The final statutory instrument today is the Sea Fishing (Enforcement of Community Satellite Monitoring Measures) (Scotland) Order 2000 Amendment Regulations 2001 (SSI 2001/448).
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Sea Fishing (Enforcement of Community Satellite Monitoring Measures) (Scotland) Order 2000 Amendment Regulations 2001 (SSI 2001/448)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Richard Lochhead SNP 5
- Alex Fergusson Con 4
- Rhoda Grant Lab 2
- Mike Rumbles LD 2
- Jamie McGrigor Con 1
- Alasdair Morrison Lab 1
- Stewart Stevenson SNP 1
The record
16 contributionsWhen the regulation that these regulations amends came into force, it was quite controversial because the industry was asked to pay for the installation of the satellite monitoring equipment on the boats, whereas other European Governments were paying for that. That is why I am sceptical about the new instrument, which seems to gold-plate the regulations in the fishing industry in Scotland. That is an on-going concern that the committee has discussed many times.Point 5 of the Executive note says:"The European Commission is aware of the problems Member States are experiencing but we understand is unlikely to take action to address matters at a community level."That is evidence that there will be gold-plating of the regulations in Scotland while fleets elsewhere in the EU will not be subject to such strict standards when their satellite monitoring equipment breaks down on the boats.There is no information on how many boats have not been calling in manually over the radio every two hours when their equipment has broken down or have been making excuses for not reporting information, which are the factors that have supposedly caused the new regulation to come before us.We might want to express our concerns about the instrument because the legislation involves costs. Indeed, the Orkney Fish Producers Organisation said that the frequency of manual position reports should be limited to four-hourly intervals because of the costs involved. The proposal is for two-hourly intervals, which would cost twice as much.At the moment, the regulation applies only to vessels that are longer than 24m, but I am sure that, when the European Commission published its cod recovery plans for the next few years, it was suggested that the regulation be extended to smaller vessels. That means that the proposal before us today will end up affecting hundreds of boats.I do not know whether the committee wants to write to the Executive with those concerns and ask for a response, or to hold back the instrument until we find out the answers.
Richard Lochhead is quite right. The other member states subsidise the installation of the gear.We must consider the safety aspect. If a vessel that is being monitored by satellite suddenly goes off the screen, that gives an indication that something might be wrong with that vessel. Satellite monitoring might easily save lives. I know that the various fishermen's associations have asked the Executive to consider funding the measure, which should be considered in relation to smaller boats, especially because it would bring about a vast improvement in safety.
I want to reinforce what Jamie McGrigor said about safety. As those of us who represent fishing communities know, safety is the No 1 priority for the skipper and the crew. I therefore suggest that we approve the instrument.
I agree with Richard Lochhead's argument on gold-plating. If the EU does not intend to take any action on the problems that member states are experiencing until 2003 and that results in an unfair burden on our industry, I see no reason to proceed with it.The implications for safety are evident. Boats have a wide range of safety provisions, including electronic locator beacons. Skippers of boats that are less than 24m long would not be prevented from installing that equipment if they wanted to. Like Richard Lochhead, I do not see the need to amend the existing regulation at this stage.
I must have picked up Richard Lochhead wrongly. Did you suggest that we should agree this regulation?
I put two options to the committee. If we have a mind to pass the regulation, we should also communicate our concerns about it to the Executive. Alternatively, we could postpone passing the regulation until we have a response from the Executive about our concerns. Either way, we should express our concerns to the Executive.
I have no problem with indicating our concerns to the Executive, but we should not delay passing the regulation, which has obvious safety implications. We should do whatever we can to ensure that crews are kept as safe as possible. If we have concerns, we should make them in writing to the Executive.
I support Rhoda Grant's comments, which are sensible. We should pass the regulation and make our points in a letter.
For Rhoda Grant's benefit, I clarify that safety is not the purpose of the regulation. The Government believes that some skippers might not be calling in their position, with the excuse that their equipment has broken down, because they are fishing where they are not supposed to be fishing. The regulation is a policing measure, not a safety one. I am not saying that the Government does not care about safety, but that the regulation is a policing measure.
I am aware that the regulation is not geared towards safety, but there are big safety implications in knowing where a boat is fishing. If skippers are not using their equipment properly and not following the laws, I am not of a mind to defend or support that, especially if that action could put their crews at risk.
From a position of ignorance—being one of the committee members who does not know much about the fishing industry—I ask whether this is not a question of someone who has nothing to hide having nothing to fear?
I do not argue with that. All that I am saying is that the regulation is an example of gold-plating. I expect that the committee would want to express the concern that we are gold-plating in this country because we do not believe that Europe is coming up to the right standards.
I refute the allegation that this regulation is gold-plating; it is not. The Executive note makes that absolutely clear:"The existing Sea Fishing (Enforcement of Community Satellite Monitoring Measures) (Scotland) Order 2000 provides for the enforcement of, in and as regards Scotland, European Community legislation which requires fishing vessels over 24 metres overall length to be fitted with satellite monitoring terminals which provide … position reports on a two hourly basis."The problem arises when skippers report a malfunction in equipment, which is an obvious safety issue. It would be wrong for the committee to send out the message that the regulation is a gold-plating measure. The regulation is a measure to ensure that manual reporting takes place in the way that the regulation requires. Overall, as far as I can see, that is a safety issue.
I want to draw a line under the issue. Do members agree that we should pass the regulation but write a letter to the Executive that expresses our view that other member states should adopt similar measures?
I intended to suggest that. We should ask the minister to use his good offices to encourage other member states to come up to speed on this matter as fast as possible. Are members content to proceed on that basis?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 18 Dec 2001 →- Scottish Parliament Rural Development Committee Tuesday 18 December 2001 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 119
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 9
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 16
- Agriculture Research Report Committee business · 2
- Amnesic Shellfish Poisoning Committee business · 32
- Work Programme Procedure · 55
- Fur Farming (Prohibition) (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.