Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Future Business

Tuesday 14 March 2000 Rural Affairs Committee Committee business 120 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

120 contributions
Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

A paper has been circulated that gives a great deal more information on what is likely to come up under future business, which has been arranged into three groups—A, B and C.Item A carries on from the item that we discussed in private at a previous meeting and, in my view, it would appropriate to take that item in private once again. Item B refers to the timetabling of a number of inquiries and bills. Is it the committee's view that that item should be taken in private as well?

Members indicated agreement.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I am putting that view to the committee.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I only ask why we should discuss that item in private.

Richard Davies
link

I made that suggestion to the convener because the paper discusses possible timetables for bills that have not formally come before the committee. They are purely speculative, as giving publicity to the timetabling of bills before decisions are made could mislead the public.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Item C refers to bids for committee time in the chamber. Unless members wish to express a view to the contrary, we could safely take that item in public. Therefore, I propose to take item C in public now and then move into private session to conclude today's business.Item C refers to bids being sought for use of committee time in the chamber. A description was given of the qualifications and qualities that are required for a suitable bid, and I understand that the Parliamentary Bureau seeks business on which committee reports have been produced already.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

While we have discussed the forestry strategy, people were looking for opportunities for further debate on and a higher profile for that issue. Would it be in order and appropriate for a strategy of that kind to be proposed as committee business by the committee? The committee might come to the view that that strategy requires more public or parliamentary attention. Would it be in order, or possible, to bid to use our time to discuss either the strategy consultation that is before us or the report on the consultation when that is published?

Richard Davies
link

To make a bid for time in the chamber, the committee would have to have taken a position on the matter and have produced a report to the Parliament upon which the debate could be structured.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

We are not simply talking about an opportunity for a parliamentary debate on a subject that might not otherwise get that opportunity; it is effectively a report from this committee that we are submitting to the Parliament for approval.

Richard Davies
link

Yes.

Alex Fergusson Con South of Scotland
link

Do we definitely get time for debate? Do we know anything about the time scale?

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We have to bid for it, and put forward a proposal.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

Could I suggest that we do not bid this time? A couple of weeks ago, we spoke about hanging fire until we get our first main report on employment patterns in rural areas completed, before we bid for time for debate.It is a good idea to use the report and give it an extra push when it comes out. I feel strongly about that. We have put it at the top of our agenda; it has always been at the top of our agenda. We may have done other things in between, but a debate would give us a good platform to launch the completed report, although the report may be finished when we go into recess and the debate might be after the recess.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

I am delighted that this item has appeared on our agenda, and I think that we should bid for time as soon as possible. The subject is important to this committee. We have had a number of reports. Three of them are mentioned on the piece of paper before us. I am of the opinion that we should look for time in the chamber to discuss again the issue of the fishing boundary, and I would be happy to say why.One of the unfortunate things about the reports that we put together is that we simply lay them before Parliament and that is that. In the report on the fishing boundary issue, however, we made recommendations, as do other committees, one of which was to the Secretary of State for Scotland.John Reid is on record as responding to the report, saying that he read it very carefully and found nothing new to change his mind about the boundary issue. Given that this committee spent a lot of time investigating the issue and putting together what was a very detailed and considered report, I feel that we deserve a much better response, and that this committee should not give up on this issue. If a constituent came up to one of us as an MSP with a case, we would not simply give up on it at the first hurdle. I think that we should adopt a similar attitude as a committee with this particular report.I therefore suggest that we bid for time, that we choose this matter as our subject and that we ask the Parliament to endorse this committee's report.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I am sure that everyone is aware that 16 committees bidding for six half-days of debate in a year is not a lot. I am most loth to take Richard Lochhead's suggestion because the Parliament has already had a debate in the chamber on the issue of fishing boundaries. We have already had a full debate on it in this committee and have put out our report.I think that it is far more important that we carefully consider our opportunities to address major issues that we have not already debated. It would be a shame if we backtracked, as Richard Lochhead is suggesting. I think that it is not appropriate at the moment to make a bid. We need to wait until we have a substantial report such as the one that we are about to undertake. I agree with the comments that Lewis Macdonald and other members have made.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

