Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Conservation of Seals (Scotland) Order 2002 (SSI 2002/404)

Tuesday 24 September 2002 Rural Development Committee Subordinate legislation 28 contributions · 5 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

28 contributions
Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Given the time, I will move straight on to the order on the conservation of seals, which we considered briefly last week under the negative procedure. There was considerable discussion last week on the policy behind the order and the procedure—or lack of procedure—associated with the order. Members should have a copy of the correspondence with the Executive, along with a cover note from the clerk outlining the procedure.As I said last week, the Subordinate Legislation Committee has nothing to report on the order. Given the fact that the Executive has answered our letter, are members content for us to make no recommendation to the Parliament? I am happy to open the question up for discussion.I am not entirely convinced that the Executive answered our letter in the most robust manner.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I raised the issue in the committee when we first considered the order. My main point was that I did not agree that the Parliament, through the Rural Development Committee, should be asked to implement what was in effect retrospective legislation. The minister has not addressed that point.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I agree entirely. We have two options. The first option is to submit a beefed-up report drawing attention to our concerns, but to make no further comment, on the basis that we do not wish to stand in the way of the order. The other option is for the committee to lodge a motion to annul.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

When we previously considered an order with retrospective effect, our decision not to object came down to the fact that if we had objected, we could have impinged on people's income. That is not the case in respect of this order. I would like to hear what other members have to say on the matter. At some stage, the committee should take a stand on retrospective legislation that comes before us in this way. I am not happy with that practice.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

One of the concerns that was expressed at our previous meeting was that the upshot is that we are dealing with retrospective legislation that could prejudice the interests of individuals who may commit a crime without knowing about that crime. That is because the order provides for the creation of a crime. In response to that point, the minister says:"It is not for the Executive to advise the Crown Office".He goes on to say:"This would be a matter for the Crown Office to decide and any decision would be made according to the individual circumstances of each case."With respect, the minister has not addressed the very simple point that was made by more than one member at the last meeting. Like Mike Rumbles, I feel that the minister's reply is not satisfactory. I am not sure what action we can take. We could write to the Crown Office, asking what its position is on retrospective legislation. We could ask whether the Crown's policy is not to prosecute in cases where the creation of a crime has been made without that being known to the citizenry. Would that be the appropriate course of action to take?

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I do not disagree, but I am worried about pressure of time. The order has to be reported on by 7 October.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Could we ask the minister to withdraw the order and to resubmit it with a different commencement date?

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Although I believe that no one could be arrested for committing a crime under the order because it was not laid and did not go through the parliamentary procedures properly, I am concerned about delaying it. We should be careful about doing that because the disease that is sweeping through the seal population is serious. If we were to delay the order, we could put the seal population at risk. I share members' concerns because I do not like legislation that has already come into effect being put in front of us. At the same time, someone who arrests a person for shooting a seal would need to be able to cite the law that that person was breaking. If the law has not passed through the Parliament properly, how can that person be in breach of it?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

That is not the position as far as I understand it. The order has Executive authority: the law is already in place but is subject to the approval of the Rural Development Committee—that is what is meant by retrospective legislation. I am not happy to put my signature to retrospective legislation when there was no need for it to be retrospective in the first place. The Executive could have laid an order with a commencement date that would have been subject to our approval. We are being asked to rubber-stamp the order, in the same way that we have been asked to rubber-stamp a number of pieces of subordinate legislation. I was reluctant to do so on those occasions, but if we had taken a stand previously, farmers would have lost badly needed income. That situation does not arise in this case.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I accept that point, but the Executive says: "it was considered appropriate that the Executive should introduce this Order as soon as possible after the end of the close season in order to ensure compliance with its obligations under the EU Habitats Directive."However, the Executive does not specify those obligations. It might be interesting to investigate that.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Why are we being asked to approve the order retrospectively? The Executive has yet to justify the retrospective nature of that approval.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Are members of the view that we should write back to the Executive to seek further clarification of those matters, on the grounds that we are unhappy with the robustness—if I may put it that way—of its reply to our original letter? Do members think that, if necessary, we should ask the Executive to delay commencement of the order? I am reluctant to go down that route if I can avoid it.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Could you write to the minister on behalf of the committee to say that, if a similar situation arises in future, the committee will seriously consider the option of annulment?

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Do you make that suggestion because, in this case, there are no financial consequences for members of the electorate or anyone else?

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Rhoda Grant said that the disease is running rampant through the seal population, but is that the case?

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Cases have been reported in England. We know from past experience that once the disease takes off, it does so very quickly and can spread rapidly through the seal population. I think that that is why action has been taken so quickly. I agree with Mike Rumbles that we should write about the order in the strongest terms. We should also ask the minister to clarify how a person can be prosecuted for an offence if the statutory instrument that includes that offence has not passed through the parliamentary process.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Should we write directly to the Crown Office about that?

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

We should ask the minister in the first place, as he laid the order before the Parliament.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We have asked the minister that question, but he has not chosen to give us a particularly strong answer, other than to say:"It is not for the Executive to advise the Crown Office on whether or not to proceed with individual prosecutions. This would be a matter for the Crown Office to decide and any decision would be made according to the individual circumstances of each case."

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

In that case, it might be best to write to the Crown Office.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

From what members have said, I think that we are considering writing a strongly worded letter that outlines our very real concerns about the order. The letter would also point out what would happen if such circumstances were to arise again. We need to make the important point about financial consequences, as on previous occasions we have had to pass such instruments on, because people's pockets would have been hit had we not done so. Therefore, we will say that the committee would be minded to block similar statutory instruments in future, so long as there were no financial consequences for anyone. In addition, we will write to the Crown Office to seek its guidance. Given those criteria, we are prepared to make no recommendation to the Parliament on this occasion. Do members agree?

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

I want to make two points. First, I am not sure of the argument about grey seals in the Moray firth being shot because people did not know whether they were grey or common seals. It is quite easy to spot the difference between grey and common seals. By the way, I am not suggesting that there should be a mass slaughter of seals—I am saying only that I do not think that those are good grounds for including grey seals in the order. Secondly, have we been given any information about the source of the outbreak? The letter says that 18,000 seals died in northern Europe, of which only 1,300 died around the Scottish coast. It was thought that many of those seals had been washed up from Ireland. My point is that, even during the last outbreak, the disease does not appear to have been a big problem in Scotland. Do we know what causes the disease? Could it be that seal populations are not being managed properly?

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Those are perfectly relevant, valid questions, but they are wider than we are able to go in this debate. We have to deal with a specific statutory instrument that the Executive is seeking to introduce.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I propose that we take the action that you outlined in your summary.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Are members content for the committee to take that course of action?Members indicated agreement.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

On that basis, we make no recommendation to Parliament on the Conservation of Seals (Scotland) Order 2002. We now move into private session to discuss our work programme.

Meeting continued in private until 15:57.

  1. Scottish Parliament Rural Development Committee Tuesday 24 September 2002 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 1
  3. Cairngorms National Park Committee business · 119
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 28

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.