a retired head of business banking from one of Scotland's three clearing banks. At the business in the Parliament conference last week, I talked to a couple of investment advisers who suggested one such individual, but whose name I do not have to hand. A retired head of banking from the Clydesdale Bank, the Royal Bank of Scotland or the Bank of Scotland would have the necessary knowledge of changing practices in relation to the cost and availability of credit. Perhaps the rules compel us to have only one person advising us. However, if we are to do the best possible job, we need the outside perspective of an academic as well as the inside perspective on cost and availability of credit—we will not get a current banker, but we could perhaps get someone who has been head of business banking in the immediate past.
Because of the summer recess, can we delegate the choice of an adviser to the convener and deputy convener?
Is that in standing orders?
Is it not just convention?
Fair enough, but there is a big difference in status between a procedure that is set out in standing orders and one that is just convention. The committee could say that, because of the urgency of the matter and the short timescale that is available, it is happy for the convener and deputy convener to choose who should do 15 days of consultancy work for us.
In this meeting
Everything on 23 Jun 2009 →- Scottish Parliament Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee Tuesday 23 June 2009 Committee business · 1
- Tourism Committee business · 137
- Work Programme Procedure · 26
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.