Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Integrated Rural Development

Tuesday 5 March 2002 Rural Development Committee Committee business 136 contributions · 9 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

136 contributions
Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Item 4 concerns integrated rural development. Members have had from the clerk a paper that outlines possibilities for two fact-finding visits for the inquiry into integrated rural development. The first is the proposed visit to Colonsay. I was slightly perturbed to find that visit plastered all over the BBC website this morning under the headline "MSPs' island trip on hold".I was not approached about that and I do not think that the clerks were approached. It is rather unfortunate that press comments are made before we have even discussed the visit at this meeting. I presume that the coverage is due to the fact that the committee papers are public. It is right that those papers are public—the Parliament is open and allows public access, despite what the article says. We have yet to come to a decision about the visit. There are severe problems with the committee's going to Colonsay for an official meeting. That is one of the matters that we must discuss today.It would be extremely difficult to hold a meeting on Colonsay because of the ferry timetable and the lack of time for the Parliament's broadcasting unit to set up and pack away. It is suggested in the clerk's paper that we have three options that would best take into account the concerns of the people of Colonsay. The first option is to send only reporters. The second is to have a meeting in Kintyre, possibly in Campbeltown, and for reporters to go on to Colonsay the following day. Option three is to hold an official committee meeting on another island on which it would be logistically easier to do so and have reporters go on to Colonsay.A fourth option has just been put to me: that we stay for two nights on Colonsay, which is the only way that we can get there and back with sufficient time for the necessary officials to do their jobs properly.I would like to open up the matter to discussion. It was the wish of the committee to have a full committee meeting on Colonsay, but we agreed not to incur enormous expense by chartering a boat to do so, or by embarking on a similar sort of enterprise.I must also point out that the only day on which one can go to Colonsay for a six-hour trip is a Wednesday. I need not remind members that that is a day on which the Parliament meets. However, we could go on a Wednesday during recess, if members wish to do so.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Correct me if I am wrong, but in the three years of the operation of the Rural Development Committee, we have had only two committee meetings outside Edinburgh—one in the Borders and one near Loch Lomond.I was pleased that we decided to have a series of four committee meetings up and down the country. We firmed up the first two and we should now firm up the second two. I am surprised that the recommendation appears to be that the second two should not be full committee meetings. To accept that recommendation would be a mistake. Our purpose is to investigate integrated rural development and the barriers to it. I understand that it is difficult to conduct a full meeting in the two areas that we have decided to visit, but dealing with that difficulty will give us experience that will inform our deliberations and our report. It is essential that we do not send one or two people off to report back to the committee or that we simply undertake informal visits. We should have proper committee visits. Backtracking on that commitment would send entirely the wrong message.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

The convener mentioned that a fourth option was to stay for two days.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

It might be useful if I asked one of the clerks to outline the public transport options for getting to and from Colonsay.

Mark Brough Clerk
link

We understand that, during the summer months only, a ferry goes to Colonsay from Kennacraig in Kintyre, stays for six hours and returns that evening, getting back to Kennacraig at quarter to 10. That option would not require the committee to stay overnight on Colonsay but would allow time for fact-finding visits or a meeting. However, as the committee has heard, it is not feasible to hold a meeting of the committee when the Parliament is meeting. It might be possible to identify a week when there was no meeting on Wednesday.The alternative is to go from either Kintyre or Oban. However, as those ferries do not wait in Colonsay, we would have to go on a Monday, for example, and wait until the next ferry back, which would be a Wednesday. That would involve two nights' stay.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

What time would we get there on the Monday?