I will call Lewis Macdonald first, then I will ask Richard to comment.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

I support Rhoda's proposal. It has been a concern for a number of members of this committee that the short-term issues that sometimes attract attention for a day or two seem to take precedence over our real, substantial, long-term work. We should ensure that the signals we send out to Parliament through the business that we seek to have discussed in the chamber reflect the committee's priorities. The committee's first established priority is our inquiry into rural unemployment. I would rather do as Rhoda Grant suggests and put in an early bid for time soon after the recess to discuss the substantive results of a substantive report on an issue that has not received the same consideration in Parliament as some of the others that have been mentioned. I think that all three items that are listed as committee reports have been discussed in Parliament during members' business. That is as it should be. It is right that the committee should seek time for a debate on what we consider to be our top priority, which is this inquiry. We should seek the same opportunity when our inquiries into fisheries and agriculture are complete, rather than use committee time to deal with other matters that can be raised during members' business.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

To my knowledge, very few reports from committees are before the Parliament, so we would have a good chance of getting more than one debate over the next year or so. We have the choice between bidding and not bidding for a debate in Parliament. I do not believe that this is a short-term issue; that was recognised in the report.I want to answer Mike Rumbles's point about going over old ground. There was a vote in Parliament in June last year, but we still took the decision to investigate the issue and produce a report. For good reasons, we did not take the view that because the issue had been voted on in Parliament, we should drop it. Because we put so much effort into the report and because every member of the committee believes that this is a very important issue, it deserves a better response than the one we have received. We can get that only by securing committee time in the chamber and asking Parliament to endorse the report.

Alex Fergusson Con South of Scotland
link

If bids are being sought, we should put in a bid for time. There is nothing to stop us doing that every time bids are sought. I have never been happy with the response to one of the first serious reports the committee produced, on which we spent considerable time. I would be happy for us to bid on that subject. That does not stop us bidding on any other subject in the future. Every time there is a round of bidding, we should be seen to take part.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

If we put in a bid for Parliament to discuss, say, the impact of the Scottish Adjacent Waters Boundaries Order 1999, which has already been debated, I do not believe that it will be accepted. The people who make these decisions in the Parliamentary Bureau or wherever will take the view that the issue has already been debated and wonder whether we have nothing else to bring before the Parliament. That would send the wrong message from this committee. As Rhoda Grant suggested, we should put in a bid in the next round for a debate on a major initiative that the committee has taken.

Alasdair Morgan SNP Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link

Members will not be surprised to hear that I take a different view. The Parliamentary Bureau will decide on this issue, and the votes there may be stacked against us, but I am not clear about who would be sending the wrong message. Would it be us, or would it be the Parliamentary Bureau by turning down our request? This is not a short-term issue. It does not require a massive inquiry, but it is of significance and relates to matters of principle, so we should debate it.

Cathy Peattie Lab Falkirk East
link

Members will not be surprised to hear that I support Rhoda Grant's view. I have said repeatedly that we need to consider issues such as employment strategies and to remember that this is not just a fisheries and agriculture committee. We are about to do three major reports, and our priority should be to debate those. I would be concerned if we spent our time discussing issues that we have already covered and did not take the opportunity to discuss the three reports. Those are the important areas on which we need to make progress.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

Given the amount of work we have put into the investigation and the fact that we made a stark recommendation to which we have had an inadequate response, we have two choices. We can allow the issue to go away and die or we can say that it is an important issue and consider the options that are open to us. The most obvious option is to take the report to the Parliament. That might provoke an adequate response. If we are unsuccessful in that bid, it will not stop us from bidding on other subjects.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

We have come to a clear choice. The idea that we use our report slot to discuss a reserved matter on which the committee has had divisions on critical points, on the basis of an alleged response that none of us has seen, seems entirely wrong. We should emphasise matters on which the committee, the Parliament and the Executive have a direct influence. Rural development is at the heart of the committee's work and we should bid for a debate on the first report that reflects that theme. That is a matter around which the whole committee can unite. I urge the committee to follow Rhoda Grant's suggestion and bid for time on that subject as soon as possible, so that we are at the top of the queue when the slot is allocated.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I understand the points that Richard Lochhead and Alasdair Morgan have made. My priorities are realism and effectiveness. We have debated the matter before, it will not be debated in Parliament again and I do not see the point in asking the bureau to put it on the agenda—it will not happen. As Lewis said, we should address the issues that concern us and for which we have some responsibility.

