Item three is petitions. Petition PE480, from Mr William Campbell, calls on the Parliament to urge the Scottish Executive to review the current situation at the Scottish Agricultural College at Auchincruive as a matter of urgency. I do not think that I have to declare an interest, but I point out to members that I was educated—so they think—at that establishment.
Official Report · Committee
Petitions
Scottish Agricultural College Auchincruive (PE480)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Fergusson Con 10
- John Scott Con 6
- Richard Lochhead SNP 4
- Mike Rumbles LD 3
- Rhoda Grant Lab 1
- John Farquhar Munro LD 1
The record
25 contributionsYou were educated?
I should say that I received further education at that establishment.Members will be aware that the SAC's financial difficulties have led to suggestions that the Auchincruive campus in Ayrshire may be scaled down, with most courses being transferred to Aberdeen. The petitioner is concerned that such a course of action is not justified. The Public Petitions Committee took evidence from the petitioner on 26 March. Some members of this committee are members of the Public Petitions Committee and I know that other members of this committee attended the meeting on 26 March for that item. In addition, several members of the Rural Development Committee took part in a members' business debate on the subject on 21 March, so committee members are well aware of the issues and the current situation.The SAC recently decided to appoint external consultants as part of the process of forming its business plan. I am sure that members will join me in welcoming that decision, which should assist in meeting the petitioner's concerns.Members have received a copy of an e-mail that was sent today—I hope that everyone has seen it—on the subject of the petition, which points out two facts. The first is that the Minister for Environment and Rural Development intimated at the members' business debate that he would ask for a breathing space and for the SAC to get back to him. Secondly, I understand that tenders will go out any day now for an independent audit to be undertaken before any decision is made. I hope that members will view those as positive steps in the right direction.
The petition raises an important subject, albeit the petition has been overtaken by events, because—thankfully—the Government has intervened following the members' debate that was secured by my colleague Adam Ingram. That intervention led to the binning of the plans that were proposed by the SAC management and a return to the drawing board, which we all must welcome. The committee should also welcome the information that independent external consultants are to be appointed. Clearly, the original plans were botched by the SAC management and that led to a question mark being put over Auchincruive.After the parliamentary debate, a lot of press coverage and comment was given to the fact that the SAC had placed a question mark over Craibstone and Aberdeen. Supporters of all three campuses question the response of the SAC and of Maitland Mackie, who is its chairman. We all want the excellent advice and research that is characteristic of the Scottish Agricultural College to be protected at all costs. Putting a question mark over the college at this stage is demoralising for Scotland's agricultural community, which is extremely concerned about what has happened.In the light of that, the committee should take the issue seriously and monitor it closely. I am in favour of bringing the SAC management before the committee. We could also perhaps take evidence from the minister, who, after all, funds the college to the tune of £18 million. We should do that at some point over the next few months—we have until October—so that we can ask some searching questions about the management strategy. The committee should also place a question mark over the role of the Scottish Agricultural College's chairman, Maitland Mackie. The college's management has lost a lot of credibility through the debacle of recent weeks, which has upset many people.No one in the college is averse to change. People accept that times move on and that there will perhaps be change. However, after Auchincruive was put on the back burner, the idea was suddenly put into the public domain that parts of Craibstone should be sold off for the sake of a retail park at Aberdeen airport. That did not go down well. We need a properly thought-out strategy from management.In the light of what has happened, the committee should put a question mark over the college's management. We should take the issue seriously by bringing people before the committee to give evidence.
Do you accept that the right time to take evidence will be after the audit has been published, so that we can take a look at all the details?
I assume that there will be a big gap between the publication of the audit and the decision in October. We need to remember that we have the summer recess.
The convener's suggestion is a positive step forward. All the developments have been quite positive. I profoundly disagree with Richard Lochhead. It is not helpful to use terms such as "botched" plans, the "binning" of plans and "debacle". The issues are serious, so we should not use such language.As I said in the debate, the Scottish Agricultural College's plans are concerned not only with Auchincruive but with the problems of the whole of the agricultural industry in Scotland. I was informed—and I believe this—that the restructuring plan that was produced was as a result of what everybody accepts are hugely difficult market conditions. After all, the SAC is the helpmate of Scottish agriculture and needs a robust plan for the future.It is not helpful to the debate to blame identified individuals, as has just happened. I am pleased with the SAC chief executive's constructive e-mail, which states:"we will hold a consultation process on the future of SAC with all stakeholders, including staff, students, funding agencies, corporate businesses, farmers, government departments, politicians, local authorities and enterprise companies."The chief executive also states that the whole process will be reviewed. That is the way to proceed. We need to take an holistic view of how people across the country are affected.