Mark Brough Clerk
link

I do not know. I could confirm that for you.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

It might well be that, if we arrived late, we would have only one full day—Tuesday—on the island.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

That would almost certainly be the case, given that the ferry back is on Wednesday. However, that would still involve three days of members' time.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

Mike Rumbles's point was a good one: the fact that one full day on the island would take up three days of our time is indicative of the sort of thing that people who live on the island have to put up with all the time.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

I remember making the same points as Mike Rumbles when we first discussed holding the meetings. It is important that the Rural Development Committee does not send out a message that it is unwilling to overcome obstacles in order to conduct an inquiry into obstacles to rural development.I wonder whether option 3 is a goer. We could hold a meeting on another island and the committee could still visit Colonsay for a six-hour trip rather than send reporters. We would not have the official reporters with us, but the committee would visit Colonsay even if only for six hours.As Mike Rumbles says, we have met outside Edinburgh only twice, which is pretty ridiculous. We should take the opportunity to expose ourselves to as many people as possible in rural areas. The committee has not even been to Inverness. We could perhaps kill two birds with one stone by visiting two islands. We could undertake one visit with the official reporters and one without them.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Okay. However, I take issue with what you say. We have held only two official meetings outside Edinburgh, but we have held quite a few public meetings outside Edinburgh, especially when we were researching the report on the impact of changing employment patterns in rural Scotland.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

There is no doubt that we have met outside Edinburgh only twice.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

That is true for official committee meetings. However, we have held other meetings outside Edinburgh.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

How many other committees have met officially outside Edinburgh, and how many times have they done so?

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We do not know. However, as the Rural Development Committee, we have always felt that we should meet outside Edinburgh.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

I do not dispute that, but two formal committee meetings outside Edinburgh might not be a bad track record compared with other committees—although I am not saying that that is the level that we want to achieve. It has always been acknowledged that it is difficult and costly for committees to meet outside Edinburgh. If the information that I asked for is not available, my question cannot be answered, but it might be useful for us to know the answer.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

The information is not immediately available, but we could get it.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Convener, I have—as have you—attended many meetings of the conveners liaison group, at which applications by committees to meet outside Edinburgh have been discussed. I have been surprised that there has never been a financial barrier to that. I am not aware that any committee has been refused permission to meet outside Edinburgh. We seem to be stuck in a sort of self-fulfilling prophecy of finding barriers where they do not exist. This is a bizarre situation, because our inquiry is about barriers to integrated rural development. It seems that we are putting our own barriers in place right at the beginning of our inquiry. We should remove those barriers.We have met informally a number of times outside Edinburgh. We have sent committee reporters out and that has been useful. However, it is an important part of the parliamentary process that the committee meet formally in various parts of Scotland. Rhoda Grant suggested that we meet on Colonsay. It would be ironic and bizarre if we pulled out of the visit at the first hurdle. That would send the wrong message. We should not only have a full committee meeting on Colonsay; we should have one in the north-east of Scotland. That is what we agreed to.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I shall ask the clerk. How many people must travel to a full committee meeting, apart from the members?

Mark Brough Clerk
link

I cannot give an exact number. There would be representatives from security, public information, the official report and broadcasting, as well as the committee's clerks.

Mark Brough Clerk
link

Yes.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

In that case, it might be more economical to hire a charter vessel from Tobermory or Kennacraig to take the team to Colonsay instead of going on the Caledonian MacBrayne ferry. Has that been investigated as a possibility?

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

It is possible to get a passenger charter from Crinan.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

I am sure that it could go round the back of Jura to Colonsay.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I must point out that members rejected that option when it was put to them previously. We received a quote for chartering a vessel to take us there. Perhaps there are other vessels that we could charter—I do not know—but it is fair to say that there would be procurement delays.If members feel that we should go down that route, that is fine. The problem, however, is getting members to attend such meetings. Only seven members are going to Dalry and it is not hard to get there.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