Alex Fergusson Con South of Scotland
link

If we do not make a bid, it will send out the message that in the nine months we have been in business, the Rural Affairs Committee has not discussed anything worth debating in Parliament. That is not the case. The covering notes state that the topic of the bid should be a subject on which the committee has reported and on which the Executive has had ample time to respond. Both criteria are met by the report on adjacent waters, as many members of the committee are not happy with the Executive's response. I understand where the Executive parties are coming from, but it seems to be a substantive issue for debate.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I am not suggesting that we should not respond at all. We could say that we want to bid for a later slot, after the recess, and explain why. We could also explain that no one apart from us is going to set that business in front of the Parliament. We might ask the bureau to recognise that we are being thoughtful in allowing others to come forward. In withdrawing our bid for this space, we would be putting in a bid for a later space.

Alasdair Morgan SNP Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link

I do not want to underrate anyone's powers of persuasion, but I suspect that we are going round in circles. We might try to reach a decision.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

It is strange that the same issue has divided the committee all the way along. The clerks have noticed the same thing and have been writing motions on voting forms for some minutes now.Do members think that we should divide on the issue?

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We have a proposal that has been gleaned from what you have said and another from Rhoda Grant.

Richard Davies
link

We have had a proposal from Rhoda Grant that the committee should bid for time immediately after the summer recess for a debate on changing employment patterns in rural areas. The other proposal, from Richard Lochhead, is that the committee seeks a debate in Parliament on its report on the impact of the Scottish Adjacent Waters Boundaries Order 1999.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

May I clarify something? My proposal is not a counter-proposal; I do not oppose Rhoda's proposal. We can all vote for both of them as far as I am concerned.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

There is a clear choice. Rhoda is proposing that we take a negotiating position; everyone understands that these are matters for negotiation. We will strengthen our bid for a debate in the early period after the recess by following Rhoda's proposal.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

I do not think that we should be spending minutes trying to interpret the politics of the Parliamentary Bureau. I am happy with Rhoda's suggestion; but I want us to make another bid for a debate in the immediate future.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I agree with Lewis. Let us not beat about the bush: this is clearly a choice between one course and another. We have Rhoda's suggestion before us and I think we should vote on it. The result will be indicative of opinion on the second suggestion.

Alex Fergusson Con South of Scotland
link

This is not a choice between conflicting alternatives: we could recommend both proposals, which I am happy to do. I have nothing whatever against Rhoda's proposal.

Alasdair Morgan SNP Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link

In terms of procedure and logic, the two proposals are not mutually exclusive, which would be the only circumstance in which we would put one against the other.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

My proposal is that we put in only one bid, to underline the importance of that topic and to ensure that we get any time that is available to discuss it. If we get time to discuss one topic, the chances are that we will not get time to discuss another. The bureau will say that we have already had time to discuss something and will therefore give the next available time to another committee. We have to strengthen our bid by putting in only one bid. That is really important.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

May I suggest that, as I have made a proposal, we vote on it? Thereafter anyone else can put forward any other proposal.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I suggest that we vote on Rhoda's proposal first.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

No, I proposed mine first. Laughter.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

I would like to be clear about the number of days that are available.

Richard Davies
link

I understand that five half-days could be allocated between now and the summer recess. One half-day is being used later this week by the Standards Committee and the Health and Community Care Committee jointly so, in theory, there are four half-days left. However, there is no guarantee that the bureau will agree to allocate all four half-days.