Does John Scott want to say anything?
It is kind of the convener to let me speak here today. I welcome the comments that colleagues have made and the convener's positive contribution. I also welcome Professor McKelvey's e-mail, which I asked him to send to the committee after my meeting with him yesterday.On 23 October, I wrote to Ross Finnie to ask for an independent inquiry into the situation at Auchincruive. It is amazing how the whole situation does not move at all and then suddenly moves very fast. I am pleased that there will now be an independent inquiry. In a letter to me today, Ross Finnie has confirmed that the independent audit will be carried out by one of the big five management consultants, who will be invited to tender for the review of SAC. That is very necessary.It is crucial that the terms of reference of the review are absolutely right. I am sure that the committee will want to make suggestions to the minister about the terms of reference. As Mr Rumbles said, we must ask whether there should be two or three principal centres of education and where they should be sited. We must also ask where the students envisage their education being delivered and how the debt that currently burdens the SAC is to be restructured, reduced or eliminated. The review provides an opportunity for the vision of the SAC to match the minister's vision for the integrated provision of education in Scotland's rural areas for the next century. I hope that that opportunity will be taken. The inquiry should also consider the possibility of other sources of funding for the sites. I know that Mr Rumbles objects to the idea of part of Craibstone being used for Aberdeen airport. I was unaware of that issue until he mentioned it.
I did not mention that—Richard Lochhead did.
I beg your pardon. All the options should be considered and the review should be wide ranging. Nothing should be sacred.
I understand that you met the minister and others at Auchincruive campus yesterday.
That is correct.
Were you given an indication of what the remit of the review might be?
No. Professor McKelvey asked me—rather embarrassingly—whether I would be happy with the proposed evaluation. I said that it was absolutely what is required.
I, too, welcome the review. I was at the meeting of the Public Petitions Committee when the issue was discussed. The review is an exceptionally good idea and shows that people can respond to issues that are raised. I suggest that we note the petition in the meantime and—should we need to—reconsider the petition when the inquiry is completed.
I want to respond to Mike Rumbles. I welcome the e-mail that we received today. Mike emphasised the need for a robust plan, but the point is that the minister thought that we did not have a robust plan, which is why he intervened—I welcome his intervention. That is why the original plan has been binned and we have gone back to the drawing board. I remind Mike that on 21 March, the minister said in the chamber:"I regret deeply the handling of the issue"and"we are not in possession of all the necessary facts."—Official Report, 21 March 2002; c 10615.The last time the minister was before the committee, which was at a meeting on the budget, he said that he had concerns about the SAC management's handling of the issue. The minister supported some of the comments that I made earlier.
I referred to your intemperate language.
There is an opportunity to get the matter right and to develop cross-party support, if the right plans are delivered. I hope that, this time round, the process will be utterly transparent and therefore justifiable and that, provided that the facts are laid out properly, the thought processes will be such that the conclusions that are arrived at will be ones that anybody would arrive at.
One would like to think that the reactions that were provoked in Parliament by the SAC's actions will ensure that that will be the case.Are members content with Rhoda Grant's proposal to note the petition and monitor the situation? Perhaps we should also write to the minister to ask him to keep us informed of developments that take place in the meantime.
We should mention John Scott's point about the audit's terms of reference.
We could simply indicate that the committee wants the audit to be as thorough and robust as possible and express the hope that the remit will take that into account. As Richard Lochhead pointed out, the minister made it plain that he was pretty dissatisfied with the way in which the issue has been handled so far. Given what he said, and the feelings that were expressed at the recent members' debate and on other occasions, I cannot believe that the audit's remit will be other than thorough. However, I am happy to take on board suggestions from members about how we solidify the point that we want to make.
Forgive me for butting in, convener. I believe that the audit must be as wide ranging as possible.
I assure John Scott that this is not the first time a member has butted in. In our letter to the minister, we can ask for the audit to be as robust and wide ranging as possible. Are members content to accept option A in the paper, which calls on us to note and monitor the situation, and to move on?Members indicated agreement.
I congratulate Mr Campbell on the role that he has played in bringing this issue to our attention from the word go. He has put a great deal of work into it. Mr Campbell is with us today, although—as I explained to him earlier—under standing orders he is not permitted to speak. However, as a good Ayrshire man, he accepted that quite happily. I thank him very much for coming.
In this meeting
Everything on 30 Apr 2002 →- Scottish Parliament Rural Development Committee Tuesday 30 April 2002 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
- Integrated Rural Development Committee business · 141
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Petitions Petitions · 25
- Petitions Petitions · 26
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.