We are in the difficult position of being damned if we go and damned if we do not. If we do not go, we will have press coverage similar to that which we have had. If we charter a boat for a huge financial outlay, we will be hammered again. We should not just rush on to Colonsay, hold an official committee meeting, then leave. It would be better to stay on the island so that we can speak informally to people.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I think that we will get more information by doing that. People might not speak openly at the meeting because their comments will be recorded in the Official Report. I would be happy for the whole committee to go to the island for an informal meeting to hear people's concerns. I do not back the proposal to charter a boat for a day, which would allow us to have a committee meeting on the island but do nothing more. I am keener on an informal visit.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I have much sympathy with that suggestion, but a possible problem is that the conveners liaison group will not be keen on funding an unofficial trip for the entire committee. However, I believe that we could argue successfully for Rhoda Grant's suggestion.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I would oppose such a suggestion at a CLG meeting, because if the whole committee is going on a fact-finding visit, we should have a proper committee meeting. It is only fair that I tell committee members that I will—because I feel strongly about the matter—say that at the CLG meeting. It would be ridiculous to pull out of an agreed committee meeting because of such impediments as the possibility of having to stay on the island for two nights.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

We should not make a mountain out of a molehill. First, I do not think that there would be a media backlash if we chartered a vessel. Secondly, the media should not dictate our agenda. I sympathise with Rhoda Grant, but we should not be hung up about having the official report with us. I reiterate that if it proves to be impractical to charter a vessel—I would prefer to examine that option—we still have a duty to use our time sensibly. We should not go down the road of spending two or three days on Colonsay because we must have the official report with us. We should visit the island for only six hours. We have a duty to expose the committee to as much of rural Scotland as possible, which means using our time sensibly.We should return to option 3, if chartering the vessel is not practical, which would mean visiting an island with the official report, then informally visiting the neighbouring island of Colonsay while we are in the area. We should not get hung up about where we go with the official report.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

If we stayed for two nights in Colonsay, our time could be used profitably. We have said often that we would like to have an away day that would involve an overnight stay, so that the committee could discuss integrated rural development issues informally. We have a marvellous opportunity to have an official committee meeting on Colonsay and to combine that—if we are forced to stay there for two nights because of the public transport problems—with an informal meeting. It would be wrong not to use our agreed agenda for such an opportunity.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

I sympathise with members' points. However, I want to respond particularly to Mike Rumble's comments. I am the constituency member for Coatbridge and Chryston. I am also a member of two parliamentary committees, which I am sure is the case for other members. I would find it difficult to devote three days to a committee fact-finding visit, particularly during the working week. The visit could take place during recess. Could the committee go to Colonsay on Tuesday during the first week of Easter recess, spend one night there and return on the Wednesday?

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

The committee could do that, but we would have to charter a boat to go there on the Tuesday.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

Could we get a ferry on the Tuesday?

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

No, but expenses would be cut by using public transport on the Wednesday.I shall make a suggestion, or we will be going around in circles. We should defer the matter until 26 March, and ask the clerks to return with the information that has been requested today. We will be able to make a definitive decision after another round of comparative costs.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

We need to ask the clerks to examine the logistics of chartering a boat that could take official report staff, sound equipment and everything else that we need. Accommodation on the island for the number of people who will be working there is another logistical element that must be considered.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

Many private charter boats will not take more than 12 passengers.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We would need two charter boats, but that is okay. I hope that members are content with that for now.I find it unfortunate that our decision making has been altered by unconfirmed reports in the press. However, that is the joy of an open Parliament.The other meeting, which was proposed by Richard Lochhead and Mike Rumbles, was to take place in Aberdeenshire. We had planned a series of visits during the week commencing 27 May, when the Parliament is in Aberdeen. The paper suggests that Monday is the only viable day on which to carry out such visits, but it would not be possible to hold a formal committee meeting then because all officials, and others, would be tied up in organising the meetings of the Parliament. Nothing would prevent us from holding a meeting, but some people would not be available; it is a simple question of logistics. If the committee wants to have a full committee meeting rather than a fact-finding visit—it appears that that is the case—we must consider another date.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