Richard Davies
link

No decision has been taken on that, but there is a requirement that there be 12 half-days a year for committee business.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

To simplify the voting process, we will consider Rhoda's proposal as the main proposal and Richard's proposal as a counter-proposal. We will vote on the counter-proposal first and then vote on the main proposal. That will simplify a problem that I can foresee arising in the near future; it will also allow me to keep to advice that I took in advance.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

Convener, will you clarify that Rhoda's proposal is that we should make one bid in relation to the employment report, and that Richard's amendment is that, in addition, we should make a bid for an earlier debate on adjacent waters? Is that the choice before us?

Alasdair Morgan SNP Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link

And will you clarify something else? We are talking about making one bid, but in how long a period? Is it one bid ever? Is it one bid for this calendar year?

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

For a debate as soon as the employment report comes out.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

Convener, I am somewhat confused by the arrangements. Are we going to vote first on Richard's amendment to Rhoda's motion?

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

But if Richard's amendment is passed, it will emasculate Rhoda's motion. Is that correct?

Alex Fergusson Con South of Scotland
link

Will there not be two bids—one for now and one for later—if Richard's amendment is passed. Actually, I did not think that Richard's proposal was an amendment.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

Would it complicate things too much to say that we want, if possible, to bid for one half-day before the recess for the fishing boundaries debate and to bid for another date after the recess for the employment debate?

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

That is Richard Lochhead's proposal. Rhoda Grant's proposal is to make our first bid for a debate on the employment report. It is straightforward.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

All I am suggesting is that our first bid should be for a debate on the fishing boundaries, which could be before or after the recess.

Irene McGugan SNP North East Scotland
link

That is the difference between his proposal and mine. My proposal is that if Richard's proposal is not taken before the summer recess it should fall and allow the employment patterns debate to take priority in the allocations after the recess.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

My proposal is that our first bid should be for a debate on the fishing boundaries, whenever it may be.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

This is the situation that we are in. Everyone agrees with Rhoda Grant's proposal. We will have the opportunity initially to vote on Richard Lochhead's proposal. If it is defeated, it is likely that there will be unanimous support for Rhoda's proposal.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

My confusion is still great. If we take Richard's proposal as an amendment and vote for it, it will destroy Rhoda's motion.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

Richard has said that this is not an amendment, but an alternative proposal. We should vote on Rhoda's first and on Richard's second.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

That is the only thing we can do.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

It is up to you, convener. At the end of the day, you must make the decision.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

If we take the votes separately, what is the wording of Rhoda Grant's proposal?

Richard Davies
link

The proposal that I have from Rhoda Grant is that the committee makes one bid for time immediately after the summer recess for a debate on the impact of changing employment patterns in rural areas.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

In debate, the proposal has become that the first bid should be for a debate on the report on employment patterns.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

I want to propose an amendment to replace Rhoda's motion, that the committee will make a bid for a debate as soon as possible on our report on the fishing boundaries.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

That is a counter-proposal. It is hardly an amendment.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

That is the same way as things work in the chamber. It simplifies matters, because everyone knows that we are voting on two things. We should vote on the amendment first.

Mike Rumbles LD West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine
link

I wish somebody would simplify things.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Do we accept Richard Lochhead's proposal as an amendment?

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

No. It sounds like an alternative proposal to me. Convener, it is for you to decide.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Although it is a substantial amendment, it can safely be treated as one. That is how decisions have been made in the chamber. Shall we move to a vote then? First, we will vote on Richard Lochhead's amendment.

Richard Davies
link

The amendment is, that the committee seeks a debate in the Parliament on its report on the impact of the Scottish Adjacent Waters Boundaries Order 1999.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

As we are not agreed, there will be a division.