I suggest that we press ahead for a full committee meeting in the north-east, and that we avoid the week of the Parliament's visit. It would make sense for us to visit the north-east at a different time because we want to ensure that people know that the Rural Development Committee is in the area. Confusion may arise in public perception if Parliament and the committee are there at the same time. For those reasons, I shall go for option 2, which is to find an alternative date and hold a formal committee meeting.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I whole-heartedly support what Richard Lochhead says. He is absolutely right. The clerks suggest Friday 7 June, which is a more suitable date.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Are you suggesting fact-finding visits, or simply a meeting of the committee?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I am suggesting a meeting of the committee on 7 June.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

You see no need for fact-finding visits in the north-east?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Fact-finding visits will always be useful, but I make it clear, as Richard Lochhead has done, that it is important to have a full committee meeting. We will have full committee meetings in the south, in Loch Lomond, in Fort William and in Colonsay. I should also like to have a full committee meeting in the north-east.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

Could I make a suggestion? If we are to have a full committee meeting on 7 June in Aberdeen, can we have, as Rhoda Grant suggested with reference to the Colonsay discussion, an hour at the beginning or end of that meeting to meet people informally? It may not be a fact-finding visit, but it would be something similar.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We will come to the format of the meetings later, but that is the sort of format that I hope to promote.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

I understood that we would visit three locations in the north-east, so I presume that we would have the formal meeting in one of those locations and fact-finding visits in the other two. Aboyne, Huntly and Buckie were the three locations that were mentioned, and we could visit them in the same day.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I am happy with that suggestion. How do other members feel?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Can I make a plea? I know that Mid Deeside Ltd is having particular problems on integrated rural development.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Can we come to the details of the visits later? We should establish the dates and locations first.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

That is what I am talking about. I would like the committee to come to Aboyne, which is what I proposed originally, for serious reasons. There are difficulties in Aboyne and up the valley of Deeside with integrated rural development, so I would like the committee to consider going to Aboyne.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

I reiterate my preferences, which were mentioned at the beginning. Both locations are in my constituency, so I have no preference, although Huntly would be more appropriate. It has a higher unemployment rate than Aboyne, and we have not been there in any shape or form. We have visited mid-Deeside before.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

We have not visited mid-Deeside.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

If members are happy with Friday 7 June, we can ask the clerks to look at the locations and find suitable premises for holding the meetings. Once we have found out what is available and where, the committee can decide where to go. There will always be individual preferences, but we might as well find out whether places are available. I am sure that the clerks will be in touch with those in the north-east who have an interest to hear their suggestions. We will consider Friday 7 June, which might mean two nights away for members who are coming a long way, but we will cross that bridge when we come to it.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

Are we in Parliament on Thursday 6 June?

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

Are you suggesting that we would have to travel to Aberdeen on the Thursday straight after the plenary session in Edinburgh?

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We would not have to do so, but it would probably make sense. We will have to wait until we know where we are going and what the logistics are.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

That is a good point. That is the week after we are in Aberdeen, and we are unsure about the plenary situation for the week. I do not know whether the debating chamber will be restored after the General Assembly; we will have to find out. The details will be available for our meeting on 26 March, and we will firm things up then.We will move on to agenda item 5, for which members have had another substantive paper from the clerks outlining the possible structure for the inquiry evidence programme. The paper outlines a framework, but asks us to consider delegating the detail to the work programme reporters and local members. That comes back to the point that Elaine Smith mentioned. It was always the firm proposal of the work reporters, agreed by the committee, that during the meetings we should get in touch with not only the usual suspects, but real people, individuals and small businesses who feel that they have something to say. That means that we must be slightly flexible and rely on input by local members, both in and outside the committee, to recommend the most suitable witnesses and examples of useful fact-finding visits. We are asking the committee to allow a bit of flexibility rather than putting down on paper today who we should see in, for example, Aboyne. Does anyone want to comment?

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

The clerks and local members could determine who should come, with the committee having to agree to their choices before the final decision.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

I will make a general point, but before I do so, I state that I am a member of the Transport and General Workers Union and that I have declared an interest.I feel strongly when I read the paper, and because of discussions that the committee has had, that the trade unions—particularly the T&G, which is heavily involved in agriculture and rural industries—have been ignored. The committee has not ignored the trade unions in the past: we asked for written evidence from them at one point after I raised the issue. When we think about witnesses, it is very important to contemplate involving the trade unions—particularly the T&G—perhaps for the final, more formal meetings in Edinburgh.It has also been brought to my attention that, although I made certain points to the minister and the Executive, the unions have still not been included in the advisory forums that have been set up. I feel strongly that the committee should take evidence from the T&G in particular.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I do not argue with that at all. You are right that the place for that would be in the final evidence-taking meetings that will be held in Edinburgh. By that time, I hope, we will have identified any gaps in the evidence and will be able to address those gaps specifically. There is no reason why the unions should not be part of that.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

Local trades councils from specific communities might also want to give evidence. I throw that suggestion to the clerks, because we have left them to decide who the most appropriate witnesses might be.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

A fortnight ago, Angus Council set up a full-day briefing for me on rural issues. A range of external organisations from Angus attended. I urge the clerks to contact the economic development officials in the local authorities to get the names of such organisations. That would be useful.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I am sure that the clerks will take that on board. It would be almost discourteous not to ask the local authorities wherever we meet at least to send a representative to the meeting. Perhaps such representatives could also appear as witnesses. Most local authorities have a rural development branch of some sort. I would be surprised if they were not on the list of witnesses.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I am getting a little concerned. We seem to intend to speak to agencies and organisations. How will we tackle our objective of getting out and speaking to the people on the ground who have faced the problems and issues? Another problem with having formal committee meetings is that we almost have to have a body that we can ask to send a representative. It is difficult to get Joe Bloggs along to a formal committee meeting to describe the problems that are involved in, for example, setting up or changing a business. That is the kind of evidence that we want.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I return to the subject of how we will structure the meetings, which Elaine Smith first broached. I will run over what I think will happen in our visits to Dalry and the south of Scotland. We will do three fact-finding visits on the Monday afternoon. We hope to have an informal meeting with a list of invited people on the Monday evening before we all have something to eat. That is where the local members and their nominations come into play.The first session of the meeting the next day would probably be with a body such as the local authority, local development agency or local enterprise company. The second session would be with specific individuals, businesses, companies or bodies that had been identified by local members or members with a local interest. We would finish up with an informal meeting between those members who are present and any members of the public who are sitting in the hall.The fact that we cannot allow somebody from the general body in the hall to give evidence to the committee at a formal session is a difficulty and a pity. It would be nice to find a way round that eventually. We might end up writing to the Procedures Committee on that point. We can bridge the gap by simply stopping the meeting and talking to people in the hall.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

The paper suggests that we could have a 30-minute break in the middle of the meeting, which would allow members of the public to comment on the evidence and ask questions or air differing opinions. That would be a better approach, because their comments and the issues that they raise could be dealt with and recorded in the Official Report afterwards.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I am more than happy to try that approach at the meeting in the South of Scotland and, if it is successful, we could continue to use the model elsewhere. I am in absolute agreement with Rhoda Grant that we should try to find a format that allows us to meet the real people—as we have always called them—who are involved in this exercise. Otherwise, we will not do any good at all.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

On the point about meeting real people, we could follow a model that involves doing some spadework in advance. We could contact agencies such as the local development company, Scottish Enterprise Grampian or any of the other organisations or trusts—such as the Royal Deeside Trust—and ask them to forward to the committee details of companies or individuals who would be willing and able to give evidence to a formal committee meeting. That would mean that we would not have the usual suspects turning up at the table to give us formal evidence. We would be able to choose in advance which people we would like to hear evidence from.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

If we were to ask the local development company for a list of nominated witnesses, would we not get the usual suspects? I would like to hear from people who have not managed to get an enterprise company grant or to get the enterprise company involved and why.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