Division list (how members voted)

ForAlex Fergusson (South of Scotland) (Con)Alex Johnstone (North-East Scotland) (Con)Richard Lochhead (North-East Scotland) (SNP)Irene McGugan (North-East Scotland) (SNP)Alasdair Morgan (Galloway and Upper Nithsdale) (SNP)Mr John Munro (Ross, Skye and Inverness West) (LD)AgainstRhoda Grant (Highlands and Islands) (Lab)Lewis Macdonald (Aberdeen Central) (Lab)Cathy Peattie (Falkirk East) (Lab)Mr Mike Rumbles (West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD)

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

The result of the division is: For 6, Against 4, Abstentions 0.

Amendment agreed to.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

How will the motion, as amended, read?

Richard Davies
link

The motion, as amended, is,That the committee seeks a debate in the Parliament on its report on the impact of the Scottish Adjacent Waters Boundaries Order 1999 and will bid, immediately after the recess, for a debate on the impact of changing employment patterns in rural areas.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

I understood that we were making a bid for only one debate and that Richard Lochhead's proposal was to continue to bid for the debate on the fishing boundaries. I did not think that he wanted us to bid for time for another debate.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We voted for the amendment as contained in Richard's statement. Effectively, that became the proposal—the motion. Are we agreed?

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

In that case we will have a vote.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

As I understand it, that was not Richard's motion. He had a counter motion to my motion that did not include having a debate on the changing employment patterns in rural areas.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

We have lost the bid for a debate on the report on current employment patterns.

Richard Lochhead SNP North East Scotland
link

So in theory we should have another vote on the amended motion.

Rhoda Grant Lab Highlands and Islands
link

His motion replaced my motion.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We should vote on the motion as amended.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

We will now vote on the motion as amended.

Division list (how members voted)

ForAlex Fergusson (South of Scotland) (Con)Alex Johnstone (North-East Scotland) (Con)Richard Lochhead (North-East Scotland) (SNP)Irene McGugan (North-East Scotland) (SNP)Alasdair Morgan (Galloway and Upper Nithsdale) (SNP)Mr John Munro (Ross, Skye and Inverness West) (LD)AgainstRhoda Grant (Highlands and Islands) (Lab)Lewis Macdonald (Aberdeen Central) (Lab)Cathy Peattie (Falkirk East) (Lab)Mr Mike Rumbles (West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine) (LD)

Motion, as amended, agreed to.

Alex Fergusson Con South of Scotland
link

Is it in order to propose a further motion, continuing—

Alex Fergusson Con South of Scotland
link

Yes we have—but I think there is some unease about what we have voted on. Laughter. Can I propose another motion?

Alex Fergusson Con South of Scotland
link

I would like to propose that, should we not have obtained time for a debate by the summer recess, we debate the report that we will then have on the impact of changing employment in rural areas.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

At this stage it is unnecessary to tie our hands. The committee might want to revisit the question in the light of the report when it is published.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

That is right. The committee has made a decision on what it considers the priorities to be. A minority on the committee deeply regrets that decision and finds it surprising that the vote was taken, but we will want to revisit this if and when we have a different set of circumstances later in the year.

Alasdair Morgan SNP Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link

I want to say for the record that that is totally ridiculous. We are talking about debating a report we have not even started the investigation for yet, far less produced or given the Executive any time to comment on. We can apply for time to debate that report when we actually produce it.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

I am sure we will want to do that, but at the moment we are not in a position to make that decision.

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

Alex, are you happy with that?

Alex Johnstone Con The Convener · North East Scotland
link

If there are no further comments, we will move to item 5 on the agenda, which we will discuss in private.

Meeting continued in private until 16:34.

  1. Scottish Parliament Rural Affairs Committee Tuesday 14 March 2000 (Afternoon) Committee business · 2
  2. Forestry Strategy Committee business · 103
  3. Sea Fishing (Enforcement of Measures for the Recovery of the Stock of Irish Sea Cod) (Scotland) Order 2000 (SSI 2000/26) Sea Fishing (Enforcement of Community Quota and Third Country Fishing Measures) (Scotland) Order 2000 (SSI 2000/34) Subordinate legislation · 29
  4. European Documents Committee business · 17
  5. Petitions Petitions · 18
  6. Future Business Committee business · 120

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.