That is exactly my point. I was only using Scottish Enterprise Grampian as an example. Let us forget about the enterprise companies—I am talking about the local community development trusts and companies, which are grass-roots development organisations. Unlike the enterprise companies, they are not top-down organisations—they are bottom-up organisations that are organised by and for local people. They would be able to give us lists of people and a range of options to choose from. They would not pre-select people for us or tell us, "This is the only person you can see". I am only making a suggestion.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Fair enough—your suggestion will be included in the Official Report of today's meeting. I would be happy if that approach could be used successfully, but I have the feeling that we would still end up with the usual suspects. I was hoping that local and constituency members would be able to feed into the process, so that we would have a proper cross-section of exactly the type of person I was talking about.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

It is difficult for the committee to avoid hearing from the usual suspects, who often have an axe to grind. We want to hear from people who can give us genuine case studies.Would it be possible for us to advertise widely, so that people who want to appear before the committee could get in touch with us? Our advertisement could say that the committee is coming to the community in question on a certain date and that we are looking for witnesses with case studies. If we were to be proactive, I have no doubt that sensible people would submit their experiences. We would be able to sift through the responses, but at some point, someone would have to make a judgment about them. Perhaps a cross-party delegation from the committee could sift through the responses, identify interesting cases and invite people to give evidence.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

That is a splendid idea, although I am not sure whether the advertising budget would extend to such an approach.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

As an add-on to Richard Lochhead's idea, we could advertise through a press release that says, "We are coming and this is what we want." Most local papers would run that as a story—it would be a good story for them.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Are you proposing to put out the information through a press release, rather than through an advertisement?

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

In the case of Huntly and Aboyne, the local papers would simply run a piece—it would not cost us any money.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

The story ran locally in the Dalry area.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I was going to suggest what Richard Lochhead just suggested—I think that that is a good idea.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

It is a sound idea.I welcome Fergus Ewing to the meeting.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I am sorry that I am a wee bit late—I was rather busy this morning.I thought that the approach described by Richard Lochhead and Rhoda Grant was the approach that we were going to take to promulgate to the public the fact that we are holding the inquiry. In my view, issuing a press release to the local papers would be a sound way of doing that and would not involve advertising costs or other expenditure. I am sure that the Parliament's visit to an area is newsworthy. I endorse the points that were made by Richard Lochhead and Rhoda Grant.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I can see the journalist from The Press and Journal nodding.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

The journalist from The Press and Journal is nodding vigorously behind us.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

The journalist from The Press and Journal always nods vigorously. That is terrific.We are happily agreed on that.We must return to the programme of evidence paper, for those who have arrived slightly late. We must move on to some of the more specific points in the paper and, if possible, agree the rationale for the evidence programme, which is described in paragraph 4(a). I am happy to give members a minute to refresh their memories.The paper outlines more or less what we have always understood. A series of meetings will be held outwith Edinburgh, then we will tie things up with two or, if necessary, three meetings back at headquarters, so to speak. Are members content with that?

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

It is odd that paragraph 4(a) mentions sea fishing and then aquaculture, but it does not mention freshwater fishing. That may seem a small point, but it is not a very sensible way of putting it. Aquaculture means fish farming and it also mentions sea fishing. I presume that all types of fishing will be included.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I am sure that that is the intention.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Given that it is just an outline paper, I hope that you will forgive that oversight.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I am glad that you are in a generous mood today, Mr McGrigor.If members are content with paragraph 4(a), we will move on to paragraph 4(b), which we have discussed considerably already. This is about agreeing in principle to hold informal networking events prior to the away meetings and, if possible, as part of other visits and to explore opportunities for participation by members of the public who attend the committee meetings. That is the important point. If we can get it right, we will get some very useful evidence, but if we get it wrong we will not get such useful evidence. We have a great opportunity to alter slightly the way that public meetings are organised. I will go through this reasonably slowly; if members want to comment, I ask them to do so.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

The concerns that Mr McGrigor expressed are covered by the second bullet point in paragraph 4(b)(i), which states:"key local individuals could be invited to an informal discussion with Committee members".

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Yes. That is part of the suggestion for the informal networking event. Thank you for that point.The bullet points in paragraph 4(b)(iii) are worth considering. They list broad themes that we will probably consider, having held the local meetings, when we come back to Edinburgh. The list is not definitive. It can be added to or subtracted from if members feel that we have covered the themes adequately in the pubic meetings.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

Health and safety is a big issue. Although it is, in a way, a reserved matter it still has an impact on agriculture in rural communities, so we might want to discuss it.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We can add that theme to the bullet points when we discuss whom we want to give evidence in Edinburgh.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

We are considering rural development and possible barriers to rural development. At a meeting that I had with Highlands and Islands Enterprise this morning, it was stated that one of the perceived barriers—certainly in Lochaber—is the lack of housing in an area where unemployment is quite low. There are skills shortages, so available housing is needed to attract the people that are needed to fill the skill shortages. Could we add housing and transport? Transport links are seen by many as impacting directly and indirectly on what is good and what is problematic about development.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I have no difficulty with that, but I would have thought that those two subjects are likely to come up on our rounds.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I wonder whether we should signal those subjects in the paper.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

We should spell out for the public the fact that those subjects are included in our agenda.

Elaine Smith Lab Coatbridge and Chryston
link

I have no problem with that. However, I presume that the committees that deal with housing and transport also take an interest in the issues of rural housing and rural transport.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

That is called cross-cutting, is it not? Much cross-cutting could be going on, because every issue has a rural aspect.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

My point is related to Fergus Ewing's. Many issues will crop up, so perhaps we should not be too prescriptive. I thought that the inquiry's purpose was to allow themes to emerge from taking evidence, as opposed to putting themes into boxes before the inquiry starts.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We do not need to be too definitive yet.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

The committee tends occasionally to go down too many routes, which means that we get what we want to hear as opposed to seeing what emerges.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I take your point. We can leave those subjects until we assess whether we have missed something out.Paragraph 4(c) is almost redundant, because we have got a bit further forward in organising the Dalry meeting. To clarify for members who arrived a little bit late: those members who can attend the Dalry meeting will make three visits on the Monday afternoon. Alasdair Morgan and—I think—David Mundell will join us. On the Monday evening, before we dine, we hope to have an informal meeting with invited people.We will have our first session with people from the bodies at the top of the list in paragraph 4(c) at the formal meeting in Dalry on the Tuesday morning. We will have our second session with a panel of people who have been identified as having particular problems in the field of rural development, or people who have a particular issue to raise or a specific interest in rural development. We will also have an informal meeting with members of the audience for 20 minutes or half an hour. We will then resume the formal meeting and discuss the points that have been raised. That is the proposed format for the meeting in Dalry. Do members have comments?

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

About the Dalry meeting or the Lochaber meeting?

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

About either. The proposed format that I described, however, was specifically for the Dalry meeting. I trust that everybody is happy about that format, which we have almost finalised.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

On the Lochaber meeting, we talked earlier about the usual suspects. Seven organisations are listed in paragraph 4(c) as suggested witnesses for the Lochaber meeting. I would label five of those organisations as the usual suspects. I have heard of the Knoydart Foundation, but I know about it only from what I read in the newspaper. I do not know the Lochaber LEADER group. Could we not also include as witnesses community development companies or community trusts? Lochaber is in Fergus Ewing's constituency, so perhaps he could suggest witnesses. Could we have more local, grass-roots organisations in addition to the usual suspects?

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Three committee members have fed in many suggestions of organisations that are not the usual suspects, which could give evidence or that we could visit.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

This morning I met HIE. That organisation will make a written submission by 14 March. If all the usual suspects make written submissions, that will allow us to devote what time we have to taking oral evidence from those who are not the usual suspects, such as members of the public, particularly if they respond to the pleas from the excellent The Press and Journal and other press avenues.I support Mike Rumbles's suggestion that we should not decide at this point to have the usual suspects as witnesses. Incidentally, I would have thought that we should have had Lochaber Enterprise, which is the local enterprise company, rather than HIE. If we are going to take local evidence, it might be more appropriate to take it from Jackie Wright, who is the chief executive of Lochaber Enterprise. I have other points to make about the Lochaber visit. However, we should not decide on witnesses until we see what written responses we get. We do not need to decide on witnesses just now, because the visit is not until 22 April or 23 April.I think that Jamie McGrigor and Rhoda Grant have submitted written suggestions. I do not know whether they would agree with that particular aspect.

Jamie McGrigor Con Highlands and Islands
link

I would agree with that. We have all sent in suggestions, but they are not reflected in the paper. The Lochaber Fishery Board is the only one of its type that has gone ahead and accepted the recommendations—it has amalgamated with several other fishery boards. It is an interesting example of a modern fishery board.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

If many of the people who respond to our press release want to give us evidence, there would be nothing wrong with our taking up in writing the points that they raise with the usual suspects after the meeting. That would leave as much of the meeting as possible for hearing what people say. We could get responses in writing to the evidence that we receive. That would make more room for ordinary people. Do you know what I mean?

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

I do indeed. There would be no difficulty with that.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

My point follows on from Jamie McGrigor's suggestion on the Lochaber Fishery Board. It is important that we keep in mind what we are trying to achieve with our inquiry. I presume that our aim is to identify obstacles to rural development and, at the same time, to find successes. Anyone from whom we hear should be able to say to us that X jobs have been created during the past 12 months as a result of a project. We must use some sort of criteria. Someone might say that they are unable to create jobs because of X, Y or Z. That is one side. Success is the other side. We should hear from people who can tell us that 12 jobs, say, have been created, rather than from people who just have a good story to tell. We need evidence that certain people will be worthwhile listening to as part of our investigation.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

We are almost there with the Dalry visit. On the Lochaber visit, I suggest that the clerks should liaise with Fergus Ewing, Rhoda Grant, Jamie McGrigor and Alasdair Morrison to identify the appropriate candidates to give evidence—formally and informally. That goes back to the flexibility that we talked about. Unless there is a violent objection, we would go along with their suggestions.

John Farquhar Munro LD Ross, Skye and Inverness West
link

An issue that has affected Lochaber over the years is the demise of the pulp mill and of aluminium smelting in the area. There have been significant job losses. British Waterways, which operates the canal system from Banavie through to Inverness, is an active job generator. We should not overlook the importance of its activities in that area. Perhaps we could involve that organisation in some way.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

It appears that British Waterways has already been noted, but thank you nonetheless. We must realise that we cannot meet everybody on the visits. It is sad that we must prioritise. I am happy to leave it to the four members who have been suggested to finalise the choice.Are we happy to leave the detailed arrangements for each evidence session to local members and members who have particular relevance to the areas concerned? It is difficult to be precise; I am sure that our approach will change in the light of each meeting that we hold. I also ask that we agree that the work programme reporters will consult constituency members and other local members when we go on our visits. Do members agree to those proposals?Members indicated agreement.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Does anyone have further comments to make on the paper?

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

I presume that in the evening of Monday 22 April we will have the chance to meet a variety of local people in an informal setting, as is being planned for Dalry. If that is the case, perhaps arrangements could be explored with John Hutchison, who is the Highland Council area officer for Lochaber. He might be able to assist us in going about that.

Alex Fergusson Con The Convener · South of Scotland
link

Good idea. I believe that you had already suggested that possibility to Highland Council. I am happy for the council to consider that. Arrangements would be similar to Dalry, with a public session in the evening.Six points are made in the summary of the paper. Is it agreed that we proceed on that basis?Members indicated agreement.

Meeting continued in private until 15:17.

  1. Scottish Parliament Rural Development Committee Tuesday 5 March 2002 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
  2. Item in Private Procedure · 1
  3. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 19
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
  5. Integrated Rural Development Committee business · 136

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.